6 Beauty and the Duty to be Beautiful
-
Maria Borges
Maria Borges is full professor of Philosophy at the University of Santa Catarina (Brazil). She is the author ofEmotion, Reason and Action in Kant (Bloomsbury, 2019), editor of the collectionJustice and Democracy in Brazil (Cambridge Scholars Publishing, 2023), Filosofia Feminista (Feminist Philosophy) (SENACSP, 2023) and Amor e Dor (Love and Pain) (Editora da UFSC, forthcoming). She published, with Cinara Nahra, the bookBody and Justice (Cambridge Scholars Publishing, 2011). Her philosophical interests are Kant, ethics, theory of emotions and feminist philosophy.
Abstract
In this chapter, I aim at analyzing the importance of beauty for contemporary women. I begin by showing some traditional views in the history of philosophy, such as Kant’s conception that “woman is beautiful while man is sublime.” I claim that beauty is still considered one of the main assets for women, not only in the “dating scene” but also in the pursue of a carrier. I show the criticism of beauty practices in the feminist literature. From the 20th century on, we see that aesthetic procedures and cosmetic surgeries can be enjoyed by an increasing number of women. If, on the one hand, this indicates a greater autonomy in relation to the body, on the other hand, being beautiful becomes a moral duty. At the end, I investigate whether beauty is always oppressive, or we could create a new inclusive idea that incorporates a plurality of bodies.
Abstract
In this chapter, I aim at analyzing the importance of beauty for contemporary women. I begin by showing some traditional views in the history of philosophy, such as Kant’s conception that “woman is beautiful while man is sublime.” I claim that beauty is still considered one of the main assets for women, not only in the “dating scene” but also in the pursue of a carrier. I show the criticism of beauty practices in the feminist literature. From the 20th century on, we see that aesthetic procedures and cosmetic surgeries can be enjoyed by an increasing number of women. If, on the one hand, this indicates a greater autonomy in relation to the body, on the other hand, being beautiful becomes a moral duty. At the end, I investigate whether beauty is always oppressive, or we could create a new inclusive idea that incorporates a plurality of bodies.
Chapters in this book
- Frontmatter V
- Table of Contents V
- List of Abbreviations
- 1 Introduction Women and Their Body: Breaking the Silence 1
-
Part I The Feminist Perspective
- 2 The Panoptic Gaze: Female Body and Place 19
- 3 The Female Body and Freedom: Conflict of Life or Colonial Dilemma in Marko Vovchok’s Narrations? 41
- 4 Relative (Non-)Existence of Female-Specific Neuropathology in Current Neuroimaging Research into Hysteria/Functional Neurological Disorders 53
- 5 Sexual Bodies: On Desire and Pleasure in Feminist and Thoughts 79
- 6 Beauty and the Duty to be Beautiful 95
- 7 Beauty Practices and Ukrainian Women Refugees in the Context of Russia-Ukraine War: Another Double Bind 109
-
Part II The Feminist Ethics Perspective
- 8 Distractibility: Wandering Between Mary Wollstonecraft and Jane Austen 129
- 9 On Being ‘Indisposed’ to Study and Work, or the Discourse of the Victorian Women’s Menstruation 147
- 10 Female Reproductive Bodies and the Shift from Risk to Threat Society: The (Mis)Use of the Powers of Pregnancy in Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale and Amy Ewing’s The Lone City-Series 163
- 11 Andrea Dworkin. Life, Death, War, and Virginity: A Radical Truth 179
- 12 Reproduction, Structural Injustice, and the Problem of Speaking for Others 197
-
Part III The Phenomenological Perspective
- 13 Women, Bodies, and Experiences: Feminist Interventions in the Philosophy of the Body 213
- 14 Between Feminist Phenomenology and Socio-Structural Critique: The Hybrid Construction of Female Embodiment in the Early Theoretical Framework of Iris Marion Young as a Locus of Radical Interdisciplinarity 233
- 15 Confined Spatiality as Deontological Feeling: Iris Marion Young, the Embodied Sense of Entitlement and Its Varieties 251
- 16 Mothers Matter: Discussing Motherhood in Gender Studies and Feminist New Materialisms 269
-
Part IV The Alternative Femininities Perspective
- 17 The Female Body and Leontion: Why Were Epicurean Women Capable of Philosophy? 287
- 18 Do Women Think with Their Body? Descartes, Malebranche, Poulain de la Barre 303
- 19 Arca as Demiurge: Cyborg’s Body, Mutant’s Body 321
- 20 The Reinvention of the Human Body: Cyborgs, String Figures and New Boundaries 339
- List of Contributors 339
- List of names
- List of subjects
Chapters in this book
- Frontmatter V
- Table of Contents V
- List of Abbreviations
- 1 Introduction Women and Their Body: Breaking the Silence 1
-
Part I The Feminist Perspective
- 2 The Panoptic Gaze: Female Body and Place 19
- 3 The Female Body and Freedom: Conflict of Life or Colonial Dilemma in Marko Vovchok’s Narrations? 41
- 4 Relative (Non-)Existence of Female-Specific Neuropathology in Current Neuroimaging Research into Hysteria/Functional Neurological Disorders 53
- 5 Sexual Bodies: On Desire and Pleasure in Feminist and Thoughts 79
- 6 Beauty and the Duty to be Beautiful 95
- 7 Beauty Practices and Ukrainian Women Refugees in the Context of Russia-Ukraine War: Another Double Bind 109
-
Part II The Feminist Ethics Perspective
- 8 Distractibility: Wandering Between Mary Wollstonecraft and Jane Austen 129
- 9 On Being ‘Indisposed’ to Study and Work, or the Discourse of the Victorian Women’s Menstruation 147
- 10 Female Reproductive Bodies and the Shift from Risk to Threat Society: The (Mis)Use of the Powers of Pregnancy in Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale and Amy Ewing’s The Lone City-Series 163
- 11 Andrea Dworkin. Life, Death, War, and Virginity: A Radical Truth 179
- 12 Reproduction, Structural Injustice, and the Problem of Speaking for Others 197
-
Part III The Phenomenological Perspective
- 13 Women, Bodies, and Experiences: Feminist Interventions in the Philosophy of the Body 213
- 14 Between Feminist Phenomenology and Socio-Structural Critique: The Hybrid Construction of Female Embodiment in the Early Theoretical Framework of Iris Marion Young as a Locus of Radical Interdisciplinarity 233
- 15 Confined Spatiality as Deontological Feeling: Iris Marion Young, the Embodied Sense of Entitlement and Its Varieties 251
- 16 Mothers Matter: Discussing Motherhood in Gender Studies and Feminist New Materialisms 269
-
Part IV The Alternative Femininities Perspective
- 17 The Female Body and Leontion: Why Were Epicurean Women Capable of Philosophy? 287
- 18 Do Women Think with Their Body? Descartes, Malebranche, Poulain de la Barre 303
- 19 Arca as Demiurge: Cyborg’s Body, Mutant’s Body 321
- 20 The Reinvention of the Human Body: Cyborgs, String Figures and New Boundaries 339
- List of Contributors 339
- List of names
- List of subjects