Home Cosmetic surgery: medicolegal considerations
Article Open Access

Cosmetic surgery: medicolegal considerations

  • Mauro Piras , Paola Delbon , Adelaide Conti , Vincenzo Graziano EMAIL logo , Emanuele Capasso , Massimo Niola and Paola Bin
Published/Copyright: August 12, 2016

Abstract

Cosmetic surgery is one of the two branches of plastic surgery. The characteristic of non-necessity of this surgical speciality implies an increased severity in the evaluation of the risk-benefit balance. Therefore, great care must be taken in providing all the information necessary in order to obtain valid consent to the intervention. We analyzed judgments concerning cosmetic surgery found in national legal databases. A document of National Bioethics Committee (CNB) was also analyzed. Conclusion: The receipt of valid, informed consent is of absolute importance not only to legitimise the medical-surgical act, but it also represents the key element in the question concerning the existence of an obligation to achieve certain results/use of certain methods in the cosmetic surgery.

1 Introduction

Cosmetic surgery is one of the two branches of plastic surgery and is characterised by the desire of the patient to improve an aspect or feature of his/her body, which he, or much more often she, perceives to be an imperfection.

From the point of view of legal medicine, the most important subjects concerning cosmetic surgery include the receipt of informed consent and the obligation to achieve a specific result and use of certain surgical treatment methods.

We analyzed judgments concerning cosmetic surgery found in national legal databases using these search terms: “cosmetic surgery”. We also examined a document concerning cosmetic surgery written by the CNB (www.presidenza.governo.it).

2 Discussion

2.1 Informed consent

Informed consent is an essential starting point and is a moral obligation for all surgical treatments. It must be understood to be an expression of the informed agreement to undergo the medical treatment offered by the doctor. Informed consent represents a true human right and has its foundation in the principles established in Article 2 of the Italian Constitution, which safeguards and promotes basic human rights, and by Articles 13 and 32 of the Italian Constitution, which establish that personal freedom is inviolable and that no one can be obliged to undergo any particular medical treatment, unless by legal requirement.

On the necessity of receiving informed consent, the Supreme Court, in 2013 [1], affirmed that informed consent, for the purposes of ascertaining criminal liability, is not a decisive factor for the legitimacy of medical activity. This is because the informed consent expressed by a patient that has been fully informed about the effects and possible contraindications of a surgical intervention, is only a true assumption of the legitimacy of the activity carried out by the doctor who administers the treatment, to whom no general right to administer healthcare is assigned, irrespective of the will of the patient; this applies even more strongly in the field of cosmetic surgery, due to its nature as non-emergency medicine.

Therefore, a surgical procedure carried out without a provision of valid, informed consent by the patient represents a breach of the individual’s rights to health and self-determination. These two rights safeguard different principles and it is possible to breach one but not another.

The right to self-determination is considered breached in all cases in which the surgical procedure is carried out following incorrectly provided informed consent by the patient. Indeed, if the treatment undertaken without valid consent leads to an improvement to the patient’s health, the right to self-determination of the patient has still been breached.

Even more so, doctor’s conduct assumes the character of non-legitimacy when, in the event of an invalid informed consent, occur post-operative complications, resulting in a breach of the individual’s rights to health and self-determination. In this sense, the Supreme Court pronounced in 2015 [2] confirming the verdict against a cosmetic surgeon, guilty of personal injuries, and condemned him to two months imprisonment (suspended) and compensation for the damage for having treated a woman with cosmetic injections of the face, without a valid informed consent, after which she developed an orofacial granuloma and a scar.

Furthermore, even in the event of the exclusion of any causal link between the surgical treatment and any subsequent post-surgical complications (even via expert witness reports by the magistrate), the non-legitimacy of the doctor’s conduct would remain as such, in that the unjustified breaching of the right to self-determination would persist.

In the case of surgical treatment not legitimised by valid informed consent, the only possible condition the doctor could recall as cause of justification is the connotation of necessity of treatment. In the case of cosmetic surgical interventions, it is clear that the state of necessity cannot be recalled as an element of treatment validation, given that they are, as mentioned above, procedures undertaken for the purposes of correcting imperfections and not for safeguarding health [3].

2.2 Obligation of results

The receipt of valid, informed consent is of absolute importance not only to legitimise the medical-surgical act, but it also represents the key element in the question concerning the existence of an obligation to achieve certain results/use of certain methods in the cosmetic surgery.

Given the objective non-necessity of cosmetic surgery, this branch of surgery has been recognised as unique and different from all other surgical specialities. This characteristic of non-necessity implies an increased severity in the evaluation of the risk-benefit balance. Therefore, great care must be taken in providing all the information necessary in order to obtain valid consent to the intervention; information classified by the Supreme Court as “particularly significant” [4].

In cosmetic surgery, as in all surgeries, complications may arise both intra- and post-surgery, and the result of an intervention is tied to both the surgeon’s ability and to factors for which he/she is not responsible, such as patient tissue reactivity.

The obligation of the surgeon is to inform the patient, very clearly and intelligibly, of the intervention methods and times, of the side effects and the risks that may be connected to the treatment [5]. Given that, as sustained by the Supreme Court in judgement n. 12830 of 06.06.2014, when a cosmetic surgery procedure causes an imperfection greater than that which it aimed to remove or improve, once it is ascertained that the patient had not been fully, carefully and scrupulously informed of such a possible outcome, the liability for the damage caused is, according to usual practice, assigned to the doctor, even if the procedure was carried out correctly.

In consideration of the above, it follows that for case law, cosmetic surgery is no longer tied, as it was up until a few years ago, to the unavoidable obligation to achieve certain results, for which the surgeon’s conduct could be deemed improper whenever the cosmetic surgery intervention led to an imperfection greater than that which it aimed to remove or improve.

The Corte di Cassazione already pronounced on this matter in 1994 [6], affirming that, in cosmetic surgery treatments, the health worker may assume the simple obligation of methods used (for which the surgeon undertakes to offer his/her own intellectual work for the aim of achieving the pre-established result, not necessarily for actually achieving it) as well as the obligation of achieving certain results, the latter to be understood not as an unconditional fact but to be evaluated with reference to prior circumstances and to the objective possibility awarded by the progress achieved by operational techniques.

And again the Supreme Court, in 2006 [7], affirmed that the non-fulfilment by the professional (doctor) of his/ her obligation cannot be deduced, ipso facto, based on his/her failure to achieve the result expected by his/her client (patient).

2.3 Cosmetic surgery on minors, an opinion of National Bioethics Committee

Finally, in relation to cosmetic surgery carried out on those under the age of consent, The National Bioethics Committee stated their opinion in a document published on 05.07.2012 [8]. In the case of treatments on underage individuals, obtaining informed consent must, first and foremost, be based on the authorisation of both parents (or their legal representatives) to undertake an intervention, as well as on thorough information of the risks and benefits of the treatment provided to the minor by expert medical staff, with a level of information suited to the minor’s level of understanding. It is to be noted that, in Italy, as established by Article 2 of Law 86/2012, it is not possible to carry out a cosmetic breast implant surgery on a minor, unless in the cases provided for by law (serious congenital breast malformations, certified by a National Health Service doctor).

3 Conclusions

Informed consent is an essential starting point and is a moral obligation for all surgical treatments. Given the objective non-necessity of cosmetic surgery, great care must be taken in providing all the information necessary in order to obtain valid consent to the intervention. The receipt of valid, informed consent is of absolute importance not only to legitimise the medical-surgical act, but it also represents the key element in the question concerning the existence of an obligation to achieve certain results/ use of certain methods in the cosmetic surgery. Cosmetic surgery is not a tie to the obligation to achieve certain results, but is a tie to the obligation of methods used.

Conflict of interest statement

  1. Authors state no conflict of interest.

References

[1] Cass. Pen., 27/11/2013, n. 234710.1109/MSPEC.2014.6934924Search in Google Scholar

[2] Cass. Pen., 15/01/2015, n. 461310.12968/prps.2015.Sup174.15Search in Google Scholar

[3] Cass. Civ., 06/06/2014, n. 12830Search in Google Scholar

[4] Cass. Civ., 06/10/1997, n. 9705Search in Google Scholar

[5] G. Giusti, Trattato di medicina legale e scienze affini, II ed, Padova, ed. CEDAM, 2009Search in Google Scholar

[6] Cass. Civ., 25/11/1994, n. 10014Search in Google Scholar

[7] Cass. Civ., 09/11/2006, n. 23918Search in Google Scholar

[8] Comitato Nazionale per la Bioetica, Aspetti bioetici della chirurgia estetica e ricostruttiva, 5/07/2012Search in Google Scholar

Received: 2016-6-27
Accepted: 2016-7-7
Published Online: 2016-8-12
Published in Print: 2016-1-1

© 2016 Mauro Piras et al.

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 3.0 License.

Articles in the same Issue

  1. Research Article
  2. The possible molecular regulation mechanism of CIK cells inhibiting the proliferation of Human Lung Adenocarcinoma NCL-H157 Cells
  3. Case Report
  4. Urethral stone of unexpected size: case report and short literature review
  5. Case Report
  6. Complete remission through icotinib treatment in Non-small cell lung cancer epidermal growth factor receptor mutation patient with brain metastasis: A case report
  7. Research Article
  8. FPL tendon thickness, tremor and hand functions in Parkinson’s disease
  9. Research Article
  10. Diagnostic value of circulating tumor cells in cerebrospinal fluid
  11. Research Article
  12. A meta-analysis of neuroprotective effect for traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) in the treatment of glaucoma
  13. Research Article
  14. MiR-218 increases sensitivity to cisplatin in esophageal cancer cells via targeting survivin expression
  15. Research Article
  16. Association of HOTAIR expression with PI3K/Akt pathway activation in adenocarcinoma of esophagogastric junction
  17. Research Article
  18. The role of interleukin genes in the course of depression
  19. Case Report
  20. A rare case of primary pulmonary diffuse large B cell lymphoma with CD5 positive expression
  21. Research Article
  22. DWI and SPARCC scoring assess curative effect of early ankylosing spondylitis
  23. Research Article
  24. The diagnostic value of serum CEA, NSE and MMP-9 for on-small cell lung cancer
  25. Case Report
  26. Dysphonia – the single symptom of rifampicin resistant laryngeal tuberculosis
  27. Review Article
  28. Development of epidermal growth factor receptor tyrosine kinase inhibitors against EGFR T790M. Mutation in non small-cell lung carcinoma
  29. Research Article
  30. Negative regulation of CDC42 expression and cell cycle progression by miR-29a in breast cancer
  31. Research Article
  32. Expression analysis of the TGF-β/SMAD target genes in adenocarcinoma of esophagogastric junction
  33. Research Article
  34. Blood cells in thyroid cancer patients: a possible influence of apoptosis
  35. Research Article
  36. Detected EGFR mutation in cerebrospinal fluid of lung adenocarcinoma patients with meningeal metastasis
  37. Mini-review
  38. Pathogenesis-oriented approaches for the management of corticosteroid-resistant or relapsedprimary immune thrombocytopenia
  39. Research Article
  40. GSTP1 A>G polymorphism and chemosensitivity of osteosarcoma: A meta-analysis
  41. Research Article
  42. A meta-analysis of adiponectin gene rs22411766 T>G polymorphism and ischemic stroke susceptibility
  43. Research Article
  44. The diagnosis and pathological value of combined detection of HE4 and CA125 for patients with ovarian cancer
  45. Research Article
  46. SOX7 inhibits tumor progression of glioblastoma and is regulated by miRNA-24
  47. Research Article
  48. Sevoflurane affects evoked electromyography monitoring in cerebral palsy
  49. Case Report
  50. A case report of hereditary spherocytosis with concomitant chronic myelocytic leukemia
  51. Case Report
  52. A case of giant saphenous vein graft aneurysm followed serially after coronary artery bypass surgery
  53. Research Article
  54. LncRNA TUG1 is upregulated and promotes cell proliferation in osteosarcoma
  55. Review Article
  56. Meningioma recurrence
  57. Case Report
  58. Endobronchial amyloidosis mimicking bronchial asthma: a case report and review of the literature
  59. Case Report
  60. A confusing case report of pulmonary langerhans cell histiocytosis and literature review
  61. Research Article
  62. Effect of hesperetin on chaperone activity in selenite-induced cataract
  63. Research Article
  64. Clinical value of self-assessment risk of osteoporosis in Chinese
  65. Research Article
  66. Correlation analysis of VHL and Jade-1 gene expression in human renal cell carcinoma
  67. Research Article
  68. Is acute appendicitis still misdiagnosed?
  69. Retraction
  70. Retraction of: application of food-specific IgG antibody detection in allergy dermatosis
  71. Review Article
  72. Platelet Rich Plasma: a short overview of certain bioactive components
  73. Research Article
  74. Correlation between CTLA-4 gene rs221775A>G single nucleotide polymorphism and multiple sclerosis susceptibility. A meta-analysis
  75. Review Article
  76. Standards of anesthesiology practice during neuroradiological interventions
  77. Research Article
  78. Expression and clinical significance of LXRα and SREBP-1c in placentas of preeclampsia
  79. Letter to the Editor
  80. ARDS diagnosed by SpO2/FiO2 ratio compared with PaO2/FiO2 ratio: the role as a diagnostic tool for early enrolment into clinical trials
  81. Research Article
  82. Impact of sensory integration training on balance among stroke patients: sensory integration training on balance among stroke patients
  83. Review Article
  84. MicroRNAs as regulatory elements in psoriasis
  85. Review Article
  86. Influenza A(H1N1)pdm09 and postpandemic influenza in Lithuania
  87. Review Article
  88. Garengeot’s hernia: two case reports with CT diagnosis and literature review
  89. Research Article
  90. Concept of experimental preparation for treating dentin hypersensitivity
  91. Research Article
  92. Hydrogen water reduces NSE, IL-6, and TNF-α levels in hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy
  93. Research Article
  94. Xanthogranuloma of the sellar region diagnosed by frozen section
  95. Case Report
  96. Laparoscopic antegrade cholecystectomy: a standard procedure?
  97. Case Report
  98. Maxillary fibrous dysplasia associated with McCune-Albright syndrome. A case study
  99. Regular Article
  100. Sialoendoscopy, sialography, and ultrasound: a comparison of diagnostic methods
  101. Research Article
  102. Antibody Response to Live Attenuated Vaccines in Adults in Japan
  103. Conference article
  104. Excellence and safety in surgery require excellent and safe tutoring
  105. Conference article
  106. Suggestions on how to make suboptimal kidney transplantation an ethically viable option
  107. Regular Article
  108. Ectopic pregnancy treatment by combination therapy
  109. Conference article
  110. Use of a simplified consent form to facilitate patient understanding of informed consent for laparoscopic cholecystectomy
  111. Regular Article
  112. Cusum analysis for learning curve of videothoracoscopic lobectomy
  113. Regular Article
  114. A meta-analysis of association between glutathione S-transferase M1 gene polymorphism and Parkinson’s disease susceptibility
  115. Conference article
  116. Plastination: ethical and medico-legal considerations
  117. Regular Article
  118. Investigation and control of a suspected nosocomial outbreak of pan-drug resistant Acinetobacter baumannii in an intensive care unit
  119. Regular Article
  120. Multifactorial analysis of fatigue scale among nurses in Poland
  121. Regular Article
  122. Smoking cessation for free: outcomes of a study of three Romanian clinics
  123. Regular Article
  124. Clinical efficacy and safety of tripterygium glycosides in treatment of stage IV diabetic nephropathy: A meta-analysis
  125. Special Issue on Italian Society for the Study of Vascular Anomalies
  126. Prevention and treatment of peritoneal adhesions in patients affected by vascular diseases following surgery: a review of the literature
  127. Special Issue on Italian Society for the Study of Vascular Anomalies
  128. Surgical treatment of recidivist lymphedema
  129. Special Issue on Italian Society for the Study of Vascular Anomalies
  130. CT and MR imaging of the thoracic aorta
  131. Special Issue on Italian Society for the Study of Vascular Anomalies
  132. Role of FDG-PET scan in staging of pulmonary epithelioid hemangioendothelioma
  133. Special Issue on Italian Society for the Study of Vascular Anomalies
  134. Sternal reconstruction by extracellular matrix: a rare case of phaces syndrome
  135. Special Issue on Italian Society for the Study of Vascular Anomalies
  136. Prenatal diagnosis, 3-D virtual rendering and lung sparing surgery by ligasure device in a baby with “CCAM and intralobar pulmonary sequestration”
  137. Special Issue on Italian Society for the Study of Vascular Anomalies
  138. Serum levels of inhibin B in adolescents after varicocelelectomy: A long term follow up
  139. Special Issue on Italian Society for the Study of Vascular Anomalies
  140. Our experience in the treatment of Malignant Fibrous Hystiocytoma of the larynx: clinical diagnosis, therapeutic approach and review of literature
  141. Special Issue on Italian Society for the Study of Vascular Anomalies
  142. Delayed recurrent nerve paralysis following post-traumatic aortic pseudoaneurysm
  143. Special Issue on Italian Society for the Study of Vascular Anomalies
  144. Integrated therapeutic approach to giant solitary fibrous tumor of the pleura: report of a case and review of the literature
  145. Special Issue on Italian Society for the Study of Vascular Anomalies
  146. Celiac axis compression syndrome: laparoscopic approach in a strange case of chronic abdominal pain in 71 years old man
  147. Special Issue on Italian Society for the Study of Vascular Anomalies
  148. A rare case of persistent hypoglossal artery associated with contralateral proximal subclavian stenosis
  149. Focus on Medico-Legal and Ethical Topics in Surgery in Italy
  150. Contralateral risk reducing mastectomy in Non-BRCA-Mutated patients
  151. Focus on Medico-Legal and Ethical Topics in Surgery in Italy
  152. Professional dental and oral surgery liability in Italy: a comparative analysis of the insurance products offered to health workers
  153. Focus on Medico-Legal and Ethical Topics in Surgery in Italy
  154. Informed consent in robotic surgery: quality of information and patient perception
  155. Focus on Medico-Legal and Ethical Topics in Surgery in Italy
  156. Malfunctions of robotic system in surgery: role and responsibility of surgeon in legal point of view
  157. Focus on Medico-Legal and Ethical Topics in Surgery in Italy
  158. Medicolegal implications of surgical errors and complications in neck surgery: A review based on the Italian current legislation
  159. Focus on Medico-Legal and Ethical Topics in Surgery in Italy
  160. Iatrogenic splenic injury: review of the literature and medico-legal issues
  161. Focus on Medico-Legal and Ethical Topics in Surgery in Italy
  162. Donation of the body for scientific purposes in Italy: ethical and medico-legal considerations
  163. Focus on Medico-Legal and Ethical Topics in Surgery in Italy
  164. Cosmetic surgery: medicolegal considerations
  165. Focus on Medico-Legal and Ethical Topics in Surgery in Italy
  166. Voluntary termination of pregnancy (medical or surgical abortion): forensic medicine issues
  167. Review Article
  168. Role of Laparoscopic Splenectomy in Elderly Immune Thrombocytopenia
  169. Review Article
  170. Endoscopic diagnosis and treatment of neuroendocrine tumors of the digestive system
  171. Review Article
  172. Efficacy and safety of splenectomy in adult autoimmune hemolytic anemia
  173. Research Article
  174. Relationship between gastroesophageal reflux disease and Ph nose and salivary: proposal of a simple method outpatient in patients adults
  175. Case Report
  176. Idiopathic pleural panniculitis with recurrent pleural effusion not associated with Weber-Christian disease
  177. Research Article
  178. Morbid Obesity: treatment with Bioenterics Intragastric Balloon (BIB), psychological and nursing care: our experience
  179. Research Article
  180. Learning curve for endorectal ultrasound in young and elderly: lights and shades
  181. Case Report
  182. Uncommon primary hydatid cyst occupying the adrenal gland space, treated with laparoscopic surgical approach in an old patient
  183. Research Article
  184. Distraction techniques for face and smile aesthetic preventing ageing decay
  185. Research Article
  186. Preoperative high-intensity training in frail old patients undergoing pulmonary resection for NSCLC
  187. Review Article
  188. Descending necrotizing mediastinitis in the elderly patients
  189. Research Article
  190. Prophylactic GSV surgery in elderly candidates for hip or knee arthroplasty
  191. Research Article
  192. Diagnostic yield and safety of C-TBNA in elderly patients with lung cancer
  193. Research Article
  194. The learning curve of laparoscopic holecystectomy in general surgery resident training: old age of the patient may be a risk factor?
  195. Research Article
  196. Self-gripping mesh versus fibrin glue fixation in laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair: a randomized prospective clinical trial in young and elderly patients
  197. Research Article
  198. Anal sphincter dysfunction in multiple sclerosis: an observation manometric study
Downloaded on 22.9.2025 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/med-2016-0044/html
Scroll to top button