Home Business & Economics 13 Land Commodification: A Structural Barrier to Degrowth Transition
Chapter
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

13 Land Commodification: A Structural Barrier to Degrowth Transition

  • , and
Become an author with De Gruyter Brill
Explore this Subject How to publish with us
De Gruyter Handbook of Degrowth
This chapter is in the book De Gruyter Handbook of Degrowth

Abstract

The willingness of politicians or business to acknowledge the necessity of a degrowth transition is scarce to non-existent (Rickters & Siemoneit, 2019). In response to this, there is broad support within the degrowth movement for the notion that a degrowth society will have to emerge from the grassroots up (see D’Alisa et al., 2015). However, serious doubts can also be levelled against such a sociocultural groundswell (Frankel, 2018; Sanne, 2002). While the degrowth movement has been explicit about the degree of ecological overshoot associated with perpetual growth, overall, certain politico- economic barriers to degrowth transition, that are faced by this potential groundswell, have not been well addressed in the literature (Strunz & Schindler, 2018; de Jesus & Mendonça, 2018). To address this gap in degrowth transition scholarship, this chapter demonstrates the way in which, for ordinary people expected to pursue a degrowth transition, costs associated with land and housing operate as a significant barrier to their involvement. As we will argue, these housing costs almost always function as a powerful economic determinant, locking people into sustained, but not sustainable, market participation. Our contribution to the literature is to analyse this terrain, exploring the way in which land privatisation (land enclosure being capitalism’s inaugural step) instigated and now continues to compel long-term participation in an unsustainable growth economy. The chapter concludes by exploring one way in which this structural obstacle to degrowth transition could be addressed. We propose an innovative public housing policy approach coupled with a ‘participation income - an approach that we argue could create a politically palatable urban commons pathway to degrowth.

Abstract

The willingness of politicians or business to acknowledge the necessity of a degrowth transition is scarce to non-existent (Rickters & Siemoneit, 2019). In response to this, there is broad support within the degrowth movement for the notion that a degrowth society will have to emerge from the grassroots up (see D’Alisa et al., 2015). However, serious doubts can also be levelled against such a sociocultural groundswell (Frankel, 2018; Sanne, 2002). While the degrowth movement has been explicit about the degree of ecological overshoot associated with perpetual growth, overall, certain politico- economic barriers to degrowth transition, that are faced by this potential groundswell, have not been well addressed in the literature (Strunz & Schindler, 2018; de Jesus & Mendonça, 2018). To address this gap in degrowth transition scholarship, this chapter demonstrates the way in which, for ordinary people expected to pursue a degrowth transition, costs associated with land and housing operate as a significant barrier to their involvement. As we will argue, these housing costs almost always function as a powerful economic determinant, locking people into sustained, but not sustainable, market participation. Our contribution to the literature is to analyse this terrain, exploring the way in which land privatisation (land enclosure being capitalism’s inaugural step) instigated and now continues to compel long-term participation in an unsustainable growth economy. The chapter concludes by exploring one way in which this structural obstacle to degrowth transition could be addressed. We propose an innovative public housing policy approach coupled with a ‘participation income - an approach that we argue could create a politically palatable urban commons pathway to degrowth.

Chapters in this book

  1. Frontmatter I
  2. Acknowledgements VII
  3. Contents IX
  4. List of Contributors XIII
  5. Foreword 1
  6. Introduction – Degrowth: Swimming Against the Ideological Tide 7
  7. Part I: Degrowth Agendas
  8. Introduction 23
  9. 1 ‘Without Growth, Everything is Nothing’: On the Origins of Growthism 25
  10. 2 Degrowth: Monetary and Nonmonetary Economies 41
  11. 3 Critiques of Work: The Radical Roots of Degrowth 55
  12. 4 Cultural Political Economy and Degrowth Politics 75
  13. 5 Sustainable Welfare: Decoupling Welfare from Growth and Prioritising Needs Satisfaction for All 89
  14. Part II: Degrowth in Practice
  15. Introduction 107
  16. 6 How and Who? The Debate About a Strategy for Degrowth 109
  17. 7 Translating Degrowth: From Policy Proposals to Praxis 129
  18. 8 Living in Abundance: Tool Libraries for Convivial Degrowth 149
  19. 9 Materialising Degrowth Agrifood Architecture with Earth 167
  20. 10 They Want Us to Live in Caves: Degrowth and the Housing Question 191
  21. Part III: The Urban and the Rural
  22. Introduction 211
  23. 11 The Case for Solidary Degrowth Spaces. Five Propositions on the Challenging Project of Spatialising Degrowth 213
  24. 12 Urban Degrowth 233
  25. 13 Land Commodification: A Structural Barrier to Degrowth Transition 251
  26. 14 Agroecology as Degrowth in Practice: Resistance Rooted in Human- Nature Relationality 273
  27. 15 Organising Nature Through Urban Gardening 291
  28. Part IV: Critical Connections
  29. Introduction 309
  30. 16 Interlocking Crises, Intersectional Visions: Ecofeminist Political Economy in Conversation with Degrowth 311
  31. 17 Dependency, Delinking and Degrowth in a New Developmental Era: Debates from Argentina 327
  32. 18 Degrowth and Psychoanalysis: From Transition to Transformation 339
  33. 19 Degrowth Disagreements with Marxism: Critical Perspectives on the Fetishisation of Value and Productivity 361
  34. 20 Not Just Newer, but Fewer: A Bridge Between Ecomodernism and Degrowth? 377
  35. Part V: Degrowth and the Global South
  36. Introduction 395
  37. 21 From Marxist Development Theories to Their Translation in the Degrowth Discourse: Transforming Unequal International Structures for Environmental Sustainability 397
  38. 22 Radical Ecological Democracy: Reflections from the South on Degrowth 417
  39. 23 Degrowth Beyond the Metropole: Theory and Praxis for a Revolutionary Degrowth 427
  40. 24 Growing Degrowth: Alliances with Environmental Movements in the Global South 447
  41. 25 ‘For the Greater Good’– Green Sacrifice Zones and Subaltern Resistance: The Politics and Potential of Degrowth and Post-Extractivist Futures 461
  42. List of Figures 479
  43. About the Editors 481
  44. Index 483
https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110778359-018

Chapters in this book

  1. Frontmatter I
  2. Acknowledgements VII
  3. Contents IX
  4. List of Contributors XIII
  5. Foreword 1
  6. Introduction – Degrowth: Swimming Against the Ideological Tide 7
  7. Part I: Degrowth Agendas
  8. Introduction 23
  9. 1 ‘Without Growth, Everything is Nothing’: On the Origins of Growthism 25
  10. 2 Degrowth: Monetary and Nonmonetary Economies 41
  11. 3 Critiques of Work: The Radical Roots of Degrowth 55
  12. 4 Cultural Political Economy and Degrowth Politics 75
  13. 5 Sustainable Welfare: Decoupling Welfare from Growth and Prioritising Needs Satisfaction for All 89
  14. Part II: Degrowth in Practice
  15. Introduction 107
  16. 6 How and Who? The Debate About a Strategy for Degrowth 109
  17. 7 Translating Degrowth: From Policy Proposals to Praxis 129
  18. 8 Living in Abundance: Tool Libraries for Convivial Degrowth 149
  19. 9 Materialising Degrowth Agrifood Architecture with Earth 167
  20. 10 They Want Us to Live in Caves: Degrowth and the Housing Question 191
  21. Part III: The Urban and the Rural
  22. Introduction 211
  23. 11 The Case for Solidary Degrowth Spaces. Five Propositions on the Challenging Project of Spatialising Degrowth 213
  24. 12 Urban Degrowth 233
  25. 13 Land Commodification: A Structural Barrier to Degrowth Transition 251
  26. 14 Agroecology as Degrowth in Practice: Resistance Rooted in Human- Nature Relationality 273
  27. 15 Organising Nature Through Urban Gardening 291
  28. Part IV: Critical Connections
  29. Introduction 309
  30. 16 Interlocking Crises, Intersectional Visions: Ecofeminist Political Economy in Conversation with Degrowth 311
  31. 17 Dependency, Delinking and Degrowth in a New Developmental Era: Debates from Argentina 327
  32. 18 Degrowth and Psychoanalysis: From Transition to Transformation 339
  33. 19 Degrowth Disagreements with Marxism: Critical Perspectives on the Fetishisation of Value and Productivity 361
  34. 20 Not Just Newer, but Fewer: A Bridge Between Ecomodernism and Degrowth? 377
  35. Part V: Degrowth and the Global South
  36. Introduction 395
  37. 21 From Marxist Development Theories to Their Translation in the Degrowth Discourse: Transforming Unequal International Structures for Environmental Sustainability 397
  38. 22 Radical Ecological Democracy: Reflections from the South on Degrowth 417
  39. 23 Degrowth Beyond the Metropole: Theory and Praxis for a Revolutionary Degrowth 427
  40. 24 Growing Degrowth: Alliances with Environmental Movements in the Global South 447
  41. 25 ‘For the Greater Good’– Green Sacrifice Zones and Subaltern Resistance: The Politics and Potential of Degrowth and Post-Extractivist Futures 461
  42. List of Figures 479
  43. About the Editors 481
  44. Index 483
Sign up now to receive a 20% welcome discount
Institutional Access
How does access work?
Winner of the OpenAthens UX Award 2026
Winner of the OpenAthens UX Award 2026
Have an idea on how to improve our website?
Please write us.
© 2026 De Gruyter Brill
Downloaded on 1.4.2026 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9783110778359-018/html
Scroll to top button