Home Chapter 8. Polyphonic strategies used in polemical dialogue
Chapter
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

Chapter 8. Polyphonic strategies used in polemical dialogue

  • Daciana Vlad
View more publications by John Benjamins Publishing Company
To Publisher Page
Spaces of Polyphony
This chapter is in the book Spaces of Polyphony

Abstract

This study aims to describe polyphonic strategies used in polemical dialogue. The forms of polyphony that occur in polemics are presented, i.e. strong and conflicting polyphony, which are both forms of dialogic polyphony (Vlad 2010); these are followed by an analysis of the polyphonic strategies adopted by Nicolas Sarkozy and Ségolène Royal in the debate for the French 2007 presidential election. Using strategies such as quotation, echo reply and manipulation, the debaters evoke their opponent’s arguments as a prelude to knocking them down. The author of the distorted discourse may also denounce such malicious discursive practices, situating polemics at the metacommunicative level.

Abstract

This study aims to describe polyphonic strategies used in polemical dialogue. The forms of polyphony that occur in polemics are presented, i.e. strong and conflicting polyphony, which are both forms of dialogic polyphony (Vlad 2010); these are followed by an analysis of the polyphonic strategies adopted by Nicolas Sarkozy and Ségolène Royal in the debate for the French 2007 presidential election. Using strategies such as quotation, echo reply and manipulation, the debaters evoke their opponent’s arguments as a prelude to knocking them down. The author of the distorted discourse may also denounce such malicious discursive practices, situating polemics at the metacommunicative level.

Chapters in this book

  1. Prelim pages i
  2. Table of contents v
  3. Introduction 1
  4. Part 1. Strategies in daily conversations
  5. Chapter 1. Strategy and creativity in dialogue 11
  6. Chapter 2. Conversational irony: Evaluating complaints 25
  7. Chapter 3. Speaking through other voices 43
  8. Part 2. Plural identities and viewpoints in acquisition and language learning
  9. Chapter 4. The self as other: Self words and pronominal reversals in language acquisition 57
  10. Chapter 5. The function of formulations in polyphonic dialogues 73
  11. Chapter 6. Observing the paradox: Interrogative-negative questions as cues for a monophonic promotion of polyphony in educational practices 87
  12. Chapter 7. Co-construction of identity in the Spanish heritage language classroom 101
  13. Part 3. The play of voices in mass media and politics
  14. Chapter 8. Polyphonic strategies used in polemical dialogue 117
  15. Chapter 9. Metacommunication and intertextuality in British and Russian parliamentary answers 129
  16. Chapter 10. The role of prosody in a Czech talk-show 143
  17. Chapter 11. Intertextuality as a means of positioning in a talk-show 161
  18. Part 4. Social and cultural polyphony and intertextuality
  19. Chapter 12. Rumour in the present Romanian press: Aspects of knowledge sources and their linguistic markers 175
  20. Chapter 13. Peritextual dialogue in the dynamics of poetry translatability 189
  21. Chapter 14. Voices through time in Meso-American textiles 205
  22. Part 5. Dialogism in literary discourse
  23. Chapter 15. “Finn Mac Cool in his mind was wrestling with his people”: Polyphonic dialogues in Flann O’Brien’s comic writing 225
  24. Chapter 16. Dialogization, ontology, metadiscourse 237
  25. Chapter 17. Ironic palimpsests in the Romanian poetry of the nineties 251
  26. Chapter 18. Polyphony in interior monologues 265
  27. General references 279
  28. Index 297
https://doi.org/10.1075/ds.15.12ch8

Chapters in this book

  1. Prelim pages i
  2. Table of contents v
  3. Introduction 1
  4. Part 1. Strategies in daily conversations
  5. Chapter 1. Strategy and creativity in dialogue 11
  6. Chapter 2. Conversational irony: Evaluating complaints 25
  7. Chapter 3. Speaking through other voices 43
  8. Part 2. Plural identities and viewpoints in acquisition and language learning
  9. Chapter 4. The self as other: Self words and pronominal reversals in language acquisition 57
  10. Chapter 5. The function of formulations in polyphonic dialogues 73
  11. Chapter 6. Observing the paradox: Interrogative-negative questions as cues for a monophonic promotion of polyphony in educational practices 87
  12. Chapter 7. Co-construction of identity in the Spanish heritage language classroom 101
  13. Part 3. The play of voices in mass media and politics
  14. Chapter 8. Polyphonic strategies used in polemical dialogue 117
  15. Chapter 9. Metacommunication and intertextuality in British and Russian parliamentary answers 129
  16. Chapter 10. The role of prosody in a Czech talk-show 143
  17. Chapter 11. Intertextuality as a means of positioning in a talk-show 161
  18. Part 4. Social and cultural polyphony and intertextuality
  19. Chapter 12. Rumour in the present Romanian press: Aspects of knowledge sources and their linguistic markers 175
  20. Chapter 13. Peritextual dialogue in the dynamics of poetry translatability 189
  21. Chapter 14. Voices through time in Meso-American textiles 205
  22. Part 5. Dialogism in literary discourse
  23. Chapter 15. “Finn Mac Cool in his mind was wrestling with his people”: Polyphonic dialogues in Flann O’Brien’s comic writing 225
  24. Chapter 16. Dialogization, ontology, metadiscourse 237
  25. Chapter 17. Ironic palimpsests in the Romanian poetry of the nineties 251
  26. Chapter 18. Polyphony in interior monologues 265
  27. General references 279
  28. Index 297
Sign up now to receive a 20% welcome discount
Institutional Access
How does access work?
Have an idea on how to improve our website?
Please write us.
© 2025 De Gruyter Brill
Downloaded on 25.10.2025 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1075/ds.15.12ch8/html
Scroll to top button