Article
Licensed
Unlicensed
Requires Authentication
A pragmatic proposal for permissible limits in external quality assessment schemes with a compromise between biological variation and the state of the art
-
Rainer Haeckel
,
Werner Wosniok
Published/Copyright:
January 25, 2012
Abstract
Permissible limits for internal and external quality assurance are either based on biological variation or on the state of the art (technical feasibility). The former approach has a scientific basis, but, in some cases, leads to limits which are either not achievable under the present technology, or which are not stringent enough. If proficiency testing is mandatory, stringent limits which cannot be fulfilled by the majority of laboratories could lead to juristic consequences. Therefore, most national guidelines were based on the state of the art, however, without providing the underlying reasoning. A simple algorithm for permissible limits in external quality assessment schemes (EQAS) is proposed based on biological variation, technical feasibility and correlated to the rate of false positive results. The proposed limits are compared with some limits from several EQAS (RiliBÄK, SEKK, RCPA, CLIA, PROLARIT). The suggested limits are slightly more stringent than the German RiliBÄK, less stringent than the Australasian guidelines and agreed best with the Czech SEKK and the Italian PROLARIT scheme. The graphical presentation of permissible limits strictly derived of biological variation with the proposed limits led to straight lines with different slopes and a cross-over at the limits for quantities with a medium biological variation (e.g., trijodthyronine). The greatest discordance between the various recommendations was observed for calcium, chloride, hemoglobin A1cand sodium.
Keywords: allowable quality specifications; biological variation; external quality assessment; permissible limits
Received: 2011-10-5
Accepted: 2011-12-15
Published Online: 2012-01-25
Published in Print: 2012-05-01
©2012 by Walter de Gruyter Berlin Boston
You are currently not able to access this content.
You are currently not able to access this content.
Articles in the same Issue
- Masthead
- Masthead
- Editorials
- Reference values and the journal: why the past is now present
- Other-than-annual variations in morning determinations of uric acid
- Reviews
- Blood biochemical markers of bone turnover: pre-analytical and technical aspects of sample collection and handling
- A comprehensive review of upper reference limits reported for (high-)sensitivity cardiac troponin assays: the challenges that lie ahead
- Mini Review
- Reference change values
- Opinion Papers
- Obtaining reference intervals traceable to reference measurement systems: is it possible, who is responsible, what is the strategy?
- Analytical performance, reference values and decision limits. A need to differentiate between reference intervals and decision limits and to define analytical quality specifications
- A pragmatic proposal for permissible limits in external quality assessment schemes with a compromise between biological variation and the state of the art
- Original Articles
- Age dependence of within-subject biological variation of nine common clinical chemistry analytes
- Population-based pediatric reference intervals for general clinical chemistry analytes on the Abbott Architect ci8200 instrument
- Uric acid biorhythm, a feature of long-term variation in a clinical laboratory database
- Age-related changes in serum amino acids concentrations in healthy individuals
- Characterisation of a highly sensitive troponin I assay and its application to a cardio-healthy population
- Are the currently used reference intervals for creatine kinase (CK) reflecting the general population? The Tromsø Study
- Age-specific thyroid hormone and thyrotropin reference intervals for a pediatric and adolescent population
- Serum thyroglobulin reference values according to NACB criteria in healthy subjects with normal thyroid ultrasound
- Thyroid volume influences serum calcitonin levels in a thyroid-healthy population: results of a 3-assay, 519 subjects study
- Impact of the reference values on the clinically-relevant cut-offs. The example of cortisol testing in children
- Trimester-specific reference intervals for haemoglobin A1c (HbA1c) in pregnancy
- The concentration of adiponectin in breast milk is related to maternal hormonal and inflammatory status during 6 months of lactation
- Age- and sex-specific reference limits for creatinine, cystatin C and the estimated glomerular filtration rate
- Determination of the biological variation of S100β and lactate dehydrogenase in disease-free patients with malignant melanoma
- Reference intervals and biological variation for kallikrein 6: influence of age and renal failure
- Faecal haemoglobin concentrations by gender and age: implications for population-based screening for colorectal cancer
- Reference intervals of extended erythrocyte and reticulocyte parameters
- Haematological and iron metabolism parameters in professional cyclists during the Giro d’Italia 3-weeks stage race
- Reference change values for lens culinaris agglutinin-reactive α-fetoprotein and des-γ-carboxy prothrombin in patients with chronic hepatitis C
- Letters to the Editor
- Disadvantages of using biological variation data for reference change values
- Reference change values may need some improvement but are invaluable tools in laboratory medicine
- Insulin-like growth factor 1 reference intervals for a chemiluminescent enzyme immunometric assay (Immulite 2000®) in an adult Mediterranean population
- Reference values for new red blood cell and platelet parameters on the Abbott Diagnostics Cell-Dyn Sapphire
- Congress Abstracts
- Swiss MedLab 2012 Congress of the Swiss Union of Laboratory Medicine (SULM)
Keywords for this article
allowable quality specifications;
biological variation;
external quality assessment;
permissible limits
Articles in the same Issue
- Masthead
- Masthead
- Editorials
- Reference values and the journal: why the past is now present
- Other-than-annual variations in morning determinations of uric acid
- Reviews
- Blood biochemical markers of bone turnover: pre-analytical and technical aspects of sample collection and handling
- A comprehensive review of upper reference limits reported for (high-)sensitivity cardiac troponin assays: the challenges that lie ahead
- Mini Review
- Reference change values
- Opinion Papers
- Obtaining reference intervals traceable to reference measurement systems: is it possible, who is responsible, what is the strategy?
- Analytical performance, reference values and decision limits. A need to differentiate between reference intervals and decision limits and to define analytical quality specifications
- A pragmatic proposal for permissible limits in external quality assessment schemes with a compromise between biological variation and the state of the art
- Original Articles
- Age dependence of within-subject biological variation of nine common clinical chemistry analytes
- Population-based pediatric reference intervals for general clinical chemistry analytes on the Abbott Architect ci8200 instrument
- Uric acid biorhythm, a feature of long-term variation in a clinical laboratory database
- Age-related changes in serum amino acids concentrations in healthy individuals
- Characterisation of a highly sensitive troponin I assay and its application to a cardio-healthy population
- Are the currently used reference intervals for creatine kinase (CK) reflecting the general population? The Tromsø Study
- Age-specific thyroid hormone and thyrotropin reference intervals for a pediatric and adolescent population
- Serum thyroglobulin reference values according to NACB criteria in healthy subjects with normal thyroid ultrasound
- Thyroid volume influences serum calcitonin levels in a thyroid-healthy population: results of a 3-assay, 519 subjects study
- Impact of the reference values on the clinically-relevant cut-offs. The example of cortisol testing in children
- Trimester-specific reference intervals for haemoglobin A1c (HbA1c) in pregnancy
- The concentration of adiponectin in breast milk is related to maternal hormonal and inflammatory status during 6 months of lactation
- Age- and sex-specific reference limits for creatinine, cystatin C and the estimated glomerular filtration rate
- Determination of the biological variation of S100β and lactate dehydrogenase in disease-free patients with malignant melanoma
- Reference intervals and biological variation for kallikrein 6: influence of age and renal failure
- Faecal haemoglobin concentrations by gender and age: implications for population-based screening for colorectal cancer
- Reference intervals of extended erythrocyte and reticulocyte parameters
- Haematological and iron metabolism parameters in professional cyclists during the Giro d’Italia 3-weeks stage race
- Reference change values for lens culinaris agglutinin-reactive α-fetoprotein and des-γ-carboxy prothrombin in patients with chronic hepatitis C
- Letters to the Editor
- Disadvantages of using biological variation data for reference change values
- Reference change values may need some improvement but are invaluable tools in laboratory medicine
- Insulin-like growth factor 1 reference intervals for a chemiluminescent enzyme immunometric assay (Immulite 2000®) in an adult Mediterranean population
- Reference values for new red blood cell and platelet parameters on the Abbott Diagnostics Cell-Dyn Sapphire
- Congress Abstracts
- Swiss MedLab 2012 Congress of the Swiss Union of Laboratory Medicine (SULM)
