5 A hall of mirrors or a pool of analytical strategies
-
Niels Åkerstrøm Andersen
Abstract
In this concluding chapter, I will seek to let the different analytics and analytical strategies in Foucault, Koselleck, Laclau and Luhmann reflect each other and, in so doing, attempt to compare them directly. This requires some form of standard of comparison – a uniform concept that will allow the distinctions to stand out. However, that in itself is a questionable operation, since the principal distinctions that define their constituent diversity are lost in such an endeavour. Nevertheless, this will not restrain me from proceeding to define a kind of ‘comprehensive view’, the advantage of which is that it paves the way for many fruitful discussions about how it is different to establish, for example, a link to the discourse analysis of Foucault or Laclau respectively.
As already noted, there is no natural universal standard of comparison. The four gentlemen do not ask to be compared and neither do they require a particular standard of reference. However, using Luhmann’s ideas, I have chosen to construct a concept of analytical strategy on which I will base my comparisons of the four writers. This will, of course, have the effect of making the others appear in a Luhmannian light, but there are reasons for my choice of perspective. The two principal reasons are width and level of abstraction. First, in my opinion, Luhmann possesses the greatest potential of inclusion due to his rather general but also highly potent theory of second-order observations. Second, Luhmann’s concepts appear to permit the development of a productive concept of analytical strategy.
Abstract
In this concluding chapter, I will seek to let the different analytics and analytical strategies in Foucault, Koselleck, Laclau and Luhmann reflect each other and, in so doing, attempt to compare them directly. This requires some form of standard of comparison – a uniform concept that will allow the distinctions to stand out. However, that in itself is a questionable operation, since the principal distinctions that define their constituent diversity are lost in such an endeavour. Nevertheless, this will not restrain me from proceeding to define a kind of ‘comprehensive view’, the advantage of which is that it paves the way for many fruitful discussions about how it is different to establish, for example, a link to the discourse analysis of Foucault or Laclau respectively.
As already noted, there is no natural universal standard of comparison. The four gentlemen do not ask to be compared and neither do they require a particular standard of reference. However, using Luhmann’s ideas, I have chosen to construct a concept of analytical strategy on which I will base my comparisons of the four writers. This will, of course, have the effect of making the others appear in a Luhmannian light, but there are reasons for my choice of perspective. The two principal reasons are width and level of abstraction. First, in my opinion, Luhmann possesses the greatest potential of inclusion due to his rather general but also highly potent theory of second-order observations. Second, Luhmann’s concepts appear to permit the development of a productive concept of analytical strategy.
Kapitel in diesem Buch
- Front Matter I
- Contents III
- List of tables and figures IV
- Acknowledgements V
- Glossary VI
- Introduction IX
- The discourse analysis of Michel Foucault 1
- Reinhart Koselleck’s history of concepts 33
- The discourse theory of Ernesto Laclau 49
- Niklas Luhmann’s systems theory 63
- A hall of mirrors or a pool of analytical strategies 93
- References 119
- Examples of other analytical strategies 125
- Further reading 127
- Index 131
Kapitel in diesem Buch
- Front Matter I
- Contents III
- List of tables and figures IV
- Acknowledgements V
- Glossary VI
- Introduction IX
- The discourse analysis of Michel Foucault 1
- Reinhart Koselleck’s history of concepts 33
- The discourse theory of Ernesto Laclau 49
- Niklas Luhmann’s systems theory 63
- A hall of mirrors or a pool of analytical strategies 93
- References 119
- Examples of other analytical strategies 125
- Further reading 127
- Index 131
