15 Organising Nature Through Urban Gardening
-
Bjørn Inge Melås
Abstract
Capitalism is not just an economic system, it is a way of organising nature (Moore, 2015). It depends on an external, cheap nature to grow and a constant search for new spaces to exhaust and dispose of its debris. Nature must work harder and this can be achieved through homogenisation - by transforming rainforests into plantations, but also through a similar flattening of our inner landscapes. Capitalism is not just globalised, it is also integrated in our minds and the way we think, act and relate (Guattari, 2000). The ecological crisis must be approached not just by its physical manifestations, but also its mental and social ecologies. Through artistic research I explore urban gardening as a transversal practice able to work on all three ecologies simultaneously. If capitalism is a way of organising nature, degrowth must have other ways. By using experiences from my research, I will explore how practices of urban gardening involve other ways of relating to and organising nature. The proposition of degrowth might involve what Félix Guattari calls heterogenesis - the production of diversity. Gardens replace parking lots and provide habitats for a variety of species, but also open up for a diversity of ways-of-being, sensing, thinking, knowing, caring, relating and living together. The environments we make, how we make them and who we include in the process matters - not just for the environments, but also for us, since we are reproducing ourselves in the process. Urban gardening might change both material and immaterial production and through practicing and developing alternatives the imaginaries of the future are expanded.
Abstract
Capitalism is not just an economic system, it is a way of organising nature (Moore, 2015). It depends on an external, cheap nature to grow and a constant search for new spaces to exhaust and dispose of its debris. Nature must work harder and this can be achieved through homogenisation - by transforming rainforests into plantations, but also through a similar flattening of our inner landscapes. Capitalism is not just globalised, it is also integrated in our minds and the way we think, act and relate (Guattari, 2000). The ecological crisis must be approached not just by its physical manifestations, but also its mental and social ecologies. Through artistic research I explore urban gardening as a transversal practice able to work on all three ecologies simultaneously. If capitalism is a way of organising nature, degrowth must have other ways. By using experiences from my research, I will explore how practices of urban gardening involve other ways of relating to and organising nature. The proposition of degrowth might involve what Félix Guattari calls heterogenesis - the production of diversity. Gardens replace parking lots and provide habitats for a variety of species, but also open up for a diversity of ways-of-being, sensing, thinking, knowing, caring, relating and living together. The environments we make, how we make them and who we include in the process matters - not just for the environments, but also for us, since we are reproducing ourselves in the process. Urban gardening might change both material and immaterial production and through practicing and developing alternatives the imaginaries of the future are expanded.
Chapters in this book
- Frontmatter I
- Acknowledgements VII
- Contents IX
- List of Contributors XIII
- Foreword 1
- Introduction – Degrowth: Swimming Against the Ideological Tide 7
-
Part I: Degrowth Agendas
- Introduction 23
- 1 ‘Without Growth, Everything is Nothing’: On the Origins of Growthism 25
- 2 Degrowth: Monetary and Nonmonetary Economies 41
- 3 Critiques of Work: The Radical Roots of Degrowth 55
- 4 Cultural Political Economy and Degrowth Politics 75
- 5 Sustainable Welfare: Decoupling Welfare from Growth and Prioritising Needs Satisfaction for All 89
-
Part II: Degrowth in Practice
- Introduction 107
- 6 How and Who? The Debate About a Strategy for Degrowth 109
- 7 Translating Degrowth: From Policy Proposals to Praxis 129
- 8 Living in Abundance: Tool Libraries for Convivial Degrowth 149
- 9 Materialising Degrowth Agrifood Architecture with Earth 167
- 10 They Want Us to Live in Caves: Degrowth and the Housing Question 191
-
Part III: The Urban and the Rural
- Introduction 211
- 11 The Case for Solidary Degrowth Spaces. Five Propositions on the Challenging Project of Spatialising Degrowth 213
- 12 Urban Degrowth 233
- 13 Land Commodification: A Structural Barrier to Degrowth Transition 251
- 14 Agroecology as Degrowth in Practice: Resistance Rooted in Human- Nature Relationality 273
- 15 Organising Nature Through Urban Gardening 291
-
Part IV: Critical Connections
- Introduction 309
- 16 Interlocking Crises, Intersectional Visions: Ecofeminist Political Economy in Conversation with Degrowth 311
- 17 Dependency, Delinking and Degrowth in a New Developmental Era: Debates from Argentina 327
- 18 Degrowth and Psychoanalysis: From Transition to Transformation 339
- 19 Degrowth Disagreements with Marxism: Critical Perspectives on the Fetishisation of Value and Productivity 361
- 20 Not Just Newer, but Fewer: A Bridge Between Ecomodernism and Degrowth? 377
-
Part V: Degrowth and the Global South
- Introduction 395
- 21 From Marxist Development Theories to Their Translation in the Degrowth Discourse: Transforming Unequal International Structures for Environmental Sustainability 397
- 22 Radical Ecological Democracy: Reflections from the South on Degrowth 417
- 23 Degrowth Beyond the Metropole: Theory and Praxis for a Revolutionary Degrowth 427
- 24 Growing Degrowth: Alliances with Environmental Movements in the Global South 447
- 25 ‘For the Greater Good’– Green Sacrifice Zones and Subaltern Resistance: The Politics and Potential of Degrowth and Post-Extractivist Futures 461
- List of Figures 479
- About the Editors 481
- Index 483
Chapters in this book
- Frontmatter I
- Acknowledgements VII
- Contents IX
- List of Contributors XIII
- Foreword 1
- Introduction – Degrowth: Swimming Against the Ideological Tide 7
-
Part I: Degrowth Agendas
- Introduction 23
- 1 ‘Without Growth, Everything is Nothing’: On the Origins of Growthism 25
- 2 Degrowth: Monetary and Nonmonetary Economies 41
- 3 Critiques of Work: The Radical Roots of Degrowth 55
- 4 Cultural Political Economy and Degrowth Politics 75
- 5 Sustainable Welfare: Decoupling Welfare from Growth and Prioritising Needs Satisfaction for All 89
-
Part II: Degrowth in Practice
- Introduction 107
- 6 How and Who? The Debate About a Strategy for Degrowth 109
- 7 Translating Degrowth: From Policy Proposals to Praxis 129
- 8 Living in Abundance: Tool Libraries for Convivial Degrowth 149
- 9 Materialising Degrowth Agrifood Architecture with Earth 167
- 10 They Want Us to Live in Caves: Degrowth and the Housing Question 191
-
Part III: The Urban and the Rural
- Introduction 211
- 11 The Case for Solidary Degrowth Spaces. Five Propositions on the Challenging Project of Spatialising Degrowth 213
- 12 Urban Degrowth 233
- 13 Land Commodification: A Structural Barrier to Degrowth Transition 251
- 14 Agroecology as Degrowth in Practice: Resistance Rooted in Human- Nature Relationality 273
- 15 Organising Nature Through Urban Gardening 291
-
Part IV: Critical Connections
- Introduction 309
- 16 Interlocking Crises, Intersectional Visions: Ecofeminist Political Economy in Conversation with Degrowth 311
- 17 Dependency, Delinking and Degrowth in a New Developmental Era: Debates from Argentina 327
- 18 Degrowth and Psychoanalysis: From Transition to Transformation 339
- 19 Degrowth Disagreements with Marxism: Critical Perspectives on the Fetishisation of Value and Productivity 361
- 20 Not Just Newer, but Fewer: A Bridge Between Ecomodernism and Degrowth? 377
-
Part V: Degrowth and the Global South
- Introduction 395
- 21 From Marxist Development Theories to Their Translation in the Degrowth Discourse: Transforming Unequal International Structures for Environmental Sustainability 397
- 22 Radical Ecological Democracy: Reflections from the South on Degrowth 417
- 23 Degrowth Beyond the Metropole: Theory and Praxis for a Revolutionary Degrowth 427
- 24 Growing Degrowth: Alliances with Environmental Movements in the Global South 447
- 25 ‘For the Greater Good’– Green Sacrifice Zones and Subaltern Resistance: The Politics and Potential of Degrowth and Post-Extractivist Futures 461
- List of Figures 479
- About the Editors 481
- Index 483