Home The frowning balance: Semiotic insinuations on the visual rhetoric of justice
Article
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

The frowning balance: Semiotic insinuations on the visual rhetoric of justice

  • Massimo Leone EMAIL logo
Published/Copyright: April 19, 2017

Abstract

Some symbols so skillfully traverse epochs and cultures that they are depicted as almost “natural” embodiments of abstract values. The balance is one of these symbols, adopted to represent justice from ancient Egypt until the present time. Power appropriates this “natural meaning” in order to construct a rhetoric of fairness. Yet, semiotics unveils that the balance, like every symbol, is not natural at all, but underpinned by a specific ideology. From the semiotic point of view, the balance is a device that produces indexes, i. e., causal signs that visually signal an invisible property, weight. Although this translation is not automatic, but based on specific indexical circumstances (such as the type of balance, the weighing techniques, and the measuring standards that are used), the balance is paradoxically turned into a symbol of justice precisely because it is depicted as a non-semiotic device, as an instrument that cannot lie, as a machine.

References

Assmann, Jan. 2001. Ma’at: Gerechtigkeit und Unsterblichkeit im Alten Agypten. Munich: Beck.Search in Google Scholar

Barasch, Moshe. 2005. The departing soul: The long life of a medieval creation. Artibus et Historiae 26(52). 13–28.10.2307/20067095Search in Google Scholar

Baschet, Jérôme. 1995. Jugement de l’âme, jugement dernier: Contradiction, complémentarité, chevauchement? Revue Mabillon 6(67). 159–203.10.1484/J.RM.2.305532Search in Google Scholar

Baschet, Jérôme. 2008. Une image à deux temps. Jugement Dernier et jugement des âmes au Moyen Age. Images Re-vues 1. 1–24.10.4000/imagesrevues.878Search in Google Scholar

Björk, Gudmund. 1945. Die Schicksalswaage. Eranos 43. 58–66.10.1002/ange.19450580508Search in Google Scholar

Buck, Adriaan de. 1935–2006. The Egyptian coffin texts, 8 vols. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Search in Google Scholar

Burgess, Jonathan S. 2004. Early images of Achilles and Memnon? Quaderni Urbinati di Cultura Classica 76(1). 33–51.10.2307/20546800Search in Google Scholar

Cai Yunzhang [蔡運章]. 1982. Lüe de zhongliang ji xiangguan wenti [寽的重量及相關問題] (The lüe weight and related questions). Zhongyuan wenwu [中原文物] (Cultural relics of the Central Plains) 3. 27–30.Search in Google Scholar

Dietrich, Bernard C. 1964. The judgment of Zeus. Rheinisches Museum für Philologie 107(2). 97–125.Search in Google Scholar

Eco, Umberto. 1975. Trattato di semiotica generale. Milan: Bompiani.Search in Google Scholar

Eco, Umberto. 1985. Sugli specchi e altri saggi. Milan: Bompiani.Search in Google Scholar

Edwards, Mark W. 1987. Homer: Poet of the Iliad. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.10.56021/9780801833298Search in Google Scholar

Erbse, Hartmut. 1986. Untersuchungen zur Funktion der Götter im homerischen Epos. Berlin & New York: W. de Gruyter.10.1515/9783110855623Search in Google Scholar

Faulkner, Raymond O. (ed.). 1973–1978. The ancient Egyptian coffin texts, 3 vols. Warminster: Aris & Phillips.Search in Google Scholar

Faulkner, Raymond O. & Eva Von Dassow (eds.). 1994. The Egyptian book of the dead. San Francisco: Chronicle.Search in Google Scholar

Gagarin, Michael. 1974. Dike in archaic Greek thought. Classical Philology 69(3). 186–197.10.1086/366085Search in Google Scholar

Gaiffier, Baudouin de. 1952. Pesée des âmes: A propos de la mort de l’empereur saint Henri II. Recherches de Science Religieuse 40(2). 222–230.Search in Google Scholar

Grieshammer, Reinhard. 1970. Das Jenseitsgericht in den Sargtexten [Ägyptologische Abhandlungen 20]. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz.Search in Google Scholar

Hocquet, Jean-Claude. 1986. Les mesures ont aussi une histoire. Histoire & Mesure 1(1). 35–49.10.3406/hism.1986.907Search in Google Scholar

Hocquet, Jean-Claude. 1990. La métrologie, voie nouvelle de la recherche historique. Comptes rendus des séances de l’Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres 134(1). 59–77.10.3406/crai.1990.14811Search in Google Scholar

Hornung, Eric. 1987. Ma’at: Gerechtigkeit für alle. Eranos 57. 385–427.Search in Google Scholar

Irvine, James A. D. 1997. Keres in Stesichorus’ “Geryoneis”: P. Oxy. 2617 fr. 1 (a)-(b) = SLG 21 reconsidered. Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik 115. 37–46.Search in Google Scholar

Jonsen, Albert R. & Stephen Toulmin. 1990. The abuse of casuistry: A history of moral reasoning. Berkeley & Los Angeles: University of California Press.Search in Google Scholar

Lichocka, Barbara. 1974. Iustitia sur les monnaies impériales romaines. Warsaw: Ed. Scient. de Pologne.Search in Google Scholar

Liu Dongrui [劉東瑞]. 1990. Tan Zhanguo shiqi de budeng bicheng “wang” tongheng” [談戰國時期的不等臂稱《王》銅衡] (On the bronze balance with different length of arms with the inscription “wang” [king] from the Warring States period) (1979). In Henan jiliangju [河南計量局] (Henan Measuring Bureau) (ed.), Zhongguo gudai duliangheng lunwenji (Collected essays on length, capacity and weight measures in ancient China), 298–303. Zhengzhou: Zhongzhou guji chubanshe.Search in Google Scholar

Manders, Erika. 2012. Coining images of power: Patterns in the representation of Roman Emperors on imperial coinage, A.D. 193–284. Leiden-Boston: Brill.10.1163/9789004224001Search in Google Scholar

Markow, Deborah. 1983–1984. The soul of the sinner. The soul of the saint: Some aspects of the iconography of particular judgment. Perceptions 3. 17–25.Search in Google Scholar

Markow, Deborah. 1984. The iconography of the soul in medieval art (1983) [dissertation]. Ann Arbor, MI: University Microfilms.Search in Google Scholar

Metcalf, William E. 1977. Review of Lichocka, Barbara. 1974. Iustitia sur les monnaies impériales romaines. Warsaw: Ed. Scient. de Pologne. Gnomon 49(4). 427–429.Search in Google Scholar

Morrison, James V. 1997. Kerostasia, the dictates of fate, and the will of Zeus in the Iliad. Arethusa 30(2). 276–296.10.1353/are.1997.0008Search in Google Scholar

Musurillo, Herbert. 1957. Sunken imagery in Sophocles’ Oedipus. Source 78(1): 36–51.10.2307/291989Search in Google Scholar

Noreña, Carlos F. 2001. The communication of the emperor’s virtues. Journal of Roman Studies 91. 146–168.10.2307/3184774Search in Google Scholar

Perry, Mary Phillips. 1912. On the psychostasis in Christian art-I. Burlington Magazine for Connoisseurs 22(116). 94–97, 100–105.Search in Google Scholar

Perry, Mary Phillips. 1913. On the psychostasis in Christian art-II. Burlington Magazine for Connoisseurs 22(118). 208–211, 214–218.Search in Google Scholar

Qiu Guangming [丘光明]. 1990. Wo guo gudai quanhengqi jianlun [我國古代權衡器簡論] (A brief account of weights and weighing instruments in the ancient period of our country). In Henan Measuring Bureau (ed.), Zhongguo gudai duliangheng lunwenji [Collected essays on length, capacity and weight measures in ancient China], 404–415. Zhengzhou: Zhongzhou guji chubanshe.Search in Google Scholar

Qiu Guangming [丘光明]. 1997. Zhongguo zui gulao de zhongliang danwei “lüe” [中國最古老的重量單位《寽》] (China’s oldest weight measuring unit “lüe”). Kaogu yu wenwu [考古與文物](Archeology and cultural relics) 4. 46–49.Search in Google Scholar

Qiu Guangming [丘光明], Qiu Long [邱隆], & Yang Ping [楊平]. 2001. Zhongguo kexue jishushi, Duliangheng juan [中國科學技術史, 度量衡卷] (The history of science and technology in China, metrology volume). Beijing: Kexue chubanshe.Search in Google Scholar

Resnik, Judith & Dennis E. Curtis. 2007. Representing justice: From Renaissance iconography to twenty-first-century. Faculty Scholarship Series. Paper 693. http://digitalcommons.law.yale.edu/fss_papers/693Search in Google Scholar

Rickett, W. Allyn. 1993. Kuan tzu [管子]. In Michael Loewe (ed.), Early Chinese texts: A bibliographical guide, 244–251. Berkeley: University of California, Institute of East Asian Studies.Search in Google Scholar

Robens, Erich, Shanath Amarasiri A. Jayaweera & Susanne Kiefer (eds.). 2014a. Balances: Instruments, manufacturers, history. Berlin & Heidelberg: Springer.10.1007/978-3-642-36447-1Search in Google Scholar

Robens, Erich, Shanath Amarasiri A. Jayaweera & Susanne Kiefer. 2014b. Balance as symbol and object of art. In Erich Robens, Shanath Amarasiri A. Jayaweera & Susanne Kiefer (eds.), Balances: Instruments, manufacturers, history, 419–518. Berlin & Heidelberg: Springer.10.1007/978-3-642-36447-1_6Search in Google Scholar

Rozokoki, Alexandra. 2009. Some new thoughts on Stesichorus’ Geryoneis. Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik 168. 3–18.Search in Google Scholar

Schuck, Karl Ludwig. 1936. Eine Untersuchung über die Entwicklung des Wägungsgedankens von der Antike bis ins Christliche Mittelalter. Die Antike 12(1). 49–64.Search in Google Scholar

Seeber, Christine. 1976. Untersuchungen zur Darstellung des Totengerichts im Alten Ägypten [Münchner ägyptologische Studien 35]. Munich: Deutscher Kunstverlag.Search in Google Scholar

Shapiro, H. Alan. 1990. The eye of the beholder: Würzburg 309 again. Antike Kunst 33(2). 83–92.Search in Google Scholar

Shaughnessy, Edward L. 1993. Shang shu [尚書]. In Michael Loewe (ed.), Early Chinese texts: A bibliographical guide, 376–389. Berkeley: Society for the Study of Early China; Institute for East Asian Studies, University of California Berkeley.Search in Google Scholar

Shun, Kwong-loi. 1997. Mencius and early Chinese thought. Stanford: Stanford University Press.10.1515/9781503616264Search in Google Scholar

Simon, Erika. 1959. Die Geburt der Aphrodite. Berlin: De Gruyter.10.1515/9783110827347Search in Google Scholar

Slatkin, Laura M. 1986. The wrath of Thetis. Transactions of the American Philological Association 116. 1–24.10.2307/283907Search in Google Scholar

Strack, Paul L. 1931–1937. Untersuchungen zur römischen Reichsprägung des zweiten Jahrhunderts. Stuttgart: W. Kohlhammer.Search in Google Scholar

Taplin, Oliver. 1992. Homeric soundings: The shaping of the Iliad. Oxford: Clarendon Press; New York: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Theobald, Ulrich & Hans Ulrich Vogel. 2004. Chinese, Japanese, and western research in Chinese historical metrology. Tübingen: Institute for Sinology and Korean Studies.Search in Google Scholar

Vankeerberghen, Griet. 2001. The Huainanzi and Liu An’s claim to moral authority. Albany: SUNY.Search in Google Scholar

Vankeerberghen, Griet. 2005–2006. Choosing balance: Weighing (“Quan”) as a metaphor for action in early Chinese texts. Early China 30. 47–89.10.1017/S0362502800002182Search in Google Scholar

Vermeule, Emily. 1979. Aspects of death in early Greek art and poetry. Berkeley: University of California Press.10.1525/9780520310827Search in Google Scholar

Vogel, Hans Ulrich. 1994. Metrology and metrosophy in premodern China. In Jean-Claude Hocquet (ed.), Une activité universelle: Peser et mesurer à travers les ages (Acta Metrologiae IV: VIe Congrès International de la Métrologie Historique, Cahiers de Métrologie, 11–12), 315–332. Caen: Editions du Lys.Search in Google Scholar

Vogel, Hans Ulrich. 1997. Weights and measures in China. In Helaine Selin (ed.), Encyclopedia of the history of science, technology, and medicine in non-Western cultures, 1010–1012. Dordrecht: Kluwer.Search in Google Scholar

Wallace-Hadrill, Andrew. 1981. The emperor and his virtues. Historia 30. 298–323.Search in Google Scholar

Wang Da [王達]. 1959. “Shiping “Zhongguo dulianghengshi” zhong Zhou Qin Han duliangheng muzhi zhi kaozheng” [試評《中國度量衡史》中周秦漢度量衡畝制之考證] (Textual criticism of the system of length, capacity, weight and area measures of the Zhou, Qin and Han [as depicted] in the “History of Chinese length, capacity and weight measures” [written by Wu [Cheng]luo]). Nongshi yanjiu jikan [農史研究集刊](Collection of Research on Agricultural History) 1.Search in Google Scholar

Willcock, Malcolm M. 1976. A companion to the Iliad: Based on the translation by Richmond Lattimore. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.10.7208/chicago/9780226125848.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

WüSt, Ernst. 1936. Die seelenwägung in Ägypten und Griechenland. Archiv für Religionswissenschaft 36. 162–171.Search in Google Scholar

Zhengzhong, Guo. 1994. The Deng steelyards of the Song dynasty (960–1279): In commemoration of the one thousandth anniversary of their manufacture by Liu Chenggui. In Jean-Claude Hocquet (ed.), Une activité universelle: Peser et mesurer à travers les ages (Acta Metrologiae IV: VIe Congrès International de la Métrologie Historique, Cahiers de Métrologie, 11–12), 297–306. Caen: Editions du Lys.Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2017-4-19
Published in Print: 2017-5-24

© 2017 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston

Articles in the same Issue

  1. Frontmatter
  2. La sémiotique juridique verbale et nonverbale comme stratégie de communication du droit: Signs, symbols, and meanings in law
  3. “Verbal and nonverbal” in semiotics
  4. The frowning balance: Semiotic insinuations on the visual rhetoric of justice
  5. Semiotics of visual evidence in law
  6. Observing laws through “understanding eyes”
  7. Interpreting law in socio-pragmatic space
  8. Conceptualizing cultural discrepancies in legal translation: A case-based study
  9. The first integrated practice of legal translation in modern China: A study of the Chinese translation of Elements of International Law, 1864
  10. Translations of early Sino-British treaties and the masked western legal concepts
  11. “Susanna and the Elders”: On the visual semiotic of shame
  12. Angels, warriors, and beacons: Totemic law, territorial coding, and monumental sculpture in post-industrial landscapes
  13. Expiration dates: Performative illusions of law and regulation
  14. From immunity to immunity. From immunity to silence: The case of Gilad Sharon
  15. Under western eyes: Articulation between indigenous justice and the national judicial system
  16. Police interpreting: The facts sheet
  17. The influence of legal tradition on Italian arbitration discourse
  18. Weighing and balancing of principles in cases with rule paradoxes
  19. “You have to teach the judge what to do”: Semiotic gaps between unrepresented litigants and the common law
  20. The semiotic interpretation of legal subjects in China’s new criminal procedure law
  21. Mission impossible? Judges’ playing of dual roles as adjudicator and mediator in Chinese court conciliation
  22. “Is it the case that … ?”: Building toward findings of fact in Japanese criminal trials
  23. Institutional interaction in traffic law enforcement in China: Resistance and obedience
  24. Duppying yoots in a dog eat dog world, kmt: Determining the senses of slang terms for the Courts
  25. Les structures sémantiques profondes du code pénal chinois
Downloaded on 14.9.2025 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/sem-2015-0071/html
Scroll to top button