Abstract
My aim is to investigate the link between Plato’s Sophist and Gorgias’s treatise On What Is Not. This relationship is worth examining because Gorgias’s treatise constitutes an essential, but insufficiently studied stage in the intellectual journey leading from Parmenides to the Sophist. My claims are that 1) Plato’s agenda in the Sophist perfectly meets the challenges Gorgias raises in the first thesis of his treatise, that 2) this becomes clear once we focus on Gorgias’s and Plato’s respective use of the verb ‘to be’ and, finally, that 3) Plato is able to overcome Parmenides’s impasse precisely because he deals with Gorgias’s treatise.
References
Ackrill, John Lloyd (1957): ‘Plato and the Copula: Sophist 251–259’, Journal of Hellenic Studies 77, pp. 1–6.10.2307/628625Search in Google Scholar
Aronadio, Francesco (2018): ‘L’articolazione argomentativa di Plat. Soph. 237b7–239a11 e la natura del medamos on’, Elenchos 39, pp. 57–98.10.1515/elen-2018-0004Search in Google Scholar
Aubenque, Pierre (1991): ‘Une occasion manquée: la genèse avortée de la distinction entre l’“étant” et le “quelque chose”’. In: Aubenque, Pierre, Michel Narcy (eds.) Etudes sur le Sophiste de Platon, publiées sous la direction de P. Aubenque; textes recueillis par M. Narcy, Naples: Bibliopolis, pp. 365–385.Search in Google Scholar
Bluck, Richard Stanley (1975): Plato’s Sophist. A Commentary, Manchester: Manchester University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Bonazzi, Mauro (2010): I Sofisti, Roma: Carocci.Search in Google Scholar
Brown, Lesley (1994): ‘The verb “to be” in Greek Philosophy: some remarks’. In: Everson, S. (ed.), Language: Companions to Ancient thought 3, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 212–36.Search in Google Scholar
Calogero, Guido (1977): Studi sull’Eleatismo, 9th edn., Florence: La Nuova Italia.Search in Google Scholar
Centrone, Bruno (2008): Platone. Sofista, Turin: Bur.Search in Google Scholar
Cornford, Francis Macdonald (1935): Plato’s Theory of Knowledge, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.Search in Google Scholar
Crivelli, Paolo (2012): Plato’s Account of Falsehood. A Study of the Sophist, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9781139015004Search in Google Scholar
Curd, Patricia (2006): ‘Gorgias and the Eleatics’. In: Sassi, Maria Michela (ed.): La costruzione del discorso filosofico nell’età dei Presocratici, Pisa: Edizioni della Normale, pp. 183–98.Search in Google Scholar
Di Iulio, Erminia (2020a): ‘À Rebours: dal Sofista a Parmenide. Platone tra “corrispondenza” e “identità”’, Rivista di Filosofia Neoscolastica 112, pp. 111–125.Search in Google Scholar
Di Iulio, Erminia (2020b): ‘Identity’s Sustainability. Parmenides on einai and noein’. In: L. Giovannetti (ed.) The Sustainability of Thought: an itinerary through the history of philosophy, Naples: Bibliopolis, pp. 19–43.Search in Google Scholar
Di Iulio, Erminia (2023): Gorgias’s Thought. An Epistemological Reading, Issues in Ancient Philosophy, London: Routledge.10.4324/9781003277620Search in Google Scholar
Dixsaut, Monique (1991): ‘La négation, le non-être et l’autre dans le Sophiste’, In: Aubenque, Pierre, Michel Narcy (eds.) Etudes sur le Sophiste de Platon, publiées sous la direction de P. Aubenque; textes recueillis par M. Narcy, Naples: Bibliopolis, pp. 165–213.Search in Google Scholar
Frede, Michael (1967): Prädikation und Existenzaussage, Hypomnemata, 18, Göttingen.Search in Google Scholar
Fronterotta, Francesco (2007): Platone. Sofista, Milan: BUR.Search in Google Scholar
Ioli, Roberta (2010): Gorgia di Leontini. Su ciò che non è, Hidelsheim: Olms.Search in Google Scholar
Ioli, Roberta (2013): Gorgia. Testimonianze e Frammenti, Rome: Carocci.Search in Google Scholar
Ioli, Roberta (2022): ‘Essere e nulla. Una riflessione su eleatismo e sofistica tra Parmenide e Gorgia’. In Volpe Enrico (ed.), Le vie dell’essere. Studi sulla ricezione antica di Parmenide, Sankt Augustin: Academia, pp. 109–130.10.5771/9783985720415-109Search in Google Scholar
Kahn, Charles (1966): ‘The Greek verb “to be” and the concept of being’, Foundations of Language 2, pp. 245–68.Search in Google Scholar
Kahn, Charles (2009): ‘Why existence does not emerge as a distinct concept in Greek philosophy’. In: Kahn, Charles: Essays on Being, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 62–74.10.1093/oso/9780199534807.003.0004Search in Google Scholar
Kerferd, George Briscoe (1955): ‘Gorgias on nature or which is not’, Phronesis 1, pp. 3–25.10.1163/156852855X00023Search in Google Scholar
Lafrance, Yvon, (1984): ‘Sur une lecture analytique des arguments concernant le non-être (Sophiste, 237b10–239a12)’, Revue de Philosophie Ancienne 2, pp. 41–76.Search in Google Scholar
Leigh, Fiona (2012): ‘Modes of Being at “Sophist” 255c-e’, Phronesis 57, pp. 1–28.10.1163/156852812X607270Search in Google Scholar
Lewis, Frank (1976): ‘Plato on “Not”’, California Studies in Classical Antiquity 9, pp. 89–115.10.2307/25010702Search in Google Scholar
Malcolm, John (1967), ‘Plato’s Analysis of to on and to me on in the Sophist’, Phronesis 12, pp. 130–146.10.1163/156852867X00093Search in Google Scholar
Mansfeld, Jaap (1988): ‘De Melisso Xenophane Gorgia: Pyrrhonizing Aristotelianism’, Rheinisches Museum 121, pp. 239–276.Search in Google Scholar
Mourelatos, Alexander (1968/69): ‘Comments on “The thesis of Parmenides”’, The Review of Metaphysics 22, pp. 735–444.Search in Google Scholar
O’Brien, Denis (1995): Le Non-Être. Deux Ètudes sur le Sophiste de Platon, Sankt Augustin, Academia.Search in Google Scholar
O’Brien, Denis (2013): ‘Does Plato refute Parmenides?’. In: Bossi Beatriz, Robinson, Thomas More (eds.): Plato’s Sophist Revisited, Berlin: De Gruyter, pp. 117–155.10.1515/9783110287134.117Search in Google Scholar
Owen, Gwilym Ellis Lane (1970): ‘Plato on not being’. In: Owen, G. E. L: Logic, Science and Dialectic (ed. by Martha Nussbaum), Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press, pp. 104–137.Search in Google Scholar
Palumbo, Lidia (1994): Il non essere e l’apparenza. Sul Sofista di Platone, Naples: Loffredo.Search in Google Scholar
Robinson, David B. (1995): ‘Sophist’. In: E. A. Duke, W. F. Hicken, W. S. M. Nicoll, D. B. Robinson, and J. C. G. Strachan (eds): Platonis Opera, Vol. 1: Tetralogiae I–II (Oxford Classical Texts), Oxford: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Rowe, Christopher (2015): Theaetetus and Sophist, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Schiappa, Edward (1997): ‘Interpreting Gorgias’s “Being” in “On Not-Being or On Nature”’, Philosophy & Rhetoric 30, pp. 13–30.Search in Google Scholar
Thomas, Christine (2008): ‘Speaking of something. Plato’s Sophist and Plato’s beard’, Canadian Journal of philosophy 38, pp. 631–667.10.1353/cjp.0.0032Search in Google Scholar
Wesoly, Marian (2013): ‘La «Dimostrazione propria» di Gorgia’, Peitho/Examina Antiqua 1, pp. 159–188.10.14746/pea.2013.1.8Search in Google Scholar
© 2023 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
Articles in the same Issue
- Titelseiten
- Preliminary Note
- Articles
- The Verb εἰμί and Its Benefits for Parmenides’ Philosophy
- Protagoras on Being: Between ὀρθοέπεια and the Eleatic Legacy
- Gorgias and Plato’s Sophist
- Language, Definition and Being in Antisthenes
- Complete versus Incomplete εἶναι in the Sophist: An unhelpful dilemma
- Senses of Being in Plato’s Timaeus
Articles in the same Issue
- Titelseiten
- Preliminary Note
- Articles
- The Verb εἰμί and Its Benefits for Parmenides’ Philosophy
- Protagoras on Being: Between ὀρθοέπεια and the Eleatic Legacy
- Gorgias and Plato’s Sophist
- Language, Definition and Being in Antisthenes
- Complete versus Incomplete εἶναι in the Sophist: An unhelpful dilemma
- Senses of Being in Plato’s Timaeus