Home Linguistics & Semiotics Complementizer-gap phenomena
Chapter
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

Complementizer-gap phenomena

Syntactic or pragmatic constraints?
  • John Löwenadler
View more publications by John Benjamins Publishing Company
Search
Investigations of the Syntax–Semantics–Pragmatics Interface
This chapter is in the book Investigations of the Syntax–Semantics–Pragmatics Interface

Abstract

Since Perlmutter (1971) the complementizer-gap effect has received much attention in linguistic research. This article investigates the solution presented in Van Valin (2005) which states that the phenomenon should be explained in pragmatic rather than syntactic terms. Using data from Swedish and several other languages I will argue that such a solution is unlikely to be correct, and that the English and Swedish facts are better explained by referring to available syntactic constructions. My conclusion is that in a cross-linguistic perspective restrictions on subject extraction must be regarded as a very heterogeneous phenomenon, and in order to explain the empirical data I will suggest a number of competing motivations related to the Accessibility Hierarchy, argument linking and syntactic templates.

Abstract

Since Perlmutter (1971) the complementizer-gap effect has received much attention in linguistic research. This article investigates the solution presented in Van Valin (2005) which states that the phenomenon should be explained in pragmatic rather than syntactic terms. Using data from Swedish and several other languages I will argue that such a solution is unlikely to be correct, and that the English and Swedish facts are better explained by referring to available syntactic constructions. My conclusion is that in a cross-linguistic perspective restrictions on subject extraction must be regarded as a very heterogeneous phenomenon, and in order to explain the empirical data I will suggest a number of competing motivations related to the Accessibility Hierarchy, argument linking and syntactic templates.

Chapters in this book

  1. Prelim pages i
  2. Table of contents v
  3. List of contributors ix
  4. Part I. Introduction by the Editor
  5. Editor's introduction xv
  6. Part II. Verbs, argument structure and transitivity
  7. "Saying" verbs in Spanish 3
  8. Split intransitivity in Japanese revisited 23
  9. Reintroducing inverse constructions in Japanese 37
  10. Transitivity in Kabardian 59
  11. Ditransitive constructions: Towards a new Role and Reference Grammar account? 75
  12. Fluid transitivity and generalized semantic roles 101
  13. Part III. Syntactic and morphological categories
  14. Unification and separation in a functional theory of morphology 119
  15. Modality in RRG 147
  16. RPs and the nature of lexical and syntactic categories in Role and Reference Grammar 161
  17. “Floating plurals”, prodrop and agreement – an optimality-based RRG approach 179
  18. Where is the precore slot? Mapping the layered structure of the clause and German sentence topology 203
  19. Part IV. Syntax, pragmatics and prosody
  20. A prosodic projection for Role and Reference Grammar 227
  21. Is Role and Reference Grammar an adequate grammatical theory for punctuation? 245
  22. The interplay of focus structure and syntax 263
  23. How missing is the missing verb? 285
  24. Predication and reference in specificational sentences – functions of English noun phrases 305
  25. Part V. The analysis of complex sentences
  26. Alternative expressions of 'want' complements 321
  27. An RRG approach to French complementation patterns 337
  28. Complementizer-gap phenomena 359
  29. Wari’ Intentional State Constructions 381
  30. Part VI. Neurolinguistic and computational aspects of RRG
  31. Unmarked transitivity 413
  32. Parsing for Role and Reference Grammar 435
  33. A Role-Lexical Module (RLM) for Biblical Hebrew 455
  34. Index of languages 479
  35. Index of subjects 481
https://doi.org/10.1075/slcs.105.26low

Chapters in this book

  1. Prelim pages i
  2. Table of contents v
  3. List of contributors ix
  4. Part I. Introduction by the Editor
  5. Editor's introduction xv
  6. Part II. Verbs, argument structure and transitivity
  7. "Saying" verbs in Spanish 3
  8. Split intransitivity in Japanese revisited 23
  9. Reintroducing inverse constructions in Japanese 37
  10. Transitivity in Kabardian 59
  11. Ditransitive constructions: Towards a new Role and Reference Grammar account? 75
  12. Fluid transitivity and generalized semantic roles 101
  13. Part III. Syntactic and morphological categories
  14. Unification and separation in a functional theory of morphology 119
  15. Modality in RRG 147
  16. RPs and the nature of lexical and syntactic categories in Role and Reference Grammar 161
  17. “Floating plurals”, prodrop and agreement – an optimality-based RRG approach 179
  18. Where is the precore slot? Mapping the layered structure of the clause and German sentence topology 203
  19. Part IV. Syntax, pragmatics and prosody
  20. A prosodic projection for Role and Reference Grammar 227
  21. Is Role and Reference Grammar an adequate grammatical theory for punctuation? 245
  22. The interplay of focus structure and syntax 263
  23. How missing is the missing verb? 285
  24. Predication and reference in specificational sentences – functions of English noun phrases 305
  25. Part V. The analysis of complex sentences
  26. Alternative expressions of 'want' complements 321
  27. An RRG approach to French complementation patterns 337
  28. Complementizer-gap phenomena 359
  29. Wari’ Intentional State Constructions 381
  30. Part VI. Neurolinguistic and computational aspects of RRG
  31. Unmarked transitivity 413
  32. Parsing for Role and Reference Grammar 435
  33. A Role-Lexical Module (RLM) for Biblical Hebrew 455
  34. Index of languages 479
  35. Index of subjects 481
Sign up now to receive a 20% welcome discount
Institutional Access
How does access work?
Have an idea on how to improve our website?
Please write us.
© 2025 De Gruyter Brill
Downloaded on 18.9.2025 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1075/slcs.105.26low/html
Scroll to top button