Home Classical, Ancient Near Eastern & Egyptian Studies Placebo is Magic or Magic is Placebo? The Greco-Roman Iatromagical Texts
Article
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

Placebo is Magic or Magic is Placebo? The Greco-Roman Iatromagical Texts

  • Eleni Chronopoulou EMAIL logo
Published/Copyright: July 1, 2021
Become an author with De Gruyter Brill

Abstract

Many of the numerous magical recipes and spells from the Greco-Roman world aim to heal or protect the practitioner. The text, however, show great diversity and heterogeneity and many of them seem to be an elaborate amalgam of different religious influences, analogies, and interactions. This variety can, among other things, play into certain aspects of the placebo effect. Here, I present a systematic categorization of Greco-Roman amulets according to physical support, format, chronology, and purpose, which together with a study of their terminology may point towards different placebo effects. Then, I examine their social context and describe the resources and the modus operandi of the magical healing, which will have further strengthened the effect of these amulets. Their reliance on cultural resources and tropes points especially towards conditioning and learned responses.

Bibliography

Ashby, Jeffrey S./Lenhart, Stephen J. (1994), “Prayer as a Coping Strategy for Chronic Pain Patients”, in: Rehabilitation Psychology 39, 205–209.10.1037/h0080317Search in Google Scholar

Betz, Hans Dieter (ed.) (1986), The Greek Magical Papyri in Translation Including the Demotic spells, Chicago.10.7208/chicago/9780226826950.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Bohak, Gideon (2008), Ancient Jewish Magic: A History, New York.10.1002/9781444308372.ch19Search in Google Scholar

Collins, Derek (2008), Magic in the Ancient Greek World, Oxford.10.1002/9780470696453Search in Google Scholar

Colloca, Luana/Benedetti, Fabrizio (2006), “How Prior Experience Shapes Placebo Analgesia”, in: Pain 124, 126–133.10.1016/j.pain.2006.04.005Search in Google Scholar

Colloca, Luana/Benedetti, Fabrizio (2009), “Placebo Analgesia Induced by Social Observational Learning”, in: Pain 144, 28–34.10.1016/j.pain.2009.01.033Search in Google Scholar

Colloca, Luana/Sigaudo, Monica/Benedetti, Fabrizio (2008), “The Role of Learning in Nocebo and Placebo Effects”, in: Pain 136, 126–133.10.1016/j.pain.2008.02.006Search in Google Scholar

Colloca, Luana/Klinger, Regine/Flor, Herta/Bingel, Ulrike (2013), “Placebo Analgesia: Psychological and Neurobiological Mechanisms”, in: Pain 154.4, 511–514.10.1016/j.pain.2013.02.002Search in Google Scholar

Csordas, Thomas J. (1983), “The Rhetoric of Transformation in Ritual Healing”, in: Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry 7, 333–375.10.1007/BF00052238Search in Google Scholar

Daniel, Robert W. (1988), “A note on the Philinna Papyrus (PGM XX 1–2)”, in: ZPE 73, 306.Search in Google Scholar

Daniel, Robert W./Maltomini, Franco (1990–1992), Supplementum Magicum, Papyrologica Coloniensia, I–II, Opladen.Search in Google Scholar

Dezutter, Jessie/Wachholtz, Amy/Corveleyn, Jozef (2011), “Prayer and Pain: The Mediating Role of Positive Re-appraisal”, in: Journal of Behavioral Medicine 34, 542–549.10.1007/s10865-011-9348-2Search in Google Scholar

De Haro Sanchez, Magali (2004), “Catalogues des papyrus iatromagiques grecs”, in: PapLup 13, 37–60.Search in Google Scholar

De Haro Sanchez, Magali (2010), “Le vocabulaire de la pathologie et de la thérapeutique dans les papyrus iatromagiques grecs: Fièvres, traumatismes et épilepsie”, in: BASP 47, 131–153.Search in Google Scholar

De Haro Sanchez, Magali (2015a), “Magie et pharmacopée: l’utilisation des végétaux dans les papyrus iatromagiques grecs”, in: Mythos 9, 149–172.Search in Google Scholar

De Haro Sanchez, Magali (2015b), “Between Medicine and Magic: the Iatromagical Formularies and Medical Receptaries on Papyri Compared”, in: ZPE 195, 179–189.Search in Google Scholar

De Haro Sanchez, Magali (2008a), “Les papyrus iatromagiques grecs et la région thébaine”, in: Alain Delattre/Paul Heilporn (eds.), “Et maintenant ce ne sont plus que des villages … Thèbes et sa région aux époques hellénistique, romaine et byzantine: Actes du colloque tenu à Bruxelles les 2 et 3 décembre 2005, Bruxelles, Association Égyptologique Reine Élisabeth – Papyrologica Bruxellensia 34, 97–102.Search in Google Scholar

De Haro Sanchez, Magali (2008b), “Les papyrus iatromagiques grecs de Kellis”, in: Lucida Intervalla 37, 79–96.Search in Google Scholar

Dickie, Matthew W. (1994), “The Identity of Philinna in the Philinna Papyrus”, in: ZPE 100, 119–122.Search in Google Scholar

Dieleman, Jacco (2005), Priests, Tongues, and Rites: The London-Leiden Magical Manuscripts and Translation in Egyptian Ritual, 100–300 CE, Leiden-Boston.10.1163/9789047406747Search in Google Scholar

Dieleman, Jacco (2012), “Coping with a Difficult Life: Magic, Healing, and Sacred. Knowledge”, in: Christina Riggs (ed), The Oxford Handbook of Roman Egypt, Oxford, 337–361.Search in Google Scholar

Dornseiff, Franz (1926), Das Alphabet in Mystik und Magie, Leipzig.Search in Google Scholar

Edmonds, Radcliffe G. (2004), “The Faces of the Moon: Cosmology, Genesis, and the Mithras Liturgy”, in: Ra’anan S. Boustan/Annette Yoshiko Reed (eds.), Heavenly Realms and Earthly Realities in Late Antique Religions, Cambridge, 275–295.10.1017/CBO9780511497889.016Search in Google Scholar

Elmholdt Jegindø, Else-Marie/Vase, Lene/Skewes, Joshua Charles/Terkelsen, Astrid Juhl/Hansen, John/Geertz, Armin W./Roepstorff, Andreas/Jensen, Troels Staehelin (2013), “Expectations Contribute to Reduced Pain Levels During Prayer in Highly Religious Participants”, in: Journal of Behavioral Medicine 36, 413–426.10.1007/s10865-012-9438-9Search in Google Scholar

Faraone, Christopher Athanasius (2012), Vanishing Acts on Ancient Greek Amulets: From Oral Performance to Visual Design, BICS Supplement 115, London.Search in Google Scholar

Faraone, Christopher Athanasius (2018), The Transformation of Greek Amulets in Roman Imperial Times, Pennsylvania.Search in Google Scholar

Faraone, Christopher Athanasius (2003), “New Light on Ancient Greek Exorcisms of the Wandering Womb”, in: ZPE 144: 189–197.Search in Google Scholar

Faraone, Christopher Athanasius (2007), “The Rise of the Demon Womb in in Greco-Roman Antiquity”, in: Maryline Parca/Angeliki Tzanetou (eds.), Finding Persephone: Women’s Rituals in the Ancient Mediterranean, Bloomington, IN, 154–164.Search in Google Scholar

Faraone, Christopher Athanasius (2010), “A Greek Magical Gemstone from the Black Sea”, Kernos, 91–114.10.4000/kernos.1569Search in Google Scholar

Faraone, Christopher Athanasius/Obbink, Dirk (eds.) (2013), The Getty Hexameters: Poetry, Magic, and Mystery in Ancient Selinous, Oxford.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199664108.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Flint, Valery/Gordon, Richard/Luck, George/Ogden, Daniel (eds.) (1999), Witchcraft and Magic in Europe: Ancient Greece and Rome, London.Search in Google Scholar

Frankfurter, David (1994), “The Magic of Writing and the Writing of Magic: The Power of the Word in Egyptian and Greek Tradition”, in: Helios 21, 189–221.Search in Google Scholar

Gager, John (1972), Moses in Greco-Roman Paganism, SBLMS 16, Nashville-New York.Search in Google Scholar

Gager, John (ed.) (1992), Curse Tablets and Binding Spells from the Ancient World, New York.10.1093/oso/9780195062267.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Goodwin, Charles W. (1852), Fragment of a Graeco-Egyptian Work upon Magic from a Papyrus in the British Museum, Cambridge Antiquarian Society, Cambridge.Search in Google Scholar

Gordon, Richard (2011), “Signa nova et inaudita: The Theory and Practice of Invented Signs in Graeco-Egyptian Magical Texts”, in: ΜΗΝΗ 11, 15–45.Search in Google Scholar

Graf, Fritz (2015), “Magie et écriture: quelques réflexions”, in: Magali De Haro Sanchez (ed.), Écrire la magie dans l’antiquité: Actes du colloque international Liège, 13–15 octobre 2011, Liège, 227–238.Search in Google Scholar

Graham, Elaine/Walton, Heather/Ward, Francis (eds.) (2005), Theological Reflections: Method, London.10.1080/13520806.2005.11759006Search in Google Scholar

Hamkins, SuEllen (2013), The Art of Narrative Psychiatry: Stories of Strength and Meaning, Oxford.10.1093/oso/9780199982042.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Heim, Richard (1892), Incantamenta Magica Graeca-Latina, Leipzig.Search in Google Scholar

Herzfeld, Michael (1986), “Closure as Cure: Tropes in the Exploration of Bodily and Social Disorder”, in: Current Anthropology 27, 107–120.10.1086/203400Search in Google Scholar

Humphrey, Nicholas (2002), “Great Expectations: The Evolutionary Psychology of Faith-Healing and the Placebo Response”, in: Claes von Hofsten/Lars Bäckman (eds.), Psychology at the Turn of the Millennium. II, Social, Developmental, and Clinical Perspectives, Hove, 225–246.Search in Google Scholar

Juslin, Patrick N./Västfjäll, Daniel (2008), “Emotional Responses to Music: The Need to Consider Underlying Mechanisms”, in: Erratum: Behavioral and Brain Sciences 31.5, 559–575.10.1017/S0140525X08005293Search in Google Scholar

Kaptchuk, Ted J. (2011), “Placebo Studies and Ritual Theory: A Comparative Analysis of Navajo, Acupuncture and Biomedical Healing”, in: Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 366.1572, 1849–1858.10.1098/rstb.2010.0385Search in Google Scholar

Kagarow, Eugen (1929), Griechische Fluchtafeln, Leipzig.Search in Google Scholar

Kirmayer, Laurence (2014), “Medicines of the Imagination”, in: Harish Naraindas/Johannes Quack/William S. Sax (eds.), Asymmetrical Conversations: Contestations, Circumventions, and the Blurring of Therapeutic Boundaries, New York.Search in Google Scholar

Koenig, Julian/Warth, Marco/Oelkers-Ax, Rieke/Wormit, Alexander/Bardenheuer, Hubert J./Resch, Franz/Thayer, Julian F./Hillecke, Thomas K. (2013), “I Need to Hear Some Sounds That Recognize the Pain in Me: An Integrative Review of a Decade of Research in the Development of Active Music Therapy Outpatient Treatment in Patients with Recurrent or Chronic Pain”, in: Research on Music and Pain 109, 1–12.10.1177/1943862113490739Search in Google Scholar

Koelsch, Stefan (2009), “A Neuroscientific Perspective on Music Therapy”, in: Ann N Y Acad Sci 1169, 74–84.10.1111/j.1749-6632.2009.04592.xSearch in Google Scholar

Kotansky, Roy (1994), Greek Magical Amulets: The Inscribed Gold, Silver, Copper, and Bronze Lamellae, Part I, Published Texts of Known Provenance, Opladen.10.1007/978-3-663-20312-4Search in Google Scholar

Kradin, Richard (2011), The Placebo Response and the Power of Unconscious Healing, London-New York.10.4324/9780203933220Search in Google Scholar

Lee, Jin Hyung (2016), “The Effects of Music on Pain: A Meta-Analysis”, in: J Music Ther 53, 430–477.10.1093/jmt/thw012Search in Google Scholar

Maas, Paul (1942), “The Philinna Papyrus”, in: JHS 62, 33–38.10.2307/626711Search in Google Scholar

Marganne, Marie-Hélène/De Haro Sanchez, Magali (2014), “At the Crossroads of Greek and Roman Medicine: The Contribution of Latin Papyri. 1 Medical Texts; 2. Iatromagical Papyri”, in: Brigitte Maire (ed.), ‘Greek’ and ‘Roman’ in Latin Medical Texts: Studies in Cultural Change and Exchange in Ancient Medicine, Leiden-Boston, 92–116.10.1163/9789004273863_008Search in Google Scholar

Marx-Wolf, Heidi/Upson-Saia, Kristi (2015), “The State of the Question: Religion, Medicine, Disability, and Health in Late Antiquity”, in JLA 8.2, 257–272.10.1353/jla.2015.0029Search in Google Scholar

Miller, Franklin/Colloca, Luana (2010), “Semiotics and the Placebo Effect”, in: Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 53.4, 509–516.10.1353/pbm.2010.0004Search in Google Scholar

Nutton, Vivian (2013), Ancient Medicine, London-New York.Search in Google Scholar

Önnerfors, Andreas (1993), “Magische Formeln im Dienste römischer Medizin”, in: ANRW 2.37.1, 157–224.10.1515/9783110887877-007Search in Google Scholar

Pachoumi, Eleni (2017), The Concepts of the Divine in the Greek Magical Papyri, Tübingen.10.1628/978-3-16-154019-6Search in Google Scholar

Petropoulos, John (2008), Greek Magic: Ancient, Medieval and Modern, New York.10.4324/9780203931882Search in Google Scholar

Poethke, Günter/Prignitz, Sebastian/Vaelske, Veit (eds.) (2012), Das Aktenbuch des Aurelios Philammon: Prozessberichte, Annona militaris und Magie in BGU IV 1024–1027, Berlin-Boston.10.1515/9783110282788Search in Google Scholar

Pradel, Fritz (1907), Griechische und Süditalienische Gebete, Beschwörungen und Rezepte des Mittelalters, Giessen.Search in Google Scholar

Preisendanz, Karl/Henrichs, Albert (eds.) (1928[1973]), Papyri Graecae Magicae: Die griechischen Zauberpapyri, I, Stuttgart.10.1515/9783110951264Search in Google Scholar

Sabbahy, Lisa (2018), Paleopathology of the Ancient Egyptians: An Annotated Bibliography 1995–2016, updated Edition, Cairo.Search in Google Scholar

Seligman, Adam B./Weller, Robert P./Puett, Michael J./Simon, Bennett (2007), Ritual and its consequences, New York.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195336009.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Sørensen, Jesper (2007), A Cognitive Theory of Magic, Lanham.Search in Google Scholar

Spiro, Howard (1999), “Clinical reflections”, in: Anne Harrington (ed.), The Placebo Effect: An Interdisciplinary Exploration, Cambridge, MA.Search in Google Scholar

Suárez De La Torre, Emilio (2011), “Versos homéricos en los papiros mágicos griegos”, in: María José García Blanco/Teresa Rodríguez Amado/María José Martín Velasco/Manuel Enrique Vázquez Buján (eds.), Ἀντίδωρον. Antidoron. Homenaje a Juan José Moralejo, Santiago de Compostela, 527–544.Search in Google Scholar

Tremlin, Todd (2006), Minds and Gods: The Cognitive Foundations of Religion, Oxford.10.1093/0195305345.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Turner, Victor (1964), “Symbols in Ndembu Ritual”, in: Max Gluckman (ed.), Closed Systems and Open Minds: The Limits of Naïvety in Social Anthropology, Edinburgh.10.1007/978-1-349-15388-6_8Search in Google Scholar

Turner, Victor (1967), The Forest of Symbols: Aspects of Ndembu Ritual, Ithaca, NY.Search in Google Scholar

Van Minnen, Peter (1995), “Medical Care in Late Antiquity”, in: Philip J. van der Eijk/Manfred H.F.J. Horstmanshoff/Piet H. Schrijvers (eds.), Ancient Medicine in its Socio-Cultural Context, Amsterdam, 153–169.10.1163/9789004418370_015Search in Google Scholar

Versnel, Henk S. (1998), “An Essay on Anatomical Curses”, in: Fritz Graf/Walter Burkert (eds.), Ansichten Griechischer Rituale, Stuttgart.10.1515/9783110962406.217Search in Google Scholar

Webb, Jamie (2019), “Putting Placebo-Controlled Trials in Developing Countries to the Interpersonal Justifiability Test”, in: Dev World Bioeth 19.3, 139–147.10.1111/dewb.12209Search in Google Scholar

Welch, John S. (2003), “Ritual in Western Medicine and its Role in Placebo Healing”, in: Journal of Religion and Health 42, 21–33.10.1023/A:1022260610761Search in Google Scholar

Williams, John N. (2000), “The Ethics of Placebo-Controlled Trials in Developing Countries to Prevent Mother-To-Child Transmission of HIV: Controversial Placebo-Trials on HIV–Infected Pregnant Women in Developing Countries like Thailand and Uganda”, in: Ann Acad Med Singapore 29.5, 557–562.Search in Google Scholar

Wünsch, Richard (1911), “Zur Geisterbannung im Altertum”, in: Festschrift zur Jahrhundertfeier der Universität zu Breslau, Mitteilungen der Schlesischen Gesellschaft für Volkskunde 13–14, Breslau, 9–32.Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2021-07-01
Published in Print: 2021-06-26

© 2021 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston

Downloaded on 26.1.2026 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/tc-2021-0002/html
Scroll to top button