Medical Ethics and Media-Created Crisis: A Case Study in Medical Malpractice Reform
-
Daniel Lorence
The objective of this study was to determine the extent of decline in level of access and quality of services reported by healthcare consumers during a media campaign to limit recovery for damages incurred through medical malpractice. Serving as a natural experiment, this campaign involved a widely publicized statewide "malpractice crisis," promoted as causing mass exodus of medical providers from the state. The (reported) resulting reduction in services, especially for the most underserved areas and populations, though unproven, had been touted as justification for amending the state constitution. Patient survey responses collected during the crisis indicated relatively high levels of satisfaction with access and quality of care during the publicized crisis (and alleged provider exodus). Similar organized malpractice crises examined from previous years suggest that policymakers should demonstrate caution when responding to a perceived crisis, especially when economic benefit for a particular interest group is at stake. Further, a lack of ethics in media through inaccurate reporting and sensationalism may lead to a seductive invitation to like ethical lapses by medical professionals in their attempts to shape policy through artificial crises creation.
©2011 Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, Berlin/Boston
Artikel in diesem Heft
- Discussion
- The Endless "Controversy:" Evolution and Its Critics
- Article
- Risk, Precaution, and Emerging Technologies
- The Interplay of Technology and Sacredness in Islam: Discussions of Muslim Scholars on Printing the Qur'an
- Medical Ethics and Media-Created Crisis: A Case Study in Medical Malpractice Reform
- IT and the NHS: Investigating Different Perspectives of IT using Soft Systems Methodology
- Book Review
- Review of Physicians at War: The Dual-Loyalties Challenge
- Review of Rescuing Science from Politics
- Review of 203 Days (Film)
- Review of Rethinking Informed Consent in Bioethics
- Review of Experimenting with the Consumer--The Mass Testing of Risky Products on the American Public
- Editorial
- Ethics, Law, Technology and Policymaking: An Editorial
Artikel in diesem Heft
- Discussion
- The Endless "Controversy:" Evolution and Its Critics
- Article
- Risk, Precaution, and Emerging Technologies
- The Interplay of Technology and Sacredness in Islam: Discussions of Muslim Scholars on Printing the Qur'an
- Medical Ethics and Media-Created Crisis: A Case Study in Medical Malpractice Reform
- IT and the NHS: Investigating Different Perspectives of IT using Soft Systems Methodology
- Book Review
- Review of Physicians at War: The Dual-Loyalties Challenge
- Review of Rescuing Science from Politics
- Review of 203 Days (Film)
- Review of Rethinking Informed Consent in Bioethics
- Review of Experimenting with the Consumer--The Mass Testing of Risky Products on the American Public
- Editorial
- Ethics, Law, Technology and Policymaking: An Editorial
