Short sentences, easy to read? Effects of connectives and layout on text comprehension by beginning readers
-
Jacqueline Evers-Vermeul
Abstract
The use of coherence markers, such as the connectives because and but, and presenting texts in an integrated layout support the text comprehension of students in secondary education (Land 2009; Van Silfhout 2014). For children in the early years of primary education, however, the picture is less clear. Children show a gradual increase in their ability to benefit from connectives in texts (Irwin and Pulver 1984), and making return sweeps at the end of lines is a relatively new skill. In a reading experiment among children in grade 2, we tested the effects of layout and the presence of connectives on children’s text comprehension. It is shown that 7- and 8-year-olds benefit from connectives, but that layout (presenting sentences with or without line breaks) does not affect text comprehension. However, children perceive texts with an integrated layout as easier. A corpusbased study revealed that books designed for children in grades 1-3 often do not show such a layout, and that fragmented layouts are predominant in texts for grades 1 and 2. Possible explanations and implications for the design of educational materials for beginning readers are discussed.
Abstract
The use of coherence markers, such as the connectives because and but, and presenting texts in an integrated layout support the text comprehension of students in secondary education (Land 2009; Van Silfhout 2014). For children in the early years of primary education, however, the picture is less clear. Children show a gradual increase in their ability to benefit from connectives in texts (Irwin and Pulver 1984), and making return sweeps at the end of lines is a relatively new skill. In a reading experiment among children in grade 2, we tested the effects of layout and the presence of connectives on children’s text comprehension. It is shown that 7- and 8-year-olds benefit from connectives, but that layout (presenting sentences with or without line breaks) does not affect text comprehension. However, children perceive texts with an integrated layout as easier. A corpusbased study revealed that books designed for children in grades 1-3 often do not show such a layout, and that fragmented layouts are predominant in texts for grades 1 and 2. Possible explanations and implications for the design of educational materials for beginning readers are discussed.
Kapitel in diesem Buch
- Frontmatter I
- Contents V
- Introduction 1
-
Part 1: Relational coherence
- The comprehension of coherence relations in expository texts at the age of 10 and 12 11
- Short sentences, easy to read? Effects of connectives and layout on text comprehension by beginning readers 41
- Explicit coherence relations in children’s and adults’ spoken narratives: the importance of und for the acquisition of German connectives 57
-
Part 2: Referential coherence
- Text organization in typically developing bilinguals and bilinguals at risk of DLD: what is different and how language independent is it? 85
- Referential coherence: Children’s understanding of pronoun anaphora. Insights from mono- and bilingual language acquisition 105
- Reference in French and German: A developmental perspective 139
- The use of pronouns as a developmental factor in early Russian language acquisition 171
- Index 207
Kapitel in diesem Buch
- Frontmatter I
- Contents V
- Introduction 1
-
Part 1: Relational coherence
- The comprehension of coherence relations in expository texts at the age of 10 and 12 11
- Short sentences, easy to read? Effects of connectives and layout on text comprehension by beginning readers 41
- Explicit coherence relations in children’s and adults’ spoken narratives: the importance of und for the acquisition of German connectives 57
-
Part 2: Referential coherence
- Text organization in typically developing bilinguals and bilinguals at risk of DLD: what is different and how language independent is it? 85
- Referential coherence: Children’s understanding of pronoun anaphora. Insights from mono- and bilingual language acquisition 105
- Reference in French and German: A developmental perspective 139
- The use of pronouns as a developmental factor in early Russian language acquisition 171
- Index 207
