Saying Amen to the Light of Dawn: Nietzsche on Praise, Prayer, and Affirmation

Hans Ruin

doi:10.1515/nietzstu-2019-0007

Article

Saying Amen to the Light of Dawn: Nietzsche on Praise, Prayer, and Affirmation

Hans Ruin

Published/Copyright: November 21, 2019

Published by

Become an author with De Gruyter Brill

Submit Manuscript Author Information Explore this Subject

From the journal Nietzsche-Studien Volume 48 Issue 1

Abstract

This article addresses the role and meaning of prayer as well as the language of piety and praise in Nietzsche’s writings, notably in Zarathustra.<fnote> This essay was first presented as a talk in German at the 2017 Nietzsche colloquium in Sils Maria, the theme of which was “Zarathustra und Dionysos”. In preparing it for a publication in English, the argument has been reworked and expanded and references have been added, while partly preserving the tone and structure of the oral delivery. I am grateful to the instructive comments and suggestions of the anonymous reviewers for Nietzsche-Studien.</fnote> Nietzsche can be read as an uncompromising critic of religion but also as the initiator of a new form of faith, described by some scholars as a “Dionysian piety”. The analysis takes its lead from the way in which Z refers to his yes-saying as also saying “amen”, exploring how Nietzsche explicitly incorporates the language of religious discourse into his writing. Examining passages where he explicitly questions the adoption of confessional language and prayer, it criticizes as overly simplistic the view of his thinking as seeking a new piety. The discussion of the significance of prayer from a psychological, linguistic, and poetological perspective highlights the experience of “inspiration” as a key to the adoption of confessional language in Z. In an interpretation of the last part of this book, it shows how its concluding scenes coalesce precisely around the role and possibility of prayer and piety, and how a crisis in the narrative is triggered by the inability of Zarathustra’s visitors to properly understand his message in this regard. A concluding interpretation of the section “Before Sunrise” in the third part of the book shows how it gathers the philosophical stakes involved in Nietzsche’s understanding of prayer, piety, and confessional praise.

Keywords: Prayer; Religion; Affirmation; Praise; Inspiration; Zarathustra; Dionysos

Bibliography

Baeumer, Max L.: “Nietzsche and the Tradition of the Dionysian”, in James C. O’Flaherty / Timothy F. Sellner / Robert M. Helm (eds.), Studies in Nietzsche and the Classical Tradition, Chapel Hill, NC 1979, 165–189Search in Google Scholar

Benson, Bruce Ellis: Pious Nietzsche: Decadence and Dionysian Faith, Bloomington, IN 2008Search in Google Scholar

Benson, Bruce Ellis / Wirzba, Norman (eds.): The Phenomenology of Prayer, New York 200510.5422/fso/9780823224951.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Böschenstein, Bernhard: “Frucht des Gewitters”: Zu Hölderlins Dionysos als Gott der Revolution, Frankfurt a. M. 1990Search in Google Scholar

Deleuze, Gilles: Nietzsche and Philosophy, trans. Hugh Tomlinson, New York 198310.5040/9781350322370Search in Google Scholar

Fraser, Giles: Redeeming Nietzsche: On the Piety of Unbelief, New York 200210.4324/9780203427873Search in Google Scholar

Heiler, Friedrich: Das Gebet: Eine religionsgeschichtliche und religionspsychologische Untersuchung, Munich 1918Search in Google Scholar

Jung, Christian: “Nietzsche und die Theologie: Neue Standpunkte zu einem verhältnislosen Verhältnis”, Nietzsche-Studien 38 (2009), 486–49310.1515/9783110208924.7.486Search in Google Scholar

Lippitt, John / Urpeth, Jim (eds.): Nietzsche and the Divine, Manchester 2000Search in Google Scholar

Mensch, James R.: “Prayer as Kenosis”, in Bruce Ellis Benson / Norman Wirzba (eds.), The Phenomenology of Prayer, New York 2005, 63–7210.5422/fso/9780823224951.003.0005Search in Google Scholar

Roberts, Tyler T.: Contesting Spirit: Nietzsche, Affirmation, Religion, Princeton, NJ 199810.1515/9781400822614Search in Google Scholar

Ruin, Hans: “Saying the Sacred”, in Jonna Bornemark / Hans Ruin (eds.), Phenomenology and Religion: New Frontiers, Stockholm 2010, 291–310Search in Google Scholar

Westphal, Merold: “Prayer as the Posture of the Decentered Self”, in Bruce Ellis Benson / Norman Wirzba (eds.), The Phenomenology of Prayer, New York 2005, 13–3110.5422/fso/9780823224951.003.0002Search in Google Scholar

Wienand, Isabelle: “Gebet/beten”, in Nietzsche-Wörterbuch, ed. Nietzsche Research Group / Paul van Tongeren / Gerd Schank / Herman Siemens, DOI: 10.1515/NO_W017186_0078Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2019-11-21

Published in Print: 2019-11-01

You are currently not able to access this content.

Articles in the same Issue

https://doi.org/10.1515/nietzstu-2019-0007

Keywords for this article

Prayer; Religion; Affirmation; Praise; Inspiration; Zarathustra; Dionysos