Home Life Sciences Effects of Some Additives on In Vitro True Digestibility of Wheat and Soybean Straw Pellets
Article Open Access

Effects of Some Additives on In Vitro True Digestibility of Wheat and Soybean Straw Pellets

  • Unal Kılıc EMAIL logo and Emre Gulecyuz
Published/Copyright: July 24, 2017

Abstract

This study was aimed to explore the nutrient content, relative feed values (RFV) and in vitro true digestibilities (IVTD) of wheat straw and soybean straw pellets produced with the addition of molasses, guar meal and sepiolite. In this experiment, 16 groups were created for 2 different straws (wheat/soybean straws), 2 different sepiolite applications (available/not available) and 4 different applications (control, guar meal, molasses, guar meal+molasses) in accordance with the 2×2×4 factorial design. A Daisy incubator was used to determine the IVTD of the feeds. According to the results, molasses and guar meal increased the RFV of soybean straws, while molasses and guar meal treatments and sepiolite did not affect the RFV of wheat straws. It was observed that sepiolite increased the RFV’s of soybean straw for guar meal and guar meal+molasses. The higher IVTD’s were found for guar meal (without sepiolite) treatment of soybean straw and guar meal (with sepiolite) treatment of wheat straw. Molasses and guar meal addition to wheat and soybean straws improved the crude protein contents. In conclusion, straw pelleting can be used as an alternative forage conservation method to close the gap in forage supply during the winter.

1 Introduction

Forages are feed sources with significant functions with regards to rumen physiology. Straws have an important potential for forage as they are abundant and relatively cheap. Straws are classified as poor quality forages due to their low protein, but high fiber, content. Therefore, practices focusing on improving the nutritive value of straws are of utmost importance in closing the gap in quality forage supply [1]. Thus, economic benefits will be possible for ruminant farming using quality forages instead of expensive compact feed sources. Physical (grinding, pelleting, steam processing, etc.), chemical (urea, ammonia, etc. treatment), and biological (bacteria, fungi, enzymes etc.) methods are used to increase the nutritive value of straws. Straws are commonly subjected to practices aimed at increasing their nutritive values by the addition of urea and molasses [2, 3]. Nevertheless, it is known that some clay minerals such as sepiolite have positive impact on the digestibility of the feed [4].

The use of silage and hay is often insufficient in meeting the feed requirements of ruminants during the winter. Recently, some forages such as alfalfa have been pelleted to be used in livestock farming. It was observed that forage pelleting reduced the scattering of the feed by animals, ensures homogeneity of the forage, and increased the feed conversion rate by 4-6% [5, 6]. Moreover, pelleting is also important in closing the gap in the need for quality forage in the winter as it offers an alternative forage storage method for livestock farmers. In addition, the advantages of pelleting poor quality forages over quality forages has been reported [7].

It was reported that a 15% molasses addition to straws increased the feed consumption of cattle, live weight gain (LWG) and milk production [8], while a 9% molasses addition increased the amount of milk fat [9]. In addition to increasing the nutritive value of the forage, molasses also increased the pellet quality [10]. Containing high amounts of galactomannan gum, guar meal are rich in lysine and methionine and offer 50-55% crude protein content. In this context, guar meal is effective in increasing the protein content of straws with poor protein content. Furthermore, it also increased the pellet quality due to its pellet binding quality [11]. According to Diaz et al. [12], the most important effect of sepiolite in ruminant rations is that it provides the ammonia to the rumen medium necessary for microbial protein synthesis.It may also protect the animal against the accumulation of ammonia at toxic levels, with microbes having adsorbed the excess ammonia which may be produced in the rumen. With this respect, it is believed that sepiolite use is advantageous both for forage quality and animal health.

The current annual wheat production in the world adds up to 729.0 million tons while annual soybean production adds up to 307.0 million tons [13]; produced 1 to 1.5 times more than the total grain production [14], straws have a great potential for forage. This study was designed to determine if the nutritive value of wheat straw and soybean straw could be increased by applying a pelleting process and with the addition of molasses, guar meal and sepiolite. We also aimed toexplore the in vitro true digestibility of the final products. The study was designed in line with the hypothesis that the additives explored in this study, in connection with wheat straw and soybean straw pellets, will have a positive effect on the nutritive value of forages and their digestibilities.

2 Materials and Methods

In this study, wheat straws and soybean straws used as feed material were obtained from 3 different locations. Sugarbeet-molasses (crude protein:7.5%), urea (nitrogen:46.0%), guar (Cyamopsis tetragonoloba) meal (crude protein:43.4%) and sepiolite were used as additives in order to increase the nutritive value of straws.

2.1 Establishment of treatment groups

Eight groups for each straw type (wheat and soybean) were created: 2 sepiolite applications (available – not available) and 4 treatments (control, guar meal, molasses and guar meal+molasses). The ratios used in this study were as follows: sepiolite 2% [15]; molasses 7% [16]; guar meal 10% [17]; guar meal + molasses 17%. Additives and straws were blended homogeneously and then each group was pelleted in 6 mm diameter pellets with 3 iterations.

2.2 Chemical analyses

The straws were milled in a hammer mill through a 1 mm sieve to determine the chemical compositions and for the In Vitro True Digestibilies assays. The samples were analyzed according to AOAC [18] procedure for ash, dry matter (DM) and nitrogen (N) contents. Crude protein was calculated by multiplying N by 6.25. The acid detergent fiber (ADF), neutral detergent fiber (NDF), crude fiber (CF) and acid detergent lignin (ADL) analysis were performed according to the method of Van Soest et al. [19] using an AnkomA2000 fiber analyser. The ether extract (EE) content was determined with the Ankom XT15 analyzer according to AOCS [20]. The contents of nitrogen free extract were determined by calculation. All chemical analyses of straws were carried out in triplicate.

2.3 Determination of in vitro true digestibilities

The rumen content used for the in vitro study consisted of 2 handfuls rumen content collected from 3 Simmental bulls (Average 18 months of age and 450-550 kg live weight) that were slaughtered at a local slaughterhouse. The bulls were fed twice daily with a diet containing good quality grass hay and maize silage (60%) and concentrates (40%). The contents were brought to the laboratory within 15-20 minutes in thermos (39.0°C). The rumen content was then mixed, taken under CO2 atmosphere and filtered through two layers of cheesecloth. A Daisy incubator makes the in vitro NDF disappearance study simple and efficient because it uses equipment designed with four rotating digestion jars and maintains constant, uniform heat and agitation within a controlled (39.0°C) chamber [19, 21]. The Daisy incubator instrument contains 4 cylinder incubators, with 1 cylinder requiring 1600 ml buffer solution and 400 ml rumen fluid as inoculums and filter bags (25 pieces). Approximately 500 mg dry weight of straws were placed into the filter bags (nitrogen free). Then, each filter bag was placed inside each of the other cylinders with solution. The cylinder was aerated for 30 seconds with CO2 immediately before being tighltly closed placed into incubator for 48h. After incubation, filter bags were cleaned with water and dried (105 °C, 3 hours). The bags were analyzed for NDF digestibility with a fibre analyzer. The In vitro experiment was carried out in five repetitions. In vitro true digestibilities of straws was estimated as follows:

IVTD,%=100((W3(W1xC1))100)/W2

where : W1: Weight of filter bag, W2: Weight of sample, W3: Final weight after NDF analysis, C1: The bag without sample was prepared also for correction.

2.4 Determination of rumen fluid pH, volatile fatty acids (VFA) and ammonia-N (NH3-N) contents

The pH value of rumen fluid was determined by using Hanna 1332 digital pH meter with 3 replications. The volatile fatty acids analysis of rumen fluid was performed by using gas chromatography (Agilent Technologies 6890N GC. Cat. 11023, Maximum temperature: 260°C, Stabilwax-DA, 30 m, 0.25 mm ID, 0.25 um df.) according to Wiedmeier et al. [22]. Rumen fluid NH3-N analysis was determined by using the Kjeldahl methods according to Blümmel et al. [23] in 3 replicates.

2.5 Determination of releative feed values

Relative feed values of straws were calculated as following [24];

Dry matter digestibility (DMD, %)= 88.9-(ADF% x 0.779)

Dry matter intake (DMI, live weight, %)= 120/(NDF%)

Relative feed value (RFV,%)= (DMD × DMI)/1.29

According to the Quality Grading Standard assigned by The Hay Marketing Task Force of the American Forage and Grassland Council, the RFV were assessed as roughages based on prime >151, 1 (premium) 151-125, 2 (good) 124-103, 3 (fair) 102-87, 4 (poor) 86-75, 5(reject) < 75.

2.6 Statistical Analysis

The data obtained from the experiments were analyzed using the SPSS 20.0 software package. The data regarding nutrient content, in vitro true digestibility were subjected to GLM procedure in accordance with the completely randomized factorial design controlling for normality and variance homogeneity.

3 Results

Nutritional contents of each treatment are shown in Table 1. Sepiolite addition increased the ash content in all groups except WC, SC and SG (P<0.001). As soybean straws are legume forage, they proved to have a higher CP content (P<0.001). It was found that any additive used in combination with wheat straw increased the CP content while it was observed that the CP content was increased in SG and SGM groups (P<0.001). It was found that sepiolite decreased the CP content in WM, WGM, SC and SGM groups (P<0.001). Higher CF and lower NFE was found in soybean straws when compared to wheat straws (P<0.001).

Table 1

Chemical composition of straw treatments, % DM

Treatments*DM*AshCPEECFNFENDFADFADL
WC90.46± 0.06e8.37±0.31efg4.63± 0.00e0.62± 0.1042.58± 0.76e43.81± 0.93a76.68± 0.43b46.89± 0.42d5.27± 0.20e
WC+S91.44± 0.01c8.17±0.34fg3.87±0.07e0.73± 0.3842.55± 1.01e44.67± 1.49a79.27± 0.80a47.55± 0.51d5.99± 0.66e
WM88.90± 0.05g9.21± 0.25def6.93± 0.05d1.40± 0.3545.51± 1.01bcde36.94± 1.18bcde76.55± 0.53b47.42±0.27d6.98± 0.31e
WM+S87.84± 0.07i10.89± 0.32c5.08± 1.84e1.01± 0.3743.47± 3.26de39.56± 1.28abc75.29± 0.66bc46.06± 0.45d6.23± 0.61e
WG91.84± 0.03b7.54± 0.16g6.82± 0.12d0.86± 0.2442.82± 1.86e41.97± 1.88ab75.66± 0.49bc45.75±0.75d5.34± 0.44e
WG+S92.35± 0.01a9.37± 0.30de7.17± 0.10d0.35± 0.1541.21± 2.23e41.88± 1.90ab74.89± 0.45bc45.51± 0.15d5.37± 0.45e
WGM88.50± 0.10h8.53±0.31efg11.8± 0.22ab0.88± 0.2941.02± 1.91e37.77± 2.06bcd73.94± 0.28cd45.69± 0.22d5.83± 0.07e
WGM+S87.65± 0.19i9.81±0.49d9.96± 0.15c0.70± 0.1343.41± 2.83de36.12± 2.93cdef73.89± 0.71cd45.36± 0.32d5.49± 0.37e
SC88.76± 0.12g8.53±0.33efg8.41± 0.18d0.65± 0.0649.47± 1.57abc32.95± 1.64defg75.02± 0.53bc58.84± 0.97a16.08± 0.53a
SC+S90.91± 0.05d8.37±0.50efg4.59± 0.02e0.85± 0.1652.22± 1.36a33.97± 0.80defg72.50± 0.04d57.37±0.47a12.71± 0.19cd
SM84.68± 0.12l11.86±0.25b8.20± 0.04d0.60± 0.5150.41± 1.44ab28.93± 0.68ghi70.14± 1.12ef53.91± 1.38bc15.87± 0.12a
SM+S85.84± 0.09k14.74± 0.32a8.04± 0.23d0.54± 0.1245.07± 1.55bcde31.60± 1.48efg66.25± 0.38g53.55± 2.34bc13.90± 1.34bc
SG90.20± 0.12f14.79± 0.20a11.18±0.49abc0.78± 0.3539.42± 0.86e33.83± 1.16defg58.54± 0.66i45.30± 1.01d12.12±0.37d
SG+S90.13± 0.03f14.36± 0.25a10.51± 0.09bc0.27± 0.0443.96± 1.71cde30.90± 1.91fgh62.52± 1.54h46.93±0.96d11.40± 0.16d
SGM84.01± 0.09m7.59± 0.45g12.72±0.76a0.82± 0.4452.68± 1.33a26.18± 1.94hi71.86± 0.96de56.27± 0.55ab14.69± 0.54ab
SGM+S86.87± 0.06j14.59± 0.20a10.84± 0.04bc0.71± 0.3249.11± 2.33abcd24.76± 2.45i68.06± 0.83fg51.53± 1.25c13.93± 0.88bc
Significance<0.001<0.001<0.0010.650<0.001<0.001<0.001<0.001<0.001
EffectsDM*AshCPEECFNFENDFADFADL
Straw0.0000.0000.0000.2570.0000.0000.0000.0000.000
Sepiolite0.0000.0000.0000.2170.6920.8730.0610.1050.003
Additive0.0000.0000.0000.4630.0010.0000.0000.0000.000
Straw*Sepiolite0.0000.0010.2590.6860.9650.7280.0290.3320.006
Straw*Additive0.0000.0000.0040.3210.0030.5010.0000.0000.016
Sepiolite*Additive0.0000.0000.0350.4470.1760.2570.0010.1230.450
Straw*Sepiolite*Additive0.0000.0000.0250.9760.0940.9010.0010.0850.093

DM: Dry matter, CP: Crude protein, EE: Ether extract, CF: Crude fibre, NFE: Nitrogen free extracts, NDF: Neutral detergent fibre, ADF: Acid detergent fibre, ADL: Acid detergent lignin. a, b, c….: Means with different supercripts in the same column are significantly different. WC: Wheat control, WM: Wheat molasses, WG:Wheat guar meal, WGM: Wheat guar meal+molasses, SC: Soybean control, SM: Soybean molasses, SG: Soybean guar meal, SGM: Soybean guar meal+molasses, +S: with sepiolite

NDF content of straws was found to be lower in the WGM group compared to the WC group (P<0.001). It was found that the NDF content was decreased in SM, SG and SGM treatments when compared to SC treatment (P<0.001). Sepiolite addition decreased the NDF content in SM and SGM treatments (P<0.001). Additives and sepiolite did no affect the ADF content of wheat straws (P>0.05). However, sepiolite addition decreased the ADF content of the soybean straws (P<0.001). ADL content of soybean straw was found to be higher than the one of wheat straw (P<0.001). It was found that guar meal addition to soybean straw decreased the ADL content, while sepiolite addition decreased the ADL content only in WC and WM groups (P<0.001). However, additives and sepiolite addition had no effect on the ADL content of wheat straws.

The contents of the rumen fluid were found to have a pH of 6.15 (6.08-6.51), total volatile fatty acid=TVFA: 92.82±0.67 mmol/L, acetic acid: 49.81±0.12 mmol/L, propionic acid: 23.37±0.44 mmol/L, butyric acid: 15.83±0.72 mmol/L, isobutyric acid: 1.89±0.32 mmol/L, isovaleric acid: 0.98±0.05 mmol/L and valeric acid: 0.94±0.08 mmol/L and NH3-N contents: 29.65± 2.04 mg/100 ml (296,5 mg/L).

Table 2 shows the effects of additive supplementation to wheat and soybean straws on forage quality and IVTD.Additives had no effect on wheat straw with respect to dry matter digestibility (DMD) (P>0.05), while wheat straws showed digestibility results similar to those of soybean straws with guar meal addition. Nevertheless, sepiolite addition increased the DMD in SGM group (P<0.001).

Table 2

Forage qualities and IVTD values for straw treatments and interactions

TreatmentsDMD, %DMI, % LWRFVQuality ClassIVTD, %
WC52.37±0.33a1.56±0.01hi63.54±0.49cd5-Reject54.50 ± 1.71bcdef
WC+S51.86±0.40a1.51±0.01i60.88±1.07def5-Reject51.84 ± 1.51efgh
WM51.96±0.21a1.57±0.01hi63.15±0.24cde5-Reject53.93 ± l.l7cdefg
WM+S53.02±0.35a1.59±0.01h65.52±0.38cd5-Reject52.30 ± 0.59defgh
WG53.26±0.58a1.59±0.01h65.50±1.13cd5-Reject53.90 ± 0.48cdefg
WG+S53.45±0.12a1.60±0.01gh66.39±0.26c5-Reject58.64 ± 0.86b
WGM53.30±0.17a1.62±0.01fgh67.06±0.20c5-Reject56.76 ± 2.54bcd
WGM+S53.56±0.25a1.62±0.02fgh67.45±0.95c5-Reject54.19 ± 1.47bcdef
SC43.06±0.76d1.60±0.01gh53.41±1.19g5-Reject50.51 ± 0.94fgh
SC+S44.21±0.37d1.66±0.00efg56.73±0.49fg5-Reject49.44 ± 1.36gh
SM46.91±1.08bc1.71±0.03de62.28±2.39cde5-Reject51.71 ± 0.64efgh
SM+S47.18±1.82bc1.81±0.01c66.28±2.83c5-Reject56.24 ± 1.84bcde
SG53.61±0.79a2.05±0.02a85.23±2.15a4-Poor64.50 ± 1.11a
SG+S52.34±0.75a1.92±0.05b78.03±3.01b4-Poor58.11 ± 1.66bc
SGM45.06±0.43cd1.67±0.02ef58.38±1.35ef5-Reject48.32 ± 0.79h
SGM+S48.76±0.97b1.76±0.02cd66.69±2.08c5-Reject57.84 ± 1.70bc
Significance<0.001<0.001<0.001<0.001
EffectsDMD, %DMI, % LWRFVIVTD, %
Straw0.0000.0000.2360.912
Sepiolite0.1030.1450.1420.423
Additive0.0000.0000.0000.000
Straw*Sepiolite0.3310.1040.2430.121
Straw*Additive0.0000.0000.0000.000
Sepiolite*Additive0.1220.0000.0090.040
Straw*Sepiolite*Additive0.0840.0000.0050.000

DMD: Dry matter digestibility, DMI: Dry matter intake, RFV: Relative feed value, IVTD: In Vitro True digestibility, WC: Wheat control, WM: Wheat molasses, WG:Wheat guar meal, WGM: Wheat guar meal+molasses, SC: Soybean control, SM: Soybean molasses, SG: Soybean guar meal, SGM: Soybean guar meal+molasses, +S: with sepiolite. a, b, c..: Means with different supercripts in the same column are significantly different.

The WC+S group showed the lowest value among other wheat straws with respect to dry matter intake (DMI), while DMI showed an increasing trend in groups with guar meal addition. In soybean straws, the highest value was obtained from SG groups (P<0.001). Soybean straws gave higher DMI values when compared to wheat straws. Sepiolite addition to the SG group of soybean straws decreased the DMI while increasing the DMI in SM and SGM groups (P<0.001). In control groups, however, the sepiolite effect on DMI was negligible.

Additives and sepiolite addition had no effect on the relative feed value (RFV) of wheat straws (P>0.05). In soybean straws, SG group proved to have the highest RFV value. Nevertheless, sepiolite addition to SG treatment decreased the RFV while increasing the RFV in the SGM group (P<0.001). According to the quality classification performed with respect to the RFV index, it was found that guar meal addition to soybean straw improved the forage quality from “5-Reject” to “4- Poor”.

Digestibility of the forages is of utmost importance when identifying their feed values. There was no effect of the treatments on IVTD in wheat straw, and the lowest IVTD value was obtained from the sepiolite addition to the WC group. The highest IVTD value was obtained in the WG groups; and sepiolite addition (WG+S) increased the IVTD (P<0.001). Similarly, highest IVTD value was obtained from the SG groups while it was found that IVTD was decreased with the sepiolite addition (SG+S) (P<0.001). In the SGM+S groups, on the other hand, sepiolite addition increased the IVTD value (P<0.001).

4 Discussion

Increased ash content of the feed decreases the nutritive values of the feedstuffs. High ash content is an indicator of the availability of contaminants such as soil, sand, clay, etc. in the feed and mineral content of the feed. The ash content (8.53%) found in this study for soybean straw (SC) was in agreement with the results of other studies (range of 7.2-13.7%) [3, 25, 26]. The ash content (8.37%) observed in this study for wheat straw (WC) was also in agreement the results of other studies ( range 5.2-10.1%) [3, 27, 28].

It is known that guar meal offered high amounts of CP (43.4%) which in return increased the CP content of straws. Sepiolite treaments caused a decrease in the CP content of the straws. Thus, CP content decreased in ratio. Various studies have reported typical CP contents for soybean straw in the range of 3.64% -9.2%. [3, 25, 29, 30], while the CP content of wheat straws has had a reported range of 2.9-4.8% [28- 33]. The CP contents observed in this study were consistent with the ranges reported in the literature [3, 28-31]. Factors such as plant variety, soil structure, fertilization, harvest time, stalk and weed seed ratios of the straws, etc., have all been noted as possible variables that affect these values [34].

The crude fibre content of soybean straw has been previously reported between 38.1% - 53.1% [3, 25, 35]. The CF content of wheat straw was found to be 42.58% in this study, at the upper end for previously reported values (38.1- 42.5%) [3, 33; 35, 36].

As feed, higher NDF contents will be consumed in lower amounts by ruminants [37], and the consumption of wheat straw will be lower than the consumption of soybean straws. The NDF content of soybean straw was reported by Mohamoud Abdi [3], Maheri-Sis et al. [26] and Mule et al. [25] as 71.46%, 80.8% and 52.0%, respectively. The value (75.0%) obtained in this study for soybean straw (SC) was similar to these reports. The NDF content (76.68%) of wheat straws reported in this study was in the range (54.4% - 85.1%) reported by a number of authors [3, 27, 28, 31, 37]. However, molasses addition to WS was expected to increase the feed consumption as it decreased the NDF content.

A low ADF content is an indicator of digestibility in feed; wheat straws were found to have a higher digestibility when compared to soybean straws. On the other hand, an increase in the digestibility was observed in the SM and SG groups of soybean straw when compared to the SC treatment. Therefore, molasses and guar meal addition is recommended for soybean straws. An ADF content range of 53.4% - 63.2% for soybean straw (SC) [3, 26, 29] has been reported, in agreement with the amount (58.84%) found in this study. The ADF value reported by some researchers [3, 27, 37] for wheat straw range from 47.5% -57.1%. The ADF content (46.89%) reported in this study for wheat straw was in agreement with the lower limit of these published accounts. We found that molasses and guar meal addition are recommendable for soybean straw as they decreased the ADF content, increasing its digestibility.

In terms of the relative feed value, physical and chemical processes performed on feed (additives, etc.) have an impact on their biological values [37]. The lower the NDF and ADF contents of the feed, the higher the RFV index of the forage. In other words, lower NDF and ADF contents indicate that the feed is classified under a quality forage class. Considering that the feed with high dry matter intake is consumed more by animals, it can be said that molasses addition or guar meal and molasses addition to soybean straws will have an appetizing effect.Guar meal addition to soybean straws increased the RFV, yet, the same effect was not the case for wheat straws. Similarly, In vitro true digestibility was increased in soybean straws, while IVTD was decreased with sepiolite addition with wheat straw. This result may be due to the different lignocellulosic structures wheat and soybean straws have [3].

The relative feed value calculated using the ADF and NDF data previoualy reported for wheat was 53.15 - 75.38 and, for soybean straws, was (45.67 - 84.62) [3, 25; 26; 27, 29, 31] The RFV value for this study was 63.54 for the WC treatment, and in the range of 60.88- 67.45 for all wheat straw treatments. The RFV value was in the range of 53.41-85.23 for soybean straw in this study, again in agreement with the literature reports. In the light of these results, it can be said that additives used in this study had a positive effect on RFV and increased the forage quality. RFV was higher in soybean straws in groups with guar meal addition, as the NDF content of guar meal was lower than soybean straw.

Sahan [33], Yilmaz [38], and Bozkurt et al [39] reported In vitro true digestibility values of 24.79%, 43.53%, 46.8%, respectively, for WS. The values observed in this study were higher than those literature reports. Such a difference may be caused by feed variety used in the experiments, fertilization practices, harvest time, feed processing (pelleting, grinding) and the differences in the application of the in vitro digestibility method [34]. Mohamoud Abdi [3] reported that the addition of molasses to WS and urea+molasses treatments increase IVTD. In this study, it was found that IVTD of WGM treatment was higher than the control group, however, molasses addition by itself did not offer any significant change in IVTD.

IVTD of soybean straw was reported as 40.11% by Mohamoud Abdi [3], and it was found that molasses and urea+molasses addition increased IVTD value. Wan et al. [40] reported that hot water and NaOH treatment increased the cellulose digestibility of soybean straw. In this study, IVTD of SC was found to be 50.51%. Although, molasses addition and urea+molasses treatments did not affected the IVTD of soybean straws, the IVTD was increased significantly by sepiolite addition. This finding shows that sepiolite plays a more effective role on IVTD in groups with molasses addition, as molasses is rich in water soluble carbohydrates. As soybean straw has a higher lignin content compared to wheat straw, soybean straw offered a lower digestibility value in control groups. This may be due to varying harvest times and different lignocellulosic structures of the straws. Nevertheless, it is clear that additives generally improved the digestibility of soybean straw.

5 Conclusions

It was found that additives can be used to improve the feed values of wheat and soybean straws. In this study, sepiolite addition to wheat straw had no effect on RFV, while RFV was higher in the SG and SGM treatments when compared to other groups. It was found that guar meal addition to soybean straw partially improved the forage quality. Moreover, the highest IVTD was obtained when guar meal was added to straws and it was found that sepiolite addition gave higher IVTD results in groups with guar meal addition. IVTD improved in all treatments with molasses and sepiolite addition. In conclusion, when pelleted with additives, soybean and wheat straws can be used in animal feed. The most important advantage of pelleting is the homogeneity of straw and additives. Thus, it is possible to mix sepiolite and guar meal additives in granular form with straw in a homogeneous manner and to then preserve such homogeneity.

  1. Conflict of interest

    Conflict interest: Authors state no conflict of interest.

Acknowledgements

This research was supported by Turkish Scientific and Technological Research Council (TOVAG 1150912).

References

[1] Hassanat F., Gervais R., Julien C., Massé DI., Lettat A., Chouinard P.Y., Petit H.V., Benchaar Replacing C. Alfalfa silage with corn silage in dairy cow diets: Effects on enteric methane production, ruminal fermentation, digestion, N balance, and milk production. Journal of Dairy Science. 2013; 96(7): 4553-67.10.3168/jds.2012-6480Search in Google Scholar

[2] Sarwar M., Khan M.A., Iqbal Z. Feed resources for livestock in Pakistan. Int. J. Agric. Biol. 2002; 4:186–192.Search in Google Scholar

[3] Mohamoud Abdi A. Effect of lignin peroxidase enzyme on feed values of different straws. Ondokuz Mayis University, Sci. Enstitute, Samsun-Turkey (MSc Thesis).pp 65. 2016Search in Google Scholar

[4] Rodríguez-Beltrán J., Rodríguez-Rojas A., Yubero E., Blázquez J. The animal food supplement sepiolite promotes a direct horizontal transfer of antibiotic resistance plasmids between bacterial species. Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy. 2013; 57(6): 2651-2653.10.1128/AAC.02363-12Search in Google Scholar

[5] Torres T.R., Do Ludke M., Ludke J.V., Dos Santos M.J.B., Lima M.R., Dos Santos P.A. Performance of broilers fed during 21 days on mash or pellet diets containing whole or ground pearl millet grain. Revista Brasileira de Ciência Avícola. 2013; 15 (4): 371-378.10.1590/S1516-635X2013000400012Search in Google Scholar

[6] Huawei H., Colleen C., Peigiang Y. Effects of conditioning temperature and time during the pelleting process on feed molecular structure, pellet durability index, and metabolic features of co-products from bio-oil processing in dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science. 2015; 98 (7): 4869-488110.3168/jds.2014-9290Search in Google Scholar

[7] Gulecyuz E., Kilic U. Pelleting forage and usability in ruminant nutrition. 12. National Zootechnia Student Congress. 9-11 May 2016. Pp: 138, 2016, Isparta-Turkey.Search in Google Scholar

[8] Biswas M.A.A., Hoque M.N., Kibria M.G., Rashid M.H., Akther M.M. Field trail and demonstration of urea molasses straw technology of feeding lactating animals. Bangladesh Research Publication Journal. 2010; 3 (4): 1129-1132.Search in Google Scholar

[9] Cohen-Zinder M. “Effect of feeding lactating cows with ensiled mixture of Moringa oleifera, wheat hay and molasses, on digestibility and efficiency of milk production.” Animal Feed Science and Technology. 2016; 211 (6): 75-83.10.1016/j.anifeedsci.2015.11.002Search in Google Scholar

[10] Misljenovic N., Colovic R., Vukmirovic D., Brlek T., Bringas C.S. The effects of sugar beet molasses on wheat straw pelleting and pellet quality. A comparative study of pelleting by using a single pellet press and a pilot-scale pellet press. Fuel Processing Technology. 2016; 144, 220-229.10.1016/j.fuproc.2016.01.001Search in Google Scholar

[11] Amarjeet A., Kumar S., Singh A. Guar a crop fetching high income to farmers Indian Farming. 2014; 64 (1): 3-5Search in Google Scholar

[12] Diaz D.E., Hagler W.M., Blackwelder J.T., Eve J.A., Hopkins B.A., Anderson K. L., Jones F.T., Whitlow L.W. Aflatoxin binders II: reduction of aflatoxin M1 in milk by sequestering agents of cows consuming aflatoxin in feed. Mycopathol. 2004; 157(2): 233-24110.1023/B:MYCO.0000020587.93872.59Search in Google Scholar

[13] FAO. Crops Production. Aavailable from http://www.fao.org/faostat/en/#data/QC Accessed date: 16.03.2017, 2014.Search in Google Scholar

[14] Erdogdu I., Altinok S., Genc A. The effect of different seeding rates of intercropped corn and soybean on some plant characteristics and forage yield Journal of Biology Sciences Research. 2013; 6(1) 06-10.Search in Google Scholar

[15] Alvarez A., Perez Castell R. Sepiolite in the field of animal nutrition. Proc. 5th Int. Cong. Industrial Minerals. 1982; Madrid, 37-45.Search in Google Scholar

[16] Sarwar M., Shahzad M.A., Nisa M.U., Afzal D., Sharif M., Saddiqi H.A. Feeding value of urea molasses-treated wheat straw ensiled with fresh cattle manure for growing crossbred cattle calves. Tropical animal health and production. 2011; 43(3): 543-548.10.1007/s11250-010-9745-5Search in Google Scholar

[17] Tran G. Guar (Cyamopsis tetragonolaba) forage seed and meal feedipedia a programme by INRA, CIRAT, AFZ and FAO. Available from http://feedipedia.org/node/311 (Accessed date: 11.05.2015), 2015.Search in Google Scholar

[18] AOAC. Officinal Methods of Analysis. 16th Edition, AOAC International, Gaithersburg, MD. 1998Search in Google Scholar

[19] Van Soest P.V., Robertson J. B., Lewis B.A., Methods for dietary fiber, neutral detergent fiber, and nonstarch polysaccharides in relation to animal nutrition. Journal of Dairy Science. 1991; 74(10): 3583-3597.10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(91)78551-2Search in Google Scholar

[20] AOCS. Official procedure, approved procedure Am 5-04, Rapid determination of oil/fat utilizing high temperature solvent extraction. J Am Oil Chem Soc. 2005; Urbana, ILSearch in Google Scholar

[21] Ankom Technology. In vitro true digestibility using th Daisy || Incubator. Available from http://www.ankom.com/media/documents/IVDMD_0805D200.pdf. Accessed date: 13.09.2010, 2005.Search in Google Scholar

[22] Wiedmeier R.D., Arambel M.J., Walters J.L. Effect of yeast culture and Aspergillus oryzae fermentation extract on ruminal characteristics and nutrient digestibility. J. Dairy Sci. 1987; 70: 2063- 2068.10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(87)80254-0Search in Google Scholar

[23] Blümmel M., Makkar H.P.S., Becker K. In Vitro Gas Production-A Technique Revisied. Journal of Animal Physiology and Animal Nutrition. 1997; 77:24–34.10.1111/j.1439-0396.1997.tb00734.xSearch in Google Scholar

[24] Rohweder D.A., Barnes R.E., Jorgensen N. Proposed hay grading standartsbased on laboratory analysis for evaluating quality. J. Anim. Sci. 1978; 47: 747-759.10.2527/jas1978.473747xSearch in Google Scholar

[25] Mule R.S., Barbind R.P., Baswade S.V., Samale D.T. Adangale, S. B. Nutritive Value of Soybean Straw in Osmanabadi Kids. Veterinary World. 2008; 1(10): 314-316.Search in Google Scholar

[26] Maheri-Sis N., Ziveh A.B. Salamatdoustnobar R., Ahmadzadeh A., Aghajanzadeh-Golshani A., Mohebbizadeh M. Determining nutritive value of soybean straw for ruminants using nylon bags technique. Pak. J. Nutr. 2011; 10: 838-841.10.3923/pjn.2011.838.841Search in Google Scholar

[27] Hassan Z., Nisa M., Shahzad M.A., Sarwar M. Replacing concentrate with wheat straw treated with urea molasses and ensiled with manure: effects on ruminal characteristics, in situ digestion kinetics and nitrogen metabolism of Nili-Ravi buffalo bulls. Asian-Australasian Journal of Animal Sciences. 2011; 24(8): 1092-1099.10.5713/ajas.2011.10337Search in Google Scholar

[28] Akcil E., Denek N. Investigation of Different Levels Eucalyptus (Eucalyptus camaldulensis) Leaves Effect on In Vitro Methane Production of Some Roughages. Harran Univ, Journal of Veterinary Faculty. 2013; 2(2):75-81.Search in Google Scholar

[29] Rossi J. Feeding Straw to Beef Cattle.” University of Georgia. College of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences & Family and Consumer Science. 2007; P. 01-02.Search in Google Scholar

[30] Redden R.R. Straw is a good alternative in rations for cows and sheep if properly supplemented with higher quality feedstuffs.” Available from https://www.ag.ndsu.edu/drought/forages-and-grazing/feeding-straw. (Accessed date: 12.06.2016), 2012.Search in Google Scholar

[31] Can A., Denek N., Yazgan K. Effect of urea and molasses supplementation on nutrient intake and digestibility of sheep fed with straw. Journal of Animal Veterinary Advances. 2004; 3 (7): 466-469.Search in Google Scholar

[32] Dhali A., Mehla R.K., Sirohi S.K., Effect of urea supplemented and urea treated straw based diet on milk urea concentration in crossbred Karan-Fries cows. Italian Journal of Animal Science. 2005; 4: 25-34.10.4081/ijas.2005.25Search in Google Scholar

[33] Sahan Z. The effect of some essential oils on in vitro true digestibility of energy, protein, cellulose source of feeds and milk yield and milk composition in high yeilding dairy cows. Cukurova University, Sci. Enstitute, Adana-Turkey (PhD Thesis). 2012Search in Google Scholar

[34] Kilic U., Saricicek B.Z. Factors affecting the results of gas production technique. Journal of Animal Production. 2006; 47 (2):54-61.Search in Google Scholar

[35] Waller J.C. Feedstuffs reference issue and buyers guide, Turkish Feed Manufacturers Association (Nutrient contents of feedstuffs). 2005; volume 76. Number 38.Search in Google Scholar

[36] Sehu A., Yalcin S., Onol A.G., Kocak D. Prediction of Dry Matter Intake and Live Weight Gain in Lambs by Some Characteristics of Roughages. Tr. J. of Veterinary and Animal Sicences. 1998; 22: 475–483.Search in Google Scholar

[37] Yavuz M. Relative feed values of some ruminant feeds and determining of in vitro digestibilities values. GOP Agricultural Faculty Journal. 2005; 22 (1): 97-101Search in Google Scholar

[38] Yilmaz Y. The Effects of Essential Oil of Oregano Oil (Origanum Vulgare) and Black Seed Oil (Nigella Sativa), on True Digestibility of Dry Matter, Organic Matter and NDF in Barley, Soybean Meal and Wheat Straw. Cukurova University, Sci. Enstitute, Adana-Turkey (MSc Thesis), pp 31. 2009Search in Google Scholar

[39] Bozkurt Z., Gorgulu M., Celik L. The effects of essential oil of Oregano (Oregano vulgare) and Black seed (Nigella sativa) and propolis on in vitro true digestibility of dry matter, organic matter and NDF IV. National Animal Nutrition Congress. 24-28 June 2007, 2007, Bursa-Turkey.Search in Google Scholar

[40] Wan C., Zhou Y., Li Y. Liquid hot water and alkaline pretreatment of soybean straw for improving cellulose digestibility. Bioresource Technology. 2011; 102(10), 6254-6259.10.1016/j.biortech.2011.02.075Search in Google Scholar PubMed

Abbreviation List
DM

Dry matter

CP

Crude protein

EE

Ether extract

CF

Crude fibre

NFE

Nitrogen free extracts

NDF

Neutral detergent fibre

ADF

Acid detergent fibre

ADL

Acid detergent lignin

WC

Wheat control

WM

Wheat molasses

WG

Wheat guar meal

WGM

Wheat guar meal+molasses

SC

Soybean control

SM

Soybean molasses

SG

Soybean guar meal

SGM

Soybean guar meal+molasses

+S

with sepiolite

Received: 2017-4-4
Accepted: 2017-5-30
Published Online: 2017-7-24

© 2017 Unal kilic, Emre Gulecyuz

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 3.0 License.

Articles in the same Issue

  1. Research Articles
  2. Field Performance and Genetic Fidelity of Micropropagated Plants of Coffea canephora (Pierre ex A. Froehner)
  3. Research Articles
  4. Foliage maturity of Quercus ilex affects the larval development of a Croatian coastal population of Lymantria dispar (Lepidoptera: Erebidae)
  5. Research Articles
  6. Structural and functional impact of SNPs in P-selectin gene: A comprehensive in silico analysis
  7. Research Articles
  8. High embryogenic ability and regeneration from floral axis of Amorphophallus konjac (Araceae)
  9. Research Articles
  10. Terpene content of wine from the aromatic grape variety ‘Irsai Oliver’ (Vitis vinifera L.) depends on maceration time
  11. Research Articles
  12. Light and smell stimulus protocol reduced negative frontal EEG asymmetry and improved mood
  13. Research Articles
  14. Swailing affects seed germination of plants of European bio-and agricenosis in a different way
  15. Research Articles
  16. Survey analysis of soil physicochemical factors that influence the distribution of Cordyceps in the Xiahe Region of Gansu Province
  17. Research Articles
  18. Production of biogas: relationship between methanogenic and sulfate-reducing microorganisms
  19. Research Articles
  20. Pentraxin 3 and atherosclerosis among type 2 diabetic patients
  21. Research Articles
  22. Evaluation of ribosomal P0 peptide as a vaccine candidate against Argulus siamensis in Labeo rohita
  23. Research Articles
  24. Variation of autosomes and X chromosome STR in breast cancer and gynecological cancer tissues
  25. Research Articles
  26. Response of antioxidant enzymes to cadmium-induced cytotoxicity in rat cerebellar granule neurons
  27. Research Articles
  28. Cardiac hypertrophy and IGF-1 response to testosterone propionate treatment in trained male rats
  29. Research Articles
  30. BRAF-activated non-protein coding RNA (BANCR) advances the development of esophageal squamous cell carcinoma via cell cycle
  31. Research Articles
  32. The influence of soil salinity on volatile organic compounds emission and photosynthetic parameters of Solanum lycopersicum L. varieties
  33. Research Articles
  34. Simple Protocol for immunoglobulin G Purification from Camel “Camelus dromedarius” Serum
  35. Research Articles
  36. Expression of psbA1 gene in Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 is influenced by CO2
  37. Research Articles
  38. Frequency of Thrombophilic Gene Mutations in Patients with Deep Vein Thrombosis and in Women with Recurrent Pregnancy Loss
  39. Research Articles
  40. Evaluation of anticancer properties of a new α-methylene-δ-lactone DL-249 on two cancer cell lines
  41. Research Articles
  42. Impact of heated waters on water quality and macroinvertebrate community in the Narew River (Poland)
  43. Research Articles
  44. Effects of Some Additives on In Vitro True Digestibility of Wheat and Soybean Straw Pellets
  45. Research Articles
  46. RNAi-mediated gene silencing in Rhynchophorus ferrugineus (Oliver) (Coleoptera: Curculionidae)
  47. Research Articles
  48. New pathway of icariin-induced MSC osteogenesis: transcriptional activation of TAZ/Runx2 by PI3K/Akt
  49. Research Articles
  50. Tudor-SN protein expression in colorectal cancer and its association with clinical characteristics
  51. Research Articles
  52. Proteomic and bioinformatics analysis of human saliva for the dental-risk assessment
  53. Research Articles
  54. Reverse transcriptase sequences from mulberry LTR retrotransposons: characterization analysis
  55. Research Articles
  56. Strain Stimulations with Different Intensities on Fibroblast Viability and Protein Expression
  57. Research Articles
  58. miR-539 mediates osteoblast mineralization by regulating Distal-less genes 2 in MC3T3-E1 cell line
  59. Research Articles
  60. Diversity of Intestinal Microbiota in Coilia ectenes from Lake Taihu, China
  61. Research Articles
  62. The production of arabitol by a novel plant yeast isolate Candida parapsilosis 27RL-4
  63. Research Articles
  64. Effectiveness of Azospirillum brasilense Sp245 on young plants of Vitis vinifera L.
  65. Research Articles
  66. Changes of photochemical efficiency and epidermal polyphenols content of Prosopis glandulosa and Prosopis juliflora leaves exposed to cadmium and copper
  67. Research Articles
  68. Ultraweak photon emission in strawberry fruit during ripening and aging is related to energy level
  69. Research Articles
  70. Molecular cloning, characterization and evolutionary analysis of leptin gene in Chinese giant salamander, Andrias davidianus
  71. Research Articles
  72. Longevity and stress resistance are affected by activation of TOR/Myc in progenitor cells of Drosophila gut
  73. Research Articles
  74. Curcumin attenuates oxidative stress in liver in Type 1 diabetic rats
  75. Research Articles
  76. Risk factors of long-term postoperative renal function after partial nephrectomy in a solitary kidney
  77. Research Articles
  78. Developmental anomalies of the right hepatic lobe: systematic comparative analysis of radiological features
  79. Review articles
  80. Genetic Defects Underlie the Non-syndromic Autosomal Recessive Intellectual Disability (NS-ARID)
  81. Review articles
  82. Research Progress on Tissue Culture and Genetic Transformation of Kenaf (Hibiscus cannabinus)
  83. Topical Issue On Precision Medicine
  84. MiR-107 inhibits proliferation of lung cancer cells through regulating TP53 regulated inhibitor of apoptosis 1 (TRIAP1)
  85. Topical Issue On Precision Medicine
  86. The functional role of exosome microRNAs in lung cancer
  87. Topical Issue On Precision Medicine
  88. The diagnostic value of serum microRNA-183 and TK1 as biomarkers for colorectal cancer diagnosis
  89. Topical Issue On Precision Medicine
  90. Screening feature modules and pathways in glioma using EgoNet
  91. Topical Issue On Precision Medicine
  92. Isoliquiritigenin inhibits colorectal cancer cells HCT-116 growth by suppressing the PI3K/AKT pathway
  93. Topical Issue On Precision Medicine
  94. Association between Caveolin-1 expression and pathophysiological progression of femoral nerves in diabetic foot amputation patients
  95. Topical Issue On Precision Medicine
  96. Biomarkers in patients with myocardial fibrosis
  97. Topical Issue On Precision Medicine
  98. Dysregulated pathways for off-pump coronary artery bypass grafting
  99. Topical Issue On Precision Medicine
  100. Individualized identification of disturbed pathways in sickle cell disease
  101. Topical Issue On Precision Medicine
  102. The prognostic value of serum PCT, hs-CRP, and IL-6 in patients with sepsis
  103. Topical Issue On Precision Medicine
  104. Sevoflurane-medicated the pathway of chemokine receptors bind chemokines in patients undergoing CABG
  105. Topical Issue On Precision Medicine
  106. The functional role of microRNAs in laryngeal carcinoma
  107. Topical Issue On Precision Medicine
  108. Revealing pathway cross-talk related to diabetes mellitus by Monte Carlo Cross-Validation analysis
  109. Topical Issue On Precision Medicine
  110. Correlation between CDKAL1 rs10946398C>A single nucleotide polymorphism and type 2 diabetes mellitus susceptibility: A meta-analysis
  111. Special Issue on Agricultural and Biological Sciences
  112. Effects of environmental variables on seedling distribution of rare and endangered Dacrydium pierrei
  113. Special Issue on Agricultural and Biological Sciences
  114. Study on synthesis and properties of nanoparticles loaded with amaryllidaceous alkaloids
  115. Special Issue on Agricultural and Biological Sciences
  116. Bacterial Infection Potato Tuber Soft Rot Disease Detection Based on Electronic Nose
  117. Special Issue on Agricultural and Biological Sciences
  118. Effects of subsoiling on maize yield and water-use efficiency in a semiarid area
Downloaded on 5.3.2026 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/biol-2017-0024/html
Scroll to top button