Homeland Security as International Security? The Case for International Relations as Disciplinary Model
-
Marcus Holmes
Abstract
This article joins the growing debate regarding the current and future state of the homeland security affairs discipline. This debate has asked questions about what the discipline should be studying, how those studies should be conducted, and where the discipline should move in the future. I argue that many of these debates have focused on methodology; this is putting the cart before the horse. Homeland security needs to concern itself with questions of ontology and epistemology before it can tackle methodology. I illustrate why these questions are vital and suggest ways in which they may be approached. Ultimately I suggest that the discipline of International Relations offers useful insights here as a disciplinary model as it has self-consciously asked, and answered, these same questions through a series of sustained debates. The article concludes by investigating what a IR-inspired homeland security affairs discipline might look like.
©2012 Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, Berlin/Boston
Artikel in diesem Heft
- Research Article
- Use of Small-Scale Test Data to Enhance Fire-Related Threat, Vulnerability, Consequence and Risk Assessment for Passenger Rail Vehicles
- Strategic Cyber Defense: Which Way Forward?
- Effect of a Marketing Program on Freshman Student Registration for an Emergency Notification System
- Strategic uses of Lessons for Building Collaborative Emergency Management System: Comparative Analysis of Hurricane Katrina and Hurricane Gustav Response Systems
- The Relationship between Turkey's Provinces' Development Levels and Social and Economic Vulnerability to Disasters
- A Review of the Key Legal dynamics of Chinese Military Involvement in Domestic Disaster Relief (MI/DDR)
- Testing Social Vulnerability Theory: A Quantitative Study of Hurricane Katrina's Perceived Impact on Residents living in FEMA Designated Disaster Areas
- If You Can't Trust, Stick to Hierarchy: Structure and Trust as Contingency Factors in Threat Assessment Contexts
- Regional Disaster Risk: Assessment and Mitigation Concepts in an All-Hazards Context
- Evacuation Patterns of Ethnic Groups Under Fire
- Risk Informed Decision Framework for Integrated Evaluation of Countermeasures against CBRN Threats
- The Influence of Politics on Federal Disaster Declaration Decision Delays
- Cross-Sectoral Scanning of Critical Infrastructures: from Functional Differences to Policy-Relevant Similarities
- Identifying Communication Strategies in Cases of Domestic Terrorism: Applying Cultural Context to the Fort Hood Shooting
- The Evolving Role of the Public Information Officer: An Examination of Social Media in Emergency Management
- Structural Dynamics of Organizations during the Evolution of Interorganizational Networks in Disaster Response
- Investigating the Roots of Crisis Management Studies and Outlining Future Trajectories for the Field
- The Multiplicity of Actors Involved in Securing America's Food Imports
- Homeland Security as International Security? The Case for International Relations as Disciplinary Model
- Challenges for Multi-sector Organizations in Tracking and Sheltering Registered Sex Offenders in Disasters
- Communicating H1N1 Risk to College Students: A Regional Cross-Sectional Survey Study
- Cultural Influence on the Implementation of Incident Command System for Emergency Management of Natural Disasters
- Influencing Factors of Emergency Information Spreading in Online Social Networks: A Simulation Approach
- Responding in Crises: A Comparative Analysis of Disaster Responses between Mainland China and Taiwan
- Updating the National Planning Scenarios: Using Wicked Problems and Capability-Based Planning Concepts for Homeland Security
- The 'Titanic Syndrome': Risk and Crisis Management on the Costa Concordia
- Book Reviews
- Review of Freedom and Order: How Democratic Governments Restrict Civil Liberties after Terrorist Attacks - and Why Sometimes They Don't
- Review of National Security Reform: How Commissions Can Drive Change During Crises
- Review of The Four Stages of Highly Effective Crisis Management
- Communication/News
- Public Health's Role in Understanding Community Resilience
- Identifying Factors that Influence Terrorist Decisions and Target Selection
- Opinion
- Emerging Dangers from Direct Botulinum Access and Use
- Failing to Establish a Unified Command in Louisiana During Hurricane Katrina
Artikel in diesem Heft
- Research Article
- Use of Small-Scale Test Data to Enhance Fire-Related Threat, Vulnerability, Consequence and Risk Assessment for Passenger Rail Vehicles
- Strategic Cyber Defense: Which Way Forward?
- Effect of a Marketing Program on Freshman Student Registration for an Emergency Notification System
- Strategic uses of Lessons for Building Collaborative Emergency Management System: Comparative Analysis of Hurricane Katrina and Hurricane Gustav Response Systems
- The Relationship between Turkey's Provinces' Development Levels and Social and Economic Vulnerability to Disasters
- A Review of the Key Legal dynamics of Chinese Military Involvement in Domestic Disaster Relief (MI/DDR)
- Testing Social Vulnerability Theory: A Quantitative Study of Hurricane Katrina's Perceived Impact on Residents living in FEMA Designated Disaster Areas
- If You Can't Trust, Stick to Hierarchy: Structure and Trust as Contingency Factors in Threat Assessment Contexts
- Regional Disaster Risk: Assessment and Mitigation Concepts in an All-Hazards Context
- Evacuation Patterns of Ethnic Groups Under Fire
- Risk Informed Decision Framework for Integrated Evaluation of Countermeasures against CBRN Threats
- The Influence of Politics on Federal Disaster Declaration Decision Delays
- Cross-Sectoral Scanning of Critical Infrastructures: from Functional Differences to Policy-Relevant Similarities
- Identifying Communication Strategies in Cases of Domestic Terrorism: Applying Cultural Context to the Fort Hood Shooting
- The Evolving Role of the Public Information Officer: An Examination of Social Media in Emergency Management
- Structural Dynamics of Organizations during the Evolution of Interorganizational Networks in Disaster Response
- Investigating the Roots of Crisis Management Studies and Outlining Future Trajectories for the Field
- The Multiplicity of Actors Involved in Securing America's Food Imports
- Homeland Security as International Security? The Case for International Relations as Disciplinary Model
- Challenges for Multi-sector Organizations in Tracking and Sheltering Registered Sex Offenders in Disasters
- Communicating H1N1 Risk to College Students: A Regional Cross-Sectional Survey Study
- Cultural Influence on the Implementation of Incident Command System for Emergency Management of Natural Disasters
- Influencing Factors of Emergency Information Spreading in Online Social Networks: A Simulation Approach
- Responding in Crises: A Comparative Analysis of Disaster Responses between Mainland China and Taiwan
- Updating the National Planning Scenarios: Using Wicked Problems and Capability-Based Planning Concepts for Homeland Security
- The 'Titanic Syndrome': Risk and Crisis Management on the Costa Concordia
- Book Reviews
- Review of Freedom and Order: How Democratic Governments Restrict Civil Liberties after Terrorist Attacks - and Why Sometimes They Don't
- Review of National Security Reform: How Commissions Can Drive Change During Crises
- Review of The Four Stages of Highly Effective Crisis Management
- Communication/News
- Public Health's Role in Understanding Community Resilience
- Identifying Factors that Influence Terrorist Decisions and Target Selection
- Opinion
- Emerging Dangers from Direct Botulinum Access and Use
- Failing to Establish a Unified Command in Louisiana During Hurricane Katrina