Eight What counts as ‘counter-conduct’? A governmental analysis of resistance in the face of compulsory community care
-
Hannah Jobling
Abstract
In this chapter the findings of an ethnographic study of Community treatment orders (CTOs) in action are reported on, focusing on how individuals made subject to CTOs perceive the role the CTO has in their lives, and their subsequent responses to its imposition. Individuals’ conceptions of self in relation to disciplinary policy interventions can lead to complex, ambiguous and perhaps unexpected responses to compulsion, which are not easily categorised into binary forms of compliance and resistance. The analysis of CTOs underlines the value of a governmentality perspective that eschews simple linear understandings of how ‘target’ groups will respond to policy interventions.
Abstract
In this chapter the findings of an ethnographic study of Community treatment orders (CTOs) in action are reported on, focusing on how individuals made subject to CTOs perceive the role the CTO has in their lives, and their subsequent responses to its imposition. Individuals’ conceptions of self in relation to disciplinary policy interventions can lead to complex, ambiguous and perhaps unexpected responses to compulsion, which are not easily categorised into binary forms of compliance and resistance. The analysis of CTOs underlines the value of a governmentality perspective that eschews simple linear understandings of how ‘target’ groups will respond to policy interventions.
Chapters in this book
- Front Matter i
- Contents iii
- Notes on contributors v
-
Continuities and change in UK social policy
- Behaviour, choice, and British pension policy 3
- Coalition health policy: a game of two halves or the final whistle for the NHS? 23
- Citizenship, conduct and conditionality: sanction and support in the 21st-century UK welfare state 41
- Housing policy in the austerity age and beyond 63
-
Contributions from the Social Policy Association Conference 2015
- ‘Progressive’ neo-liberal conservatism and the welfare state: incremental reform or long-term destruction? 89
- Exploring out-of-work benefit claimants’ attitudes towards welfare reform and conditionality 105
- The Troubled Families Programme: in, for and against the state? 127
- What counts as ‘counter-conduct’? A governmental analysis of resistance in the face of compulsory community care 147
-
Individualised budgets in social policy
- Social insurance for individualized disability support: implementing the Australian National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) 173
- Right time, right place? The experiences of rough sleepers and practitioners in the receipt and delivery of personalised budgets 191
- Personal health budgets: implementation and outcomes 211
- Personalised care funding in Norway: a case of gradual co-production 233
- Individualised funding for older people and the ethic of care 251
- Index 269
Chapters in this book
- Front Matter i
- Contents iii
- Notes on contributors v
-
Continuities and change in UK social policy
- Behaviour, choice, and British pension policy 3
- Coalition health policy: a game of two halves or the final whistle for the NHS? 23
- Citizenship, conduct and conditionality: sanction and support in the 21st-century UK welfare state 41
- Housing policy in the austerity age and beyond 63
-
Contributions from the Social Policy Association Conference 2015
- ‘Progressive’ neo-liberal conservatism and the welfare state: incremental reform or long-term destruction? 89
- Exploring out-of-work benefit claimants’ attitudes towards welfare reform and conditionality 105
- The Troubled Families Programme: in, for and against the state? 127
- What counts as ‘counter-conduct’? A governmental analysis of resistance in the face of compulsory community care 147
-
Individualised budgets in social policy
- Social insurance for individualized disability support: implementing the Australian National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) 173
- Right time, right place? The experiences of rough sleepers and practitioners in the receipt and delivery of personalised budgets 191
- Personal health budgets: implementation and outcomes 211
- Personalised care funding in Norway: a case of gradual co-production 233
- Individualised funding for older people and the ethic of care 251
- Index 269
