The Development of a Quantitative Evaluation Tool for Simulations in Nursing Education
-
Martha Todd
In a complex healthcare environment, educating nursing students to safely care for clients is a challenging endeavor. As the use of high fidelity simulations increases, the ability to evaluate students is essential. A review of the literature identified a lack of tested simulation evaluation instruments to accurately measure student performance. A simulation evaluation tool was developed and tested with senior nursing students. Content validity was established from the literature and from the review of the tool by an expert panel. Reliability was established using sixteen simulation sessions, with two trained evaluators at each session. Percent agreement by evaluators ranged from 84.4% to 89.1%. Additional research needs to verify these results with different evaluators, varying levels of students, and additional scenarios. A valid, reliable tool to evaluate simulation experiences improves student assessment skills and ultimately clinical performance.
©2011 Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, Berlin/Boston
Articles in the same Issue
- Editorial
- Be a Champion for Academic Nursing
- Article
- Curriculum Innovation in an Accelerated BSN Program: The ACE Model
- Faculty Teaching Time: A Comparison of Web-Based and Face-to-Face Graduate Nursing Courses
- Enhancing Baccalaureate Nursing Information Technology Outcomes: Faculty Perspectives
- A Descriptive Qualitative Study of Student Learning in a Psychosocial Nursing Class Infused with Art, Literature, Music, and Film
- Developing a Self-Concept of Nurse in Baccalaureate Nursing Students
- Creating a Community of Scholars: Using a Community Development Approach to Foster Scholarship with Nursing Faculty
- Understanding Decimal Numbers: A Foundation for Correct Calculations
- "Failure to Assign Failing Grades": Issues with Grading the Unsafe Student
- Factors Influencing Intent to Stay in Academia for Nursing Faculty in the Southern United States of America
- Integrating Spirituality into Undergraduate Nursing Curricula
- The Influence of End-of-Life Education on Attitudes of Nursing Students
- Limited Use of the Human Patient Simulator by Nurse Faculty: An Intervention Program Designed to Increase Use
- Diffusion of Innovation: Embedding Simulation into Nursing Curricula
- Online Post LPN to BN Students' Views of Transitioning to a New Nursing Role
- Nursing Student-Patient Relationships: A Descriptive Study of Students' and Patients' Views
- Comparing NET and ERI Standardized Exam Scores between Baccalaureate Graduates Who Pass or Fail the NCLEX-RN©
- Debriefing with the OPT Model of Clinical Reasoning during High Fidelity Patient Simulation
- Nursing Students with Disabilities: One Faculty's Journey
- Factors Related to Academic Success in At-Risk Senior Nursing Students
- LIVE: A Tool to Support Student/Teacher Enactment of Community Health Nursing Praxis
- Examining the Effects of Problem-Based Learning and NCLEX-RN Scores on the Critical Thinking Skills of Associate Degree Nursing Students in a Southeastern Community College
- Preparing the Community Health Nursing Workforce: Internal and External Enablers and Challenges Influencing Undergraduate Nursing Programs in Canada
- Problem-Based Learning: An Innovative Approach to Teaching Physical Assessment in Advanced Practice Nursing Curriculum
- `Constructing Communities for Learning in Nursing'
- Investigating Nursing Students' Perceptions of the Changes in a Nursing Curriculum by Means of the Dundee Ready Education Environment Measure (DREEM) Inventory: Results of a Cluster Analysis
- The Integration of Simulation into a Clinical Foundations of Nursing Course: Student and Faculty Perspectives
- Return to Nursing Programmes: Justifications for a Mental Health Specific Course
- Social Responsibility: Conceptualization and Embodiment in a School of Nursing
- Using Service-Learning to Develop Health Promotion and Research Skills in Nursing Students
- Group Learning Strategies for Nursing Students: Reflections on the Tutor Role
- Linking Learning and Confidence in Developing Expert Practice
- Generic and Professional Outcomes of a General Nursing Education Program - A National Study of Higher Education
- We Have a High-Fidelity Simulator, Now What? Making the Most of Simulators
- A Rubric for Improving the Quality of Online Courses
- Social Justice as a Framework for Undergraduate Community Health Clinical Experiences in the United States
- Girl Scout Badge Day as a Service Learning Experience
- High-Fidelity Patient Simulation and Nursing Students' Self-Efficacy: A Review of the Literature
- Stories as Integrated Patterns of Knowing in Nursing Education
- Integrative Thinking and Learning in Undergraduate Nursing Education: Three Strategies
- Improving Communication among Healthcare Providers: Preparing Student Nurses for Practice
- The Development of a Quantitative Evaluation Tool for Simulations in Nursing Education
- The Use of Hi Fidelity Simulation to Enhance Nursing Students' Therapeutic Communication Skills
- Nursing Graduate Supervision of Theses and Projects at a Distance: Issues and Challenges
- Evaluation of an Online Graduate Nursing Curriculum: Examining Standards of Quality
Articles in the same Issue
- Editorial
- Be a Champion for Academic Nursing
- Article
- Curriculum Innovation in an Accelerated BSN Program: The ACE Model
- Faculty Teaching Time: A Comparison of Web-Based and Face-to-Face Graduate Nursing Courses
- Enhancing Baccalaureate Nursing Information Technology Outcomes: Faculty Perspectives
- A Descriptive Qualitative Study of Student Learning in a Psychosocial Nursing Class Infused with Art, Literature, Music, and Film
- Developing a Self-Concept of Nurse in Baccalaureate Nursing Students
- Creating a Community of Scholars: Using a Community Development Approach to Foster Scholarship with Nursing Faculty
- Understanding Decimal Numbers: A Foundation for Correct Calculations
- "Failure to Assign Failing Grades": Issues with Grading the Unsafe Student
- Factors Influencing Intent to Stay in Academia for Nursing Faculty in the Southern United States of America
- Integrating Spirituality into Undergraduate Nursing Curricula
- The Influence of End-of-Life Education on Attitudes of Nursing Students
- Limited Use of the Human Patient Simulator by Nurse Faculty: An Intervention Program Designed to Increase Use
- Diffusion of Innovation: Embedding Simulation into Nursing Curricula
- Online Post LPN to BN Students' Views of Transitioning to a New Nursing Role
- Nursing Student-Patient Relationships: A Descriptive Study of Students' and Patients' Views
- Comparing NET and ERI Standardized Exam Scores between Baccalaureate Graduates Who Pass or Fail the NCLEX-RN©
- Debriefing with the OPT Model of Clinical Reasoning during High Fidelity Patient Simulation
- Nursing Students with Disabilities: One Faculty's Journey
- Factors Related to Academic Success in At-Risk Senior Nursing Students
- LIVE: A Tool to Support Student/Teacher Enactment of Community Health Nursing Praxis
- Examining the Effects of Problem-Based Learning and NCLEX-RN Scores on the Critical Thinking Skills of Associate Degree Nursing Students in a Southeastern Community College
- Preparing the Community Health Nursing Workforce: Internal and External Enablers and Challenges Influencing Undergraduate Nursing Programs in Canada
- Problem-Based Learning: An Innovative Approach to Teaching Physical Assessment in Advanced Practice Nursing Curriculum
- `Constructing Communities for Learning in Nursing'
- Investigating Nursing Students' Perceptions of the Changes in a Nursing Curriculum by Means of the Dundee Ready Education Environment Measure (DREEM) Inventory: Results of a Cluster Analysis
- The Integration of Simulation into a Clinical Foundations of Nursing Course: Student and Faculty Perspectives
- Return to Nursing Programmes: Justifications for a Mental Health Specific Course
- Social Responsibility: Conceptualization and Embodiment in a School of Nursing
- Using Service-Learning to Develop Health Promotion and Research Skills in Nursing Students
- Group Learning Strategies for Nursing Students: Reflections on the Tutor Role
- Linking Learning and Confidence in Developing Expert Practice
- Generic and Professional Outcomes of a General Nursing Education Program - A National Study of Higher Education
- We Have a High-Fidelity Simulator, Now What? Making the Most of Simulators
- A Rubric for Improving the Quality of Online Courses
- Social Justice as a Framework for Undergraduate Community Health Clinical Experiences in the United States
- Girl Scout Badge Day as a Service Learning Experience
- High-Fidelity Patient Simulation and Nursing Students' Self-Efficacy: A Review of the Literature
- Stories as Integrated Patterns of Knowing in Nursing Education
- Integrative Thinking and Learning in Undergraduate Nursing Education: Three Strategies
- Improving Communication among Healthcare Providers: Preparing Student Nurses for Practice
- The Development of a Quantitative Evaluation Tool for Simulations in Nursing Education
- The Use of Hi Fidelity Simulation to Enhance Nursing Students' Therapeutic Communication Skills
- Nursing Graduate Supervision of Theses and Projects at a Distance: Issues and Challenges
- Evaluation of an Online Graduate Nursing Curriculum: Examining Standards of Quality