Chapter 8. Cognitive grammar and reconstrual
-
Chloe Harrison
and Louise Nuttall
Abstract
This chapter examines the cognitive and experiential processes of re-reading, and their contribution to the conceptualisation of a fictional world. Fictional worlds are experienced dynamically, and often in multiple sittings, separated by varying lengths of time. While the myriad of contextual factors which distinguish sittings makes re-reading a difficult object of study, this aspect of our natural, everyday encounters with texts is worthy of consideration in stylistic discussion. As a first step in this direction, this chapter demonstrates an awareness of multiple readings, and the distinct experiences they represent, as part of a cognitive stylistic account of textual interpretation.
Firstly, a theoretical account of re-reading is outlined in terms of Cognitive Grammar and, in particular, its concept of construal. This account is demonstrated through analysis of the short story “The Freeze-Dried Groom” from Margaret Atwood’s 2014a collection Stone Mattress. Applying Cognitive Grammar's multidimensional model of construal, and a further process of reconstrual, we make specific predictions concerning readers’ experiences of this story’s fictional world on a first- and second-reading, looking in particular at changing conceptualisations of tone, atmosphere and narrative perspective, and the linguistic processing responsible. Based on this analytical case study, we propose a need for further investigation of texts which surprise readers, or which feature a twist or reveal, and the ways in which information is attended to across multiple readings.
Abstract
This chapter examines the cognitive and experiential processes of re-reading, and their contribution to the conceptualisation of a fictional world. Fictional worlds are experienced dynamically, and often in multiple sittings, separated by varying lengths of time. While the myriad of contextual factors which distinguish sittings makes re-reading a difficult object of study, this aspect of our natural, everyday encounters with texts is worthy of consideration in stylistic discussion. As a first step in this direction, this chapter demonstrates an awareness of multiple readings, and the distinct experiences they represent, as part of a cognitive stylistic account of textual interpretation.
Firstly, a theoretical account of re-reading is outlined in terms of Cognitive Grammar and, in particular, its concept of construal. This account is demonstrated through analysis of the short story “The Freeze-Dried Groom” from Margaret Atwood’s 2014a collection Stone Mattress. Applying Cognitive Grammar's multidimensional model of construal, and a further process of reconstrual, we make specific predictions concerning readers’ experiences of this story’s fictional world on a first- and second-reading, looking in particular at changing conceptualisations of tone, atmosphere and narrative perspective, and the linguistic processing responsible. Based on this analytical case study, we propose a need for further investigation of texts which surprise readers, or which feature a twist or reveal, and the ways in which information is attended to across multiple readings.
Chapters in this book
- Prelim pages i
- Table of contents v
- List of contributors vii
- Preface xi
- Acknowledgments xiii
- Chapter 1. Introduction 1
-
Part 1. Foundations of fictional worlds
- Chapter 2. Immersion and emergence in children’s literature 15
- Chapter 3. A predictive coding approach to Text World Theory 33
- Chapter 4. World-building as cognitive feedback loop 53
-
Part 2. Forming fictional worlds
- Chapter 5. Experiencing horrible worlds 75
- Chapter 6. Framing the narrative 97
- Chapter 7. Constructing inferiority through comic characterisation 119
- Chapter 8. Cognitive grammar and reconstrual 135
-
Part 3. Fictional worlds in context
- Chapter 9. Immersive reading and the unnatural text-worlds of “Dead Fish” 157
- Chapter 10. Experiencing literature in the poetry classroom 177
- Chapter 11. Sharing fiction 199
- Chapter 12. Afterword 219
- Subject index 225
Chapters in this book
- Prelim pages i
- Table of contents v
- List of contributors vii
- Preface xi
- Acknowledgments xiii
- Chapter 1. Introduction 1
-
Part 1. Foundations of fictional worlds
- Chapter 2. Immersion and emergence in children’s literature 15
- Chapter 3. A predictive coding approach to Text World Theory 33
- Chapter 4. World-building as cognitive feedback loop 53
-
Part 2. Forming fictional worlds
- Chapter 5. Experiencing horrible worlds 75
- Chapter 6. Framing the narrative 97
- Chapter 7. Constructing inferiority through comic characterisation 119
- Chapter 8. Cognitive grammar and reconstrual 135
-
Part 3. Fictional worlds in context
- Chapter 9. Immersive reading and the unnatural text-worlds of “Dead Fish” 157
- Chapter 10. Experiencing literature in the poetry classroom 177
- Chapter 11. Sharing fiction 199
- Chapter 12. Afterword 219
- Subject index 225