1 Freedom of speech in England and the anglophone world,1500–1850
-
Jason Peacey
Abstract
Amid considerable debate within modern societies about whether or not there ought to be limits to freedom of speech, this introductory chapter argues that historical perspectives have been all too lacking, and all too simplistic. This chapter sets the book in its modern context – in terms of the challenges that have emerged to Western liberalism as a result of religious pluralism and the challenge of hate speech – and highlights the rather simplistic ways in which freedom of speech has conventionally been anchored in ideas and developments that emerged in early modern Britain. It surveys the historiographical debates that have seen this ‘Whiggish’ narrative subjected to critical scrutiny, and sets up the volume by demonstrating both continuity and change across the early modern world. This means recognising the centrality of religious issues as well as secular concerns, and the complex ways in which contemporaries grappled with the theory and practice of freedom of speech and freedom of the press. It means acknowledging the complex relationship that existed between regulation, restraint and liberty, and the dynamic interplay that can be observed between rights and duties, truth and error, genre and audience.
Abstract
Amid considerable debate within modern societies about whether or not there ought to be limits to freedom of speech, this introductory chapter argues that historical perspectives have been all too lacking, and all too simplistic. This chapter sets the book in its modern context – in terms of the challenges that have emerged to Western liberalism as a result of religious pluralism and the challenge of hate speech – and highlights the rather simplistic ways in which freedom of speech has conventionally been anchored in ideas and developments that emerged in early modern Britain. It surveys the historiographical debates that have seen this ‘Whiggish’ narrative subjected to critical scrutiny, and sets up the volume by demonstrating both continuity and change across the early modern world. This means recognising the centrality of religious issues as well as secular concerns, and the complex ways in which contemporaries grappled with the theory and practice of freedom of speech and freedom of the press. It means acknowledging the complex relationship that existed between regulation, restraint and liberty, and the dynamic interplay that can be observed between rights and duties, truth and error, genre and audience.
Kapitel in diesem Buch
- Front matter i
- Contents v
- Notes on contributors vii
- Acknowledgements x
- Abbreviations xi
- 1 Freedom of speech in England and the anglophone world,1500–1850 1
- 2 Thomas Elyot on counsel, kairos and freeing speech in Tudor England 28
- 3 Pearls before swine 47
- 4 ‘Free speech’ in Elizabethan and early Stuart England 63
- 5 The origins of the concept of freedom of the press 98
- 6 Swift and free speech 119
- 7 Defending the truth 135
- 8 ‘The warr … against heaven by blasphemors and infidels’ 151
- 9 David Hume and ‘Of the Liberty of the Press’ (1741) in its original contexts 171
- 10 The argument for the freedom of speech and press during the ratification of the US Constitution, 1787–88 192
- 11 Before – and beyond – On Liberty 211
- 12 Unfree, unequal, unempirical 236
- Index 257
Kapitel in diesem Buch
- Front matter i
- Contents v
- Notes on contributors vii
- Acknowledgements x
- Abbreviations xi
- 1 Freedom of speech in England and the anglophone world,1500–1850 1
- 2 Thomas Elyot on counsel, kairos and freeing speech in Tudor England 28
- 3 Pearls before swine 47
- 4 ‘Free speech’ in Elizabethan and early Stuart England 63
- 5 The origins of the concept of freedom of the press 98
- 6 Swift and free speech 119
- 7 Defending the truth 135
- 8 ‘The warr … against heaven by blasphemors and infidels’ 151
- 9 David Hume and ‘Of the Liberty of the Press’ (1741) in its original contexts 171
- 10 The argument for the freedom of speech and press during the ratification of the US Constitution, 1787–88 192
- 11 Before – and beyond – On Liberty 211
- 12 Unfree, unequal, unempirical 236
- Index 257
