Home Using papyrus fiber ash as a sustainable filler modifier in preparing low moisture sensitivity HMA mixtures
Article Open Access

Using papyrus fiber ash as a sustainable filler modifier in preparing low moisture sensitivity HMA mixtures

  • Tameem Mohammed Hashim EMAIL logo , Ghadeer Haider Abbas , Fatimah Fahem Al-Khafaji , Ali Abdul Ameer Alwash , Mohammed Zuhear Al-Mulali and Yasar Ameer Ali
Published/Copyright: August 29, 2022

Abstract

In this study, a sustainable filler made from papyrus fiber ash (PFA) is used as a partial cement replacement in hot mix asphalt mixtures (HMA). The replacement levels used are 0, 5, 10, and 15% by weight of ordinary Portland cement. The hot mix asphalt samples were subjected to Marshal volumetric properties (stability, flow, and air voids) and service tests (tensile strength ratio test and immersion compression test) to predict the influence of the used filler modifier on the moisture sensitivity of blended HMA. Best results have been achieved by using 10% of PFA, whereas all the prepared samples with the mentioned percentage of the filler modifier showed a lower sensitivity to moisture in comparison with the control samples, which contained 0% of PFA. The used technique proved to be very efficient in keeping the pavement safe from deformation caused by moisture. At the same time, using sustainable filler materials proved to be an environmentally eco-friendly method.

1 Introduction

Flexible pavement represents the most popular type of pavement since it is highly durable, resistant to water damage at some levels, and has very low flexural strength. The rising volume of traffic is causing continuous damage to the road pavement. Therefore, pavements need to be modified to resist such loading conditions and to provide a smooth, high-quality surface that is cost-effective and has a long service life [1].

Papyrus is a thick, paper-like material that was employed as a writing surface in ancient times. It was produced from the papyrus plant’s pith and used by the ancient Egyptians to make reed boats, mats, rope, sandals, and baskets, in addition to being used as a writing material [2].

Water can penetrate the flexible pavement from its surface, causing different types of failure. Therefore, a strengthening process must be carried out by using different types of additives, such as the ash of papyrus fibers, to increase the resistance of the pavement to moisture effects and make it more durable [3].

The main parameter controlling the performance of the pavement is its ability to prevent water from remaining underneath its layers. Moisture damage in the flexible pavement is mainly caused by a chemical reaction inside the pavement between aggregate, asphalt binder, and water. As a result of the chemical reaction caused by moisture, the adhesive power between the aggregate and the asphalt binder has decreased, as has the cohesive power of the binder. In addition, the rising dynamic loading of traffic under water saturation conditions can create a pore water pressure that leads to pavement moisture failure [4].

Modification processes of asphalt binder lead to a long life for pavement depending on the type of fillers such as cement, lime, quarry dust, etc., and its percentage. Papyrus fiber ash (PFA) can be used as a filler modifier since it is generally inexpensive when compared to others and has a unique composition that enables the pavement to resist moisture failure by increasing its durability [5].

Moisture damage in the flexible pavement can lead to permanent deformation, cracking, reduction in the load-carrying capacity of pavements, and excessive settlement. As a result, moisture damage represents the condition of the pavement following the occurrence of several distresses, which may occur concurrently or individually [6].

As a result, the adhesion and cohesion powers inside the pavement are naturally weakened by time or as an effect caused by moisture. Effectively, the chemical composition and surface tension of the filler, aggregate, and asphalt binder are the main factors that affect the adhesion and cohesion powers of flexible pavement [6].

In the case of water entrapment inside the voids of flexible pavement, it can cause high internal pressure and stresses, which can be called pore water pressure. That kind of pressure leads to fracture of the binder film around the particles of filler and aggregate. High pressure from traffic loading can accelerate the diffusion process of water in the layers of pavement [7].

Ali Adili et al. [2] have examined the use of papyrus fibers in soil stabilization and proved that using such an additive has improved the failure deviator stress and shear stress of soil.

Abdulhussein et al. [8] investigated the effects of adding papyrus fibers on the physical characteristics of concrete, whereas the compressive strength and split tensile strength of concrete have both increased as a result of this technique.

In this study, PFA has been used as a filler modifier in a hot mixed asphalt mixture (HMA) to produce an efficient, flexible pavement with the aid of resistance to moisture damage.

2 Experimental work

Certain factors were selected to evaluate the moisture sensitivity of various HMA mixtures, such as the type and content of the filler modifier, aggregate gradation, and the type of asphalt.

2.1 Materials

2.1.1 Asphalt cement (bitumen)

A type of asphalt cement was used with 40–50 penetration grade brought from Al-Nassiriya refineries. Table 1 shows the physical characteristics and tests of the asphalt cement.

Table 1

Physical properties and tests of asphalt cement

Test Unit Result SCRB specification
Penetration (25 C, 100 g, 5 s) ASTM Ds 1/10 mm 46 40–50
Kinematic viscosity at 135°C ASTM D2170 CST 370
Ductility (25°C, 5 cm/mm) ASTM D113 cm 110 >100
Flash point (Cleveland open-cup) ASTM D92 °C 268 Min. 232
Specific gravity at 25°C ASTM D70 1.04 1.01–1.05

2.1.2 Aggregate

The used course aggregate was crushed stones brought from Al-Najaf quarry, which is widely utilized in the south and middle parts of Iraq in asphalt paving projects. The aggregate particles are generally off-white with sharp surfaces.

Fine aggregate was also brought from Al-Najaf quarry. The combined aggregate was sieved and recombined in proper proportions to meet the Iraqi specifications of SCRB, R/9 for the base course.

Table 2 presents the physical properties of the selected coarse and fine aggregate, whereas the selected gradation for the base course is presented in Table 3. The results of the tests indicated that the selected aggregates met the Iraqi specifications (SCRB, R/9).

Table 2

Physical properties of the aggregate

Property ASTM designation Coarse aggregate Fine aggregate
Apparent specific gravity C-127 2.65 2.54
C-128
Bulk specific gravity C-127 2.36 2.35
C-128
Angularity D 5821 95%
% Wear (Los Angeles) C-131 25%
Max 35%
% Water absorption C127 1.42 2.8
C-128
Table 3

Asphalt mixture grading

Sieve size (inch) Sieve size (mm) Base course
Sp. limits Gradation
1 1/2 37.5 100 100
1 25.0 90–100 97
3/4 19.0 76–90 86
1/2 12.5 56–80 71
3/8 9.5 48–74 61
No. 4 4.75 29–59 44
No. 8 2.36 19–45 36
No. 50 0.3 5–17 12
No. 200 0.075 2–8 6

Aggregate gradation for the base course was chosen in this study since the mentioned layer is very important in distributing the loads from the upper layers to the underneath ones and also shapes the hard structural support for the pavement surface layer. Thus, such a layer should be modified to endure the loading conditions.

2.1.3 Mineral filler

Ordinary Portland cement was utilized as mineral fillers with the aid of its physical properties as shown in Table 4.

Table 4

Filler’s physical properties

Property Test result
Fineness (cm2/g) 3,045
Specific gravity (g/cm2) 3.15
% Passing sieve No. 200 95

2.1.4 Filler modifier

The papyrus was collected from the southern marshes of Iraq to prepare the PFA. It is usually pretreated for extracting the required fiber ash as follows:

  • Burning it in the air to reduce its size at a temperature of 100°C.

  • Grinding the burned papyrus using the lab grinder (Los Angeles abrasion machine), then passing it through sieve number 200.

  • Heating the filler which passed through sieve number 200 in a special oven at a temperature from 350 to 450°C to produce the requested ashes as shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1 
                     Production stages of PFA.
Figure 1

Production stages of PFA.

2.2 Lab tests

2.2.1 Immersion compression test

The test procedure is conducted according to AASHTO T167 to predict the loss of strength due to the effect of water on compacted hot asphalt mixtures. The index of retained strength (IRS) is determined by comparing the compressive strength of new compacted specimens with the compressive strength of replicated specimens immersed in water under specific conditions [9]. The compression apparatus is shown in Figure 2.

Figure 2 
                     The setup of compression apparatus.
Figure 2

The setup of compression apparatus.

2.2.2 Tensile strength ratio (TSR)

The used technique for the indirect tensile strength (AASHTO T 283) (TSR) test is by preparing two groups of asphalt samples. The first group is freeze–thaw conditioned samples and the second group is unconditioned samples at 60°C. By dividing the calculated tensile strength of the conditioned samples by the tensile strength of the unconditioned asphalt samples we get the percentage of TSR; higher values of TSR lead to the production of hot asphalt mixtures with high resistance to moisture damage [9]. The maximum load was recorded using the following formula for calculating the tensile strength:

(1) S t = 2 , 000 × P π × t × D ,

where S t is the indirect tensile strength (kPa), P the maximum load (N), t the specimen thickness (mm), and D the specimen diameter (mm).

After conducting the indirect tensile strength for both conditioned and unconditioned samples, the ratio of TSR is calculated as follows:

(2) TSR = S 2 S 1 ,

where TSR is the tensile strength ratio, S 2 the average indirect tensile strength of conditioned samples, and S 1 the average indirect tensile strength of unconditioned samples.

The indirect tensile strength apparatus and the tested specimens are shown in Figure 3.

Figure 3 
                     The setup of indirect tensile strength apparatus.
Figure 3

The setup of indirect tensile strength apparatus.

3 Results and discussions

The volumetric properties for the prepared asphalt samples are shown in Table 5.

Table 5

Marshall volumetric properties (ASTM D6927-06)

(PFA)% in HMA mixtures Stability (kN) Flow (mm) Stiffness (kN/mm) Bulk density (g/cm3) Air void (%)
Min. 8 kN 2–4 mm 3–5
0 6.7 2.7 2.48 2.320 4.2
5 8.5 3.1 2.74 2.311 3.7
10 10.6 2.9 3.66 2.297 4.1
15 7.8 3.2 2.44 2.225 4.5

The levels of stability, flow, stiffness, density, and air voids for all the prepared samples are demonstrated in Figure 4.

Figure 4 
               Curves represent the Marshall volumetric properties.
Figure 4

Curves represent the Marshall volumetric properties.

The physical properties of the generated mixtures which contain PFA as partial filler replacement is discussed below.

Stability levels increase as the PFA content in the mix increases, especially at 10%, then it starts to decrease gradually when PFA content reaches 15%. The reasons for such an increase owing to enhancing the friction forces between aggregate particles and achieving the best particle interlock [10]. The stability level starts to drop at 15% of PFA because the mixture has reached a critical point, whereas the combined filler at a high level of PFA tends to absorb more asphalt binder in comparison with the control mixture [11]. Therefore, friction power between aggregate particles starts to decrease, leading to a gradual decrease in the level of stability.

The air content in the generated mixtures tends to have a stable level in comparison with the control mixture, although it begins to increase slightly at 15% of PFA owing to the absorption process of asphalt binder by the combined filler at a high percentage of PFA [11].

Flow levels increase as the PFA content in the mix increases due to the increased air content in the modified mixtures in comparison with the control mixture.

All the modified asphalt mixtures have the most satisfying Marshall properties, and all the levels are within the Iraqi specifications (SCRB, R/9). The optimum percentage of adding PFA as a replacement to Portland cement is 10%. The best physical properties (stability, flow, and air voids) and service tests (TSR and IRS) of the generated mixtures are achieved at 10% of PFA (Figure 5).

Figure 5 
               Photo represents the generated asphalt samples.
Figure 5

Photo represents the generated asphalt samples.

The results of the moisture sensitivity tests are tabulated in Table 6. The levels of the TSR test and the IRS are demonstrated in Figures 6 and 7.

Table 6

The results of TSR and IRS tests

(PFA)% in HMA mixtures TSR (%) IRS (%)
0 68 66
5 76 71.3
10 84 73
15 82.5 69.6
Figure 6 
               Graph represents the results of the TSR test.
Figure 6

Graph represents the results of the TSR test.

Figure 7 
               Graph represents the results of the IRS test.
Figure 7

Graph represents the results of the IRS test.

The following points were concluded depending on the analysis process of the results:

  • Using 10% of PFA as a replacement for Portland cement within asphalt mixtures, proved to be the optimum percentage of filler modifier due to its effect in enhancing the volumetric properties and moisture sensitivity of asphalt.

  • Using PFA as a replacement for Portland cement within asphalt mixtures has increased the values of TSR and IRS regularly, and this leads to enhancing the characteristics of the mix against moisture effects. The enhancement of the asphalt mixtures in mechanical and service levels is applied due to the eventual reaction between the asphalt cement and the added filler modifier. Consequently, as a result of that reaction, the bond between the asphalt cement and the coated aggregate becomes relatively stronger [12].

4 Conclusions

  1. The modified HMA samples have the highest TSR and IRS values in comparison with control specimens.

  2. The estimated cost of the pavement which has been modified with PFA was lower than the cost of conventional pavement, owing to the reduction in the quantity of the virgin materials which are used in preparing the asphalt mixtures, and taking into consideration the cost of maintenance every 5–6 years of the service life of the pavement.

  3. Using the PFA as a filler modifier in HMA mixtures is highly recommended because it can reduce the failure of the pavement due to cracking or rutting caused by heavy traffic loads.

  4. The use of sustainable materials as a modifier in HMA mixtures, such as PFA, can provide an economical, cost-effective, environmentally friendly, and mechanical aspect.

Acknowledgments

The authors wish to express their appreciation to Al-Mustaqbal University College for their support in completing the experimental tests.

  1. Funding information: The authors state no funding involved.

  2. Author contributions: All authors have accepted responsibility for the entire content of this manuscript and approved its submission.

  3. Conflict of interest: The authors state no conflict of interest.

References

[1] Zhang H, Chen Z, Xu G, Shi C. Physical, rheological and chemical characterization of aging behaviors of thermochromic asphalt binder. Fuel. 2018;211:850–8.10.1016/j.fuel.2017.09.111Search in Google Scholar

[2] Ali Adili A, Azzam R, Spagnoli G, Schrader J. Strength of soil reinforced with fiber materials (Papyrus). Soil Mech Found Eng. 2012 Jan;48(6):241–7.10.1007/s11204-012-9154-zSearch in Google Scholar

[3] Jitsangiam P, Nikraz H, Nusit K. Asphalt concrete moisture damage resistance: an evaluation of the coating ability of aggregates and binders. Mater Sci Forum. 2018;934:217–21.10.4028/www.scientific.net/MSF.934.217Search in Google Scholar

[4] Moghadas Nejad F, Azarhoosh A, Hamedi GH, Roshani H. Rutting performance prediction of warm mix asphalt containing reclaimed asphalt pavements. Road Mater Pavement Des. 2013;15(1):207–19.10.1080/14680629.2013.868820Search in Google Scholar

[5] Bhat M, Mittal O. Effect of fillers on bituminous mixes I. Int J Adv Res Educ Technol (IJARET). 2016 Apr;3(2):178–82.Search in Google Scholar

[6] Sebaaly PE. Comparison of lime and liquid additives on the moisture damage of hot mix asphalt. The National Lime Association; 2007.Search in Google Scholar

[7] Arambula Mercado E. Influence of fundamental material properties and air void structure on moisture damage of asphalt mixes. Texas A&M University ProQuest Dissertations Publishing; 2007.Search in Google Scholar

[8] Abdulhussein FK, Jawad ZF, Frayah QJ, Salman AJ. Investigation of the effect of addition nano-papyrus cane on the mechanical properties of concrete. Civ Eng J. 2021 Feb 1;7(2):226–35.10.28991/cej-2021-03091649Search in Google Scholar

[9] Khosla NP, Harikrishnan KI. Tensile strength – a design and evaluation tool for superpave mixtures; Berkeley: N.C. Department of Transportation, Research and Analysis Group. No. FHWA/NC/2006-24. 2007.Search in Google Scholar

[10] Lu Q. Investigation of conditions for moisture damage in asphalt concrete and appropriate laboratory test methods [dissertation]. Berkeley: University of California; 2005.Search in Google Scholar

[11] Santucci L. Minimizing moisture damage in asphalt pavements pavement research center. UC Berkeley, Technology Transfer Program. 2010;2(2).Search in Google Scholar

[12] Sobhan MA, Mofiz SA, Humyra T, Awall MR. Effect of water on the strength of bituminous mixes with waste concrete aggregates. In: Miura S, Ishikawa T, Yoshida N, Hisari Y, Abe N, editors. Advances in Transportation Geotechnics II. Leiden: CRC Press; 2012. p. 394–9.10.1201/b12754-57Search in Google Scholar

Received: 2022-04-12
Revised: 2022-05-01
Accepted: 2022-05-06
Published Online: 2022-08-29

© 2022 Tameem Mohammed Hashim et al., published by De Gruyter

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Articles in the same Issue

  1. Research Articles
  2. Calcium carbonate nanoparticles of quail’s egg shells: Synthesis and characterizations
  3. Effect of welding consumables on shielded metal arc welded ultra high hard armour steel joints
  4. Stress-strain characteristics and service life of conventional and asphaltic underlayment track under heavy load Babaranjang trains traffic
  5. Corrigendum to: Statistical mechanics of cell decision-making: the cell migration force distribution
  6. Prediction of bearing capacity of driven piles for Basrah governatore using SPT and MATLAB
  7. Investigation on microstructural features and tensile shear fracture properties of resistance spot welded advanced high strength dual phase steel sheets in lap joint configuration for automotive frame applications
  8. Experimental and numerical investigation of drop weight impact of aramid and UHMWPE reinforced epoxy
  9. An experimental study and finite element analysis of the parametric of circular honeycomb core
  10. The study of the particle size effect on the physical properties of TiO2/cellulose acetate composite films
  11. Hybrid material performance assessment for rocket propulsion
  12. Design of ER damper for recoil length minimization: A case study on gun recoil system
  13. Forecasting technical performance and cost estimation of designed rim wheels based on variations of geometrical parameters
  14. Enhancing the machinability of SKD61 die steel in power-mixed EDM process with TGRA-based multi criteria decision making
  15. Effect of boron carbide reinforcement on properties of stainless-steel metal matrix composite for nuclear applications
  16. Energy absorption behaviors of designed metallic square tubes under axial loading: Experiment-based benchmarking and finite element calculation
  17. Synthesis and study of magnesium complexes derived from polyacrylate and polyvinyl alcohol and their applications as superabsorbent polymers
  18. Artificial neural network for predicting the mechanical performance of additive manufacturing thermoset carbon fiber composite materials
  19. Shock and impact reliability of electronic assemblies with perimeter vs full array layouts: A numerical comparative study
  20. Influences of pre-bending load and corrosion degree of reinforcement on the loading capacity of concrete beams
  21. Assessment of ballistic impact damage on aluminum and magnesium alloys against high velocity bullets by dynamic FE simulations
  22. On the applicability of Cu–17Zn–7Al–0.3Ni shape memory alloy particles as reinforcement in aluminium-based composites: Structural and mechanical behaviour considerations
  23. Mechanical properties of laminated bamboo composite as a sustainable green material for fishing vessel: Correlation of layer configuration in various mechanical tests
  24. Singularities at interface corners of piezoelectric-brass unimorphs
  25. Evaluation of the wettability of prepared anti-wetting nanocoating on different construction surfaces
  26. Review Article
  27. An overview of cold spray coating in additive manufacturing, component repairing and other engineering applications
  28. Special Issue: Sustainability and Development in Civil Engineering - Part I
  29. Risk assessment process for the Iraqi petroleum sector
  30. Evaluation of a fire safety risk prediction model for an existing building
  31. The slenderness ratio effect on the response of closed-end pipe piles in liquefied and non-liquefied soil layers under coupled static-seismic loading
  32. Experimental and numerical study of the bulb's location effect on the behavior of under-reamed pile in expansive soil
  33. Procurement challenges analysis of Iraqi construction projects
  34. Deformability of non-prismatic prestressed concrete beams with multiple openings of different configurations
  35. Response of composite steel-concrete cellular beams of different concrete deck types under harmonic loads
  36. The effect of using different fibres on the impact-resistance of slurry infiltrated fibrous concrete (SIFCON)
  37. Effect of microbial-induced calcite precipitation (MICP) on the strength of soil contaminated with lead nitrate
  38. The effect of using polyolefin fiber on some properties of slurry-infiltrated fibrous concrete
  39. Typical strength of asphalt mixtures compacted by gyratory compactor
  40. Modeling and simulation sedimentation process using finite difference method
  41. Residual strength and strengthening capacity of reinforced concrete columns subjected to fire exposure by numerical analysis
  42. Effect of magnetization of saline irrigation water of Almasab Alam on some physical properties of soil
  43. Behavior of reactive powder concrete containing recycled glass powder reinforced by steel fiber
  44. Reducing settlement of soft clay using different grouting materials
  45. Sustainability in the design of liquefied petroleum gas systems used in buildings
  46. Utilization of serial tendering to reduce the value project
  47. Time and finance optimization model for multiple construction projects using genetic algorithm
  48. Identification of the main causes of risks in engineering procurement construction projects
  49. Identifying the selection criteria of design consultant for Iraqi construction projects
  50. Calibration and analysis of the potable water network in the Al-Yarmouk region employing WaterGEMS and GIS
  51. Enhancing gypseous soil behavior using casein from milk wastes
  52. Structural behavior of tree-like steel columns subjected to combined axial and lateral loads
  53. Prospect of using geotextile reinforcement within flexible pavement layers to reduce the effects of rutting in the middle and southern parts of Iraq
  54. Ultimate bearing capacity of eccentrically loaded square footing over geogrid-reinforced cohesive soil
  55. Influence of water-absorbent polymer balls on the structural performance of reinforced concrete beam: An experimental investigation
  56. A spherical fuzzy AHP model for contractor assessment during project life cycle
  57. Performance of reinforced concrete non-prismatic beams having multiple openings configurations
  58. Finite element analysis of the soil and foundations of the Al-Kufa Mosque
  59. Flexural behavior of concrete beams with horizontal and vertical openings reinforced by glass-fiber-reinforced polymer (GFRP) bars
  60. Studying the effect of shear stud distribution on the behavior of steel–reactive powder concrete composite beams using ABAQUS software
  61. The behavior of piled rafts in soft clay: Numerical investigation
  62. The impact of evaluation and qualification criteria on Iraqi electromechanical power plants in construction contracts
  63. Performance of concrete thrust block at several burial conditions under the influence of thrust forces generated in the water distribution networks
  64. Geotechnical characterization of sustainable geopolymer improved soil
  65. Effect of the covariance matrix type on the CPT based soil stratification utilizing the Gaussian mixture model
  66. Impact of eccentricity and depth-to-breadth ratio on the behavior of skirt foundation rested on dry gypseous soil
  67. Concrete strength development by using magnetized water in normal and self-compacted concrete
  68. The effect of dosage nanosilica and the particle size of porcelanite aggregate concrete on mechanical and microstructure properties
  69. Comparison of time extension provisions between the Joint Contracts Tribunal and Iraqi Standard Bidding Document
  70. Numerical modeling of single closed and open-ended pipe pile embedded in dry soil layers under coupled static and dynamic loadings
  71. Mechanical properties of sustainable reactive powder concrete made with low cement content and high amount of fly ash and silica fume
  72. Deformation of unsaturated collapsible soils under suction control
  73. Mitigation of collapse characteristics of gypseous soils by activated carbon, sodium metasilicate, and cement dust: An experimental study
  74. Behavior of group piles under combined loadings after improvement of liquefiable soil with nanomaterials
  75. Using papyrus fiber ash as a sustainable filler modifier in preparing low moisture sensitivity HMA mixtures
  76. Study of some properties of colored geopolymer concrete consisting of slag
  77. GIS implementation and statistical analysis for significant characteristics of Kirkuk soil
  78. Improving the flexural behavior of RC beams strengthening by near-surface mounting
  79. The effect of materials and curing system on the behavior of self-compacting geopolymer concrete
  80. The temporal rhythm of scenes and the safety in educational space
  81. Numerical simulation to the effect of applying rationing system on the stability of the Earth canal: Birmana canal in Iraq as a case study
  82. Assessing the vibration response of foundation embedment in gypseous soil
  83. Analysis of concrete beams reinforced by GFRP bars with varying parameters
  84. One dimensional normal consolidation line equation
Downloaded on 5.9.2025 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/jmbm-2022-0072/html
Scroll to top button