Butler's Unduly Worry about Foucault. The Paradoxically Constituted and Constructed Body
-
Åsa Carlson
Abstract
Judith Butler finds Michel Foucault's ideas about the body incoherent: the body is both constituted and causally constructed by culture. The alleged incoherence stems from this double role that culture supposedly plays in relation to body. On the one hand, if we take constitution as the primary relation between culture and body, then they are inseparable; the body is so to speak made of culture. If, on the other hand, we take construction as primary, culture and body are separate entities - culture works on the body. In order to avoid this paradox, Butler introduces the concept materialization. This paper argues that for the notion of materialization to be comprehensible, it has to be interpreted as a dually constructive and constitutive notion. Nevertheless, the paradoxical nature of the body-culture relation is not reinstated. With a suitable understanding of the notion of constitution no paradox follows from the claims ascribed to Foucault. In addition, if we understand the concept of constitution as a quasi-transcendental condition, most of Butler's objectives are preserved, despite the rejection of materialization.
© Philosophia Press 2008
Artikel in diesem Heft
- Evil Everywhere. The Ordinariness of Kantian Radical Evil
- What is Naturalism? Towards a Univocal Theory
- Wittgenstein and the Fate of Metaphysics
- Butler's Unduly Worry about Foucault. The Paradoxically Constituted and Constructed Body
- On the Performative and the Pragmatic. Performative vs. Pragmatic Self-Contradictions
- Philosophical Fiction and the Act of Fiction-Making
- On Richard Shusterman's Pragmatist Challenge to Arthur Danto's Philosophy of Art
- Less is More, and More is Needed. Reply to Jan Faye
- Nothing but the Truth. A Reply to Søren Harnow Klausen
- John Gibson, Wolfgang Huemer & Luca Pocci (eds.): A Sense of the Worlds. Routledge Studies in Contemporary Philosophy. New York & London: Routledge, 2007 (344 pp.)
Artikel in diesem Heft
- Evil Everywhere. The Ordinariness of Kantian Radical Evil
- What is Naturalism? Towards a Univocal Theory
- Wittgenstein and the Fate of Metaphysics
- Butler's Unduly Worry about Foucault. The Paradoxically Constituted and Constructed Body
- On the Performative and the Pragmatic. Performative vs. Pragmatic Self-Contradictions
- Philosophical Fiction and the Act of Fiction-Making
- On Richard Shusterman's Pragmatist Challenge to Arthur Danto's Philosophy of Art
- Less is More, and More is Needed. Reply to Jan Faye
- Nothing but the Truth. A Reply to Søren Harnow Klausen
- John Gibson, Wolfgang Huemer & Luca Pocci (eds.): A Sense of the Worlds. Routledge Studies in Contemporary Philosophy. New York & London: Routledge, 2007 (344 pp.)
