Situated language use is influenced by a number of dynamic phenomena that introduce lexical variability and path dependence, such as fluid discourse granularity, priming, and alignment in dialogue. The empirical tradition of usage-based lexicology does not account for such variability. In fact, its primary theoretical approaches appear to presuppose high population convergence on particular lexemes in language production. This is implied in several key concepts of phraseological and constructionist models, notably entrenchment, the principle of no synonymy, and the idiom principle, as well as the dominance of the statistical paradigm in the field. In spite of its relevance for linguistic theory and corpus methodology, this assumption appears to be untested. This study provides an analysis of inter-individual lexical overlap of verbs and nouns in five task-based corpora of (mostly) German. Results indicate that speakers are maximally variable and highly divergent in their lexical use in spite of narrow communicative constraints and group homogeneity. A qualitative analysis links this variability to situational (cognitive, socio-pragmatic, and discourse-level) engagement with the task and material, which results in referential diversity, spontaneous meaning mapping, and abundant word formation. The degree of observed variability raises questions with respect to the stochastic properties and functional mechanics of entrenchment and the role of repetition of identical material, such as lexicalized chunks, in conventionalization. It further emphasizes the need for a better understanding of the distributions that underlie pooled data, without which the validity of frequential extrapolation to individual behavior and system status stands to question. This is of particular relevance to language assessment and other practices of contrastive analysis of speaker productions, e.g., in multilingualism studies.
Contents
- Research Articles
-
March 17, 2025
-
March 27, 2025
-
June 2, 2025
-
June 13, 2025
-
July 2, 2025
-
July 30, 2025
-
August 16, 2025
-
Open AccessTheory of ecology of pressures as a tool for classifying language shift in bilingual communitiesSeptember 1, 2025
-
September 4, 2025
-
September 10, 2025
-
October 14, 2025
-
October 17, 2025
-
Open AccessRhetorical questions and epistemic stance in an Italian Facebook corpus during the COVID-19 pandemicOctober 17, 2025
-
October 22, 2025
-
Open AccessThere are people who … existential-attributive constructions and positioning in Spoken Spanish and GermanOctober 28, 2025
- Special Issue: Request for confirmation sequences across ten languages, edited by Martin Pfeiffer & Katharina König - Part II
-
February 20, 2025
-
July 9, 2025
- Special Issue: Classifier Handshape Choice in Sign Languages of the World, coordinated by Vadim Kimmelman, Carl Börstell, Pia Simper-Allen, & Giorgia Zorzi
-
Open AccessClassifier handshape choice in Russian Sign Language and Sign Language of the NetherlandsMarch 17, 2025
-
March 26, 2025
-
March 27, 2025
-
April 22, 2025
-
June 21, 2025