Abstract
This article argues that the education crisis in South Africa stems largely from a literacy problem. The prediction that use of the primary language is beneficial in formal schooling is not unambiguously met in the South African context when examining evidence from large-scale literacy assessments. Understanding the reasons for this is critical for improving the use of African languages in early schooling. This article examines the Zulu and English reading literacy skills of a Grade 4 cohort of learners after three years of schooling in their home language. The research reveals low reading levels in both languages, suggesting a mismatch between language policy and literacy accomplishment. It is suggested that one of the primary reasons for the poor results in schools that have African languages as initial LoLT lies in the oral orientation to classroom practices in these schools. A more fully specified language in education model is proposed where an emphasis on literacy in the primary language may help to shift the focus where it belongs.
Acknowledgements
This research was made possible with funding from the DG Murray Trust. The ideas and opinions expressed here are not necessarily those of the funders. Sincere thanks to the principal and all the learners and staff at the school for participating so generously and willingly in the project.
References
Abadzi, Helen.2006. Efficient learning for the poor. Washington, DC: The World Bank.10.1596/978-0-8213-6688-2Search in Google Scholar
Abd-Kadir, Jan & FrankHardman. 2007. The discourse of whole-class teaching: A comparative study of Kenyan and Nigerian primary English lessons. Language and Education21(1). 1–15.10.2167/le684.0Search in Google Scholar
Adams, Marilyn.1990. Beginning to read: Thinking and learning about print. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Search in Google Scholar
Benson, Carol.2010. How multilingual African contexts are pushing educational research and practice in new directions. Language and Education24(4). 323–336.10.1080/09500781003678704Search in Google Scholar
Block, Cathy C. & MichaelPressley. 2007. Best practices in teaching comprehension. In L. B.Gambrell, L. M.Morrow & M.Pressley (eds.), Best practices in literacy instruction, 220–242. New York: Guilford Press.Search in Google Scholar
Bus, Adriana & MarinusVan Ijzendoorn.1999. Phonological awareness and early reading: A meta-analysis of experimental training studies. Journal of Educational Psychology91. 403–414.10.1037/0022-0663.91.3.403Search in Google Scholar
Carlisle, Joanne, MargaretBeeman, LyleDavis & GalilaSpharim.1999. Relationship of metalinguistic capabilities and reading achievement for children who are becoming bilingual. Applied Psycholinguistics20. 459–478.10.1017/S0142716499004014Search in Google Scholar
Chall, Jeanne, VickiJacobs & LukeBaldwin.1990. The reading crisis: Why poor children fall behind. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.10.4159/9780674029354Search in Google Scholar
Chiape, Penny & LindaSiegel.1999. Phonological awareness and reading acquisition in English- and Punjabi-speaking Canadian children. Journal of Educational Psychology91. 2–28.10.1037/0022-0663.91.1.20Search in Google Scholar
Chick, Keith.1996. Safe talk: collusion in apartheid education. In H.Coleman (ed.), Society and the language classroom. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Cipielewski, James & KeithStanovich.1992. Predicting growth in reading ability from children’s exposure to print. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology54. 74–89.10.1016/0022-0965(92)90018-2Search in Google Scholar
Comeau, Liane, PierreCormier, EricGrandmaison & DianeLacroix.1999. A longitudinal study of phonological processing skills in children learning to read in a second language. Journal of Educational Psychology91. 29–43.10.1037/0022-0663.91.1.29Search in Google Scholar
Cummins, Jim1991. Conversational and academic language proficiency in bilingual contexts. AILA Review8. 75–89.Search in Google Scholar
Cummins, Jim2000. Language, power and pedagogy: Bilingual children in the crossfire. Clevedon: Multilingual Matters.10.21832/9781853596773Search in Google Scholar
Cutting, Laurie, AprilMeterek, CarolynCole, TerryLevine & MarkMahone.2009. Effects of fluency, oral language, and executive function on reading comprehension performance. Annals of Dyslexia59. 34–54.Search in Google Scholar
Dehaene, Stanislas.2009. Reading in the brain: the new science of how we read. London: Penguin Books.Search in Google Scholar
Fleisch, Brahm.2008. Primary education in crisis. Cape Town: Juta & Co.Search in Google Scholar
Geva, Esther & Zohreh Y.Zadeh.2006. Reading efficiency in native English-speaking and English-as-a-second-language children: The role of oral proficiency and underlying cognitive-linguistic processes. Scientific Studies of Reading10(1). 31–57.10.1207/s1532799xssr1001_3Search in Google Scholar
Gibbons, Pauline.2009. English learners, academic literacy and thinking. Portsmith, NH: Heinemann.Search in Google Scholar
Goldenberg, Claude.2008. Teaching English language learners: What the research does –And does not –say. American Educator Summer. 8–44.Search in Google Scholar
Grabe, William.2009. Reading in a second language. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Graham, Barbara E.2010. Mother tongue education: Necessary? Possible? Sustainable?Language and Education24(4). 309–321.10.1080/09500781003678696Search in Google Scholar
Hart, Betty & ToddRisley.1995. Meaningful differences. Baltimore, MD: Paul H. Brookes.Search in Google Scholar
Hasbrouck, Jan & GeraldTindal. 2006. Oral reading fluency norms: A valuable assessment tool for reading teachers. The Reading Teacher5. 636–644.10.1598/RT.59.7.3Search in Google Scholar
Howie, Sarah, Surettevan Staden, MishackTshele, CillaDowse & LiseZimmerman.2012. PIRLS 2011: South African children’s reading literacy achievement Summary Report. Pretoria: University of Pretoria.Search in Google Scholar
Hungi, Njora & FlorenceThuku.2010. Variations in reading achievement. International Review of Education56. 63–101.10.1007/s11159-009-9148-xSearch in Google Scholar
Jackson, Mary-Jane. 2013. Explaining linguistic thresholds and reading comprehension skills-transfer in a Grade 6, isiXhosa-English additive bilingual context. Grahamstown: Rhodes University MA dissertation.Search in Google Scholar
Juel, Connie & CeciliaMinden-Cupp. 2000. Learning to read words: Linguistic units and instructional strategies. Reading Research Quarterly35. 458–492.10.1598/RRQ.35.4.2Search in Google Scholar
Kuhn, Melanie & StevenStahl.2003. Fluency: A review of developmental and remedial practices. Journal of Educational Psychology95(1). 3–21.10.1037/0022-0663.95.1.3Search in Google Scholar
Kuhn, Melanie & TimothyRasinski.2007. Best practices in fluency instruction. In L. B.Gambrell, LesleyMorrow & MichaelPressley (eds.), Best practices in literacy instruction, 204–219. New York: Guilford Press.Search in Google Scholar
Lipka, Orly & LindaSiegel.2007. The development of reading skills in children with English as second language. Scientific Studies of Reading11(2). 105–131.10.1080/10888430709336555Search in Google Scholar
Lockheed, Marlaine & SantiegoCueto.2006. Editorial: Research on education equity and quality in developing and transition countries. International Journal of Educational Research45. 97–101.10.1016/j.ijer.2006.11.006Search in Google Scholar
Madiba, Mbulungeni.2012. Language and academic achievement: Perspectives on the potential role of indigenous African languages as a Lingua academica. Per Linguam28(2). 15–27.10.5785/28-2-528Search in Google Scholar
McGuiness, Diane2004. Early reading instruction. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press.Search in Google Scholar
Muter, Valerie. & KayDiethelm.2001. The contribution of phonological skills and letter knowledge to early reading development in a multilingual population. Language Learning51(2). 187–219.10.1111/1467-9922.00153Search in Google Scholar
National Reading Panel. 2000. Teaching children to read: An evidence-based assessment of the scientific literature on reading and its implications for reading instruction. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.Search in Google Scholar
Nchindila, Bernard.2012. A study of reading and academic achievement in English in Zambian schools. Pretoria: University of South Africa doctoral thesis.Search in Google Scholar
NEEDU Report (National Education Evaluation and Development Unit). 2009. Ministerial Committee Report. Pretoria: Department of Education.Search in Google Scholar
NEEDU National Report 2012: The state of literacy teaching and learning in the Foundation Phase. (National Education Evaluation and Development Unit). 2013. Pretoria: Department of Education.Search in Google Scholar
Paris, Scott.2005. Reinterpreting the development of reading skills. Reading Research Quarterly40(2). 184–202.10.1598/RRQ.40.2.3Search in Google Scholar
Ramachandran, Vilayanur S.2011. The tell tale brain. New York: W. W. Norton.Search in Google Scholar
Rapp, David, Paul Vanden Broek, KristenMcMaster, PanayiotaKendeou & ChristineEspin. 2007. Higher-order comprehension processes in struggling readers: A perspective for research and intervention. Scientific Studies of Reading11(4). 289–312.10.1080/10888430701530417Search in Google Scholar
Sadoski, Mark & AllanPaivio.2007. Toward a unified theory of reading. Scientific Studies of Reading11(4). 337–356.10.1080/10888430701530714Search in Google Scholar
Saville-Troike, Muriel. 1984. What really matters in second language learning for academic purposes?TESOL Quarterly18. 199–219.10.2307/3586690Search in Google Scholar
Snow, Catherine & DavidDickinson.1991. Skills that aren’t basic in a new conception of literacy. In E. M.Jennings & A. C.Purves (eds.), Literate systems and individual lives, 175–213. New York: State University of New York Press.Search in Google Scholar
Stanovich, Keith.1986. Matthew effects in reading: Some consequences of individual differences in the acquisition of literacy. Reading Research Quarterly21. 360–406.10.1598/RRQ.21.4.1Search in Google Scholar
Stanovich, Keith & AnneCunningham. 1993. Where does knowledge come from? Specific associations between print exposure and information acquisition. Journal of Educational Psychology85(2). 211–229.10.1037/0022-0663.85.2.211Search in Google Scholar
Stuart, Morag1999. Getting ready for reading: Early phoneme awareness and phonics teaching improves reading and spelling in inner-city second language learners. British Journal of Educational Psychology69. 587–605.10.1348/000709999157914Search in Google Scholar
Thomas, Wayne & VirginiaCollier. 2002. A national study of school effectiveness for language minority students’ long-term academic achievement. Santa Cruz, CA: Centre for Research on Education Diversity and Excellence. http://www.crede.ucsc.edu/research/llaa/1.1_final.html (accessed 10 February 2013).Search in Google Scholar
Van Rooy, Bertus & ElizabethPretorius.2013. Is reading in an agglutinating language different from an analytic language? An analysis of Zulu and English reading based on eye movements. Southern African Linguistics and Language Studies31(3). 281–297.10.2989/16073614.2013.837603Search in Google Scholar
Venter, Elize, Surettevan Staden & Celiadu Toit. 2008. South Africa’s performance on international benchmarks. In SarahHowie, ElizeVenter, Surette VanStaden, LisaZimmerman, CarolineLong, Celia DuToit, VanessaScherman & ElizabethArcher (eds.), PIRLS 2006 Summary Report: South African Children’s Reading Achievement, 25–29. Pretoria: CEA, University of Pretoria.Search in Google Scholar
Wang, Min & KeikoKoda.2005. Commonalities and differences in word identification skills among learners of English as a second language. Language Learning55(1). 71–98.10.1111/j.0023-8333.2005.00290.xSearch in Google Scholar
Wells, C. G.1986. The meaning makers: children learning language and using language to learn. London: Hodder and Stoughton.Search in Google Scholar
Williams, Eddie.2006. Bridges and barriers: Language in African education and development. Manchester: St. Jerome Publishers.Search in Google Scholar
Wolf, Maryanne.2008. Proust and the squid. Cambridge: Icon Books.Search in Google Scholar
©2015 by De Gruyter Mouton
Articles in the same Issue
- Frontmatter
- Introduction
- Identity negotiation in a super-diverse community: The fuzzy languaging logic of high school students in Soweto
- Odonymic changes in Central Pretoria: Representation, identity and textual construction of place
- Failure to launch: matching language policy with literacy accomplishment in South African schools
- “Amaphi ama-subjects eniwa-enjoy-ayo esikolweni?”: Code-switching and language practices among bilingual learners in the Eastern Cape
- Investigating literacy narratives among ethno-linguistically diverse South African students
- Translanguaging practices in complex multilingual spaces: A discontinuous continuity in post-independent South Africa
- The social dimension of reading literacy development in South Africa: Bridging inequalities among the various language groups
- Book Review
- Pol Cuvelier, Theodorus Du Plessis, Michael Meeuwis, Reinhild Vandekerckhove and Vic Webb: Multilingualism for empowerment
- Small Languages and Small Language Communities 79
- An ethnography of the standardization reform: A case of policy-making in the context of the Upper Perené Arawak community of Peru
Articles in the same Issue
- Frontmatter
- Introduction
- Identity negotiation in a super-diverse community: The fuzzy languaging logic of high school students in Soweto
- Odonymic changes in Central Pretoria: Representation, identity and textual construction of place
- Failure to launch: matching language policy with literacy accomplishment in South African schools
- “Amaphi ama-subjects eniwa-enjoy-ayo esikolweni?”: Code-switching and language practices among bilingual learners in the Eastern Cape
- Investigating literacy narratives among ethno-linguistically diverse South African students
- Translanguaging practices in complex multilingual spaces: A discontinuous continuity in post-independent South Africa
- The social dimension of reading literacy development in South Africa: Bridging inequalities among the various language groups
- Book Review
- Pol Cuvelier, Theodorus Du Plessis, Michael Meeuwis, Reinhild Vandekerckhove and Vic Webb: Multilingualism for empowerment
- Small Languages and Small Language Communities 79
- An ethnography of the standardization reform: A case of policy-making in the context of the Upper Perené Arawak community of Peru