Waismann and Waismann’s Wittgenstein
-
Mauro Luiz Engelmann
Abstract
Friedrich Waismann’s views sometimes hide Wittgenstein’s ideas and methods and sometimes they appear mixed with them. In light of the recent literature and guided by a contrasting overview of Waismann’s and Wittgenstein’s published and unpublished works, I argue that underlying Waismann’s variations on themes by Wittgenstein was the logical empiricist aspiration to unify various kinds of knowledge and explain their relative position within the web of science. Waismann’s unique variation of logical empiricism is meant to accommodate Wittgenstein’s critique of philosophy in an alternative account of the relative position of logic, mathematics, natural science, ethics, and religion. I intend to delineate some aspects of this ambitious project underlying Waismann’s writings.
Acknowledgements
Thanks to Juliet Floyd and Jasmin Trächtler for insightful comments on an early draft of this paper. Thanks to two reviewers for comments and objections that were certainly very fruitful and helped me to improve this paper.
Bibliography
Baker, Gordon: Wittgenstein’s Method: Neglected Aspects, Oxford 2004.10.1002/9780470753088Search in Google Scholar
Baker, Gordon & Hacker, Peter: Understanding and Meaning, Oxford 1980.Search in Google Scholar
Bauer, Philipp L.: Waismanns Wiener Zeit. Ein historisch-philosophischer Bericht, in: Friedrich Stadler (ed.): Wittgenstein And the Vienna Circle: 100 Years After the Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, Cham 2023, 521 – 552.10.1007/978-3-031-07789-0_16Search in Google Scholar
Carnap, Rudolf: Intellectual Autobiography, in: Paul A. Schilpp (ed.): The Philosophy of Rudolf Carnap, La Salle 1991, 3 – 84.Search in Google Scholar
Coliva, Annalisa: Waismann on Belief and Knowledge in: Dejan Makovec & Stewart Shapiro (eds.): Friedrich Waismann: The Open Texture of Analytic Philosophy, Cham 2019, 89 – 106.10.1007/978-3-030-25008-9_5Search in Google Scholar
Dawson, John W. Jr: Discussion on the foundation of mathematics, translated and ed. by John W. Dawson Jr., in: Journal of History and Philosophy of Logic, 5 (1984), 111 – 129.10.1080/01445348408837065Search in Google Scholar
Dostoevsky, Fiodor: Crime and Punishment, London 1997.Search in Google Scholar
Edmonds, David: The Murder of Professor Schlick: The Rise and Fall of the Vienna Circle, Princeton 2020.10.1515/9780691185842Search in Google Scholar
Engelmann, Mauro L.: The Multiple Complete Systems Conception as Fil Conducteur of Wittgenstein’s Philosophy of Mathematics, in: Volker Munz, Klaus Puhl & Joseph Wang (eds.): Language and World. Papers of the 32nd Wittgenstein International Symposium 2009, Kirchberg am Wechsel 2009, 111 – 113. Search in Google Scholar
Engelmann, Mauro L.: What Wittgenstein’s ‘Grammar’ Is Not (On Garver, Baker and Hacker, and Hacker on Wittgenstein on ‘Grammar’), in: Wittgenstein-Studien 2 (2011), 71 – 102.10.1515/9783110236231.71Search in Google Scholar
Engelmann, Mauro L.: Wittgenstein’s Philosophical Development: Phenomenology, Grammar, Method, and the Anthropological View, Basingstoke 2013.Search in Google Scholar
Engelmann, Mauro L.: The Faces of Necessity, Perspicuous Representation, and the Irreligious “Cult of the Useful”: The Spenglerian Background of the First Set of Remarks on Frazer, in: Lars Albinus & Joseph Rothhaupt (eds.): Wittgenstein’s Remarks on Frazer: The Text and the Matter, Berlin 2016: 129 – 174.10.1515/9783110455069-006Search in Google Scholar
Engelmann, Mauro L.: What Does a Phenomenological Language Do? (Revisiting Some Remarks on Logical Form in its Context), in: Marcos Silva (ed.): Colors in Wittgenstein’s Philosophical Development, Basingstoke 2017, 95 – 126.10.1007/978-3-319-56919-2_5Search in Google Scholar
Engelmann, Mauro L.: Phenomenology in Grammar: Explicitation-verificationsm, Arbitrariness, and the Vienna Circle, in: Oskari Kuusela, Mihail Ometita, & Timur Uçan (eds.): Wittgenstein and Phenomenology, London 2018a, 22 – 46.10.4324/9781315626307-2Search in Google Scholar
Engelmann, Mauro L.: Wittgenstein on Sentence-Hypotheses and Certainty, in: David Stern (ed.): Wittgenstein in the 1930s: Between the Tractatus and the Investigations, Cambridge 2018b, 61 – 76.10.1017/9781108349260.004Search in Google Scholar
Engelmann, Mauro L.: Reading Wittgenstein’s Tractatus, Cambridge 2021.10.1017/9781108887892Search in Google Scholar
Engelmann, Mauro L.: What Would it Look Like? Wittgenstein’s Radical Thought Experiments, in: Florian Franken Figueiredo (ed.): Wittgenstein’s Philosophy in 1929, London 2023, 80 – 96.10.4324/9781003298823-8Search in Google Scholar
Engelmann, Mauro L.: Answering Sraffa on Religion: Wittgenstein Walking the Tightrope, in: JoLMA-The Journal for the Philosophy of Language, Mind and The Arts, Special Issue: Perspectives on Wittgenstein's Philosophical Investigations, ed. by Luigi Perissinotto and Elena Valeri, 5/3 (2024), 71 – 91.10.30687/Jolma/2723-9640/2024/03/004Search in Google Scholar
Engelmann, Mauro L.: Mauthner, Wittgenstein, and the Kraus Circle, in: Esther Heinrich-Ramharter, Alois Pichler and Friedrich Stadler (eds.): 100 Years of ‘Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus’ – 70 Years after Wittgenstein’s Death, Berlin 2025, 45 – 58.10.1515/9783111453040-006Search in Google Scholar
Engelmann, Mauro L. & Floyd, Juliet: Wittgenstein on Religion as a Form of Life: From a ‘Jamesian Type’ to Links with Religious Community, in: Duncan Pritchard & Nuno Venturinha (eds.): Wittgenstein and the Epistemology of Religious Belief, forthcoming.Search in Google Scholar
Floyd, Juliet: Wittgenstein’s Philosophy of Mathematics, Cambridge 2021.10.1017/9781108687126Search in Google Scholar
Lavers, Gregory: Waismann: From Wittgenstein’s Tafelrunde to His Writings on Analyticity in: Dejan Makovec & Stewart Shapiro (eds.): Friedrich Waismann: The Open Texture of Analytic Philosophy, Cham 2019, 131 – 158.10.1007/978-3-030-25008-9_7Search in Google Scholar
Limbeck-Lilienau, Christoph: Waismann in the Vienna Circle in: Dejan Makovec & Stewart Shapiro (eds.): Friedrich Waismann: The Open Texture of Analytic Philosophy, Cham 2019, 29 – 46.10.1007/978-3-030-25008-9_2Search in Google Scholar
Mac Cumhaill, Clare & Wiseman, Rachael: Metaphysical Animals: How Four Women Brought Philosophy Back to Life, New York 2022.Search in Google Scholar
Manninen, Juha: Waismann’s Testimony of Wittgenstein’s Fresh Starts in 1931 – 35, in: Brian F. McGuinness (ed.): Friedrich Waismann – Causality and Logical Positivism, Vienna 2011, 243 – 266.10.1007/978-94-007-1751-0_10Search in Google Scholar
Manninen, Juha Wittgensteins virtuelle Präsenz im Wiener Kreis, 1931 – 35, in: Friedrich Stadler (ed.): Wittgenstein and the Vienna Circle: 100 Years After the Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, Cham 2023, 269 – 314.10.1007/978-3-031-07789-0_14Search in Google Scholar
McGuinness, Brian: Waismann: The Wandering Scholar, in: Brian F. McGuinness (ed.): Friedrich Waismann. Causality and Logical Positivism, Vienna 2011, 9 – 16.10.1007/978-94-007-1751-0_1Search in Google Scholar
McGuinness, Brian: Relations with and within the Circle, in: Brian McGuinness: Approaches to Wittgenstein, London 2002, 184 – 200.10.4324/9780203404928-23Search in Google Scholar
Marion, Mathieu: Waismann’s Lectures on Causality: An Introduction, in: Brian F. McGuinness (ed.): Friedrich Waismann. Causality and Logical Positivism, Vienna 2011, 31 – 51.10.1007/978-94-007-1751-0_3Search in Google Scholar
Moore, Edward G.: Philosophical Papers, 2nd edition, New York 1965.Search in Google Scholar
Morris, Katherine J.: “How I See Philosophy”: An Apple of Discord Among Wittgenstein Scholars in: Dejan Makovec & Stewart Shapiro (eds.): Friedrich Waismann: The Open Texture of Analytic Philosophy, Cham 2019, 107 – 130.10.1007/978-3-030-25008-9_6Search in Google Scholar
Pereira, Luiz C.: O que Waismann poderia ter dito a Wittgenstein mas … (Parte 1), in: Analytica 17/2 (2013), 279 – 289.10.35920/arf.v17i2.2174Search in Google Scholar
Quine, Willard Van Orman: From a Logical Point of View, Cambridge, MA 2003.Search in Google Scholar
Russell, Bertrand: The Analysis of Mind, London 1997.Search in Google Scholar
Russell, Gillian: Breaking the Spell: Waismann’s Papers on the Analytic/Synthetic Distinction, in: Dejan Makovec & Stewart Shapiro (eds.): Friedrich Waismann: The Open Texture of Analytic Philosophy, Cham 2019, 159 – 188.10.1007/978-3-030-25008-9_8Search in Google Scholar
Sandis, Constantine: Producing a Justification: Waismann on Ethics and Science, in: Dejan Makovec & Stewart Shapiro (eds.): Friedrich Waismann: The Open Texture of Analytic Philosophy, Cham 2019, 47 – 66.10.1007/978-3-030-25008-9_3Search in Google Scholar
Schlick, Moritz: General Theory of Knowledge, La Salle 1985.Search in Google Scholar
Schroeder, Severin: Wittgenstein on Mathematics, London 2021.10.4324/9781003056904Search in Google Scholar
Schroeder, Severin & Tomany, Harry: Friedrich Waismann’s Philosophy of Mathematics, in: Dejan Makovec & Stewart Shapiro (eds.): Friedrich Waismann: The Open Texture of Analytic Philosophy, Cham 2019, 67 – 88.10.1007/978-3-030-25008-9_4Search in Google Scholar
Schulte, Joachim: Waismann as Wittgenstein’s Spokesman, in: Brian McGuinness (ed.): Friedrich Waismann. Causality and Logical Positivism, Vienna 2011, 225 – 242.10.1007/978-94-007-1751-0_9Search in Google Scholar
Stadler, Friedrich: Wittgenstein and the Vienna Circle – The Vienna Circle and Wittgenstein. A critical Reconsideration, in: Friedrich Stadler (ed.): Wittgenstein and the Vienna Circle: 100 Years After the Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, Cham 2023, 3 – 34.10.1007/978-3-031-07789-0_1Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: Analytic – Synthetic, in: Friedrich Waismann: How I see Philosophy, ed. by Rom Harré, London 1968a, 122 – 207.10.1007/978-1-349-00102-6_5Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: The Decline and Fall of Causality, in: Friedrich Waismann: How I see Philosophy, ed. by Rom Harré, London 1968b, 208 – 256.10.1007/978-1-349-00102-6_6Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: How I See Philosophy, in: Friedrich Waismann: How I see Philosophy, ed. by Rom Harré, London 1968c, 1 – 38.10.1007/978-1-349-00102-6_1Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: Language Strata, in: Friedrich Waismann: How I see Philosophy, ed. by Rom Harré, London 1968d, 91 – 121.10.1007/978-1-349-00102-6_4Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: Verifiability, in: Friedrich Waismann: How I see Philosophy, ed. by Rom Harré, London 1968e, 39 – 66.10.1007/978-1-349-00102-6_2Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: The Principles of Linguistic Philosophy, ed. by Rom Harré, London, 1968 f.Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: Was ist logische Analyse?, in: Friedrich Waismann: Gesammelte Aufsätze, ed. by Gerd Reitzig, Frankfurt 1973, 42 – 66.Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: Belief and Knowledge, in: Friedrich Waismann: Philosophical Papers, ed. by Brian McGuinness, Dordrecht 1977a, 166 – 178.10.1007/978-94-010-1144-0_13Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: The Linguistic Technique, in: Friedrich Waismann: Philosophical Papers, ed. by Brian McGuinness, Dordrecht 1977b, 150 – 165.10.1007/978-94-010-1144-0_12Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: Two Accounts of Knowing, in: Friedrich Waismann: Philosophical Papers, ed. by Brian McGuinness, Dordrecht 1977c, 179 – 185.10.1007/978-94-010-1144-0_14Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: What is Logical Analysis?, in: Friedrich Waismann: Philosophical Papers, ed. by Brian McGuinness, Dordrecht 1977d, 81 – 103.10.1007/978-94-010-1144-0_8Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: Theses, in: WWK 1979: 233 – 261.Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: Lectures on the Foundations of Mathematics, ed. by Wolfgang Grassl, Amsterdam 1982.10.1163/9789004458444Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: The Nature of Mathematics: Wittgenstein’s Standpoint. In Stuart Shanker (ed.): From the Tractatus to the Remarks on the Foundations of Mathematics: Wittgenstein on the Philosophy of Mathematics Volume III, London 1986, 60 – 67.Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: Ethics and Science, in: Friedrich Waismann, Josef Schächter & Moritz Schlick: Ethics and the Will, ed. by Brian McGuinness & Joachim Schulte, Dordrecht 1994a, 33 – 52.Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: Will and Motive, in: Friedrich Waismann, Josef Schächter & Moritz Schlick: Ethics and the Will, ed. by Brian McGuinness and Joachim Schulte, Dordrecht 1994b, 53 – 138.10.1007/978-94-011-0828-7Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: Introduction to Mathematical Thinking: The Formation of Concepts in Modern Mathematics, Mineola 2003.Search in Google Scholar
Waismann, Friedrich: Einführung in die moderne Philosophie, ed. by Juha Manninen, in: Friedrich Stadler (ed.): Wittgenstein And the Vienna Circle: 100 Years After the Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, Cham 2023, 344 – 406.Search in Google Scholar
© 2025 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
Articles in the same Issue
- Titelei
- Inhalt
- Titlepages
- Titlepages
- Articles
- Hinweis für Leser / Note for Readers
- Tractarian Nonsense and Literary Language
- The Middle Wittgenstein on Aesthetics
- The Question of Linguistic Idealism in the Tractatus
- Waismann and Waismann’s Wittgenstein
- Die Grenzen welcher Sprache?
- Wittgenstein on Freud’s Interpretation of Dreams
- Wittgenstein über die Erkenntnis Anderer
- Shouldered In and Out of the Reality of Mortality
- On Deep Moral Disagreement Between Theists and Atheists
- Redrawing and publishing the graphics in Wittgenstein’s Nachlass
- Special Topic:Das erlösende Wort in dürftigen Zeiten – Wittgensteins Fortschritts-, Zivilisations- und Kulturkritik
- Einleitung
- Text und Kontext
- Wozu Philosophie und Kunst in Zeiten der Unkultur?
- „[I]ch sehe jedes Problem von einem religiösen Standpunkt.”
- Wittgensteins „erlösende Worte”
- Wittgenstein über die Bildung von Begriffen
- Buchbesprechungen / Book Reviews
- David R. Cerbone: Wittgenstein on Realism and Idealism
- Peter Eigner: Die Wittgensteins. Geschichte einer unglaublich reichen Familie
- Raimundo Henriques: Self-Understanding in the Tractatus and Wittgenstein’s Architecture: From Adolf Loos to the Resolute Reading
- Shunichi Takagi, Pascal F. Zambito (eds.): Wittgenstein and Nietzsche
Articles in the same Issue
- Titelei
- Inhalt
- Titlepages
- Titlepages
- Articles
- Hinweis für Leser / Note for Readers
- Tractarian Nonsense and Literary Language
- The Middle Wittgenstein on Aesthetics
- The Question of Linguistic Idealism in the Tractatus
- Waismann and Waismann’s Wittgenstein
- Die Grenzen welcher Sprache?
- Wittgenstein on Freud’s Interpretation of Dreams
- Wittgenstein über die Erkenntnis Anderer
- Shouldered In and Out of the Reality of Mortality
- On Deep Moral Disagreement Between Theists and Atheists
- Redrawing and publishing the graphics in Wittgenstein’s Nachlass
- Special Topic:Das erlösende Wort in dürftigen Zeiten – Wittgensteins Fortschritts-, Zivilisations- und Kulturkritik
- Einleitung
- Text und Kontext
- Wozu Philosophie und Kunst in Zeiten der Unkultur?
- „[I]ch sehe jedes Problem von einem religiösen Standpunkt.”
- Wittgensteins „erlösende Worte”
- Wittgenstein über die Bildung von Begriffen
- Buchbesprechungen / Book Reviews
- David R. Cerbone: Wittgenstein on Realism and Idealism
- Peter Eigner: Die Wittgensteins. Geschichte einer unglaublich reichen Familie
- Raimundo Henriques: Self-Understanding in the Tractatus and Wittgenstein’s Architecture: From Adolf Loos to the Resolute Reading
- Shunichi Takagi, Pascal F. Zambito (eds.): Wittgenstein and Nietzsche