5. The treason of translation?
-
John Edwards
Abstract
It is perfectly obvious that using a translator or interpreter has practical benefits; it is perhaps less obvious that psychological disadvantages may present themselves. The translator is one whose linguistic competence gives entry to (at least) two language communities, and there may be apprehension. As George Steiner has pointed out, “there is in every act of translation – and specially where it succeeds – a touch of treason. Hoarded dreams, patents of life are being taken across the frontier.” The old Italian proverb is blunter: traduttori traditori. This reflects the familiar idea that concealment is as much a feature of language as is communication. Privacy, the construction of fictionalised myths, legends and stories, and outright dissimulation are at once important and threatened by translation and translators; one contemporary theme here is the “appropriation” of native stories by outsiders, for in many cultures, particularly those with powerful and rich oral traditions, stories belong to the group or, indeed, to some designated story-teller. There is, then, a potential tension between the necessity of translation and its invasive qualities. This chapter suggests some points relevant to this tension – with particular regard to ethnic-group boundaries and the politics of group identity.
Abstract
It is perfectly obvious that using a translator or interpreter has practical benefits; it is perhaps less obvious that psychological disadvantages may present themselves. The translator is one whose linguistic competence gives entry to (at least) two language communities, and there may be apprehension. As George Steiner has pointed out, “there is in every act of translation – and specially where it succeeds – a touch of treason. Hoarded dreams, patents of life are being taken across the frontier.” The old Italian proverb is blunter: traduttori traditori. This reflects the familiar idea that concealment is as much a feature of language as is communication. Privacy, the construction of fictionalised myths, legends and stories, and outright dissimulation are at once important and threatened by translation and translators; one contemporary theme here is the “appropriation” of native stories by outsiders, for in many cultures, particularly those with powerful and rich oral traditions, stories belong to the group or, indeed, to some designated story-teller. There is, then, a potential tension between the necessity of translation and its invasive qualities. This chapter suggests some points relevant to this tension – with particular regard to ethnic-group boundaries and the politics of group identity.
Chapters in this book
- Prelim pages i
- Table of contents v
- Preface vii
- Introduction. Between temples and templates 1
-
Part 1. Translation and reconciliation
- 1. Translation as reconciliation 17
- 2. Interpreting at the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY) 37
- 3. Translating and interpreting sign language 53
- 4. Translators in a global community 73
-
Part 2. Translation and negotiation
- 5. The treason of translation? 89
- 6. The poetics of experience 107
-
Part 3. Translation and the interpretation of texts
- 7. Translation and the rediscovery of the multinational Central European 127
- 8. Transcriação / Transcreation 139
- 9. Expression and translation of philosophy 161
- 10. The semantics of invention 169
- Contributors 191
- Index 195
Chapters in this book
- Prelim pages i
- Table of contents v
- Preface vii
- Introduction. Between temples and templates 1
-
Part 1. Translation and reconciliation
- 1. Translation as reconciliation 17
- 2. Interpreting at the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY) 37
- 3. Translating and interpreting sign language 53
- 4. Translators in a global community 73
-
Part 2. Translation and negotiation
- 5. The treason of translation? 89
- 6. The poetics of experience 107
-
Part 3. Translation and the interpretation of texts
- 7. Translation and the rediscovery of the multinational Central European 127
- 8. Transcriação / Transcreation 139
- 9. Expression and translation of philosophy 161
- 10. The semantics of invention 169
- Contributors 191
- Index 195
