Experimental evaluation of ranking and selection methods in term extraction
-
Hiroshi Nakagawa
Abstract
An automatic term extraction system consists of a term candidate extraction subsystem, a ranking subsystem and a selection subsystem. In this paper, we experimentally evaluate two ranking methods and two selection methods. As for ranking, a dichotomy of unithood and termhood is a key notion. We evaluate these two notions experimentally by comparing Imp based ranking method that is based directly on termhood and C-value based method that is indirectly based on both termhood and unithood. As for selection, we compare the simple threshold method with the window method that we propose. We did the experimental evaluation with several Japanese technical manuals. The result does not show much difference in recall and precision. The small difference between the extracted terms by these two ranking methods depends upon their ranking mechanism per se.
Abstract
An automatic term extraction system consists of a term candidate extraction subsystem, a ranking subsystem and a selection subsystem. In this paper, we experimentally evaluate two ranking methods and two selection methods. As for ranking, a dichotomy of unithood and termhood is a key notion. We evaluate these two notions experimentally by comparing Imp based ranking method that is based directly on termhood and C-value based method that is indirectly based on both termhood and unithood. As for selection, we compare the simple threshold method with the window method that we propose. We did the experimental evaluation with several Japanese technical manuals. The result does not show much difference in recall and precision. The small difference between the extracted terms by these two ranking methods depends upon their ranking mechanism per se.
Chapters in this book
- Prelim pages i
- Table of contents vi
- Introduction viii
- A graph-based approach to the automatic generation of multilingual keyword clusters 1
- The automatic construction of faceted terminological feedback for interactive document retrieval 29
- Automatic term detection 53
- Incremental extraction of domain-specific terms from online text resources 89
- Knowledge-based terminology management in medicine 111
- Searching for and identifying conceptual relationships via a corpus-based approach to a Terminological Knowledge Base (CTKB) 127
- Qualitative terminology extraction 149
- General considerations on bilingual terminology extraction 167
- Detection of synonymy links between terms 185
- Extracting useful terms from parenthetical expressions by combining simple rules and statistical measures 209
- Software tools to support the construction of bilingual terminology lexicons 225
- Determining semantic equivalence of terms in information retrieval 245
- Term extraction using a similarity-based approach 261
- Extracting knowledge-rich contexts for terminography 279
- Experimental evaluation of ranking and selection methods in term extraction 303
- Corpus-based extension of a terminological semantic lexicon 327
- Term extraction for automatic abstracting 353
- About the contributors 371
- Subject Index 377
Chapters in this book
- Prelim pages i
- Table of contents vi
- Introduction viii
- A graph-based approach to the automatic generation of multilingual keyword clusters 1
- The automatic construction of faceted terminological feedback for interactive document retrieval 29
- Automatic term detection 53
- Incremental extraction of domain-specific terms from online text resources 89
- Knowledge-based terminology management in medicine 111
- Searching for and identifying conceptual relationships via a corpus-based approach to a Terminological Knowledge Base (CTKB) 127
- Qualitative terminology extraction 149
- General considerations on bilingual terminology extraction 167
- Detection of synonymy links between terms 185
- Extracting useful terms from parenthetical expressions by combining simple rules and statistical measures 209
- Software tools to support the construction of bilingual terminology lexicons 225
- Determining semantic equivalence of terms in information retrieval 245
- Term extraction using a similarity-based approach 261
- Extracting knowledge-rich contexts for terminography 279
- Experimental evaluation of ranking and selection methods in term extraction 303
- Corpus-based extension of a terminological semantic lexicon 327
- Term extraction for automatic abstracting 353
- About the contributors 371
- Subject Index 377
