Skip to main content
Presented to you through Paradigm Publishing Services

John Benjamins Publishing Company

Visit our Partner Page See all our books
Chapter
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

Chapter 14. Extra-syntactic factors in the that- trace effect

  • and

Abstract

Using predictions from the Interface Hypothesis and the grammar of Spanish-English bilinguals, we test whether non-syntactic factors play a role in the that-trace effect. Though generally analyzed syntactically, some work on that-trace supports a syntax-prosody account (Kandybowicz, 2006). The Interface Hypothesis predicts that bilinguals will have difficulty with interface phenomena but not narrow syntax, such that testing bilinguals’ knowledge of that-trace provides a unique testing ground for comparing the two approaches. We demonstrate that bilinguals have the syntactic underpinnings necessary for both syntactic and syntax-prosody accounts of that-trace; however, they differ from the monolinguals with regard to that-trace, extending the phenomenon’s restriction on extraction to a new context, supporting a syntax-prosody account of that-trace.

Abstract

Using predictions from the Interface Hypothesis and the grammar of Spanish-English bilinguals, we test whether non-syntactic factors play a role in the that-trace effect. Though generally analyzed syntactically, some work on that-trace supports a syntax-prosody account (Kandybowicz, 2006). The Interface Hypothesis predicts that bilinguals will have difficulty with interface phenomena but not narrow syntax, such that testing bilinguals’ knowledge of that-trace provides a unique testing ground for comparing the two approaches. We demonstrate that bilinguals have the syntactic underpinnings necessary for both syntactic and syntax-prosody accounts of that-trace; however, they differ from the monolinguals with regard to that-trace, extending the phenomenon’s restriction on extraction to a new context, supporting a syntax-prosody account of that-trace.

Chapters in this book

  1. Prelim pages i
  2. Table of contents v
  3. Preface ix
  4. Introduction 1
  5. Part 1. Language structure and use
  6. Chapter 1. se -marked directed motion constructions 11
  7. Chapter 2. Subcategorization and change 31
  8. Chapter 3. Variable clitic placement in US Spanish 49
  9. Chapter 4. Variable negative concord in Brazilian Portuguese 71
  10. Chapter 5. The simultaneous lenition of Spanish /ptk/ and /bdɡ/ as a chain shift in progress 95
  11. Chapter 6. Are Argentines a- blind? 121
  12. Chapter 7. The importance of motivated comparisons in variationist studies 143
  13. Chapter 8. The past persists into the present 169
  14. Chapter 9. “El vos nuestro es, ¡Ey vos , chigüín!” 191
  15. Part 2. Interacting grammars
  16. Chapter 10. Acquisition of articulatory control or language-specific coarticulatory patterns? 213
  17. Chapter 11. Voice onset time and the child foreign language learner of Spanish 237
  18. Chapter 12. “Extraña uno lo que es la tortillas” 259
  19. Chapter 13. Mothers’ use of F0 after the first year of life in American English and Peninsular Spanish 281
  20. Chapter 14. Extra-syntactic factors in the that- trace effect 309
  21. Chapter 15. An initial examination of imperfect subjunctive variation in Catalonian Spanish 333
  22. Chapter 16. Testing English influence on first person singular “yo” subject pronoun expression in Sonoran Spanish 355
  23. Index 373
Contemporary Trends in Hispanic and Lusophone Linguistics
This chapter is in the book Contemporary Trends in Hispanic and Lusophone Linguistics
https://doi.org/10.1075/ihll.15.15hei

Chapters in this book

  1. Prelim pages i
  2. Table of contents v
  3. Preface ix
  4. Introduction 1
  5. Part 1. Language structure and use
  6. Chapter 1. se -marked directed motion constructions 11
  7. Chapter 2. Subcategorization and change 31
  8. Chapter 3. Variable clitic placement in US Spanish 49
  9. Chapter 4. Variable negative concord in Brazilian Portuguese 71
  10. Chapter 5. The simultaneous lenition of Spanish /ptk/ and /bdɡ/ as a chain shift in progress 95
  11. Chapter 6. Are Argentines a- blind? 121
  12. Chapter 7. The importance of motivated comparisons in variationist studies 143
  13. Chapter 8. The past persists into the present 169
  14. Chapter 9. “El vos nuestro es, ¡Ey vos , chigüín!” 191
  15. Part 2. Interacting grammars
  16. Chapter 10. Acquisition of articulatory control or language-specific coarticulatory patterns? 213
  17. Chapter 11. Voice onset time and the child foreign language learner of Spanish 237
  18. Chapter 12. “Extraña uno lo que es la tortillas” 259
  19. Chapter 13. Mothers’ use of F0 after the first year of life in American English and Peninsular Spanish 281
  20. Chapter 14. Extra-syntactic factors in the that- trace effect 309
  21. Chapter 15. An initial examination of imperfect subjunctive variation in Catalonian Spanish 333
  22. Chapter 16. Testing English influence on first person singular “yo” subject pronoun expression in Sonoran Spanish 355
  23. Index 373
Downloaded on 19.4.2026 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1075/ihll.15.15hei/html
Scroll to top button