“An Especially Thankless Work”? Filtering Practices in Emergency Shelters and Ethical Dilemmas for Street-level Social Workers in Western Switzerland
-
Béatrice Bertho
Béatrice Bertho is a socio-anthropologist and senior research fellow at the University of Applied Sciences and Arts Western Switzerland (HES-SO). She completed her PhD on social policies and gender in Burkina Faso and is currently coordinating research on the engagement of girls in football teams in Cameroon and Senegal. In addition to these topics, she is currently developing her research and teaching interests in local Swiss social policies in relation to homelessness and migration.Hélène Martin is an anthropologist, professor of gender studies at the University of Applied Sciences and Arts Western Switzerland (HES-SO), and co-responsible of the Gender and Social Work Competence Network. In recent years, she has been working on the construction of the body and sexuality in an intersectional approach, with particular interest in the neoliberal injunctions of selfentrepreneurship. For the past two years, she has also been engaged in research on homelessness: the social treatment of extreme poverty leads her to reflect on vulnerabilities constructed by intersecting logics of coloniality, class and gender.
Abstract
Based on an ethnographic survey conducted in services for the homeless in French-speaking Switzerland, this paper examines street-level social workers’ struggles between the implementation of official policies and their direct work with people. Beyond their common condition of homelessness, people looking for shelter are a very heterogeneous group: undocumented migrants and foreign workers rub shoulders with poor, local pensioners, or with persons suffering from drug addiction or mental illness. Guided by national and international residence and labour legislation, local authorities and institutions have their own policies – more or less strict in their exclusion of poor migrants – regarding the legitimate beneficiaries of a place in the emergency accommodation system. In this article, we analyse the encounters of street-level social workers with homeless people and examine the practical, value-based and ethical dilemmas they face, as well the use of their discretionary power in making more - or less - appropriate shelter available for destitute migrants.
About the authors
Béatrice Bertho is a socio-anthropologist and senior research fellow at the University of Applied Sciences and Arts Western Switzerland (HES-SO). She completed her PhD on social policies and gender in Burkina Faso and is currently coordinating research on the engagement of girls in football teams in Cameroon and Senegal. In addition to these topics, she is currently developing her research and teaching interests in local Swiss social policies in relation to homelessness and migration.
Hélène Martin is an anthropologist, professor of gender studies at the University of Applied Sciences and Arts Western Switzerland (HES-SO), and co-responsible of the Gender and Social Work Competence Network. In recent years, she has been working on the construction of the body and sexuality in an intersectional approach, with particular interest in the neoliberal injunctions of selfentrepreneurship. For the past two years, she has also been engaged in research on homelessness: the social treatment of extreme poverty leads her to reflect on vulnerabilities constructed by intersecting logics of coloniality, class and gender.
Bibliography
Alden, Sarah (2015): “On the Frontline: The Gatekeeper in Statutory Homelessness Services”, Housing Studies 30(6): 924–941.10.1080/02673037.2014.991380Suche in Google Scholar
Ansermet, Claire; Tabin, Jean-Pierre (2014): “Misère de la gestion de la misère”, Le sociographe 48 (2014/4): 45–55.10.3917/graph.048.0045Suche in Google Scholar
Armingeon, Klaus; Bertozzi, Fabio; Bonoli, Giuliano (2004): “Swiss worlds of welfare”, West European Politics 27(1): 20–44.10.1080/01402380412331280793Suche in Google Scholar
Bowpitt, Graham; Dwyer, Peter; Sundin, Eva; Weinstein, Mark (2011): “The HOME study: Comparing the priorities of multiply excluded homeless people and support agencies”, University of Salford, available at https://www.researchgate.net/publication/244046324_The_support_priorities_of_multiply_excluded_homeless_people_and_their_compatibility_with_support_agency_agendas_-_New_research_into_multiple_exclusion_homelessness (Accessed 18 May 2020).10.1108/14608791111170274Suche in Google Scholar
Cramer, Helen (2005): “Informal and Gendered Practices in a Homeless Persons Unit”, Housing Studies 20(5): 737–751.10.1080/02673030500213987Suche in Google Scholar
Cullen, Sandra; Howe, Leo (1991): “People, Cases and Stereotypes: a study of staff practice in a DSS benefit office”, The Cambridge Journal of Anthropology 15(1): 1-26.Suche in Google Scholar
Drilling, Matthias; Dittmann, Jörg; Bischoff, Tobias (2019): Homelessness and housing exclusion. LIVES working paper 2019/76. Swiss National Centre of Competence in Research.Download at: https://lives-nccr.ch/sites/default/files/pdf/publication/lives_wp_76_drilling_en.pdf (access on 20.11.2020).Suche in Google Scholar
Drilling, Matthias; Mühlethaler, Esther; Iyadurai, Gosalia (2020): Homelessness. First Country Report Switzerland. Muttenz: ISOS/FNHW.Suche in Google Scholar
Edgar, Bill; Doherty, Joe; Meert, Henk (2004): Immigration and homelessness in Europe. Bristol: Policy Press.10.51952/9781447366706Suche in Google Scholar
Ehrler, Franziska; Sager, Fritz (2011): “Marketization in a federal system: new modes of governance in unemployment insurance and social assistance in Switzerland”, in: Rik van Berkel; Willibrord de Graaf; Tomáš Sirovátka (eds) : The governance of active welfarestates in Europe. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 153–172.10.1057/9780230306714_8Suche in Google Scholar
Ferrera, Maurizio (2005): The boundaries of welfare: European integration and the new spatial politics of social protection. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/0199284660.001.0001Suche in Google Scholar
Fitzpatrick, Suzanne; Johnsen, Sarah; Bramley, Glen (2012): “Multiple exclusion homelessness amongst migrants in the UK”, European Journal of Homelessness 6(1): 31-5.Suche in Google Scholar
Franz, Lucille (2020): “Enquêter auprès des démunis: la responsabilité du chercheur face à ses enquêtés”, in: Marta Roca i Escoda; Claudine Burton-Jeangros; Pablo Diaz Almudever; Ilario Rossi (eds.): Enjeux éthiques dans l’enquête en sciences sociales. Sociograph, Sociological Research Studies 45. Geneva: University of Geneva, 79–103.Suche in Google Scholar
Frauenfelder, Arnaud; Togni, Carola (2007): “Les ’abus’ à l’aide sociale: une rhétorique au coeur du gouvernement de la misère”, Carnets de bord en sciences humaines 2007/13: 43–55.Suche in Google Scholar
Gardella, Édouard (2014a): “Secourir les sans-abri en détresse. La norme d’inconditionnalité dans l’urgence sociale”, in: Axelle Brodiez-Dolino; Isabelle von Bueltzingsloewen; Benoit Eyraud, Christian Laval; Bertrand Ravan (eds.): Vulnérabilités sanitaires et sociales. Approches sociologiques et historiques. Rennes: Presses Universitaires de Rennes, 233–257.Suche in Google Scholar
Gardella, Edouard (2014b): “L’urgence comme chronopolitique. Le cas de l’hébergement dessans-abri”, Temporalités. Revue de sciences sociales et humaines 2014/19[online]. Download at: https://journals.openedition.org/temporalites/2764 (access on 23.11.2020).10.4000/temporalites.2764Suche in Google Scholar
Grimard, Carolyne (2016): Entre l’accueil bas seuil et le logement social: quelles pratiques d’intervention au quotidien? Le rôle de La Tuile dans les trajectoires de sans-abrisme à Fribourg. Rapport de recherche pour La Tuile, Fribourg, Université de Fribourg.Suche in Google Scholar
Hjörne, Eva; Juhila, Kirsi; Van Nijnatten, Carolus (2010): “Negotiating dilemmas in the practices of street‐level welfare work”, International Journal of Social Welfare 19(3): 303–309.10.1111/j.1468-2397.2010.00721.xSuche in Google Scholar
Hughes, Everett C. (1962): “Good people and dirty work”, Social problems 10(1): 3–11.10.2307/799402Suche in Google Scholar
Kakpo, Nathalie; Cattacin, Sandro (2011): Local welfare in Switzerland: Housing, employment and child care. Welfare innovations at the local leven in favour of cohesion, WILCO Publication no. 7.Suche in Google Scholar
Lévi-Strauss, Claude (1966): The Savage Mind. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Suche in Google Scholar
Lipsky, Michael (2010): Street-Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Suche in Google Scholar
Lipsky, Michael; Smith, Steven Rathgeb (1989): “When social problems are treated as emergencies”, Social Service Review 63(1): 5–25.10.1086/603675Suche in Google Scholar
Martin, Hélène; Bertho, Béatrice (2020): “Crimes et châtiments dans la modernité tardive.Politiques urbaines du sans-abrisme”, Sciences et Actions Sociales 2020/13 [online].Download at: http://www.sas-revue.org/images/pdf/N13d13/Crimes-et-chatiments-dansla-modernite-tardive.pdf (access 23.11.2020).10.3917/sas.013.0053Suche in Google Scholar
Meigniez, Maëlle (2020, forthcoming): “L’engagement associatif entre pluralité des logiques d’aide et reconnaissance d’une politique d’action sociale”, Revue des Sciences de la Société.10.4000/sds.11229Suche in Google Scholar
Mostowska, Magdalena (2014): “‘We Shouldn’t but We Do…’: Framing the Strategies for Helping Homeless EU migrants in Copenhagen and Dublin”, The British Journal of Social WorkF44 (suppl. 1): i18–i34.10.1093/bjsw/bcu043Suche in Google Scholar
Mostowska, Magdalena (2015): “Institutionalisation and Deformalisation: Reorganising Access to Service Provision for Homeless EU Migrants”, European Journal of Homelessness 9(2):113–136.Suche in Google Scholar
O’Sullivan, Eoin (2010): “Welfare states and homelessness”, in: Eoin O’Sullivan; Volker Busch Geertsema; Deborah Quilgars; Nicholas Pleace: Homeless Research in Europe. Brussels:Feantsa, 65–84. Download at: https://www.feantsaresearch.org/download/fullpdf7911858974750407904.pdf (access on 23.11.2020).Suche in Google Scholar
Parker, Roy A. (1967): “Social administration and scarcity: the problem of rationing” in: Eric Butterworth; Robert Homan (eds.): Social Welfare in modern Britain. London: Fontana, 204-12.Suche in Google Scholar
Renedo, Alicia (2014): “Care versus control: the identity dilemmas of UK homelessness professionals working in a contract culture”, Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology 24(3): 220–233.10.1002/casp.2162Suche in Google Scholar
Sanchez-Mazas, Margarita (2015): “The construction of ‘official outlaws’. Social-psychological and educational implications of a deterrent asylum policy”, Frontiers in psychology 6(No. 382): 1–4.10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00382Suche in Google Scholar
Schmid, Olivier; Bonsack, Charles (2018): “Housing First, un changement de référentiel dans la lutte contre l’exclusion du logement”, Swiss Archives of Neurology, Psychiatry and Psychotherapy 169(7): 198–207.10.4414/sanp.2018.00621Suche in Google Scholar
Schuwey, Claudia; Knöpfel, Carlo (2014): Nouveau manuel sur la pauvreté en Suisse. Lucerne: Caritas Suisse.Suche in Google Scholar
Tabin, Jean-Pierre; Frauenfelder, Arnaud; Togni, Carola; Keller, Véréna (2011): “Whose poor? Social welfare and local political boundaries”, European Journal of Social Work 14(4): 463–477.10.1080/13691457.2010.500278Suche in Google Scholar
Tabin, Jean-Pierre; Knüsel, René (2014): Lutter contre les pauvres. Les politiques face à la mendicité dans le canton de Vaud. Lausanne: Éditions d’en bas.Suche in Google Scholar
Temesvary, Zsolt (2019): “Hungarian Homeless People in Basel: Homelessness and Social Exclusion from a Lifeworld-oriented Social Work Perspective”, European Journal of Homelessness 13(2): 29–51.Suche in Google Scholar
Terray, Emmanuel (1999): “Le travail des étrangers en situation irrégulière ou la délocalisation sur place”, in: Étienne Balibar; Monique Chemillier-Gendreau; Jacqueline Costa-Lascoux; Emmanuel Terray (eds.): Sans-papiers: l’archaïsme fatal. Paris: La Découverte, 9–34.10.3917/dec.balib.1999.01.0009Suche in Google Scholar
Torelli, Julian; Puddephatt, Antony (2020) “Reframing ‘Dirty Work’: The Case of Homeless Shelter Workers”, Symbolic Interaction 17.06.2020 [online]. Download at:https://doi.org/10.1002/symb.495 (access 23.11.2020).10.1002/symb.495Suche in Google Scholar
Wyss, Anna (2019): “Stuck in mobility? Interrupted journeys of migrants with precarious legal status in Europe”, Journal of Immigrant & Refugee Studies 17(1): 77-93.10.1080/15562948.2018.1514091Suche in Google Scholar
© 2021 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston, Germany
Artikel in diesem Heft
- Frontmatter
- Editorial: Governing the Poor – Migration and Poverty
- “An Especially Thankless Work”? Filtering Practices in Emergency Shelters and Ethical Dilemmas for Street-level Social Workers in Western Switzerland
- The Production of Precarity in Denmark’s Asylum Regime
- At the intersection of immigration and welfare governance in the United States: State, county and frontline levels and clients’ perspectives
- Governing Young Poor in Switzerland and Reinforcing Their Work Ethics
- Child Money and Food Stamps: A comparative analysis of Mongolian welfare programmes in the Ger Districts of Ulaanbaatar
- Punishing the Poor and Fighting “Immigration into the Social System” – Welfare Reforms by the Conservative and Far-right Government in Austria 2017–2019
Artikel in diesem Heft
- Frontmatter
- Editorial: Governing the Poor – Migration and Poverty
- “An Especially Thankless Work”? Filtering Practices in Emergency Shelters and Ethical Dilemmas for Street-level Social Workers in Western Switzerland
- The Production of Precarity in Denmark’s Asylum Regime
- At the intersection of immigration and welfare governance in the United States: State, county and frontline levels and clients’ perspectives
- Governing Young Poor in Switzerland and Reinforcing Their Work Ethics
- Child Money and Food Stamps: A comparative analysis of Mongolian welfare programmes in the Ger Districts of Ulaanbaatar
- Punishing the Poor and Fighting “Immigration into the Social System” – Welfare Reforms by the Conservative and Far-right Government in Austria 2017–2019
