Home Chapter 22. A primer for linguists on the reading wars
Chapter
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

Chapter 22. A primer for linguists on the reading wars

  • Edwin Battistella
View more publications by John Benjamins Publishing Company
Search
All Things Morphology
This chapter is in the book All Things Morphology

Abstract

As linguists and teachers, we may be asked our opinions on contentious issues of reading instruction such as phonics versus whole language. This chapter reviews debates about reading instruction in the United States, introducing the relevant concepts, issues, research, and personalities to linguists. The chapter begins with a look at pre-nineteenth century views on reading and nineteenth and early twentieth century practices. The mid-twentieth century publication of Why Johnny Can’t Read led to renewed interest in phonics and in linguistics-based reading materials. At the same time, another linguistically-inspired approach, whole language, was being proposed. Today, we have a politically fraught landscape of what are often described as ‘reading wars.’ The chapter ends with a set of recommendations for navigating this landscape.

Abstract

As linguists and teachers, we may be asked our opinions on contentious issues of reading instruction such as phonics versus whole language. This chapter reviews debates about reading instruction in the United States, introducing the relevant concepts, issues, research, and personalities to linguists. The chapter begins with a look at pre-nineteenth century views on reading and nineteenth and early twentieth century practices. The mid-twentieth century publication of Why Johnny Can’t Read led to renewed interest in phonics and in linguistics-based reading materials. At the same time, another linguistically-inspired approach, whole language, was being proposed. Today, we have a politically fraught landscape of what are often described as ‘reading wars.’ The chapter ends with a set of recommendations for navigating this landscape.

Chapters in this book

  1. Prelim pages i
  2. Table of contents v
  3. Chapter 1. All things morphology 1
  4. Part I. Paradigms
  5. Chapter 2. Making sense of morphology 17
  6. Chapter 3. A formal restriction on gender resolution 41
  7. Part II. Words, stems, and affixes
  8. Chapter 4. Signs and words 57
  9. Chapter 5. Leaving the stem by itself 81
  10. Chapter 6. Stem constancy under the microscope 99
  11. Chapter 7. Major lexical categories and graphemic weight 117
  12. Chapter 8. Word formation in the brain 127
  13. Chapter 9. The suffixing preference 147
  14. Part III. Competition, inheritance, and defaults
  15. Chapter 10. Feature-based competition 171
  16. Chapter 11. Competition in comparatives 199
  17. Chapter 12. Multi-layered default in Ripano 215
  18. Part IV. Morphomes
  19. Chapter 13. Morphomes all the way down! 239
  20. Chapter 14. Conditional exponence 255
  21. Chapter 15. My favorite morphome 279
  22. Chapter 16. In further pursuit of the adjective 289
  23. Chapter 17. Two-suffix combinations in native and non-native English 305
  24. Part V. Interfaces
  25. Chapter 18. A short history of phonology in America 327
  26. Chapter 19. Realization Optimality Theory 349
  27. Chapter 20. A-prefixing in the ex-slave narratives 377
  28. Chapter 21. Trajectory of children’s verb formation in Hebrew as a heritage language 395
  29. Chapter 22. A primer for linguists on the reading wars 415
  30. Index of languages 431
  31. Index of names 433
  32. Index of terms 435
https://doi.org/10.1075/cilt.353.22bat

Chapters in this book

  1. Prelim pages i
  2. Table of contents v
  3. Chapter 1. All things morphology 1
  4. Part I. Paradigms
  5. Chapter 2. Making sense of morphology 17
  6. Chapter 3. A formal restriction on gender resolution 41
  7. Part II. Words, stems, and affixes
  8. Chapter 4. Signs and words 57
  9. Chapter 5. Leaving the stem by itself 81
  10. Chapter 6. Stem constancy under the microscope 99
  11. Chapter 7. Major lexical categories and graphemic weight 117
  12. Chapter 8. Word formation in the brain 127
  13. Chapter 9. The suffixing preference 147
  14. Part III. Competition, inheritance, and defaults
  15. Chapter 10. Feature-based competition 171
  16. Chapter 11. Competition in comparatives 199
  17. Chapter 12. Multi-layered default in Ripano 215
  18. Part IV. Morphomes
  19. Chapter 13. Morphomes all the way down! 239
  20. Chapter 14. Conditional exponence 255
  21. Chapter 15. My favorite morphome 279
  22. Chapter 16. In further pursuit of the adjective 289
  23. Chapter 17. Two-suffix combinations in native and non-native English 305
  24. Part V. Interfaces
  25. Chapter 18. A short history of phonology in America 327
  26. Chapter 19. Realization Optimality Theory 349
  27. Chapter 20. A-prefixing in the ex-slave narratives 377
  28. Chapter 21. Trajectory of children’s verb formation in Hebrew as a heritage language 395
  29. Chapter 22. A primer for linguists on the reading wars 415
  30. Index of languages 431
  31. Index of names 433
  32. Index of terms 435
Sign up now to receive a 20% welcome discount
Institutional Access
How does access work?
Have an idea on how to improve our website?
Please write us.
© 2025 De Gruyter Brill
Downloaded on 10.9.2025 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1075/cilt.353.22bat/html
Scroll to top button