Reliable Evaluation of Acceptability of Weld for Final Disposal Based on the Canister Copper Weld Inspection Using Different NDT Methods
-
Jorma Pitkänen
Abstract
The inspection of the sealing weld is an important phase for the evaluation of the acceptability of final disposal canister, but the weld is only a part of the 3D shielding of copper shell. The main tasks for reliable NDT evaluation requires an extensive evaluation of the parameters – which contains typical inspection related items like repeatability, S/N ratio, POD, setting up the equipment for inspection, and all practices for inspections. The other parameters are material parameters, their variation must be taken into account in the evaluation of NDT reliability. Further parameters include human factors, i. e. human inspectors and their interaction with technical systems; their effects were studied on an example of the evaluation of eddy current data. Final parameters are related to evaluation of detected defects, which means sizing and base for acceptance and this can be done in different ways. Some examples are given and results are compared with different methods for instance between radiographic testing and ultrasonic testing by raw data analysis and PA-SAFT results. Also, preliminary curves for the evaluation of metallographic results of 55 defects will be shown by EB weld measurements. Some practical items concerning copper inspections will be also discussed related to acceptability.
Kurzfassung
Die Prüfung der Verschlussschweißnaht ist eine wichtige Phase in der Akzeptanzbewertung der Endlagerungskanister, obwohl die Verschlussschweißnaht nur ein Teil der dreidimensionalen Bedeckung der Kupfereinhüllung ist. Die Hauptaufgabe für die sichere zerstörungsfreie Prüfung (ZfP) erfordert eine umfangreiche Bewertung der Prüfparameter, die die typischen Prüfeinzelheiten, wie z. B. Wiederholbarkeit, Signal-Rausch-Verhältnis, POD, Einstellung der Geräte und alle Prüfvorgehen enthalten. Weitere Parameter sind die Schwankungen von Materialeigenschaften, die berücksichtigt werden müssen. Andere Parameter sind menschliche Faktoren, wie z. B. die Prüfer, und deren Interaktion mit den technischen Systemen, beispielsweise bei der Bewertung der Wirbelstromdaten. Weitere Einflussgrößen auf die Prüfung entstehen bei der Bewertung gefundener Fehler, bei der Größenbestimmung von Fehlern und basierend auf der strukturellen Integrität bei der Akzeptanz von definierten Fehlergrößen/Fehlerarten an verschiedenen Positionen in der Schweißnaht. Der Artikel zeigt einige Beispiele und den Vergleich zwischen verschiedenen ZfP-Methoden, z. B. der radiographische Prüfung, der Ultraschallprüfung mit Bewertung von Rohdaten und der Ultraschallprüfung mit Bewertung mittels PA-SAFT. Auch die vorläufigen Kurven für die metallographische Bewertung von 55 Fehlern der Elektronenstrahlschweißung sind gezeigt. Darüber hinaus wird auch eine praktische Vorgehensweise bei der Definition der Akzeptanzkriterien für die Kupferschweißnahtsprüfung diskutiert.
References
1 H.Raiko: Canister Design 2012, Report POSIVA 2012–13, Posiva OySearch in Google Scholar
2 J.Pitkänen, T.Salonen, M.Bertovic, C.Müller, M.Pavlovic: NDT Reliability in Risk Minimization during Manufacturing and Welding of Spent Nuclear Fuel Disposal Components – A Realistic Tool for Reliable Inspections, Proceedings of the 4th European American Workshop on Reliability of NDE, 24th–26th June 2009, Berlin, Germany, p. 21Search in Google Scholar
3 J.Pitkänen, R.Paussu, P.Pohjanne, I.Virkkunen, M.Kemppainen, A.Lipponen, M.Sarkimo, K.Simola, K.-M.Reddy: Metallographic Study of Detected Indications in EB Copper Welds for Verifying the NDT Reliability of Inspection, Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on NDE in Relation to Structural Integrity for Nuclear and Pressurized Components, 29th September-1st October 2010, Berlin, GermanySearch in Google Scholar
4 J.Pitkänen, T.Salonen, A.Lipponen, M.Sarkimo, R.Paussu: Ultrasonic testing of copper welds, Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on NDE in Relation to Structural Integrity for Nuclear and Pressurized Components, 29th September-1st October 2010, Berlin, GermanySearch in Google Scholar
5 J.Pitkänen, A.Lipponen, H.Raiko, G.Brekow, D.Brackrock: Defect sizing using PA ultrasonic testing and acceptance in copper lids, tubes and welds for disposal canister, Proceedings of the 10th International Conference on NDE in Relation to Structural Integrity for Nuclear and Pressurized Components, October 1st–3rd 2013, Cannes, France, p. 11Search in Google Scholar
6 J.Pitkänen, A.Lipponen, K.Lahdenperä, I.Kiselmann: Eddy current inspection for detection of surface and near surface defects in copper components and an electron beam welds, Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on NDE in Relation to Structural Integrity for Nuclear and Pressurized Components, 12th–14th May 2009, Yokohama, Japan, p. 13Search in Google Scholar
7 J.Pitkänen, A.Lipponen, K.Lahdenperä, I.Kiselmann: Detection and sizing in copper components using eddy current, Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on NDE in Relation to Structural Integrity for Nuclear and Pressurized Components, 22nd–24th May 2012, Seattle, USASearch in Google Scholar
8 J.Pitkänen, T.Salonen, S.Sandlin, U.Ronneteg: Defect detectability in EB welded copper disposal canister with 9 MeV accelerator, Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on NDE in Relation to Structural Integrity for Nuclear and Pressurized Components, Budapest, 12th–14th October 2007, p. 14Search in Google Scholar
9 J.Pitkänen, R.Paussu, P.Seppälä, T.Saastamoinen, D.Kanzler, C.Müller: Remote visual inspection of disposal canister EB weld, Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on NDE in Relation to Structural Integrity for Nuclear and Pressurized Components, 22nd–24th May 2012, Seattle, USASearch in Google Scholar
10 J.Pitkänen, W.Arnold, S.Hirsekorn: The effect of grain size to defect detectability in copper components in ultrasonic testing, Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on NDE in Relation to Structural Integrity for Nuclear and Pressurized Components, 12th–14th October 2007, Budapest, Hungary, p. 14Search in Google Scholar
11 J.Pitkänen: Posiva Report 2010–04 – Inspection of bottom and lid welds for disposal canisters, September 2010, p. 98Search in Google Scholar
12 MIL-HDBK-1823A: Non-destructive evaluation system reliability assessment, Department of Defence Handbook, 2009Search in Google Scholar
13 A. P.Berens: NDE Reliability Data Analysis, In: Metals Handbook, Volume 17, 9th Edition: Non-destructive Evaluation and Quality Control, ASM International, OH, 1989Search in Google Scholar
14 D.Kanzler, C.Müller, J.Pitkänen: Evaluation of radiographic performance with an advanced POD approach, Proceedings of the 5th European American Workshop on Reliability of NDE, 7th–10th October 2013, Berlin, Germany, p. 6Search in Google Scholar
15 M.Bertovic, B.Fahlbruch, C.Müller: Human Factors Perspective on the Reliability of NDT in Nuclear Applications, Material Testing 4 (2013), Vol. 55, pp. 243–253Search in Google Scholar
16 M.Bertovic: Human factors in NDT of the EB weld, Posiva Report 2012–38, p. 111 (to be published)Search in Google Scholar
17 ASME XI 2013: Article IWA3300 Standards for examination evaluation, Rules for inservice inspection of nuclear power plant components, American society of mechanical engineers, New York, USA, pp. 14–25Search in Google Scholar
18 J.Pitkänen: Posiva Report 2012–35 – Inspection of disposal canisters components, December 2013, p. 95Search in Google Scholar
© 2014, Carl Hanser Verlag, München
Articles in the same Issue
- Inhalt/Contents
- Inhalt
- Fachbeiträge/Technical Contributions
- Burst Strength of Composite Cylinders – Assessment of the Type of Statistical Distribution
- Effects of Zn/Cu Ratio and Silicon on Microstructure, Mechanical Properties, Tarnish and Corrosion Resistance of As-Cast 940 Silver Alloys
- Analysis of the Frequency as an Integral Method for the Testing of Anisotropic 3D Sheet Metal Structure
- Mechanical and Thermal Properties of a Cu-CNT Composite with Carbon Nanotubes Synthesized by CVD Process
- The Mechanical and Electrical Properties of the Ternary Bi-Ga-Sb System
- Experimental Investigation of the Corrosion Mechanism of Cemented Soils in Magnesium Sulfate Solution
- Experimental and Analytical Study of Masonry Constructions Reinforced with Bed Joints
- The Fracture Toughness of Fe2B Formed on Boronized AISI 304
- Effects of Ferroboron and Ferrochromium Powder Addition on Abrasive Wear Resistance of Fe-Based Hardfacing Coatings
- Fabrication of Al/Mg Bimetal Compound Casting by Lost Foam Technique and Liquid-Solid Process
- Effects of Si and Zn on Machinability and Wear Resistance of AZ91 and AS91 Magnesium Alloys
- DIRECTT-Rekonstruktionen im Vergleich zur gefilterten Rückprojektion
- Reduzierung von Missing-Wedge-Artefakten der CT mit DIRECTT
- Röntgentomografische Untersuchung eines kommerziellen Lithium-Ionen-Kondensators*
- Machining Parameter Optimization of Bidirectional CFRP Composite Pipe by Genetic Algorithm
- Investigation of Lost Foam Casted Aluminum Bimetal Microstructures
- Taguchi-Based Grey Relation Optimization of Machining Parameters and Cutting Path Strategies in CNC Pocket Milling Operations
- Reliable Evaluation of Acceptability of Weld for Final Disposal Based on the Canister Copper Weld Inspection Using Different NDT Methods
- Evaluation of the Reliability of NDTesting in Russian Railway Transport
- Vorschau/Preview
- Vorschau
Articles in the same Issue
- Inhalt/Contents
- Inhalt
- Fachbeiträge/Technical Contributions
- Burst Strength of Composite Cylinders – Assessment of the Type of Statistical Distribution
- Effects of Zn/Cu Ratio and Silicon on Microstructure, Mechanical Properties, Tarnish and Corrosion Resistance of As-Cast 940 Silver Alloys
- Analysis of the Frequency as an Integral Method for the Testing of Anisotropic 3D Sheet Metal Structure
- Mechanical and Thermal Properties of a Cu-CNT Composite with Carbon Nanotubes Synthesized by CVD Process
- The Mechanical and Electrical Properties of the Ternary Bi-Ga-Sb System
- Experimental Investigation of the Corrosion Mechanism of Cemented Soils in Magnesium Sulfate Solution
- Experimental and Analytical Study of Masonry Constructions Reinforced with Bed Joints
- The Fracture Toughness of Fe2B Formed on Boronized AISI 304
- Effects of Ferroboron and Ferrochromium Powder Addition on Abrasive Wear Resistance of Fe-Based Hardfacing Coatings
- Fabrication of Al/Mg Bimetal Compound Casting by Lost Foam Technique and Liquid-Solid Process
- Effects of Si and Zn on Machinability and Wear Resistance of AZ91 and AS91 Magnesium Alloys
- DIRECTT-Rekonstruktionen im Vergleich zur gefilterten Rückprojektion
- Reduzierung von Missing-Wedge-Artefakten der CT mit DIRECTT
- Röntgentomografische Untersuchung eines kommerziellen Lithium-Ionen-Kondensators*
- Machining Parameter Optimization of Bidirectional CFRP Composite Pipe by Genetic Algorithm
- Investigation of Lost Foam Casted Aluminum Bimetal Microstructures
- Taguchi-Based Grey Relation Optimization of Machining Parameters and Cutting Path Strategies in CNC Pocket Milling Operations
- Reliable Evaluation of Acceptability of Weld for Final Disposal Based on the Canister Copper Weld Inspection Using Different NDT Methods
- Evaluation of the Reliability of NDTesting in Russian Railway Transport
- Vorschau/Preview
- Vorschau