Startseite Altertumswissenschaften & Ägyptologie Cicero vs. Mark Antony: identity construction and ingroup/outgroup formation in Philippics One and Three
Kapitel
Lizenziert
Nicht lizenziert Erfordert eine Authentifizierung

Cicero vs. Mark Antony: identity construction and ingroup/outgroup formation in Philippics One and Three

  • Merlijn Breunesse
Veröffentlichen auch Sie bei De Gruyter Brill
Erkunden Sie dieses Fachgebiet So veröffentlichen Sie bei uns
Volume II Clause and Discourse
Ein Kapitel aus dem Buch Volume II Clause and Discourse

Abstract

This chapter is concerned with the beginning of the conflict between Cicero and Mark Antony, which was sparked by the orator’s performance of the Philippics and ended with his death in 43 BCE. This starting point has been the subject of much debate among many scholars, including Ramsey (2003), Manuwald (2007), and Usher (2010). Based on Cicero’s intent with and Antony’s interpretation of the speeches, the content of the speeches, and the political climate of 44-43 BCE Rome, they have argued convincingly in favor of either Philippic One or Philippic Three as the conflict’s beginning. This chapter adds to their analyses by taking a Social Constructionist approach to the texts, considering the subtle ways in which Cicero constructs Antony’s identity in Philippics One and Three through his use of language. Taking the three dimensions of identity construction suggested by Bamberg (e.g. 2011a) - sameness/difference, agency, and diachronic identity navigation - as a starting point, it investigates the linguistic devices that contribute to ingroup/outgroup formation. Based on an analysis of phenomena such as category-bound activities, footing-shifts, agency expression, and dissociative demonstratives, it concludes that the conflict between Cicero and Antony started with Philippic Three.

Abstract

This chapter is concerned with the beginning of the conflict between Cicero and Mark Antony, which was sparked by the orator’s performance of the Philippics and ended with his death in 43 BCE. This starting point has been the subject of much debate among many scholars, including Ramsey (2003), Manuwald (2007), and Usher (2010). Based on Cicero’s intent with and Antony’s interpretation of the speeches, the content of the speeches, and the political climate of 44-43 BCE Rome, they have argued convincingly in favor of either Philippic One or Philippic Three as the conflict’s beginning. This chapter adds to their analyses by taking a Social Constructionist approach to the texts, considering the subtle ways in which Cicero constructs Antony’s identity in Philippics One and Three through his use of language. Taking the three dimensions of identity construction suggested by Bamberg (e.g. 2011a) - sameness/difference, agency, and diachronic identity navigation - as a starting point, it investigates the linguistic devices that contribute to ingroup/outgroup formation. Based on an analysis of phenomena such as category-bound activities, footing-shifts, agency expression, and dissociative demonstratives, it concludes that the conflict between Cicero and Antony started with Philippic Three.

Kapitel in diesem Buch

  1. Frontmatter I
  2. Preface V
  3. Contents VII
  4. Clause
  5. Constructions
  6. Linguistic theory in daily lexicographical practice: dealing with arguments and satellites in the entries of regnare and nectere in the Thesaurus Linguae Latinae 1
  7. The expression of knowledge in Latin: cognosco, nosco, scio, nescio and ignoro 20
  8. Los verbos latinos timeo y metuo: sintaxis, semántica y pragmática 48
  9. Potest + passive infinitives: auxiliary or impersonal verb? 67
  10. Ruinam dare : les complexités d’une construction latine à verbe support 79
  11. On the use of the ablative of the gerund and the nominative of the present participle in Latin technical literature 96
  12. Praedicativum and subject complement: a question revisited in light of the Latin verb sto 116
  13. Der lateinische Dativ: neue Wege in Transitivität und funktionaler Semantik 134
  14. Between syntax and magic: some peculiarities of nominal syntax in Latin curse tablets 155
  15. Les complétives en quoniam : étude à partir du latin biblique 174
  16. Semantics
  17. Animacy in Latin: explaining some peripheral phenomena 199
  18. Gallia est omnis divisa in partes tres: Sapir’s typology and different perspectives on totality 219
  19. General extenders in Latin 241
  20. Les parcours sémantiques vers l’adversatif : une approche typologique des langues anciennes 259
  21. The diffraction of iam: contextual effects in interpretation 280
  22. Le système latin de la déixis et de l’endophore : l’évolution linguistique chez Sénèque 296
  23. Discourse
  24. Tense and discourse
  25. On the expression of relative time in Latin narrations 319
  26. Progression thématique et types de séquences chez quelques historiens romains 339
  27. Engaging the audience: an intersubjectivity approach to the historic present tense in Latin 351
  28. ‘I hereby present the use of the Latin first-person perfect indicative as a performative’ 374
  29. Politeness and identity
  30. Expressing happiness as a manifestation of positive politeness in Roman comedy 393
  31. Impoliteness in Plautus’ comedies 413
  32. How to assess politeness in response to impoliteness: some examples from Latin comedy 431
  33. Cicero vs. Mark Antony: identity construction and ingroup/outgroup formation in Philippics One and Three 448
  34. Ego sum Amphitruo: Selbstidentifikation in der römischen Komödie 464
  35. Index 479
https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110678222-024

Kapitel in diesem Buch

  1. Frontmatter I
  2. Preface V
  3. Contents VII
  4. Clause
  5. Constructions
  6. Linguistic theory in daily lexicographical practice: dealing with arguments and satellites in the entries of regnare and nectere in the Thesaurus Linguae Latinae 1
  7. The expression of knowledge in Latin: cognosco, nosco, scio, nescio and ignoro 20
  8. Los verbos latinos timeo y metuo: sintaxis, semántica y pragmática 48
  9. Potest + passive infinitives: auxiliary or impersonal verb? 67
  10. Ruinam dare : les complexités d’une construction latine à verbe support 79
  11. On the use of the ablative of the gerund and the nominative of the present participle in Latin technical literature 96
  12. Praedicativum and subject complement: a question revisited in light of the Latin verb sto 116
  13. Der lateinische Dativ: neue Wege in Transitivität und funktionaler Semantik 134
  14. Between syntax and magic: some peculiarities of nominal syntax in Latin curse tablets 155
  15. Les complétives en quoniam : étude à partir du latin biblique 174
  16. Semantics
  17. Animacy in Latin: explaining some peripheral phenomena 199
  18. Gallia est omnis divisa in partes tres: Sapir’s typology and different perspectives on totality 219
  19. General extenders in Latin 241
  20. Les parcours sémantiques vers l’adversatif : une approche typologique des langues anciennes 259
  21. The diffraction of iam: contextual effects in interpretation 280
  22. Le système latin de la déixis et de l’endophore : l’évolution linguistique chez Sénèque 296
  23. Discourse
  24. Tense and discourse
  25. On the expression of relative time in Latin narrations 319
  26. Progression thématique et types de séquences chez quelques historiens romains 339
  27. Engaging the audience: an intersubjectivity approach to the historic present tense in Latin 351
  28. ‘I hereby present the use of the Latin first-person perfect indicative as a performative’ 374
  29. Politeness and identity
  30. Expressing happiness as a manifestation of positive politeness in Roman comedy 393
  31. Impoliteness in Plautus’ comedies 413
  32. How to assess politeness in response to impoliteness: some examples from Latin comedy 431
  33. Cicero vs. Mark Antony: identity construction and ingroup/outgroup formation in Philippics One and Three 448
  34. Ego sum Amphitruo: Selbstidentifikation in der römischen Komödie 464
  35. Index 479
Jetzt anmelden und 20% sparen
Institutioneller Zugang
Wie funktioniert Authentifizierung?
Haben Sie eine Idee, wie wir unsere Website verbessern können?
Bitte schreiben Sie uns.
© 2025 De Gruyter Brill
Heruntergeladen am 2.10.2025 von https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9783110678222-024/html
Button zum nach oben scrollen