The impact of globalization and Europeanization on the societal foundations of Brexit
-
Stefan A. Schirm
Abstract
How and why did a society’s ideas and interests concerning international economic integration shape politicians’ nation-centered policy (NCP) preferences? Which form of critical junctures and turning points contributed to strengthening demands for NCP? I argue that the traditional LIO, globalization and economic regionalization had two core adverse effects on large segments of Western societies, which triggered socioeconomic divisions and rising support for NCP. First, the liberalization of finance and trade in the framework of international organizations like the WTO and EU contributed to economic losses and gains that increased inequality of income distribution. This has alienated voters that materially lost or only gained little and de-legitimized international integration in the eyes of voters who grew ideationally discontent with inequality. Second, the increasing powers of seemingly opaque and non-accountable multilateral bureaucracies and rules have left many voters with the impression of heteronomy and loss of control. These effects of international economic integration have prompted some parties and politicians to grasp discontent and advocate a more nation-centered course, especially in liberal market economies with weak compensation for economic inequality, such as in the United Kingdom. Following the Societal Approach, these arguments will be examined regarding UK’s Brexit decision.
Abstract
How and why did a society’s ideas and interests concerning international economic integration shape politicians’ nation-centered policy (NCP) preferences? Which form of critical junctures and turning points contributed to strengthening demands for NCP? I argue that the traditional LIO, globalization and economic regionalization had two core adverse effects on large segments of Western societies, which triggered socioeconomic divisions and rising support for NCP. First, the liberalization of finance and trade in the framework of international organizations like the WTO and EU contributed to economic losses and gains that increased inequality of income distribution. This has alienated voters that materially lost or only gained little and de-legitimized international integration in the eyes of voters who grew ideationally discontent with inequality. Second, the increasing powers of seemingly opaque and non-accountable multilateral bureaucracies and rules have left many voters with the impression of heteronomy and loss of control. These effects of international economic integration have prompted some parties and politicians to grasp discontent and advocate a more nation-centered course, especially in liberal market economies with weak compensation for economic inequality, such as in the United Kingdom. Following the Societal Approach, these arguments will be examined regarding UK’s Brexit decision.
Chapters in this book
- Frontmatter I
- Preface V
- About the Editors VII
- Contents IX
- Introduction: Turning Points, Typology, and Puzzles 1
-
I Pushing Back Globalisation? Brexit and Trump
- The impact of globalization and Europeanization on the societal foundations of Brexit 17
- Brexit: From ever closer union to differentiated integration? 35
- The American public and Trump’s trade war with China 53
- Digitalization, Trumpismo, and the end of the liberal world order? 75
-
II Challenging the World Order? China, Russia, and Ukraine
- The end of the age of military intervention: Liberal interventionism and global order since the end of the Cold War 99
- Crowding out the West? China’s Belt and Road Initiative and the Asian infrastructure investment bank 117
- American renewal or decline? The Biden administration, Europe, and the invasion of Ukraine 143
-
III Calling for Social Change? Norms and Practices
- A tipping point in feminist foreign policy in Europe? A constructivist analysis based on the norm life cycle model 169
- The turning point that was not: The Arab Spring, realism, and the circularity of Western policies toward the Arab world 189
- Emerging and fading practices in the era of the internet: A reflexive approach to analysing intelligence professionals’ changing practices of data collection 209
-
IV Changing Frozen Policies? Migration, Health, and Lobbying
- The 2015 refugee situation as a turning point? Migration- and integration-related debates in the German Bundestag 233
- COVID-19 as a potential turning point in German health policy 257
- Obstacles on the path to lobbying transparency in Europe: Assessing the German turning point at the end of the Merkel era 279
-
V Dealing with Crises? Leadership and Market
- Re-regulating the European high-tech capitalism? The EU’s digitalization strategy at a turning point after the COVID-19 pandemic 311
- The Social Market Economy and institutional development: Change in times of crisis 335
-
VI Reflecting on Uncertainty? Epistemics and Critique
- The emergent discourse on global threats and risks: An analysis of the contemporary empirical evidence extant in scientific journals 351
- On the precipice of the unknown: Discussing the paradigm of uncertainty as a political challenge to Western democracies 383
- Index 407
Chapters in this book
- Frontmatter I
- Preface V
- About the Editors VII
- Contents IX
- Introduction: Turning Points, Typology, and Puzzles 1
-
I Pushing Back Globalisation? Brexit and Trump
- The impact of globalization and Europeanization on the societal foundations of Brexit 17
- Brexit: From ever closer union to differentiated integration? 35
- The American public and Trump’s trade war with China 53
- Digitalization, Trumpismo, and the end of the liberal world order? 75
-
II Challenging the World Order? China, Russia, and Ukraine
- The end of the age of military intervention: Liberal interventionism and global order since the end of the Cold War 99
- Crowding out the West? China’s Belt and Road Initiative and the Asian infrastructure investment bank 117
- American renewal or decline? The Biden administration, Europe, and the invasion of Ukraine 143
-
III Calling for Social Change? Norms and Practices
- A tipping point in feminist foreign policy in Europe? A constructivist analysis based on the norm life cycle model 169
- The turning point that was not: The Arab Spring, realism, and the circularity of Western policies toward the Arab world 189
- Emerging and fading practices in the era of the internet: A reflexive approach to analysing intelligence professionals’ changing practices of data collection 209
-
IV Changing Frozen Policies? Migration, Health, and Lobbying
- The 2015 refugee situation as a turning point? Migration- and integration-related debates in the German Bundestag 233
- COVID-19 as a potential turning point in German health policy 257
- Obstacles on the path to lobbying transparency in Europe: Assessing the German turning point at the end of the Merkel era 279
-
V Dealing with Crises? Leadership and Market
- Re-regulating the European high-tech capitalism? The EU’s digitalization strategy at a turning point after the COVID-19 pandemic 311
- The Social Market Economy and institutional development: Change in times of crisis 335
-
VI Reflecting on Uncertainty? Epistemics and Critique
- The emergent discourse on global threats and risks: An analysis of the contemporary empirical evidence extant in scientific journals 351
- On the precipice of the unknown: Discussing the paradigm of uncertainty as a political challenge to Western democracies 383
- Index 407