Disappearing ink! Unraveling the fading of a contemporary design object
-
Gregory D. Smith
,
Victor J. Chen
Abstract
In 2009 the Indianapolis Museum of Art acquired Fernando Brizio’s contemporary ceramic, Painting a Fresco with GiottoGiotto Turbocolor Marker"?>#3, as part of its effort to grow a collection of modern and contemporary European design objects. The artwork comprises an unglazed white faience vase that has been pierced with 30 brightly colored felt-tip markers whose dried ink stains create a whimsical polka-dot surface. The vase immediately joined a traveling exhibition, and when it returned to the museum after nearly a year of display, many of the ink spots had faded dramatically, some having nearly vanished. Technical analysis was undertaken to (1) determine the cause of the fading and the composition of its Giotto brand Turbocolor markers, (2) to determine the future fading potential of the object, and (3) to suggest new safeguards to protect this and similar objects from future damage. Non-destructive analysis of the vase using Raman spectroscopy proved challenging due to the overall application of an acrylic varnish by the artist and the intense fluorescence of many of the marker inks. Using liquid chromatography with mass spectrometry on surrogate pens acquired in 2014, the 30 markers utilized in the object were ultimately determined to contain 9 primary synthetic dyes and numerous synthetic byproducts. The inks are comprised of food colorants, which accounts for their rapid fading. In situ microfade testing showed that the vase is still extremely light sensitive and will fade further under even the most stringent lighting protocols. An artist interview provided valuable information about Brizio‘s thoughts concerning the life of these objects, his working methods, and the interpretation of the Giotto series of ceramics. The artwork has since been deaccessioned from the museum’s collection but has taken on a new role in gallery didactics focused on the materials of modern design and the ephemeral and changing nature of some artworks. This project highlights the urgency of characterizing the fading rate of potentially light sensitive modern art or directly identifying the colorants used in contemporary artworks prior to their first exhibition.
Acknowledgements
The authors acknowledge the generous gift of the Alliance of the Indianapolis Museum of Art who funded the purchase of the artwork. Former design curator Mr R. Craig Miller is recognized for initially bringing the condition issues related to the vase to our attention. Surrogate Giotto Turbocolor markers were donated by the manufacturer F.I.L.A. Italia, and some powdered dyestuffs were generously provided by Abbey Color of Philadelphia. Eric Lubrick is thanked for his assistance in acquiring professional quality images of the artwork. Financial assistance was provided by the Carter Family Fund and the Frenzel Family Charitable Lead Trust. Mr Luke Gallion is acknowledged for his earlier work using TLC to separate the dye components of the Giotto brand markers. We appreciate the input and support of Newfields’ Associate Curator of Design and Decorative Arts, Shelly Selim. Finally, Mr Fernando Brizio is to be thanked for his thoughtful replies to our inquiries regarding the Giotto series and his willingness to let our experiences with his vase assist in the future preservation of contemporary art and design.
References
[1] Selim S. 2018. Personal communication. February 1 2018.Search in Google Scholar
[2] Brizio F. Personal communication 2014.Search in Google Scholar
[3] Marcus JS. A 21st-century artisan. Wall Street J. 2011 March 25. https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748704608504576208320312276158.Search in Google Scholar
[4] Miller RC, Spark P, McDermott C. European design since 1985: shaping the new century. London: Merrell, 2009.Search in Google Scholar
[5] Ahlberg P, Smith GD. Perspectives on: an art museum laboratory. Lab Manager. 2013;8:62–5.Search in Google Scholar
[6] Owen A. Modern materials in drawings part 1 – media. Drawing. 1985;7:56–9.Search in Google Scholar
[7] Lafontaine R. The lightfastness of felt-tip pens. J IIC Can Group. 1978;4:9–16.Search in Google Scholar
[8] Ellis MH. Drawings in fibre-tipped pen – new conservation challenges. In: Richmond A, editor. Modern works, modern problems? Conference papers. Leigh, UK: Institute of Paper Conservation, 1994:114–21.Search in Google Scholar
[9] Feller R. Felt-tipped markers and the need for standards of lightfastness for artists’ colorants. Bulletin IIC – Amer Group. 1967;8:24–6.10.2307/3179156Search in Google Scholar
[10] Ellis MH. The porous pointed pen as artistic medium. In: Fairbrass S, editor. The institute of paper conservation: conference papers, Manchester, 1992. Leigh, UK: Institute of Paper Conservation, 1992:11–8.Search in Google Scholar
[11] Michalski S. 1997. The lighting decision. In Fabric of an exhibition, preprints of textile symposium 97, Canadian Conservation Institute: Ottawa, 97–104.Search in Google Scholar
[12] Whitmore PM, Pan X, Bailie C. Predicting the fading of objects: identification of fugitive colorants through direct nondestructive lightfastness measurements. J Am Inst Conserv. 1999;38:395–409.10.2307/3179999Search in Google Scholar
[13] Giotto. 2018. https://www.fila.it/it/en/brand/giotto/ Accessed June 27, 2018.Search in Google Scholar
[14] Sodo A, Bicchieri M, Guiso M, Ricci MA, Ricci G. Raman investigations on marker pen inks. J Raman Spectrosc. 2012;43:1781–7.10.1002/jrs.4070Search in Google Scholar
[15] van der Werf ID, Andriani E, Albanese A, Daurelio G, Marano D, Sabbatini L, et al. Laser removal and chemical characterisation of graffiti paint spray and felt-tip markers on stone monuments. In: Townsend JH, Toniolo L, Cappitelli F, editors. Conservation science 2007. London: Archetype, 2008:23–32.Search in Google Scholar
[16] Dupuis-Labbé D, Enshaian M-C. Les 39 dessins du “Mystère Picasso”: genèse d’une création, évolution d’un projet de conservation-restauration. Technè. 2005;22:88–95.Search in Google Scholar
[17] Banks BA, Rutledge SK, Karla M, Norris MJ, Real WA, Haytas CA. Use of an atmospheric oxygen beam for restoration of defaced paintings. In: Bridgland J, editor. 12th Triennial meeting, Lyon, 29 August-3 September 1999: preprints (ICOM Committee for Conservation). vol. 1. London: Earthscan Ltd., 1999:271–5.Search in Google Scholar
[18] Germinario G, Garrappa S, D’Ambrosio V, van der Werf ID, Sabbatini L. Chemical composition of felt-tip pen inks. Anal Bioanal Chem. 2018;410:1079–94.10.1007/s00216-017-0687-xSearch in Google Scholar PubMed
[19] Garrappa S, Germinario G, van der Werf ID, Mirabile A, Sabbatini L. Multi-analytical study of artist felt-tip pen inks. In: 2nd IMEKO International Conference on Metrology for Archaeology and Cultural Heritage. Budapest, Hungary: IMEKO, 2016:136–9.Search in Google Scholar
[20] Izzo FC, Vitale V, Fabbro C, van Keulen H. Multi-analytical investigation of felt-tip pen inks: formulation and preliminary photo-degradation study. Microchem J. 2016;124:919–28.10.1016/j.microc.2015.09.008Search in Google Scholar
[21] Germinario G, Rigantea ECL, van der Werf ID, Sabbatinia L. Pyrolysis-gas chromatography–mass spectrometry of triarylmethane dyes. J Anal Appl Pyrolysis. 2017;127;229–39.10.1016/j.jaap.2017.08.001Search in Google Scholar
[22] Tsuge S, Ohtani H, Watanabe C. Pyrolysis-GC/MS data book of synthetic polymers. Oxford: Elsevier, 2011.Search in Google Scholar
[23] Green FJ. Sigma-Aldrich® handbook of stains, dyes and indicators. Milwaukee, WI, USA: Sigma Aldrich Company. 1990.Search in Google Scholar
[24] Smith GD, Clark RJH. Raman microscopy in archaeological science. J Arch Sci. 2004;31:1137–60.10.1016/j.jas.2004.02.008Search in Google Scholar
[25] Smith GD, Clark RJH. Raman microscopy in art history and conservation science. Rev Conserv. 2001;2:92–106.10.1179/sic.2001.46.Supplement-1.92Search in Google Scholar
[26] Casadio F, Mauck K, Chefitz M, Freeman R. Direct identification of early synthetic dyes: FT-Raman study of the illustrated broadside prints of José Gaudalupe Posada (1852–1913). J Raman Spectrosc. 2010;100:885–99.10.1007/s00339-010-5668-2Search in Google Scholar
[27] Zaffino C, Passaretti A, Poldi G, Fratelli M, Tibiletti A, Bestetti R, et al. A multi-technique approach to the chemical characterization of colored inks in contemporary art: the materials of Lucio Fontana. J Cult Herit. 2017;23:87–97.10.1016/j.culher.2016.09.006Search in Google Scholar
[28] Carona M. 2011a. Fernando Brizio in wonderland. http://upmagazine-tap.com/en/pt_artigos/fernando-brizio-in-wonderland/ Accessed July 24 2018.Search in Google Scholar
[29] Carona M. 2011b. Fernando Brizio … design made in PT. http://azul-profundo-ferdos.blogspot.com/2011/10/fernando-brizio-design-made-in-pt.html Accessed July 24 2018.Search in Google Scholar
[30] Smith GD. Cow urine, Indian yellow, and art forgeries: an update. For Sci Int. 2017;276:e30–4.10.1016/j.forsciint.2017.04.013Search in Google Scholar PubMed
[31] Ploeger R, Shugar AN, Smith GD, Chen V. Late nineteenth century accounts of Indian yellow: the analysis of samples from the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew. Dyes Pigments. 2019;160:418–431.in press10.1016/j.dyepig.2018.08.014Search in Google Scholar
[32] Brosseau CL, Gambardella A, Casadio F, Grzywacz CM, Wouters J, Van Duyne RP. Ad-hoc surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy methodologies for the detection of artist dyestuffs: thin layer chromatography-surface enhanced Raman spectroscopy in situ on the fiber analysis. Anal Chem. 2009;81:3056–62.10.1021/ac802761vSearch in Google Scholar PubMed
[33] Saviello D, Trabace M, Alyami A, Mirabile A, Giorgi R, Baglioni P, et al. A combined surface enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS )/UV-vis approach for the investigation of dye content in commercial felt tip pens inks. Talanta. 2018;181:448–53.10.1016/j.talanta.2018.01.049Search in Google Scholar PubMed
[34] Saviello D, Di Gioia A, Turenne PI, Trabace M, Giorgi R, Mirabile A, et al. Handheld surface-enhanced Raman scattering identification of dye chemical composition in felt-tip pen drawings. J Raman Spectrosc. 2018;1–10. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/jrs.5411.10.1002/jrs.5411Search in Google Scholar
[35] Griffin R, Spears L. Other methods of colour analysis: 12.1 high-performance liquid chromatography. In: Robertson J, Grieve M, editors. Forensic analysis of fibers, 2nd ed. London: Taylor & Francis, 1999: 315–22.Search in Google Scholar
[36] Kirby J, ed. The diversity of dyes in history and archaeology. London: Archetype, 2017.Search in Google Scholar
[37] Volná K, Holcapek M, Kolárova L, Lemr K, Cáslavsky J, Kacer P, et al. Comparison of negative ion electrospray mass spectra measured by seven tandem mass analyzers towards library formation. Rapid Comm Mass Spectrom. 2008;22:101–8.10.1002/rcm.3334Search in Google Scholar PubMed
[38] Chen VJ, Smith GD, Holden A, Paydar N, Kiefer K. The dating of an Uzbek ceremonial coat by dye analysis using liquid chromatography -mass spectrometry. Dyes Pigments. 2016;131:320–32.10.1016/j.dyepig.2016.04.019Search in Google Scholar
[39] Frick D. The coloration of food . Rev Prog Color. 2003;33:15–32.10.1111/j.1478-4408.2003.tb00141.xSearch in Google Scholar
[40] Yang Y, Zhang J, Shao B. Quantitative analysis of fourteen synthetic dyes in jelly and gummy candy by ultra performance liquid chromatography. Anal Methods. 2014;6:5872–8.10.1039/C4AY00371CSearch in Google Scholar
[41] Bento WAS, Lima BP, Paim APS. Simultaneous determination of synthetic colorants in yogurt by HPLC. Food Chem. 2015;183:154–60.10.1016/j.foodchem.2015.03.050Search in Google Scholar PubMed
[42] Weisz A, Mazzola EP, Ito Y. Preparative separation of di- and trisulfonated components of Quinoline yellow using affinity-ligand pH-zone-refining counter-current chromatography. J Chrom A. 2001;1216:4161–8.10.1016/j.chroma.2009.02.064Search in Google Scholar PubMed PubMed Central
[43] Scheifers SM, Verma S, Cooks RG. Characterization of organic dyes by secondary ion mass spectrometry. Anal Chem. 1983;55:2260–6.10.1021/ac00264a015Search in Google Scholar
[44] Cioccolani E. Personal communication. September 11, 2018.Search in Google Scholar
[45] van der Werf ID, Germinario G, Palmisano F, Sabbatini L. Characterisation of permanent markers by pyrolysis gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. Anal Bioanal Chem. 2011;399:3483–90.10.1007/s00216-011-4714-zSearch in Google Scholar PubMed
[46] Pfingstag G. Colorants in inks for writing, drawing and marking. J Soc Dyers Colorists. 1993;109;188–92.10.1111/j.1478-4408.1993.tb01556.xSearch in Google Scholar
[47] Druzik J. Oriel microfading tester (MFT): a brief description. In: Joel Thompson, Amanda Holden, Glenn Petersen, Sarah Stevens, editors. Textile specialty group postprints. vol. 20. Washington, DC: AIC, 2010:135–43.Search in Google Scholar
[48] Townsend JH, Thomas J, Hackney S, Lerwill A. The benefits and risks of anoxic display for colorants. In: Saunders D, Townsend JH, Woodcock S, editors. Conservation and access: contributions to the London Congress 15–19 September 2008. London: IIC, 2008:76–81.10.1179/sic.2008.53.Supplement-1.76Search in Google Scholar
[49] Casella L, Sanderson K. Display of Alfred Stieglitz and Edward Steichen autochrome plates: anoxic sealed package and lighting conditions. Top Photographic Preserv. 2011;14:162–7.Search in Google Scholar
[50] Beltran V, Druzik J, Maekawa S. Large-scale assessment of light-induced color change in air and anoxic environments. Stud Conserv. 2012;57:42–57.10.1179/2047058411Y.0000000006Search in Google Scholar
[51] Bahr S. 2018. Gallery was remade with touch in mind. Indianapolis Star, July 27th, 2018, 8A.Search in Google Scholar
© 2019 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
Articles in the same Issue
- Disappearing ink! Unraveling the fading of a contemporary design object
- Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy in heritage science
- Mechanistic role of plant-based bitter principles and bitterness prediction for natural product studies I: Database and methods
- Homogeneous visible light mediated transition metal catalysis other than Ruthenium and Iridium
- Total reflection X-ray fluorescence
- Cheminformatics techniques in antimalarial drug discovery and development from natural products 1: basic concepts
Articles in the same Issue
- Disappearing ink! Unraveling the fading of a contemporary design object
- Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy in heritage science
- Mechanistic role of plant-based bitter principles and bitterness prediction for natural product studies I: Database and methods
- Homogeneous visible light mediated transition metal catalysis other than Ruthenium and Iridium
- Total reflection X-ray fluorescence
- Cheminformatics techniques in antimalarial drug discovery and development from natural products 1: basic concepts
