Able leaders and fallible men: success and excess in Iliadic battle exhortations
-
Poulheria Kyriakou
Abstract:
Battle exhortations are found throughout the fighting books of Homer’s Iliad, primarily in the narrative of the great battle that spans books 11 to 18. The early examples of exhortations prefigure their increasingly important role in later books, especially 15 and 17. From the perspective of the macro-narrative, the frequency of exhortations and the choice of motifs they feature serve as indicators of the progress of fighting. On the level of micro-narratives, the exhortations of individual leaders highlight their strengths and weaknesses, and to an extent those of their respective camps, especially in the case of paired exhortations and those delivered by the same leader such as Hector or Ajax. The narrator employs exhortations as a means of illustrating the back and forth between personal, emotional commitments, or deluded expectations, and sober, collective pursuit of a strategic goal. Despite their seniority or prowess, the exhorting leaders do not present themselves as models the addressees, especially the rank and file, should emulate. This indicates that the narrative of exhortations privileges collectivity and cooperation over competitiveness, fostering the ideal of fighting in solidarity for the common goal. The failure to draw distinctions by stressing one’s achievements or advantages contrasts with several rebukes, and with the paraenetic speeches of Nestor off the battlefield. References to the all-important epic ideal of the pursuit or acquisition of glory, and even to the past, occur very rarely. This is noteworthy, especially as the past also looms large in paraenetic speeches delivered off the battlefield, primarily those of Nestor and Phoenix. Iliadic speakers on the battlefield are generally efficient, although naturally to varying degrees, but they run the danger of deviating from their goal because of their personal illusions and limitations. Exhortations show how the attempt to achieve the common goal, to do one’s duty as leader and comrade, and especially to fulfill one’s personal ambitions may sometimes shape an idiosyncratic or distorted view of past and future.
Bibliography
Aceti, C. / Leuzzi, D. / Pagani, L. (eds.) (2008), Eroi nell’Iliade, Roma.Suche in Google Scholar
Adkins, A.W.H. (1969), “Εὔχομαι, εὐχωλή, and εὖχος in Homer”, in: CQ 19, 20–33.Suche in Google Scholar
Alden, M. (2000), Homer beside himself, Oxford.Suche in Google Scholar
Andersen, Ø. (1978), Die Diomedesgestalt in der Ilias, Oslo.Suche in Google Scholar
Andersen, Ø. (1990), “The making of the past in the Iliad”, in: HSCP 93, 25–45.10.2307/311281Suche in Google Scholar
Barker, E.T.E. (2009), Entering the agon, Oxford.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199542710.001.0001Suche in Google Scholar
Cairns, D.L. (1993), Aidôs, Oxford.10.1002/9781444350302.wbhe0034Suche in Google Scholar
de Jong, I.J.F. (1987), Narrators and focalizers, Amsterdam.Suche in Google Scholar
Donlan, W. (1998), “Political reciprocity in Dark Age Greece: Odysseus and his hetairoi”, in: C. Gill et al. (eds.), Reciprocity in ancient Greece, Oxford, 51–71.Suche in Google Scholar
Edwards, M.W. (1991), The Iliad: a commentary. Volume V: books 17–20, Cambridge.10.1017/CBO9781139165976Suche in Google Scholar
Fenik, B. (1968), Typical battle scenes in the Iliad, Wiesbaden.Suche in Google Scholar
Fenik, B. (1986), Homer and the Nibelungenlied, Cambridge (Mass.).10.4159/harvard.9780674333642Suche in Google Scholar
Fingerle, A. (1939), Typik der homerischen Reden, Diss. Munich.Suche in Google Scholar
Frazer, R.M. (1985), “The crisis of leadership among the Greeks and Poseidon’s intervention in Iliad 14”, in: Hermes 113, 1–9.Suche in Google Scholar
Griffin, J. (1980), Homer on life and death, Oxford.Suche in Google Scholar
Griffin, J. (1986), “Homeric words and speakers”, in: JHS 106, 36–57.10.2307/629641Suche in Google Scholar
Hainsworth, B. (1993), The Iliad: a commentary. Volume III: books 9–12, Cambridge.10.1017/CBO9780511518386Suche in Google Scholar
Haubold, J. (2000), Homer’s people, Cambridge.10.1017/CBO9781107297975Suche in Google Scholar
Heiden, B. (2008), Homer’s cosmic fabrication, Oxford.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195341072.001.0001Suche in Google Scholar
Hoekstra, A. (1962), “A note on the dative of purpose (dativus finalis) in Greek”, in: Mnemosyne 15, 15–23.Suche in Google Scholar
Janko. R. (1992), The Iliad: a commentary. Volume IV: books 13–16, Cambridge.10.1017/CBO9780511620249Suche in Google Scholar
Keitel, E. (1987), “Homeric antecedents to the cohortatio in the ancient historians”, in: CW 80, 153–72.10.2307/4350006Suche in Google Scholar
Kirk, G.S. (1990), The Iliad: a commentary. Volume II: books 5–8, Cambridge.10.1017/CBO9780511620270Suche in Google Scholar
Knudsen, Rachel Ahern (2014), Homeric speech and the origins of rhetoric, Baltimore.10.1353/book.28978Suche in Google Scholar
Kyriakou, P. (2001), “Warrior vaunts in the Iliad”, in: RhM 144, 250–77.Suche in Google Scholar
Latacz, J. (1977), Kampfparänese, Kampfdarstellung und Kampfwirklichkeit in der Ilias, bei Kallinos und Tyrtaios, Munich.Suche in Google Scholar
Lohmann, D. (1970), Die Komposition der Reden in der Ilias, Berlin.10.1515/9783110833768Suche in Google Scholar
Mackie, H. (1996), Talking Trojan, Lanham.Suche in Google Scholar
Martin, R. (1989), The language of heroes, Ithaca-London.Suche in Google Scholar
Michel, C. (1971), Erläuterungen zum N der Ilias, Heidelberg.Suche in Google Scholar
Moulton, C. (1981), “The speech of Glaukos in Iliad 17”, in: Hermes 109, 1–18.Suche in Google Scholar
Μπεζαντάκος, Ν.Π. (1996), Η ρητορική της Ομηρικής μάχης, Αθήνα.Suche in Google Scholar
Muellner, L. (1976), The meaning of ΕΥΧΟΜΑΙ through its formulas, Innsbruck.Suche in Google Scholar
Neal, T. (2006), The wounded hero, Bern.Suche in Google Scholar
O’Sullivan, J.N. (1989), “θοός, -ῶς”, in: LfgrE ΙΙ 13, 1053–55.Suche in Google Scholar
Parks, W. (1990), Verbal dueling in heroic narrative, Princeton.10.1515/9781400860883Suche in Google Scholar
Rabel, R.J. (1991), “Agamemnon’s Iliad”, in: GRBS 32, 103–117.Suche in Google Scholar
Richardson, S. (1990), The Homeric narrator, Nashville.Suche in Google Scholar
Schnapp-Gourbeillon, A. (1981), Lions, héros, masques. Paris.10.3917/dec.schna.1981.01Suche in Google Scholar
Stoevesandt, M. (2004), Feinde-Gegner-Opfer, Basel.Suche in Google Scholar
Stoevesandt, M. (2008), Homers Ilias Gesamtkommentar. Band IV. Sechster Gesang (Z). Faszikel 2, Kommentar, Berlin-New York.Suche in Google Scholar
Taplin, O. (1990), “Agamemnon’s role in the Iliad”, in C. Pelling (ed.), Characterization and individuality in Greek literature, Oxford, 60–82.Suche in Google Scholar
van Wees, H. (1988), “Kings in combat: Battles and heroes in the Iliad”, in: CQ 38, 1–24.10.1017/S0009838800031219Suche in Google Scholar
von Erffa, C. (1937), Aidos und verwandte Begriffe in ihrer Entwicklung von Homer bis Demokrit, Leipzig.Suche in Google Scholar
Whitman, C.H. / Scodel, R. (1981), “Sequence and simultaneity in Iliad Ν, Ξ, and Ο”, in: HSCP 85, 1–15.Suche in Google Scholar
Willcock, M. (1977), “Ad hoc invention in the Iliad”, in: HSCP 81, 41–53.10.2307/311110Suche in Google Scholar
Willcock, M. (2002), “Menelaos in the Iliad”, in: M. Reichel / A. Rengakos (eds.), Epea pteroenta: Beiträge zur Homerforschung, Stuttgart, 221–229.Suche in Google Scholar
Winter, F.J. (1956), Die Kampfszenen in den Gesängen M N O der Ilias, Diss. Frankfurt.Suche in Google Scholar
Wißmann, J. (1997), Motivation und Schmähung, Stuttgart.10.1007/978-3-476-04284-2Suche in Google Scholar
© 2017 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
Artikel in diesem Heft
- Titelseiten
- Towards a new critical edition of the scholia to the Iliad: a specimen
- Able leaders and fallible men: success and excess in Iliadic battle exhortations
- The Cult of Demeter on Andros and the Homeric Hymn to Demeter
- Interactions with the Beloved in Greek Literature: Conceptual Blending and Levels of Representation
- The Drunken World of Dionysos
- When prophecy drives the prophet crazy (Aesch. Sept. 792–821, 832–839)
- Furia as an Auctor in Seneca’s Thyestes
- Lost Dictionaries, Forgotten Entries. Two Byzantine lexica on the Athenian ΣΩΦΡΟΝΙΣΤΑΙ
- List of Contributors
Artikel in diesem Heft
- Titelseiten
- Towards a new critical edition of the scholia to the Iliad: a specimen
- Able leaders and fallible men: success and excess in Iliadic battle exhortations
- The Cult of Demeter on Andros and the Homeric Hymn to Demeter
- Interactions with the Beloved in Greek Literature: Conceptual Blending and Levels of Representation
- The Drunken World of Dionysos
- When prophecy drives the prophet crazy (Aesch. Sept. 792–821, 832–839)
- Furia as an Auctor in Seneca’s Thyestes
- Lost Dictionaries, Forgotten Entries. Two Byzantine lexica on the Athenian ΣΩΦΡΟΝΙΣΤΑΙ
- List of Contributors
