Home Classical, Ancient Near Eastern & Egyptian Studies Caesurae, Cola, and Discourse Acts: A Functional Discourse Grammar Approach to Homeric Colometry
Chapter Publicly Available

Caesurae, Cola, and Discourse Acts: A Functional Discourse Grammar Approach to Homeric Colometry

  • Rutger J. Allan

    Rutger J. Allan is Associate Professor of Ancient Greek at the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam. He has published on a variety of topics in Ancient Greek linguistics relating to verbal semantics and discourse analysis, and has a particular interest in cognitive linguistic and narratological approaches to Greek narrative texts. He is the author of The Middle Voice in Ancient Greek. A Study in Polysemy (2003), and coeditor of The Language of Literature (2007) and The Greek Future and its History (2017).
Become an author with De Gruyter Brill
Explore this Subject How to publish with us
Advances in Ancient Greek Linguistics
This chapter is in the book Advances in Ancient Greek Linguistics

Abstract

One of the most influential colometric models of the Homeric hexameter is that of Hermann Fränkel (1926). Fränkel’s model revolves around the idea that each hexameter is divided into four cola, separated from one another by three caesurae that were audible in performance as intonational boundaries, and that were, at the same time, sense boundaries (“Sinnesfuge”). A shortcoming of Fränkel’s intuitively attractive approach is that it does not formulate explicit linguistic criteria that can be used to determine caesura positions. I argue that a Functional Discourse Grammar approach is able to provide these missing linguistic criteria, by treating caesurae as discourse-pragmatic boundaries. With this approach, most caesurae can be analyzed as boundaries between extra-clausal constituents (expressing Subsidiary Discourse Acts, such as Themes, Settings, Elaborations, and vocatives) and their host clause (Nuclear Discourse Act). I also postulate the existence of cola with the pragmatic function of Left-dislocated Focus. A discourse-pragmatic approach along these lines by and large confirms Fränkel’s central claim: the vast majority of the hexameters can indeed be divided into four cola. However, such an approach also provides evidence for a more flexible view, usually associated with Kirk’s approach to colometry, that not all word divisions at regular caesura positions are sense boundaries, resulting in two or three-colon lines. These exceptional cases, however, are less frequent than Kirk claims.

Abstract

One of the most influential colometric models of the Homeric hexameter is that of Hermann Fränkel (1926). Fränkel’s model revolves around the idea that each hexameter is divided into four cola, separated from one another by three caesurae that were audible in performance as intonational boundaries, and that were, at the same time, sense boundaries (“Sinnesfuge”). A shortcoming of Fränkel’s intuitively attractive approach is that it does not formulate explicit linguistic criteria that can be used to determine caesura positions. I argue that a Functional Discourse Grammar approach is able to provide these missing linguistic criteria, by treating caesurae as discourse-pragmatic boundaries. With this approach, most caesurae can be analyzed as boundaries between extra-clausal constituents (expressing Subsidiary Discourse Acts, such as Themes, Settings, Elaborations, and vocatives) and their host clause (Nuclear Discourse Act). I also postulate the existence of cola with the pragmatic function of Left-dislocated Focus. A discourse-pragmatic approach along these lines by and large confirms Fränkel’s central claim: the vast majority of the hexameters can indeed be divided into four cola. However, such an approach also provides evidence for a more flexible view, usually associated with Kirk’s approach to colometry, that not all word divisions at regular caesura positions are sense boundaries, resulting in two or three-colon lines. These exceptional cases, however, are less frequent than Kirk claims.

Chapters in this book

  1. frontmatter I
  2. Preface V
  3. Contents IX
  4. List of Figures and Diagrams XV
  5. List of Tables XVII
  6. Abbreviations XXI
  7. Part I History of the Greek Language, Phonetics, Morphology
  8. Linguistic Variation and the Study of Ancient Greek Dialects 3
  9. Open Questions in Ancient Greek Phonology: Some New Evidence from Enclitics 33
  10. Post-Nasal Deaspiration in Ancient Greek: Mirage or Reality? 65
  11. Greek Verbs in -βω: A Survey 81
  12. Action Nouns in -τιζ/-σιζ as Second Members of Nominal Compounds in Greek 93
  13. The Syntax and Semantics of ([N+V]V) Verbal Compounds in Ancient Greek 107
  14. Σκορακίζω: ‘Curse (by Saying ἐζ κόρακαζ)’. About Delocutive Derivation in Ancient Greek and Performative 127
  15. Part II Lexicon, Semantics
  16. Nature-based Metaphors as Body-part Terms in Ancient Greek: On καρπόζ ‘Wrist’ and ἀστράγαλοζ ‘Ankle(Bone)’ 147
  17. Grammaticalization of Adverbs in Ancient Greek: The Case of Homeric μάλα 159
  18. Smells like Metonymy 179
  19. Cultural Reconstruction through Linguistic Analysis: The Case of AG ταρχύω and ταριχ∊ύω 195
  20. On Hom. ἐπίφρων and πρόφρων in View of Homeric Human Physiology 211
  21. Analytical Constructions and Synthetic Encoding of Complex Predicates at the Semantics-Pragmatics Interface 225
  22. Part III Syntax 1: Clause
  23. Number Agreement of a Predicate in Singular with Two or More Coordinated Noun Phrases in Nominative in Homer 247
  24. The Construction of the Verb μιμνήσκομαι in the Homeric Language 261
  25. On a Double Case Construction in Ancient Greek: The Whole-Part Construction in Homeric Greek 279
  26. Taking Stock of Greek Support-Verb Constructions: Synchronic and Diachronic Variability in the Documentary Papyri 297
  27. Hyperbaton in Herodotus: A Functional Discourse Grammar Perspective 315
  28. Adverb Placement in Demosthenes’ First Philippic 335
  29. Case Attraction in Infinitive Clauses: A Distributive Account 351
  30. Part IV Syntax 2: Verb and Modality
  31. Dangling between Diachrony, Register and Atticism: A Language Ecology Approach to Modal Morphosyntax in Post-Classical Greek 373
  32. Information Source and Epistemic Modality in the Classical Usage of ἀνάγκη and ἀναγκαῖον 389
  33. The Preverb ἀντι- in Ancient Greek: From Space to Reciprocity 409
  34. Part V Syntax 3: Coordination and Subordination
  35. Null-Subject Genitive Absolute and Co-Referentiality in 5th Cent. BCE Ionic and Attic Prose 435
  36. On the Oblique Optative in Ionic and Attic Prose Completive Sentences with ὥζ and ὅτι: Remarks Towards a Comparative Study 451
  37. Relativization of Syntactic and Semantic Functions in Classical Greek: A Case Study Based on Sophocles’ Heptad 467
  38. Backgrounding, Theticals and Periphrastic τυγχάν∊ιν 483
  39. βούλ∊ι/-∊σθ∊, θέλ∊ιζ/-∊τ∊ Plus Subjunctive in Classical Greek: Subordination or Coordination? 499
  40. Relative Clauses in Septuagint Greek: Some Preliminary Remarks 515
  41. Addition Clauses in Ancient Greek 535
  42. Pragmatic and Discursive Functions of Non-Canonical Conditional Sentences 553
  43. The Mixed Pattern and the Other Conjunctive Strategies in Herodotus’ Greek: An Analysis from a Typological Perspective 569
  44. Participle Constructions in Post-Classical Greek: The Example of the “Confessions” of Asia Minor 587
  45. Part VI Pragmatics and Discourse
  46. Caesurae, Cola, and Discourse Acts: A Functional Discourse Grammar Approach to Homeric Colometry 609
  47. Vocative and ‘Terms of Address’ in the Odyssey 627
  48. The Pragmatics of Rhetorical Questions in Sophocles’ Tragedies: An Analysis of Antigone and Electra 641
  49. Verbal Impoliteness in Greek Oratory: The Case of οὗτοζ 659
  50. From Disjunct to Connective: The Particle οὖν in Herodotus’ Histories and its Association with Anaphoric Elements 671
  51. On the Use of the Interjection ὦ in the Dialogues of the Odyssey: An Analysis of (ὦ) γέρον, (ὦ) γύναι, and (ὦ) ξ∊ῖν∊ 683
  52. Structure and Function in Catalogic Discourse: The Case of Iliadic Androktasíai 701
  53. Part VII Digital Research
  54. Linguistic Annotation for a Catalog of Ancient Greek Authors and Works 721
  55. Formulaic Networks as Prototypical Categories: Combining the Ancient Greek Dependency Treebank with the Ancient Greek WordNet for a Pilot Study on the Iliad 737
  56. Linguistic Complexity in Ancient Greek: Sentence Complexity and Digital Treebanks 759
  57. Representing Semantic Roles in Greek Treebanks 777
  58. “Proleptic” Arguments in the Greek Treebanks 795
  59. Tongue, Language or Noise? Word Sense Disambiguation in Ancient Greek with Corpus-Based Methods 813
  60. List of Contributors 829
  61. Index Locorum
  62. Index Rerum
https://doi.org/10.1515/9783111648644-034

Chapters in this book

  1. frontmatter I
  2. Preface V
  3. Contents IX
  4. List of Figures and Diagrams XV
  5. List of Tables XVII
  6. Abbreviations XXI
  7. Part I History of the Greek Language, Phonetics, Morphology
  8. Linguistic Variation and the Study of Ancient Greek Dialects 3
  9. Open Questions in Ancient Greek Phonology: Some New Evidence from Enclitics 33
  10. Post-Nasal Deaspiration in Ancient Greek: Mirage or Reality? 65
  11. Greek Verbs in -βω: A Survey 81
  12. Action Nouns in -τιζ/-σιζ as Second Members of Nominal Compounds in Greek 93
  13. The Syntax and Semantics of ([N+V]V) Verbal Compounds in Ancient Greek 107
  14. Σκορακίζω: ‘Curse (by Saying ἐζ κόρακαζ)’. About Delocutive Derivation in Ancient Greek and Performative 127
  15. Part II Lexicon, Semantics
  16. Nature-based Metaphors as Body-part Terms in Ancient Greek: On καρπόζ ‘Wrist’ and ἀστράγαλοζ ‘Ankle(Bone)’ 147
  17. Grammaticalization of Adverbs in Ancient Greek: The Case of Homeric μάλα 159
  18. Smells like Metonymy 179
  19. Cultural Reconstruction through Linguistic Analysis: The Case of AG ταρχύω and ταριχ∊ύω 195
  20. On Hom. ἐπίφρων and πρόφρων in View of Homeric Human Physiology 211
  21. Analytical Constructions and Synthetic Encoding of Complex Predicates at the Semantics-Pragmatics Interface 225
  22. Part III Syntax 1: Clause
  23. Number Agreement of a Predicate in Singular with Two or More Coordinated Noun Phrases in Nominative in Homer 247
  24. The Construction of the Verb μιμνήσκομαι in the Homeric Language 261
  25. On a Double Case Construction in Ancient Greek: The Whole-Part Construction in Homeric Greek 279
  26. Taking Stock of Greek Support-Verb Constructions: Synchronic and Diachronic Variability in the Documentary Papyri 297
  27. Hyperbaton in Herodotus: A Functional Discourse Grammar Perspective 315
  28. Adverb Placement in Demosthenes’ First Philippic 335
  29. Case Attraction in Infinitive Clauses: A Distributive Account 351
  30. Part IV Syntax 2: Verb and Modality
  31. Dangling between Diachrony, Register and Atticism: A Language Ecology Approach to Modal Morphosyntax in Post-Classical Greek 373
  32. Information Source and Epistemic Modality in the Classical Usage of ἀνάγκη and ἀναγκαῖον 389
  33. The Preverb ἀντι- in Ancient Greek: From Space to Reciprocity 409
  34. Part V Syntax 3: Coordination and Subordination
  35. Null-Subject Genitive Absolute and Co-Referentiality in 5th Cent. BCE Ionic and Attic Prose 435
  36. On the Oblique Optative in Ionic and Attic Prose Completive Sentences with ὥζ and ὅτι: Remarks Towards a Comparative Study 451
  37. Relativization of Syntactic and Semantic Functions in Classical Greek: A Case Study Based on Sophocles’ Heptad 467
  38. Backgrounding, Theticals and Periphrastic τυγχάν∊ιν 483
  39. βούλ∊ι/-∊σθ∊, θέλ∊ιζ/-∊τ∊ Plus Subjunctive in Classical Greek: Subordination or Coordination? 499
  40. Relative Clauses in Septuagint Greek: Some Preliminary Remarks 515
  41. Addition Clauses in Ancient Greek 535
  42. Pragmatic and Discursive Functions of Non-Canonical Conditional Sentences 553
  43. The Mixed Pattern and the Other Conjunctive Strategies in Herodotus’ Greek: An Analysis from a Typological Perspective 569
  44. Participle Constructions in Post-Classical Greek: The Example of the “Confessions” of Asia Minor 587
  45. Part VI Pragmatics and Discourse
  46. Caesurae, Cola, and Discourse Acts: A Functional Discourse Grammar Approach to Homeric Colometry 609
  47. Vocative and ‘Terms of Address’ in the Odyssey 627
  48. The Pragmatics of Rhetorical Questions in Sophocles’ Tragedies: An Analysis of Antigone and Electra 641
  49. Verbal Impoliteness in Greek Oratory: The Case of οὗτοζ 659
  50. From Disjunct to Connective: The Particle οὖν in Herodotus’ Histories and its Association with Anaphoric Elements 671
  51. On the Use of the Interjection ὦ in the Dialogues of the Odyssey: An Analysis of (ὦ) γέρον, (ὦ) γύναι, and (ὦ) ξ∊ῖν∊ 683
  52. Structure and Function in Catalogic Discourse: The Case of Iliadic Androktasíai 701
  53. Part VII Digital Research
  54. Linguistic Annotation for a Catalog of Ancient Greek Authors and Works 721
  55. Formulaic Networks as Prototypical Categories: Combining the Ancient Greek Dependency Treebank with the Ancient Greek WordNet for a Pilot Study on the Iliad 737
  56. Linguistic Complexity in Ancient Greek: Sentence Complexity and Digital Treebanks 759
  57. Representing Semantic Roles in Greek Treebanks 777
  58. “Proleptic” Arguments in the Greek Treebanks 795
  59. Tongue, Language or Noise? Word Sense Disambiguation in Ancient Greek with Corpus-Based Methods 813
  60. List of Contributors 829
  61. Index Locorum
  62. Index Rerum
Sign up now to receive a 20% welcome discount
Institutional Access
How does access work?
Have an idea on how to improve our website?
Please write us.
© 2025 De Gruyter Brill
Downloaded on 17.10.2025 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9783111648644-034/html
Scroll to top button