Article
Licensed
Unlicensed
Requires Authentication
A new general regression-based approach for method comparison studies
-
Salvatore Sotgia
Published/Copyright:
May 22, 2008
Abstract
Background: A scatter plot combined with correlation and regression analysis to assess the agreement between analytical methods that measure the same quantity has a long tradition in clinical chemistry. However, only when linearity is absolute this approach may be useful to estimate whether the methods under comparison produce the same errors in measurement. The aim of this study is to provide a new original regression-based tool which does not suffer from the problems of the classical regression/correlation method and that is also easy to use and to interpret.
Methods: To evaluate the performance of the new method, the results of some analytical determinations were compared by the new procedure, the Bland-Altman test, Passing-Bablok regression and Mountain plot.
Results: All the tests used to compare the data allowed superimposable interpretations, both when methods under comparison were in agreement and in disagreement.
Conclusions: The understanding of the new test is truly intuitive and it is reduced to the appraisal of how much the equation of the best-fit line (Y=X) is able to predict the value of the Y. The goodness of this prediction can be evaluated by the coefficient of determination, whose value is closely connected to the differences between the methods under comparison. The result of our simulation is that quite high agreement between the methods occurs for determination coefficient equal or greater than 0.98.
Clin Chem Lab Med 2008;46:1046–9.
Received: 2008-1-30
Accepted: 2008-3-21
Published Online: 2008-5-22
Published in Print: 2008-07-01
©2008 by Walter de Gruyter Berlin New York
You are currently not able to access this content.
You are currently not able to access this content.
Articles in the same Issue
- Editorial
- CCLM: Evolving to meet the needs of today's laboratory professionals and scientists
- Bacterial detection and blood product contamination
- Editorial: Rapid diagnostic tests to detect pathogenic microorganisms
- Reviews
- Rapid methods for diagnosis of bloodstream infections
- Validation criteria for nucleic acid amplification techniques for bacterial infections
- Incidence of bacterial transmission and transfusion reactions by blood components
- Strategies of bacteria screening in cellular blood components
- Methods for the detection of bacterial contamination in blood products
- Bacteria detection by flow cytometry
- Rapid screening by real-time 16S rDNA PCR for bacterial contamination of blood products
- Microbial safety of cell based medicinal products – what can we learn from cellular blood components?
- Genetics and Molecular Diagnostics
- Screening for genetic heterogeneity in the interferon sensitivity determining region of the hepatitis C virus genome by polymerase chain reaction with melting curve analysis
- Thiopurine S-methyltransferase (TPMT) pharmacogenetics: three new mutations and haplotype analysis in the Estonian population
- Genetic testing for adult-type hypolactasia in Italian families
- Improved real-time detection of the H63D and S65C mutations associated with hereditary hemochromatosis using a SimpleProbe assay format
- Easy detection of 5,10-methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase 1298A/C genotype by mutagenically separated PCR assay
- General Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine
- Mediterranean diet and plasma concentration of inflammatory markers in old and very old subjects in the ZINCAGE population study
- Plasma interleukin-1β, -6, -8 and tumor necrosis factor-α as highly informative markers of pelvic inflammatory disease
- The effect of hypothyroidism, hyperthyroidism, and their treatment on parameters of oxidative stress and antioxidant status
- Breath isoprene – aspects of normal physiology related to age, gender and cholesterol profile as determined in a proton transfer reaction mass spectrometry study
- Prohormone brain natriuretic peptide (proBNP), BNP and N-terminal-proBNP circulating levels in chronic hemodialysis patients. Correlation with ventricular function, fluid removal and effect of hemodiafiltration
- A comparison of two different assays for determining S-100B in serum and urine
- Diagnostic, clinical and laboratory turnaround times in troponin T testing
- Validation and Outcome Studies
- An international comparability study to determine the sources of uncertainty associated with a non-competitive sandwich fluorescent ELISA
- A new general regression-based approach for method comparison studies
- Letters to the Editor
- Procalcitonin values in preeclamptic women are related to severity of disease
- Cross-reactivity between λ antiserum and fibrinogen: a double trap in interpretation of serum protein electrophoresis
- Erroneous result of white blood cell differential count in a patient with mixed hyperlipidemia
- Lack of association of GH T1663A variation and IGFBP3–202A/C polymorphism with risk of ischemic stroke in Chinese
- Erratum
- Quality planning and analytical quality requirements derived from biology
Articles in the same Issue
- Editorial
- CCLM: Evolving to meet the needs of today's laboratory professionals and scientists
- Bacterial detection and blood product contamination
- Editorial: Rapid diagnostic tests to detect pathogenic microorganisms
- Reviews
- Rapid methods for diagnosis of bloodstream infections
- Validation criteria for nucleic acid amplification techniques for bacterial infections
- Incidence of bacterial transmission and transfusion reactions by blood components
- Strategies of bacteria screening in cellular blood components
- Methods for the detection of bacterial contamination in blood products
- Bacteria detection by flow cytometry
- Rapid screening by real-time 16S rDNA PCR for bacterial contamination of blood products
- Microbial safety of cell based medicinal products – what can we learn from cellular blood components?
- Genetics and Molecular Diagnostics
- Screening for genetic heterogeneity in the interferon sensitivity determining region of the hepatitis C virus genome by polymerase chain reaction with melting curve analysis
- Thiopurine S-methyltransferase (TPMT) pharmacogenetics: three new mutations and haplotype analysis in the Estonian population
- Genetic testing for adult-type hypolactasia in Italian families
- Improved real-time detection of the H63D and S65C mutations associated with hereditary hemochromatosis using a SimpleProbe assay format
- Easy detection of 5,10-methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase 1298A/C genotype by mutagenically separated PCR assay
- General Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine
- Mediterranean diet and plasma concentration of inflammatory markers in old and very old subjects in the ZINCAGE population study
- Plasma interleukin-1β, -6, -8 and tumor necrosis factor-α as highly informative markers of pelvic inflammatory disease
- The effect of hypothyroidism, hyperthyroidism, and their treatment on parameters of oxidative stress and antioxidant status
- Breath isoprene – aspects of normal physiology related to age, gender and cholesterol profile as determined in a proton transfer reaction mass spectrometry study
- Prohormone brain natriuretic peptide (proBNP), BNP and N-terminal-proBNP circulating levels in chronic hemodialysis patients. Correlation with ventricular function, fluid removal and effect of hemodiafiltration
- A comparison of two different assays for determining S-100B in serum and urine
- Diagnostic, clinical and laboratory turnaround times in troponin T testing
- Validation and Outcome Studies
- An international comparability study to determine the sources of uncertainty associated with a non-competitive sandwich fluorescent ELISA
- A new general regression-based approach for method comparison studies
- Letters to the Editor
- Procalcitonin values in preeclamptic women are related to severity of disease
- Cross-reactivity between λ antiserum and fibrinogen: a double trap in interpretation of serum protein electrophoresis
- Erroneous result of white blood cell differential count in a patient with mixed hyperlipidemia
- Lack of association of GH T1663A variation and IGFBP3–202A/C polymorphism with risk of ischemic stroke in Chinese
- Erratum
- Quality planning and analytical quality requirements derived from biology
