17 The Tuol Sleng Museum of Genocidal Crimes: Phnom Penh, Cambodia
-
Eamonn Carrabine
Abstract
In the 40 years since Tuol Sleng prison (also known as S-21) was established as a museum to document, archive and educate visitors about the Khmer Rouge genocide it has become a troubling symbol of atrocity tourism and the uneasy politics of memory, mourning and witnessing encountered at such sites. There, in what had once been a school, those who were alleged to have committed crimes against the state were interrogated, tortured, starved and killed. Of the estimated fourteen thousand14,000 prisoners it detained from 1975 to 1979, only seven are known to have survived (Linfield, 2010: 54). When the Vietnamese liberated the barricaded compound of Tuol Sleng in 1979, they found dead bodies in shackles, bloodstained walls, human bones, stacks of corpses in shallow graves, torture instruments, photographic archives, ‘confession’ files and bureaucratic memos left by the fleeing Khmer Rouge. The army preserved everything and within two weeks a group of journalists from socialist countries were invited to the prison, while the museum was officially opened in July 1980. Inside, the display of physical horrors, objects and pictures are so vivid and shocking that the visitors find it a deeply disturbing experience.
Today it is mostly international tourists who visit and arrive with some knowledge of the site’s sinister role during the Khmer Rouge period, while for Cambodian people these memorials occupy an uncertain political role in the post-genocide landscape. It is because of the scale of the atrocities committed by the Khmer Rouge in the 1970s that a complex politics of memory has arisen in the country and that these sites of official commemoration are often experienced as theatres of macabre spectacle prompts important ethical questions on the display of crime at them and in the global circulation of a horrific past.
Abstract
In the 40 years since Tuol Sleng prison (also known as S-21) was established as a museum to document, archive and educate visitors about the Khmer Rouge genocide it has become a troubling symbol of atrocity tourism and the uneasy politics of memory, mourning and witnessing encountered at such sites. There, in what had once been a school, those who were alleged to have committed crimes against the state were interrogated, tortured, starved and killed. Of the estimated fourteen thousand14,000 prisoners it detained from 1975 to 1979, only seven are known to have survived (Linfield, 2010: 54). When the Vietnamese liberated the barricaded compound of Tuol Sleng in 1979, they found dead bodies in shackles, bloodstained walls, human bones, stacks of corpses in shallow graves, torture instruments, photographic archives, ‘confession’ files and bureaucratic memos left by the fleeing Khmer Rouge. The army preserved everything and within two weeks a group of journalists from socialist countries were invited to the prison, while the museum was officially opened in July 1980. Inside, the display of physical horrors, objects and pictures are so vivid and shocking that the visitors find it a deeply disturbing experience.
Today it is mostly international tourists who visit and arrive with some knowledge of the site’s sinister role during the Khmer Rouge period, while for Cambodian people these memorials occupy an uncertain political role in the post-genocide landscape. It is because of the scale of the atrocities committed by the Khmer Rouge in the 1970s that a complex politics of memory has arisen in the country and that these sites of official commemoration are often experienced as theatres of macabre spectacle prompts important ethical questions on the display of crime at them and in the global circulation of a horrific past.
Chapters in this book
- Front Matter i
- Contents v
- List of figures x
- About the editors xi
- Acknowledgements xiii
- Introduction 1
- Cocaine Bear: Fun Mall, Lexington, Kentucky, USA 9
- Whitney Plantation: New Orleans, Louisiana, USA 14
- National Portrait Gallery, Smithsonian Institution: Washington, DC, USA 24
- From Newgate Prison to Tyburn Tree: the Old Bailey, London, UK 29
- Jack the Ripper tour: Whitechapel, London, UK 35
- The Alcatraz East Crime Museum: Pigeon Forge, Tennessee, USA 41
- The Museum of Death: Hollywood, Los Angeles, USA 50
- The Royal Armouries Museum: Leeds, UK 55
- The Black Dahlia tour: Los Angeles, California, USA 59
- The ‘Execution Dock’: Wapping, East London, UK 65
- Auschwitz: Oświęcim, Poland 71
- Jeju 4:3 memorial: Jeju Island, South Korea 80
- Museum Dr. Guislain: Ghent, Belgium 88
- Karosta Prison Hotel: Liepāja, Latvia 92
- The Clink prison-based restaurant: Brixton, London, UK 98
- The 9/11 memorial and museum: New York, New York, USA 104
- The Tuol Sleng Museum of Genocidal Crimes: Phnom Penh, Cambodia 107
- Choeung Ek killing field: Phnom Penh, Cambodia 116
- Blue lights in the Red Light District: Amsterdam, the Netherlands 122
- Trophy hunting: sub-Saharan Africa 128
- ‘The ugly side to the beautiful game’: Qatar 135
- Burning Man festival: Black Rock Desert, Nevada, USA 140
- Magaluf: Majorca 147
- ‘Holiday Hooters’: Hong Kong 153
- Scilla: Calabria, Italy 159
- The Kray twins tours: London, UK 165
- Backpacking in the outback: Uluru, Northern Territory, Australia 171
- The hippie trail: Nepal, South Asia 177
- The Museum of Confiscated Art: Brest, Belarus 182
- Steroid holidays: Sharm El Sheikh, Sinai Peninsula, Egypt 187
- The souks: Tunis, Tunisia 194
- Mezhyhirya Residence Museum: Novi Petrivtsi, Ukraine 200
- The great British seaside: various locations, UK 207
- The Biggie mural: Brooklyn, New York, USA 213
- The Rebus guided tour: Edinburgh, UK 217
- Volunteer tourism – ‘doing it for the ’gram’: Cambodia, Southeast Asia 223
- The staycation: home 230
- The ‘suicide forest’: Aokigahara, Japan 235
- Pitcairn Island: Pitcairn Islands, Pacific Ocean 245
- Favela tours: Rio de Janeiro, Brazil 251
- Skid Row walking tours: Los Angeles, California, USA 258
- The 2019–20 anti-extradition protests: Hong Kong 264
- The Maldives: Republic of Maldives, Indian Ocean 271
- Death Road: La Paz to Coroico, Bolivia 276
- Vulture brains and muthi markets: Johannesburg, South Africa 282
- Dark tourism, ecocide and Alpine ski resorts: the Alps, Europe 288
- Boho Zone: Middlesbrough, UK 293
- One Hyde Park: London, UK 299
- Amazon warehouse tours: Rugeley, UK or virtual tour 305
- Disney World: Orlando, Florida, USA 315
- Conclusion 322
- References 325
- Index 394
Chapters in this book
- Front Matter i
- Contents v
- List of figures x
- About the editors xi
- Acknowledgements xiii
- Introduction 1
- Cocaine Bear: Fun Mall, Lexington, Kentucky, USA 9
- Whitney Plantation: New Orleans, Louisiana, USA 14
- National Portrait Gallery, Smithsonian Institution: Washington, DC, USA 24
- From Newgate Prison to Tyburn Tree: the Old Bailey, London, UK 29
- Jack the Ripper tour: Whitechapel, London, UK 35
- The Alcatraz East Crime Museum: Pigeon Forge, Tennessee, USA 41
- The Museum of Death: Hollywood, Los Angeles, USA 50
- The Royal Armouries Museum: Leeds, UK 55
- The Black Dahlia tour: Los Angeles, California, USA 59
- The ‘Execution Dock’: Wapping, East London, UK 65
- Auschwitz: Oświęcim, Poland 71
- Jeju 4:3 memorial: Jeju Island, South Korea 80
- Museum Dr. Guislain: Ghent, Belgium 88
- Karosta Prison Hotel: Liepāja, Latvia 92
- The Clink prison-based restaurant: Brixton, London, UK 98
- The 9/11 memorial and museum: New York, New York, USA 104
- The Tuol Sleng Museum of Genocidal Crimes: Phnom Penh, Cambodia 107
- Choeung Ek killing field: Phnom Penh, Cambodia 116
- Blue lights in the Red Light District: Amsterdam, the Netherlands 122
- Trophy hunting: sub-Saharan Africa 128
- ‘The ugly side to the beautiful game’: Qatar 135
- Burning Man festival: Black Rock Desert, Nevada, USA 140
- Magaluf: Majorca 147
- ‘Holiday Hooters’: Hong Kong 153
- Scilla: Calabria, Italy 159
- The Kray twins tours: London, UK 165
- Backpacking in the outback: Uluru, Northern Territory, Australia 171
- The hippie trail: Nepal, South Asia 177
- The Museum of Confiscated Art: Brest, Belarus 182
- Steroid holidays: Sharm El Sheikh, Sinai Peninsula, Egypt 187
- The souks: Tunis, Tunisia 194
- Mezhyhirya Residence Museum: Novi Petrivtsi, Ukraine 200
- The great British seaside: various locations, UK 207
- The Biggie mural: Brooklyn, New York, USA 213
- The Rebus guided tour: Edinburgh, UK 217
- Volunteer tourism – ‘doing it for the ’gram’: Cambodia, Southeast Asia 223
- The staycation: home 230
- The ‘suicide forest’: Aokigahara, Japan 235
- Pitcairn Island: Pitcairn Islands, Pacific Ocean 245
- Favela tours: Rio de Janeiro, Brazil 251
- Skid Row walking tours: Los Angeles, California, USA 258
- The 2019–20 anti-extradition protests: Hong Kong 264
- The Maldives: Republic of Maldives, Indian Ocean 271
- Death Road: La Paz to Coroico, Bolivia 276
- Vulture brains and muthi markets: Johannesburg, South Africa 282
- Dark tourism, ecocide and Alpine ski resorts: the Alps, Europe 288
- Boho Zone: Middlesbrough, UK 293
- One Hyde Park: London, UK 299
- Amazon warehouse tours: Rugeley, UK or virtual tour 305
- Disney World: Orlando, Florida, USA 315
- Conclusion 322
- References 325
- Index 394