Home New Perspectives on the Date of the Great Festival of Ptolemy II
Article
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

New Perspectives on the Date of the Great Festival of Ptolemy II

  • Yuri Kuzmin EMAIL logo
Published/Copyright: February 7, 2018
Become an author with De Gruyter Brill

Summary:

The dating of the Great Festival at Alexandria described by Callixeinus (in Athenaeus) is controversial: the most widely accepted dates are the winters of 279/78, 275/74 or 271/70 BC. To the arguments for a date in the mid-270s BC should be added Athenaeus' mention (5.196 f) of a pavilion decorated with „silver“ and „golden“ thyreoi, i. e. oblong shields apparently of Celtic origin. This type of shield was not known in the Hellenistic East before the invasion of Celts into Asia Minor in 278 BC. Their appearance in the decoration of the pavilion may be connected to the destruction of the rebellious Celtic mercenaries of Ptolemy II Philadelphus on an island in the Nile Delta ca. 275 BC. This event was topical in royal propaganda of Philadelphus (in poetry, coinage, etc.). If the depiction of thyreoi alludes to this event 275/74 BC appears to be the most likely date for the Great Festival.

Acknowledgements:

I should like to extend my thanks to D. J. Thompson (Cambridge) as well as Ch. Fischer-Bovet (Los Angeles), K. M. Kalinin (Samara), I. A. Ladynin (Moscow), M. Minas-Nerpel (Swansea), V. P. Nikonorov (St. Petersburg), S. Pfeiffer (Halle), P. J. Rhodes (Durham) and A. L. Zelinskiy (Kiev). None of them, of course, is responsible for the conclusions set forth in this paper.

Bibliography

Barbantani (2001): S. Barbantani, Φάτις νικηφόρος. Frammenti di elegia encomiastica nell'età delle Guerre Galatiche: Supplementum Hellenisticum 958 e 969, Milan 2001.Search in Google Scholar

Bar-Kochva (1974): B. Bar-Kochva, Menas' Inscription and Corupedion, SCI 1, 1974, 14–23.Search in Google Scholar

Bennett (n.d.): C. Bennett, Arsinoe II (Available at http://www.tyndalehouse.com/egypt/ptolemies/arsinoe_ii_fr.htm).Search in Google Scholar

Bresciani et al. (2003): E. Bresciani – S. Giannotti – Ch. Gorini – L. Grassi – A. Menchetti – N. Rogoznica, Ancora sull'iscrizione demotica di Elefantina, Egitto e Vicino Oriente 26, 2003, 33–39.Search in Google Scholar

Bringmann (2000): K. Bringmann, Geben und Nehmen. Monarchische Wohltätigkeit und Selbstdarstellung im Zeitalter des Hellenismus, Berlin 2000.Search in Google Scholar

Calandra (2011): E. Calandra, The Ephemeral and the Eternal. The Pavilion of Ptolemy Philadelphos in the Court of Alexandria, Athens 2011.Search in Google Scholar

Caneva (2013): S. Caneva, Arsinoe II divinizzata al fianco del re vivente Tolemeo II. Uno studio di propaganda greco-egiziana (270–246 A.C.), Historia 62.3, 2013, 280–322.Search in Google Scholar

Caneva (2014): S. Caneva, Ruler Cults in Practice. Sacrifices and Libations for Arsinoe Philadelphos, from Alexandria and Beyond, in: T. Gnolli – F. Muccioli (eds.), Divinizazzione, culto del sovrano e apoteosi. Tra antichità e Medioevo, Bologna 2014, 85–115.Search in Google Scholar

Carney (2013): E. D. Carney, Arsinoë of Egypt and Macedon. A Royal Life, Oxford 2013.Search in Google Scholar

Chamoux (1956): F. Chamoux, Le roi Magas, RH 216, 1956, 18–34.Search in Google Scholar

Chaniotis (2007): A. Chaniotis, [rev.] R. A. Hazzard, Imagination of Monarchy. Studies in Ptolemaic Propaganda, CW 100.2, 2007, 175–176.10.1353/clw.2007.0005Search in Google Scholar

Coarelli (1990): F. Coarelli, La pompè di Tolomeo Filadelfo e il mosaico nilotico di Palestrina, Ktèma 15, 1990, 225–251.Search in Google Scholar

Coşkun (2012): A. Coşkun, Deconstructing a Myth of Seleucid History. The So-Called „Elephant Victory“ Revisited, Phoenix 66.1–2, 2012, 57–73.10.7834/phoenix.66.1-2.0057Search in Google Scholar

Couissin (1927): P. Couissin, Les armes gauloises figurées sur les monuments grecs, étrusques et romains, RA 25.1, 1927, 138–176.Search in Google Scholar

Domingo Gygax (2002): M. Domingo Gygax, Zum Mitregenten des Ptolemaios II. Philadelphos, Historia 51.1, 2002, 49–56.Search in Google Scholar

Durrbach – Roussel (1935): F. Durrbach – P. Roussel (eds.), Inscriptions de Délos III, Paris 1935.Search in Google Scholar

Eichberg (1987): M. Eichberg, Scutum. Die Entwicklung einer italisch-etruskischen Schildform von den Anfängen bis zur Zeit Caesars, Frankfurt am Main – Bern – New York – Paris 1987.Search in Google Scholar

Fischer-Bovet (2014): Ch. Fischer-Bovet, Army and Society in Ptolemaic Egypt, Cambridge 2014.10.1017/CBO9781139035231Search in Google Scholar

Foertmeyer (1988): V. Foertmeyer, The Dating of the Pompe of Ptolemy II Philadelphus, Historia 37.1, 1988, 90–104.Search in Google Scholar

Franzmeyer (1904): W. Franzmeyer, Kallixenos' Bericht über das Prachtzelt und den Festzug Ptolemaeus II. (Athenaeus. V. Capp. 25–35), Diss. Strasbourg 1904.Search in Google Scholar

Fraser (1972a): P. M. Fraser, Ptolemaic Alexandria I, Oxford 1972.Search in Google Scholar

Fraser (1972b): P. M. Fraser, Ptolemaic Alexandria II, Oxford 1972.Search in Google Scholar

Gabelko (2005): O. L. Gabelko, История Вифинского царства (A History of the Bithynian Kingdom), St. Petersburg 2005.Search in Google Scholar

Gagsteiger (1993): G. Gagsteiger, Die ptolemäischen Waffenmodelle aus Memphis, Hildesheim 2003.Search in Google Scholar

Grainger (2010): J. Grainger, The Syrian Wars, Leiden – Boston 2010.10.1163/ej.9789004180505.i-450Search in Google Scholar

Hazzard (2000): R. A. Hazzard, Imagination of Monarchy. Studies in Ptolemaic Propaganda, Toronto – Buffalo – London 2000.10.3138/9781442676008Search in Google Scholar

Hazzard – Pim Vatter FitzGerald (1991): R. A. Hazzard – M. Pim Vatter FitzGerald, The Regulation of the Ptolemaieia: a Hypothesis Explored, Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society of Canada 85.1, 1991, 6–23.Search in Google Scholar

Head (1982): D. Head, Armies of the Macedonian and Punic Wars, Goring-by-Sea 1982.Search in Google Scholar

Heinen (1972): H. Heinen, Untersuchungen zur hellenistischen Geschichte des 3. Jahrhunderts v. Chr. Zur Geschichte der Zeit des Ptolemaios Keraunos und zum Chremonideischen Krieg, Wiesbaden 1972.Search in Google Scholar

Heinen (1984): H. Heinen, The Syrian-Egyptian Wars and the New Kingdoms of Asia Minor, in: CAH2 VII.1, 1984, 412–445.10.1017/CHOL9780521234450.015Search in Google Scholar

Hölbl (2001): G. Hölbl, A History of the Ptolemaic Empire, London – New York 2001.Search in Google Scholar

Huß (1998): W. Huß, Ptolemaios der Sohn, ZPE 121, 1998, 229–250.Search in Google Scholar

Huß (2001): W. Huß, Ägypten in hellenistischer Zeit: 332–30 v. Chr., Munich 2001.Search in Google Scholar

Huß (2004): W. Huß, Noch einmal: Ptolemaios der Sohn, ZPE 149, 2004, 232.Search in Google Scholar

Keyser (2016): P. T. Keyser, Venus and Mercury in the Grand Procession of Ptolemy II, Historia 65.1, 2016, 31–52.Search in Google Scholar

Knoepfler (2007): D. Knoepfler, De Delphes à Thermos: un témoignage épigraphique méconnu sur le trophée galate des Étoliens dans leur capitale (le traité étolo-béotien), CRAI 151.3, 2007, 1215–1253.10.3406/crai.2007.91343Search in Google Scholar

Kuzmin – Ladynin (2014): Y. Kuzmin – I. Ladynin, [rev.] E. D. Carney, Arsinoë of Egypt and Macedon, Eos 101.1, 2014, 118–121.Search in Google Scholar

Laubscher (1987): H.-P. Laubscher, Ein ptolemäisches Gallierdenkmal, AK 30.2, 1987, 131–154.Search in Google Scholar

Launey (1949): M. Launey, Recherches sur les armées hellénistiques I, Paris 1949.Search in Google Scholar

Liampi (1998): K. Liampi, Der makedonische Schild, Bonn 1998.Search in Google Scholar

Maehler (1988): H. Maehler, [rev.] E. E. Rice, The Grand Procession of Ptolemy Philadelphus, JEA 74, 1988, 290–292.10.1177/030751338807400154Search in Google Scholar

Marquaille (2008): C. Marquaille, The Foreign Policy of Ptolemy II, in: P. McKechnie – Ph. Guillaume (eds.), Ptolemy II Philadelphus and His World, Leiden – Boston 2008, 39–64.10.1163/ej.9789004170896.i-488.10Search in Google Scholar

Meyboom (1995): P.G.P. Meyboom, The Nile Mosaic of Palestrina. Early Evidence of Egyptian Religion in Italy, Leiden – New York – Cologne 1995.10.1163/9789004283831Search in Google Scholar

Micoff (1954): V. Micoff, Le tombeau antique près de Kazanlăk, Sofia 1954.Search in Google Scholar

Minas (1994): M. Minas, Die Pithom-Stele. Chronologische Bemerkungen zur frühen Ptolemäerzeit, in: M. Minas – J. Zeidler (eds.), Aspekte Spätägyptischer Kultur. Festschrift für Erich Winter zum 65. Geburtstag, Mainz 1994, 203–211.Search in Google Scholar

Mineur (1984): W. H. Mineur, Callimachus, Hymn to Delos. Introduction and Commentary, Leiden 1984.10.1163/9789004328181Search in Google Scholar

Mørkholm (1991): O. Mørkholm, Early Hellenistic Coinage. From the Accession of Alexander to the Peace of Apamea (336–188 B.C.), Cambridge 1991.Search in Google Scholar

Müller (2009): S. Müller, Das hellenistische Königspaar in der medialen Repräsentation: Ptolemaios II. und Arsinoe II, Berlin – New York 2009.Search in Google Scholar

Nachtergael (1977): G. Nachtergael, Les Galates en Grèce et les Sôtéria de Delphes. Recherches d'histoire et d'épigraphie hellénistiques, Brussels 1977.Search in Google Scholar

Nefedkin (2009): A. K. Nefedkin, On the Origin of Greek Cavalry Shields in the Hellenistic Period, Klio 91.2, 2009, 356–366.10.1524/klio.2009.0017Search in Google Scholar

van Oppen (2010): B. van Oppen, The Death of Arsinoe II Philadelphus. The Evidence Reconsidered, ZPE 174, 2010, 139–150.Search in Google Scholar

van Oppen de Ruiter (2015): B. van Oppen de Ruiter, Berenice II Euergetis: Essays in Early Hellenistic Queenship, New York 2015.10.1057/9781137494627Search in Google Scholar

Otto (1931): W. Otto, Zu den syrischen Kriegen der Ptolemäer, Philologus 86, 1931, 401–418.10.1524/phil.1931.86.14.407Search in Google Scholar

Price (1991): M. Price, [rev.] A. Davesne – G. Le Rider, Le trésor de Meydancikkale, NC 151, 1991, 241–244.Search in Google Scholar

von Prott (1898): H. von Prott, Das ἐγκώμιον εἰς Πτολεμαῖον und die Zeitgeschichte, RhM 53, 1898, 460–476.Search in Google Scholar

Reinach (1911): A. J. Reinach, Les Gaulois en Égypte, REA 13, 1911, 33–74.10.3406/rea.1911.1650Search in Google Scholar

Rice (1983): E. E. Rice, The Grand Procession of Ptolemy Philadelphus, Oxford 1983.Search in Google Scholar

Ritter (1975): H. Ritter, Zum Schild auf den Münzen des Philadelphos, Schweizer Münzblätter 25, 1975, 2–3.Search in Google Scholar

Salzmann (1980): D. Salzmann, Überlegungen zum Schild des Ptolemaios Philadelphos und verwandten Denkmälern, Schweizer Münzblätter 30, 1980, 33–39.Search in Google Scholar

Schäfer (2011): D. Schäfer, Makedonische Pharaonen und Hieroglyphische Stelen. Historische Untersuchungen zur Satrapenstele und verwandten Denkmälern, Leuven 2011.Search in Google Scholar

Schreiber (2011): T. Schreiber, „Ἀρσινόης θεᾶς φιλαδέλφου“ – Ein Miniaturaltar der Arsinoë II. im Archäologischen Museum der Westfälischen Wilhelms-Universität Münster, Boreas 34, 2011, 187–201.Search in Google Scholar

Schrijvers (2007): P. H. Schrijvers, A Literary View of the Nile Mosaic at Praeneste, in: L. Bricault – M. J. Versluys – P. G. P. Meyboom (eds.), Nile into Tiber. Egypt in the Roman World, Leiden 2007, 223–239.10.1163/ej.9789004154209.i-562.60Search in Google Scholar

Sekunda (2001): N. Sekunda, Hellenistic Infantry Reforms in 160's BC, Łódź 2001.Search in Google Scholar

Sekunda (2008): N. Sekunda, Military Forces. A) Land Forces, in: Ph. Sabin – H. van Wees – M. Whitby (eds.), The Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Warfare I, Cambridge 2008, 325–357.10.1017/CHOL9780521782739.012Search in Google Scholar

Sekunda (2013): N. V. Sekunda, The Antigonid Army, Gdańsk 2013.Search in Google Scholar

Spalinger (2005): A. J. Spalinger, War in Ancient Egypt. The New Kingdom, Malden [MA] – Oxford 2005.10.1002/9780470774861Search in Google Scholar

Stewart (2014): A. Stewart, Art in the Hellenistic World. An Introduction, Cambridge 2014.10.1017/CBO9781107262270Search in Google Scholar

Studniczka (1914): F. Studniczka, Das Symposion Ptolemaios II. Nach der Beschreibung des Kallixeinos, Leipzig 1914.Search in Google Scholar

Tarn (1933): W. W. Tarn, Two Notes on Ptolemaic History, JHS 53.1, 1933, 57–68.10.2307/627247Search in Google Scholar

Thompson (2000): D. J. Thompson, Philadelphus' Procession. Dynastic Power in the Mediterranean Context, in: L. Mooren (ed.), Politics, Administration and Society in the Hellenistic and Roman World, Leuven 2000, 365–388.Search in Google Scholar

Tunny (2000): J. A. Tunny, Ptolemy „the Son“ Reconsidered: Are There Too Many Ptolemies?, ZPE 131, 2000, 83–92.Search in Google Scholar

Turner (1984): E. G. Turner, Ptolemaic Egypt, in: CAH2 VII.1, 1984, 118–174.10.1017/CHOL9780521234450.006Search in Google Scholar

Vinogradov (1999): J. G. Vinogradov, Der Staatsbesuch der „Isis“ im Bosporos, Ancient Civilizations from Scythia to Siberia 5.3–4, 1999, 271–302.10.1163/157005799X00223Search in Google Scholar

Voegtli (1973): H. Voegtli, Der Schild des Philadelphos, Schweizer Münzblätter 23, 1973, 86–89.Search in Google Scholar

Walbank (1979): F. W. Walbank, A Historical Commentary on Polybius III, Oxford 1979.Search in Google Scholar

Walbank (1984): F. W. Walbank, [rev.] E. E. Rice, The Grand Procession of Ptolemy Philadelphus, LCM 9.4, 52–54.Search in Google Scholar

Walbank (2002): F. W. Walbank, Two Hellenistic Processions. A Matter of Self-Definition, in: F. W. Walbank, Polybius, Rome and the Hellenistic World. Essays and Reflections, Cambridge 2002, 79–90.10.1017/CBO9780511482953.006Search in Google Scholar

Wallenstein – Pakkanen (2009): J. Wallenstein – J. Pakkanen, A New Inscribed Statue Base from the Sanctuary of Poseidon at Kalaureia, Opuscula 2, 2009, 155–165.10.30549/opathrom-02-07Search in Google Scholar

Wolf – Lorber (2011): D. Wolf – C. Lorber, The „Galatian Shield without Σ“ Series of Ptolemaic Bronze Coins, NC 171, 7–53.Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2018-2-7

© 2018 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston

Articles in the same Issue

  1. Titelseiten
  2. Titelseiten
  3. Artikel
  4. Le paludi di Eritre: un'interpretazione ecologico-ambientale
  5. Die Gründung der Stadt Tarent und die Gesetze des Lykurg. Eine neue Sicht auf Spartas Geschichte in archaischer Zeit
  6. How not to Appease Athena: A Reconsideration of Xerxes' Purported Visit to the Troad (Hdt. 7.42–43)
  7. Hermippus FGrH 1026 F84: Dionysius I, the theatre and the cult of the Muses in Syracuse
  8. New Perspectives on the Date of the Great Festival of Ptolemy II
  9. Riesgo marítimo, astrología y devoción en Roma
  10. Sulla und der Kampf um das Volkstribunat
  11. Civil Strife, Power and Authority in the Judicial Sphere: A Case Study from Roman Palestine
  12. Beobachtungen zu den Büchern 18–20 der Antiquitates Iudaicae des Flavius Josephus
  13. Bäuerliche Zeitvermessung bei Palladius
  14. El „Sueño de Escipión“ (Cic. rep.), el „díptico de la Consecratio“ (British Museum) y la rehabilitación oficial de Virio Nicómaco Flaviano (431)
  15. Literaturkritik
  16. Brian Campbell – Lawrence A. Tritle (Hgg.), The Oxford Handbook of Warfare in the Classical World, Oxford – New York (Oxford University Press) 2013.
  17. Michael Zeuske, Handbuch Geschichte der Sklaverei. Eine Globalgeschichte von den Anfängen bis zur Gegenwart, Berlin – Boston (De Gruyter) 2013.
  18. Jan Dirk Harke, Corpus der römischen Rechtsquellen zur antiken Sklaverei (CRRS). Teil III. Die Rechtspositionen am Sklaven. 2. Ansprüche aus Delikten am Sklaven, Stuttgart (Franz Steiner Verlag) 2013.
  19. Klaus Geus – Martin Thiering (Hgg.), Features of Common Sense Geography. Implicit Knowledge Structures in Ancient Geographical Texts, Zürich u. a. (Lit Verlag) 2014.
  20. Johann Pall Arnason – Kurt Arnold Raaflaub – Peter Wagner (Hgg.), The Greek Polis and the Invention of Democracy. A Politico-cultural Transformation and Its Interpretations, Oxford – Chichester (Wiley-Blackwell) 2013.
  21. Richard V. Cudjoe, The Social and Legal Position of Widows and Orphans in Classical Athens, Athens (Centre for Ancient Greek and Hellenistic Law; Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences) 2010.
  22. Vladimir F.Stolba – Eugeny Rogov (Hgg.), Panskoye I. Volume 2. The Necropolis, Aarhus (Aarhus University Press) 2012.
  23. Bernhard Maier, Geschichte und Kultur der Kelten, München (C.H. Beck) 2012.
  24. Andreas Hofeneder, Die Religion der Kelten in den antiken literarischen Zeugnissen. Sammlung, Übersetzung und Kommentierung. Vol. III: Von Arrianos bis zum Ausklang der Antike, Wien (Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften) 2011.
  25. Erich Kistler, Funktionalisierte Keltenbilder. Die Indienstnahme der Kelten zur Vermittlung von Normen und Werten in der hellenistischen Welt, Berlin (Verlag Antike) 2009.
  26. Jean-Marie Lassère, Africa, quasi Roma (256 av. J.-C. – 711 ap. J.-C.), Paris (CNRS Éditions) 2015.
  27. Alan Bowman – Andrew Wilson(Hgg.), The Roman Agricultural Economy. Organization, Investment, and Production, Oxford (Oxford University Press) 2013.
  28. Cristina Soraci, Sicilia frumentaria. Il grano siciliano e l'annona di Roma V a. C.– V d. C., Roma (L'Erma di Bretschneider) 2011.
  29. Richard Jenkyns, God, Space, & City in the Roman Imagination, Oxford – New York (Oxford University Press) 2013.
  30. Sergio Castagnetti, Le „leges libitinariae“ flegree. Edizione e commento, Napoli (Satura Editrice) 2012.
  31. Patrizia Arena, Feste e rituali a Roma. Il principe incontra il popolo nel Circo Massimo, Bari (Edipuglia) 2010.
  32. Nicolas Mathieu, L'Épitaphe et la Mémoire. Parenté et identité sociale dans les Gaules et Germanies romaines, Rennes (Presses Universitaire de Rennes) 2011.
  33. Stine Birk, Depicting the Dead. Self-Representation and Commemoration on Roman Sarcophagi with Portraits, Aarhus (Aarhus University Press) 2013.
  34. Björn Schöpe, Der römische Kaiserhof in severischer Zeit (193–235 n. Chr.), Stuttgart (Franz Steiner Verlag) 2014.
  35. Patrice Faure, Lʼaigle et le cep. Les centurions légionnaires dans lʼEmpire des Sévères, 2 Bde., Bordeaux (Ausonius) 2013.
  36. Ekaterina Nechaeva, Embassies – Negotiations – Gifts. Systems of East Roman Diplomacy in Late Antiquity, Stuttgart (Franz Steiner Verlag) 2014.
  37. Samuel Christian Zinsli, Kommentar zur Vita Heliogabali der Historia Augusta, Bonn (Habelt) 2014.
  38. Bruno Bleckmann – Timo Stickler (Hgg.), Griechische Profanhistoriker des fünften nachchristlichen Jahrhunderts, Stuttgart (Franz Steiner Verlag) 2014.
  39. Misha Meier – Steffen Patzold (Hgg.), Chlodwigs Welt. Organisation von Herrschaft um 500, Stuttgart (Franz Steiner Verlag) 2014.
  40. Eike Faber, Von Ulfila bis Rekkared. Die Goten und ihr Christentum, Stuttgart (Franz Steiner Verlag) 2014.
  41. Andreas Mehl – Alexander V. Makhlayuk – Oleg L. Gabelko (Hgg.),Ruthenia Classica Aetatis Novae. 2013.
  42. Caspar Meyer, Greco-Scythian Art and the Birth of Eurasia. From Classical Antiquity to Russian Modernity, Oxford (Oxford University Press) 2013.
Downloaded on 25.10.2025 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/klio-2017-0035/html
Scroll to top button