Home The Time of Composition of Cassius Dio’s “Roman History”: a Reconsideration
Article
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

The Time of Composition of Cassius Dio’s “Roman History”: a Reconsideration

  • Mads Ortving Lindholmer EMAIL logo
Published/Copyright: June 8, 2021
Become an author with De Gruyter Brill

Summary

The question of Cassius Dio’s time of writing is characterised by scant evidence and a lack of consensus. This article will present a highly significant correction to our understanding of the most important passage for this question, as well as two passages that have not generally been taken into consideration. The article will argue that Dio finished his main work in the late 210s and thereby support a so-called ‘early dating’. This is central for the current re-evaluation of Dio since it gives a clearer picture of the background against which Dio conceived his work and his many sophisticated interpretations. 

Bibliography

Barnes 1978: T. Barnes, The Sources of the Historia Augusta, Brussels 1978.Search in Google Scholar

Barnes 1984: T. Barnes, The Composition of Cassius Dio’s “Roman History”, Phoenix 38, 1984, 240–255.10.2307/1088277Search in Google Scholar

Berbessou-Broustet 2016: B. Berbessou-Broustet, Xiphilin, abréviateur de Cassius Dion, in: V. Fromentin – E. Bertrand – M. Coltelloni-Trannoy – M. Molin – G. Urso (eds.), Cassius Dion. Nouvelles lectures, Bordeaux 2016, 81–94.10.4000/books.ausonius.15519Search in Google Scholar

Bowersock 1965: G. W. Bowersock, Review of F. Millar, A Study of Cassius Dio, Gnomon 37, 1965, 469–474.10.25291/VR/1965-VR-469Search in Google Scholar

Brunt 1980: P. Brunt, On Historical Fragments and Epitomes, CQ 30, 1980, 477–494.10.1017/S0009838800042403Search in Google Scholar

Burden-Strevens 2020: C. Burden-Strevens, Cassius Dio’s Speeches and the Collapse of the Roman Republic. The “Roman History”, Books 3–56, Leiden 2020.10.1163/9789004431362Search in Google Scholar

Burden-Strevens – Lindholmer 2019: C. Burden-Strevens – M. O. Lindholmer (eds.), Cassius Dio’s Forgotten History of Early Rome. The “Roman History”, Books 1–21, Leiden 2019.10.1163/9789004384552Search in Google Scholar

Carter 1987: J. Carter, Cassius Dio. The Roman History. The Reign of Augustus, Harmondsworth 1987.Search in Google Scholar

Cary 1914–1927: E. Cary (ed.), Cassius Dio. Roman History I–IX, London 1914–1927.Search in Google Scholar

Coudry 2016: M. Coudry, Cassius Dio on Pompey’s Extraordinary Commands, in: C. H. Lange – J. M. Madsen (eds.), Cassius Dio. Greek Intellectual and Roman Politician, Leiden 2016, 33–50.10.1163/9789004335318_004Search in Google Scholar

Duncan-Jones 1990: R. Duncan-Jones, Structure and Scale in the Roman Economy, Cambridge 1990.10.1017/CBO9780511552649Search in Google Scholar

Edmondson 1992: J. Edmondson (ed.), Dio. The Julio-Claudians, Selections from Books 58–63 of the Roman History of Cassius Dio, London 1992.Search in Google Scholar

Eisman 1977: M. Eisman, Dio and Josephus. Parallel Analyses, Latomus 36, 1977, 657–673.Search in Google Scholar

Elliot 1955: C. Elliot, New Evidence for the Speed of the Roman Imperial Post, Phoenix 9, 1955, 76–80.10.2307/1086706Search in Google Scholar

Evans 1998: J. Evans, The History and Practice of Ancient Astronomy, Oxford, 1998.10.1119/1.19412Search in Google Scholar

Fromentin 2013: V. Fromentin, Zonaras abréviateur de Dion Cassius. A la Recherche de la Préface Perdue de l’Histoire Romaine, Erga-Logoi 1, 2013, 23–39.10.7358/erga-2013-001-fromSearch in Google Scholar

Fromentin et al. 2016: V. Fromentin – E. Bertrand – M. Coltelloni-Trannoy – M. Molin – G. Urso (eds.), Cassius Dion. Nouvelles lectures, Bordeaux 2016.Search in Google Scholar

Gabba 1955: E. Gabba, Sulla Storia Romana di Cassio Dione, RSI 67, 1955, 289–333.Search in Google Scholar

Gradoni 2013: M. Gradoni, The Parthian Campaigns of Septimius Severus. Causes, and Roles in Dynastic Legitimation, in: E. De Sena (ed.), The Roman Empire during the Severan Dynasty, Piscataway 2013, 3–23.10.31826/9781463214340-003Search in Google Scholar

Hose 1994: M. Hose, Erneuerung der Vergangenheit. Die Historiker im Imperium Romanum von Florus bis Cassius Dio, Stuttgart – Leipzig 1994.10.1515/9783110932126Search in Google Scholar

Kaldellis 2017: A. Kaldellis, How Perilous Was It to Write Political History in Late Antiquity?, Studies in Late Antiquity 1, 38–64.10.1525/sla.2017.1.1.38Search in Google Scholar

Kemezis 2014: A. Kemezis, Greek Narratives of the Roman Empire under the Severans. Cassius Dio, Philostratus and Herodian, Cambridge 2014.10.1017/CBO9781107477308Search in Google Scholar

Kemezis 2016a: A. Kemezis, Dio, Caesar and the Vesontio Mutineers (38.34–47). A Rhetoric of Lies, in: C. H. Lange – J. M. Madsen (eds.), Cassius Dio. Greek Intellectual and Roman Politician, Leiden 2016, 238–257.10.1163/9789004335318_014Search in Google Scholar

Kemezis 2016b: A. Kemezis, The Fall of Elagabalus as Literary Narrative and Political Reality. A Reconsideration, Historia 65, 2016, 348–390.10.25162/historia-2016-0019Search in Google Scholar

Kolb 2000: A. Kolb, Transport und Nachrichtentransfer im Römischen Reich, Berlin 2000.10.1524/9783050048246Search in Google Scholar

Lange – Madsen 2016: C. H. Lange – J. M. Madsen (eds.), Cassius Dio. Greek Intellectual and Roman Politician, Leiden 2016.10.1163/9789004335318Search in Google Scholar

Letta 1979: C. Letta, La composizione dell’opera di Cassio Dione. Cronologia e sfondo storico-politico, in: E. Gabba (ed.), Ricerche di storiografia antica, I: Ricerche di storiografia greca di età romana, Pisa 1979, 117–189.Search in Google Scholar

Letta 2003: C. Letta, Documenti d’archivio e iscrizione nell’opera di Cassio Dione. Un sondaggio sulla narrazione fino ad Augusto, in: A. Biraschi – P. Desideri – S. Roda – G. Zecchini (eds.), L’uso dei documenti nella storiografia antica, Naples 2003, 597–622.Search in Google Scholar

Letta 2007: C. Letta, L’eruzione del Vesuvio del 202 d.C. e la composizione dell’opera di Cassio Dione, Athenaeum 95, 2007, 41–47.Search in Google Scholar

Letta 2019: C. Letta, La carriera politica di Cassio Dione e la genesi della sua Storia romana, Studi Classici e orientali 62.2, 2019, 163–180.10.12871/978883339221912Search in Google Scholar

Lindholmer 2018a: M. O. Lindholmer, Cassius Dio and the ‘Age of Δυναστεία’, GRBS 58, 2018, 561–590.Search in Google Scholar

Lindholmer 2018b: M. O. Lindholmer, Reading Diachronically. A New Reading of Book 36 of Cassius Dio’s “Roman History”, Histos 12, 2018, 139–168.Search in Google Scholar

Lindholmer 2019a: M. O. Lindholmer, Breaking the Idealistic Paradigm. Competition in Dio’s Earlier Republic, in: C. Burden-Strevens – M. O. Lindholmer (eds.), Cassius Dio’s Forgotten History of Early Rome. The ‘Roman History’, Books 1–21, Leiden 2019, 190–214.10.1163/9789004384552_009Search in Google Scholar

Lindholmer 2019b: M. O. Lindholmer, The Fall of Cassius Dio’s Roman Republic, Klio 101, 2019, 473–504.10.1515/klio-2019-0039Search in Google Scholar

Mallan 2013: C. Mallan, The Style, Method, and Programme of Xiphilinus’ Epitome of Cassius Dio’s Roman History, GRBS 53, 2013, 610–644.Search in Google Scholar

Marincola 1997: J. Marincola, Authority and Tradition in Ancient Historiography, Cambridge 1997.10.1017/CBO9780511584831Search in Google Scholar

Markov 2008: K. Markov, Towards the Chronology of Cassius Dio’s “Roman History”, VDI 2, 2008, 142–154.Search in Google Scholar

Markov 2016: K. Markov, Towards the Peculiarities of Cassius Dio’s Public Career in 220s, История: Вестник Нижегородского университета им. Н.И. Лобачевского 3, 2016, 57–62.Search in Google Scholar

Millar 1964: F. Millar, A Study of Cassius Dio, Oxford 1964.Search in Google Scholar

Millar 2005: F. Millar, Rome in Greek Culture. Cassius Dio and Ulpian, in: L. Troiani – G. Zecchini (eds.), La cultura storica nei primi due secoli dell’impero romano, Rome 2005, 17–40.Search in Google Scholar

Molin 2016: M. Molin, Biographie de l’historien Cassius Dion, in: V. Fromentin – E. Bertrand – M. Coltelloni-Trannoy – M. Molin – G. Urso (eds.), Cassius Dion. Nouvelles lectures, Bordeaux 2016, 431–446.10.4000/books.ausonius.15739Search in Google Scholar

Murison 1999: C. Murison, Rebellion and Reconstruction, Galba to Domitian. An Historical Commentary on Cassius Dio’s Roman History, Books 64–67 (A.D. 68–96), Atlanta 1999.Search in Google Scholar

Osgood 2016: J. Osgood, Cassius Dio’s Secret History of Elagabalus, in: C. H. Lange – J. M. Madsen (eds.), Cassius Dio. Greek Intellectual and Roman Politician, Leiden 2016, 177–190.10.1163/9789004335318_011Search in Google Scholar

Ramsay 1925: A. Ramsay, The Speed of the Roman Imperial Post, JRS 15, 1925, 60–74.10.2307/295601Search in Google Scholar

Rea 1993: J. Rea, A Letter of the Emperor Elagabalus, Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik, 1993, 96, 127–132.Search in Google Scholar

Reimarus 1750–1752: H. Reimarus, Cassii Dionis Cocceiani Historiae Romanae quae supersunt I–II, Hamburg 1750–1752.Search in Google Scholar

Reinhold 1988: M. Reinhold, From Republic to Principate. An Historical Commentary on Cassius Dio’s Roman History Books 49–52 (36–29 B.C.), Atlanta 1988.Search in Google Scholar

Rich 1989: J. Rich, Dio on Augustus, in: A. Cameron (ed.), History as Text. The Writing of Ancient History, Chapel Hill 1989, 86–110.Search in Google Scholar

Rich 1990: J. Rich (ed.), Cassius Dio. The Augustan Settlement (Roman History 53–55.9), Warminster 1990.10.2307/j.ctv10tq4w9Search in Google Scholar

Riepl 1913: W. Riepl, Das Nachrichtenwesen des Altertums mit besonderer Rücksicht auf die Römer, Leipzig 1913.Search in Google Scholar

Rubin 1980: Z. Rubin, Civil-War Propaganda and Historiography, Brussels 1980.Search in Google Scholar

Schmidt 1997: M. Schmidt, Die ‘zeitgeschichtlichen’ Bücher im Werk des Cassius Dio. Von Commodus zu Severus Alexander, in: ANRW 34.3, 1997, 2591–2649.10.1515/9783110815146-017Search in Google Scholar

Schmidt 1989: M. Schmidt, Cassius Dio, Buch LXX. Bemerkungen zur Technik des Epitomators Ioannes Xiphilinos, Chiron 19, 1989, 55–59.Search in Google Scholar

Schwartz 1899: E. Schwartz, s.v. Cassius (40), in: RE 3.2, 1899, 1684–1722.Search in Google Scholar

Scott 2017: A. Scott, Cassius Dio’s Julia Domna. Character Development and Narrative Function, TAPhA 147, 2017, 413–433.10.1353/apa.2017.0014Search in Google Scholar

Scott 2018: A. Scott, Emperors and Usurpers. An Historical Commentary on Cassius Dio’s Roman History, Oxford 2018.10.1093/oso/9780190879594.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Slavich 2001: C. Slavich, Πόλεμοι καὶ στάσεις. ‘Propaganda severiana’ nell’opera di Cassio Dione, Studi Classici e Orientali 47, 2001, 131–166.Search in Google Scholar

Sordi 2000: M. Sordi, Le date di composizione dell’opera di Dione Cassio, PapLup 9, 2000, 391–395.Search in Google Scholar

Stoffel 1994: P. Stoffel, Über die Staatspost, die Ochsengespanne und die requirierten Ochsengespanne. Eine Darstellung des römischen Postwesens auf Grund der Gesetze des Codex Theodosianus und des Codex Iustinianus, Bern 1994.Search in Google Scholar

Swan 1997: P. Swan, How Cassius Dio Composed His Augustan books. Four Studies, in: ANRW 34.3, 1997, 2524–2557.10.1515/9783110815146-015Search in Google Scholar

Swan 2004: P. Swan, The Augustan Succession. An Historical Commentary on Cassius Dio’s Roman History, Books 55–56 (9 B.C.–A.D. 14), Oxford 2004.10.1093/oso/9780195167740.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Treadgold 2013: W. Treadgold, The Middle Byzantine Historians, New York 2013.10.1057/9781137280862Search in Google Scholar

Vagi 1999: D. Vagi, Coinage and History of the Roman Empire, c. 82 B.C.–A.D. 480, Chicago 1999.Search in Google Scholar

Vrind 1923: G. Vrind, De Cassii Dionis Vocabulis quae ad ius publicum pertinent, The Hague 1923.Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2021-06-08
Published in Print: 2021-06-26

© 2021 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston

Articles in the same Issue

  1. Titelseiten
  2. Aufsätze
  3. Living by the Clock. The Introduction of Clock Time in the Greek World
  4. Rituali per i fondatori. Callimaco (fr. 43 Pf. = 50 Mass.) e le norme rituali da Selinunte (CGRN 13 A 9–15)
  5. IG II2 1623, 276–285. Athens versus Pirates: between Recovery, Need and Patriotism
  6. Salmakis and the Priests of Halikarnassos
  7. The Date of the Athenian-Roman foedus
  8. La battaglia di Pidna. Aspetti topografici e strategici
  9. The Time of Composition of Cassius Dio’s “Roman History”: a Reconsideration
  10. Laughing in the Face of Death: a Survey of Unconventional Hellenistic and Greek-Roman Funerary Verse-Inscriptions
  11. Leichenzüge und Lachen. Humorräume und Lachkultur im antiken Rom
  12. Supplicationes. Dankfeste als Komponente inneraristokratischer Konkurrenz in der römischen Republik
  13. ‚Warlords‘, Dynastiebildung und Mobilität. Hypothesen zum Problem der ‚Ansiedlung‘
  14. Diplomacy at the End of the World: Theoderic’s Letters to the Warni and Hesti
  15. Literaturkritik
  16. Aneurin Ellis-Evans, The Kingdom of Priam. Lesbos and the Troad between Anatolia and the Aegean, Oxford (Oxford University Press) 2019, 384 S., 8 Kt., 51 s/w Abb., ISBN 978-0-19883198-3 (geb.), £ 79,–
  17. Jan B. Meister, ‚Adel‘ und gesellschaftliche Differenzierung im archaischen und frühklassischen Griechenland, Stuttgart (Franz Steiner Verlag) 2020 (Historia Einzelschriften 263), 443 S., ISBN 978-3-515-12715-8 (geb.), € 80,–
  18. Katharina Knäpper, Hieros kai Asylos. Territoriale Asylie im Hellenismus in ihrem historischen Kontext, Stuttgart (Franz Steiner Verlag) 2018 (Historia-Einzelschriften 250), 348 S., ISBN 978-3-515-11992-4 (geb.), € 64,–
  19. Thomas Heine Nielsen, Two Studies in the History of Ancient Greek Athletics, Kopenhagen (The Royal Danish Academy of Sciences and Letters) 2018 (Scientia Danica. Series H, Humanistica 8.16), ISBN 978-87-7304-412-4 (brosch.), DKK 200,–
  20. Sabine Müller, Alexander der Große. Eroberungen – Politik – Rezeption, Stuttgart (Kohlhammer) 2019, 396 S., ISBN 978-3-17-031346-0 (brosch.), € 32,–
  21. Henning Börm, Mordende Bürger. Stasis und Bürgerkrieg in griechischen Poleis des Hellenismus, Stuttgart (Franz Steiner Verlag) 2019 (Historia Einzelschriften 258), 362 S., ISBN 978-3-515-12311-2 (geb.), € 64,–
  22. Stefan Feuser, Hafenstädte im östlichen Mittelmeerraum vom Hellenismus bis in die römische Kaiserzeit. Städtebau, Funktion und Wahrnehmung, Berlin (De Gruyter) 2020 (URBS 8), 391 S., 136 Abb., ISBN 978-3-11-058032-7 (geb.), € 119,95
  23. Frederico De Romanis, The Indo-Roman Pepper Trade and the Muziris Papyrus, Oxford (Oxford University Press) 2020; 51 s/w Abb., 416 S., ISBN 978-0-19-884234-7 (geb.), £ 85,–
  24. John S. Kloppenborg, Christ’s Associations. Connecting and Belonging in the Ancient City, New Haven – London (Yale University Press), 2019, 536 S., ISBN 978-0-300-21704-9 (geb.), $ 40,–
  25. Sema Karataş, Zwischen Bitten und Bestechen. Ambitus in der politischen Kultur der römischen Republik – Der Fall des Cn. Plancius, Stuttgart (Franz Steiner Verlag) 2019 (Hermes Einzelschrift 115), 328 S., ISBN 978-3-515-12394-5 (brosch.), € 55,–
  26. Francisco Pina Polo – Alejandro Díaz Fernández, The Quaestorship in the Roman Republic, Berlin – Bosten (De Gruyter) 2019, 376 S., ISBN 978-3-11-066341-9 (geb.), € 99,95€
  27. John F. Drinkwater, Nero. Emperor and Court, Cambridge (Cambridge University Press) 2019, XVIII, 449 S., ISBN 978-1-108-47264-7 (geb.), £ 32,99
  28. Martin Ziegert, Zwischen Tradition und Innovation. Die Münzprägung Vespasians, Wien (Österreichische Forschungsgesellschaft für Numismatik) 2020 (VIN 22), 322 S., 14 Taf., ISBN 978-3-9504268-1-6 (geb.), € 49,–
  29. Daniela Urbanová, Latin Curse Tablets of the Roman Empire, Innsbruck (Institut für Sprachen und Literaturen der Universität Innsbruck, Bereich Sprachwissenschaft) 2018 (Innsbrucker Beiträge zur Kulturwissenschaft Neue Folge 17), 557 S., ISBN 978-3-85124-245-4, € 96,–
  30. Alain Villaret, Les dieux augustes dans l’Occident romain. Un phénomène d’acculturation, Bordeaux (Ausonius éditions) 2019 (Scripta Antiqua 126), 450 S., ISBN 978-2-356-13329-8 (geb.), € 25,–
  31. Anne-Valérie Pont, La fin de la cité grecque. Métamorphoses et disparition d’un modèle politique et institutionnel local en Asie Mineure, de Dèce à Constantin, Genf (Droz) 2020 (Hautes Etudes du monde gréco-romain), 608 S., ISBN 978-2-600-05742-4 (brosch.), € 45,–
  32. Christoph Hammann, Katharsis in Kaiserzeit und Spätantike. Vorstellungen von Reinigung und Reinheit in Medizin, platonischer Philosophie und christlicher Theologie des 2. bis 4. Jahrhunderts n. Chr., Göttingen (Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht) 2020 (Hypomnemata 208), 983 S., ISBN 978-3-525-31723-5 (geb.), € 100,–
  33. Muriel Moser, Emperor and Senators in the Reign of Constantius II. Maintaining Imperial Rule between Rome and Constantinople in the Fourth Century AD, Cambridge (Cambridge University Press) 2018, XVII, 420 S., ISBN 978-1-108-48101-4 (geb.), £ 90,–
  34. Andreas Schwab, Fremde Religion in Herodots „Historien“. Religiöse Mehrdimensionalität bei Persern und Ägyptern, Stuttgart (Franz Steiner Verlag) 2020, 307 S., ISBN 978-3-515-12720-2 (brosch.), € 46,–
  35. Simon Hornblower, Lykophron’s Alexandra, Rome and the Hellenistic World, Oxford (Oxford University Press) 2018, XXIV, 254 S., ISBN 978-0-19-87236-8 (geb.), £ 63,–
  36. Irmgard Männlein-Robert (Hg.), Über das Glück. Marinos, Das Leben des Proklos, eingeleitet, übersetzt und mit interpretierenden Essays versehen von Matthias Becker, John Dillon, Udo Hartmann, Christoph Helmig, Irmgard Männlein-Robert, Dominic O’Meara, Stefan Schorn, Benjamin Topp, unter Mitwirkung von Oliver Schelske, Tübingen (Mohr Siebeck) 2019 (SAPERE XXXIV), XIII, 451 S., ISBN 978-3-16-157638-6 (geb.), € 94,–
  37. Stephen Mitchell – David French (Hgg.), The Greek and Latin Inscriptions of Ankara (Ancyra), II: Late Roman, Byzantine and other Texts, München (C.H.Beck) 2019 (Vestigia 72), VIII, 347 S., ISBN 978-3-406-73234-8 (geb.), € 108,–
  38. Tonio Hölscher, Visual Power in Ancient Greece and Rome. Between Art and Social Reality, Oakland (University of California Press) 2018, 426 S., ISBN 978-0-520-96788-5 (geb.), $ 49,95
  39. Alexander the Great’s Route to Gaugamela and Arbela
Downloaded on 7.9.2025 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/klio-2020-0310/html?lang=en&srsltid=AfmBOoqqF3Tpc9RCFWnc4IxvuMAv1goM7a3tgruf6v11QQj_9cYiPKuk
Scroll to top button