Depictions of Diversity in Books Recommended for Storytime: A Cautionary Tale
-
Erin Ingram
und
Maria Cahill
Abstract
Elements of equity, diversity, and inclusion (EDI) in diverse books support children’s intellectual, social, and emotional development. Public library storytime programs serve as venues to showcase books with characters of varied backgrounds, identities, and experiences who may or may not reflect those of the communities the libraries serve. Because storytime providers often rely on online resources to plan their programs, it is important to investigate the presence and quality of EDI elements in books recommended for storytimes by these resources. The present study analyzed the text, illustrations, and WorldCat metadata for a random sample of 481 children’s books recommended by six popular online resources for storytime planning. Results revealed an overall lack of EDI in the recommended books with few characters representing parallel cultures, living with a disability or chronic illness, practicing a religion other than Christianity, or communicating in a language other than English. The paper includes implications for storytime providers and library administrators in the areas of program planning, professional development, and program assessment.
Funding source: Institute of Museum and Library Services
Award Identifier / Grant number: LG-96-17-0199-17
Appendix A: Online resources in this study’s random sample
Esther. 2012. “Welcome to My Storytime Wiki.” Esther Storytimes. PBworks. http://estherstorytimes.pbworks.com/w/page/19315771/FrontPage (accessed October 29, 2019).
Fitzgerald, K. 2015. “Book Lists.” Storytime Secrets (blog). https://storytimesecrets.blogspot.com/p/books.html (accessed October 26, 2019).
Kaap, J. 2019. “Category: Preschool Storytimes.” Silly Librarian. http://sillylibrarian.com/blog/?cat=5 (accessed October 24, 2019).
Krabbenhoft, L., and D. Horrocks. 2019. “Storytime Resources.” Jbrary. https://jbrary.com/category/storytime-resources/ (accessed October 20, 2019).
McManus, J. 2018. “Themes for Storytime.” MCLS Kids. Pbworks. http://mclskids.pbworks.com/w/page/26296055/Themes%20for%20Storytime (accessed October 31, 2019).
Salo, K. 2014. “Themes.” Storytime Katie. https://storytimekatie.com/themes/ (accessed October 20, 2019).
Appendix B: Awards for Children’s Books
American Indian Youth Literature Awards, sponsored by the American Indian Library Association – http://ailanet.org/activities/american-indian-youth-literature-award/
Américas Book Award for Children’s and Young Adult Literature, sponsored by the Consortium of Latin American Studies Programs – http://claspprograms.org/pages/detail/68/Award-Winners
Arab American Book Award, sponsored by the Arab American National Museum – https://arabamericanmuseum.org/book-awards/
Asian/Pacific American Award for Literature, sponsored by the Asian Pacific American Librarians Association – http://www.apalaweb.org/awards/literature-awards/
Batchelder Award, sponsored by the Association for Library Service to Children – http://www.ala.org/alsc/awardsgrants/bookmedia/batchelderaward/batchelderpast
Carter G. Woodson Book Award, sponsored by the National Council for Social Studies – https://www.socialstudies.org/get-involved/carter-g-woodson-book-award-and-honor-winners
Christian Book Award, sponsored by the Evangelical Christian Publishers Association – https://christianbookawards.com/winners.html
Coretta Scott King Book Awards, sponsored by the American Library Association’s Ethnic and Multicultural Information Exchange Round Table (EMIERT) – http://www.ala.org/ala/mgrps/rts/emiert/cskbookawards/index.cfm
Dolly Gray Children’s Literature Award, sponsored by the Council for Exceptional Children’s Division on Autism and Developmental Disabilities – https://www.dollygrayaward.com/home
Hans Christian Andersen Awards, sponsored by the International Board on Books for Young People – https://www.ibby.org/awards-activities/awards/hans-christian-andersen-awards
Jane Addam’s Children’s Book Awards, sponsored by the Jane Addams Peace Association – https://www.janeaddamschildrensbookaward.org/
Pura Belpré Award, sponsored by the Association for Library Service to Children and REFORMA – http://www.ala.org/alsc/awardsgrants/bookmedia/belpremedal
Schneider Family Book Award, sponsored by Katherine Schneider and the American Library Association – http://www.ala.org/awardsgrants/schneider-family-book-award
Skipping Stones Honor Awards, sponsored by Skipping Stones, an international educational magazine – https://www.skippingstones.org/wp/book-awards/
South Asia Book Award, sponsored by the South Asia National Outreach Consortium – https://southasiabookaward.wisc.edu/
Stonewall Book Award – Mike Morgan & Larry Romans Children’s & Young Adult Literature Award, sponsored by the American Library Association’s Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, and Transgender Round Table (GLBTRT) – http://www.ala.org/awardsgrants/stonewall-book-awards-mike-morgan-larry-romans-children’s-young-adult-literature-award
Sydney Taylor Book Award, sponsored by the Association of Jewish Libraries – https://jewishlibraries.starchapter.com/images/downloads/Sydney_Taylor_Book_Award/stbaallawardwinnersever.pdf
Walter Dean Myers Awards for Outstanding Children’s Literature, sponsored by We Need Diverse Books – https://diversebooks.org/programs/walter-awards/
Appendix C: Websites with Recommendations for Diverse Children’s Literature
https://americanindiansinchildrensliterature.blogspot.com/p/best-books.html
Debbie Reese, writer of the blog American Indians in Children’s Literature recommends “Best Books” written by or about American Indians or First Nations people, organized by publication year.
http://booksforkidsingayfamilies.blogspot.com/
Patricia A. Sarles reviews and indexes children’s books with LGBTQ characters.
Curated by Varian Johnson and colleagues who provide recommendations for African American children’s books.
https://ccbc.education.wisc.edu/diversity-statistics-book-search/
Search among recently published children’s books by categories such as diversity subject and aspects of the primary character. Indexed by the Cooperative Children’s Book Center which assigns a star to recommended books.
http://www.clrsig.org/nbgs-lists.html
Notable Books for a Global Society chosen annually by a Children’s Literature and Reading Special Interest Group from the International Literacy Association.
https://cynthialeitichsmith.com/lit-resources/read/diversity/multicultural/multi_biblio/
Multicultural Children’s and Young Adult Books reviewed by Cynthia Leitich Smith.
http://decoloresreviews.blogspot.com
Beverly Slapin and colleagues review books written in Spanish and English for the blog De Colores: The Raza Experience in Books for Children.
http://dia.ala.org/content/free-program-downloads
El día de los niños/El día de los libros (Children’s Day/Book Day) Diversity Initiative book lists, updated yearly.
https://diversebookfinder.org/category/collection/
Various recommendations for high quality children’s books about Black, Indigenous, and People of Color (BIPOC) characters published since 2002.
http://en.childrenslibrary.org/books/index.shtml
The International Children’s Digital Library is a searchable database of free ebooks written in many languages as well as in English and another language.
https://feministbooksforkids.com/category/picture-books/
Recommendations curated by topics such as “29 Children’s Books About Female Scientists,” “10 Children’s Books About Blended Families,” and “12 Children’s Books About Gentle Boys and Men” from a self-described writer, mom, and activist.
http://glbtrt.ala.org/rainbowbooks/
The Rainbow List, recommendations from members of the American Library Association’s Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, and Transgender Round Table (GLBTRT), organized by publication year and genre.
https://www.ibby.org/awards-activities/awards/ibby-honour-list
Honour Lists of titles chosen biennially by members of the International Board on Books for Young People.
https://www.slj.com/?detailStory=muslim-representation-in-picture-books
School Library Journal contributors Sara G. Ahmed, Mahasin Abuwi Aleem, Ariana Sani Hussain, and Hadeal Salamah recommend picture books with Muslim characters.
References
Adkins, D., C. Virden, and C. Yier. 2015. “Learning about Diversity: The Roles of LIS Education, LIS Associations, and Lived Experience.” Library Quarterly 85 (9): 139–49, https://doi.org/10.1086/680153.Suche in Google Scholar
Al-Hazza, T. C., and K. T. Bucher. 2008. “Building Arab Americans’ Cultural Identity and Acceptance with Children’s Literature.” The Reading Teacher 62 (3): 210–19, https://doi.org/10.1598/RT.62.3.3.Suche in Google Scholar
American Library Association (ALA). 2019. “ALA and US Library Associations Affirm Commitment to Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion.” American Library Association. http://www.ala.org/news/press-releases/2019/06/ala-and-us-library-associations-affirm-commitment-equity-diversity-and (accessed May 3, 2020).Suche in Google Scholar
American Library Association (ALA). 2020. “ALA Takes Responsibility for Past Racism, Pledges a More Equitable Association.” American Library Association. http://www.ala.org/news/press-releases/2020/06/ala-takes-responsibility-past-racism-pledges-more-equitable-association (accessed May 3, 2020).Suche in Google Scholar
Beck, I. L., and M. G. McKeown. 2001. “Text Talk: Capturing the Benefits of Read-Aloud Experiences for Young Children.” The Reading Teacher 55 (1): 10–20.Suche in Google Scholar
Bentley, D. F., and M. Souto-Manning. 2016. “Toward Inclusive Understandings of Marriage in an Early Childhood Classroom: Negotiating (Un)readiness, Community, and Vulnerability through a Critical Reading of ‘King and King’.” Early Years 36 (2): 195–206, https://doi.org/10.1080/09575146.2015.1104899.Suche in Google Scholar
Bishop, R. S. 1990. “Mirrors, Windows, and Sliding Glass Doors.” Perspectives 6 (3): ix–xi.Suche in Google Scholar
Bogan, K. 2020. “Diversity Audit: A Practical Guide.” Don’t Shush Me! Adventures of a Future Ready High School Librarian. https://dontyoushushme.com/2020/06/15/diversity-audit-a-practical-guide/ (accessed May 3, 2020).Suche in Google Scholar
Braden, E. G., and S. J. Rodriguez. 2016. “Beyond Mirrors and Windows: A Critical Content Analysis of Latinx Children’s Books.” Journal of Language and Literacy Education 12 (2): 56–83, http://jolle.coe.uga.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/56-83_JoLLE_2016_202_Braden__Rodriguez.pdf (accessed March 18, 2022).Suche in Google Scholar
Bronson, A. 2016. “Mirrors and Windows.” Public Libraries 55 (6): 28–30, http://publiclibrariesonline.org/2017/01/feature-mirrors-and-windows-diversity-in-childrens-picture-books/ (accessed March 18, 2022).Suche in Google Scholar
Brown, C. C. 2017. Harnessing the Power of Google. Santa Barbara: Libraries Unlimited.10.5040/9798400661877Suche in Google Scholar
Bulatowicz, D. M. 2017. “Diverse Literature in Elementary School Libraries: Who Chooses and Why?” PhD diss. Montana State University.Suche in Google Scholar
Califa Group. n.d. “Search”. Retrieved May 3, 2020. Califa Group. https://infopeople.org/search/google/storytime (accessed May 3, 2020).Suche in Google Scholar
Campana, K., E. J Mills, J. L. Capps, E. T. Dresang, A. Carlyle, C. A. Metoyer, I. B. Urban, E. N. Feldman, M. Brouwer, K. Burnett, and B. Kotrla. 2016. “Early Literacy in Library Storytimes: A Study of Measures of Effectiveness.” Library Quarterly 86 (4): 369–88, https://doi.org/10.1086/688028.Suche in Google Scholar
Campbell, E. 2017. “Diversity as Evolutionary in Children’s Literature: The Blog Effect.” Children & Libraries 15 (3): 9–13, https://journals.ala.org/index.php/cal/article/view/6419 (accessed March 18, 2022).10.5860/cal.15.3.9Suche in Google Scholar
Colorado Libraries for Early Literacy. 2019. “2019 CLEL Conference Materials.” Colorado Libraries for Early Literacy. https://www.clel.org/2019-conference-materials (accessed May 3, 2020).Suche in Google Scholar
Crisp, T., S. M. Knezek, M. Quinn, G. E. Bingham, K. Girardeau, and F. Starks. 2016. “What’s on our Bookshelves? The Diversity of Children’s Literature in Early Childhood Classroom Libraries.” Journal of Children’s Literature 42 (2): 29–42.Suche in Google Scholar
Diamant-Cohen, B., and M. A. Hetrick. 2014. Transforming Preschool Storytime: A Modern Vision and a Year of Programs. Chicago: ALA Neal-Schuman.Suche in Google Scholar
Dyches, T. T., K. Egan, K. T. Moss, H. P. Grow, S. Black, and M. A. Prater. 2018. “Same but Different: Characters with Developmental Disabilities in Current Juvenile Literature.” DADD Online Journal: Research to Practice 5 (1): 73–89, https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/facpub/2978/ (accessed March 18, 2022).Suche in Google Scholar
Evans-Santiago, B., and Lin, M. 2016. “Inclusion with Sensitivity Teaching children with LGBTQ Families.” Young Children 71 (2): 56–63.Suche in Google Scholar
Fort, V. 2019. “Programming with Diversity in Mind: Conducting a Diversity Audit.” School Library Connection.Suche in Google Scholar
Ghoting, S. N., and P. Martin-Diaz. 2006. Early Literacy Storytimes @ Your Library: Partnering with Caregivers for Success. Chicago: ALA Editions of the American Library Association.Suche in Google Scholar
Gonzalez, A. M., J. R. Steele, and A. S. Baron. 2017. “Reducing Children’s Implicit Racial Bias through Exposure to Positive Out-Group exemplars.” Child Development 88 (1): 123–30, https://doi.org/10.1111/cdev.12582.Suche in Google Scholar
Hefflin, B. R., and M. A. Barksdale-Ladd. 2001. “African American Children’s Literature that Helps Students Find Themselves: Selection Guidelines for Grades K-3.” The Reading Teacher 54 (8): 810–819.Suche in Google Scholar
Horning, K. T., M. V. Lindgren, M. Schliesman, and E. M. Townsend. 2015. “A Few Observations on Publishing in 2014.” Cooperative Children’s Book Center, University of Wisconsin–Madison. https://ccbc.education.wisc.edu/observations-on-publishing-in-2014/ (accessed May 3, 2020).Suche in Google Scholar
Husband, T. 2018. “Using Multicultural Picture Books to Promote Racial Justice in Urban Early Childhood Literacy Classrooms.” Urban Education: 1–27. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0042085918805145.10.1177/0042085918805145Suche in Google Scholar
Huyck, D., and S. P. Dahlen. 2019. “Picture This: Diversity in Children’s Books 2018 Infographic.” Sarah Park. https://readingspark.wordpress.com/2019/06/19/picture-this-diversity-in-childrens-books-2018-infographic/ (accessed May 3, 2020).Suche in Google Scholar
Jaeger, P. T., N. A. Cooke, C. Feltis, M. Hamiel, F. Jardine, and K. Shilton. 2015. “The Virtuous Circle Revisited: Injecting Diversity, Inclusion, Rights, Justice, and Equit into LIS from Education to Advocacy.” Library Quarterly 85 (2): 150–71. https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/680154.10.1086/680154Suche in Google Scholar
Jensen, K. 2018. “Diversity Auditing 101: How to Evaluate Your Collection.” School Library Journal. https://www.slj.com/?detailStory=diversity-auditing-101-how-to-evaluate-collection (accessed May 3, 2020).Suche in Google Scholar
Johnson, A. 2015. “Diversity on my Mind.” American Libraries 46 (3/4): 82.Suche in Google Scholar
Jones, R. P., and D. Cox. 2017. “America’s Changing Religious Identity.” Public Religion Research Institute. https://www.prri.org/research/american-religious-landscape-christian-religiously-unaffiliated/ (accessed May 3, 2020).Suche in Google Scholar
Justice, L. M., and S. Piasta. 2001. “Developing Children’s Print Knowledge through Adult-Child Storybook Reading Interactions: Print Referencing as an Instructional Practice.” In Handbook of Early Literacy Research, edited by S. B. Neuman and D. K. Dickinson, 200–13. New York: Guilford Publications.Suche in Google Scholar
Koen, M. 2021. “Sustainable Future for Early Childhood: Applying the African Ubuntu Philosophy to Contribute to the Holistic Development of Young Children.” In Sustainable Development in Africa: Fostering Sustainability in One of the World’s Most Promising Continents, edited by W. L. Filho, R. Pretorius, and L. O. de Sousa, 131–46. Cham, Switzerland: Springer.10.1007/978-3-030-74693-3_8Suche in Google Scholar
Koss, M. D. 2015. “Diversity in Contemporary Picture Books: A Content Analysis.” Journal of Children’s Literature 41(1): 32–42.Suche in Google Scholar
Krueger, A. H., and T. Lee. 2016. “Storytime-Palooza!.” Children & Libraries 14 (3): 18–22, https://journals.ala.org/index.php/cal/article/view/6077 (accessed March 18, 2022).10.5860/cal.14n3.18Suche in Google Scholar
Lifshitz, J. 2016. Curating Empathy. Literacy Today 33 (6): 24–26.Suche in Google Scholar
Library Juice Academy. 2020. “Youth Services” Library Juice Academy. https://libraryjuiceacademy.com/topic/youth-services/?post_type=projects (accessed May 3, 2020).Suche in Google Scholar
MacMillan, K., and C. Kirker. 2009. Storytime Magic: 400 Fingerplays, Flannelboards, and Other Activities. Chicago: American Library Association.Suche in Google Scholar
McKenzie, P. J., R. K. Stooke, and L. E. F. McKechnie. 2013. “Learning the Library: The Work of Public Library Storytime Participants.” Proceedings of the Annual Conference of CAIS/Actes du congrès annuel de l’ACSI, https://doi.org/10.29173/cais232.Suche in Google Scholar
Mortensen, A. 2019. “Measuring Diversity in the Collection.” Library Journal 144 (4): 28–30, https://www.libraryjournal.com/?detailStory=Measuring-Diversity-in-the-Collection (accessed March 18, 2022).Suche in Google Scholar
Naidoo, J. C. 2014. The Importance of Diversity in Library Programs and Material Collections for Children. Association for Library Service to Children. http://www.ala.org/alsc/sites/ala.org.alsc/files/content/ALSCwhitepaper_importance%20of%20diversity_with%20graphics_FINAL.pdf (accessed March 18, 2022).Suche in Google Scholar
OLC. n.d. “Webinars & Online Learning.” Ohio Library Council. https://olc.org/resources/education/webinars-online-learning/ (accessed May 3, 2020).Suche in Google Scholar
Oliveira-Formosinho, J., and S. Barros Araújo. 2011. “Early Education for Diversity: Starting from Birth. European Early Childhood Research Journal 19 (2): 223–35.10.1080/1350293X.2011.574410Suche in Google Scholar
Roos, B. 2020. “How to Conduct a Diversity Audit.” ALSC Blog. Association for Library Service to Children. https://www.alsc.ala.org/blog/2020/09/how-to-conduct-a-diversity-audit/ (accessed May 3, 2020).Suche in Google Scholar
Roy, L. 2007. “Let Book Joy Begin @ Your Library®! Ten Years of El Dia de los Niños/El Dia de los Libros.” Library Media Connection 25 (4): 14–6.Suche in Google Scholar
Russell, C. 2019. “Tackling Copyright Concerns When Taking Storytime Online.” School Library Journal. https://www.slj.com/?detailStory=tackling-copyright-concerns-when-taking-storytime-online (accessed March 18, 2022).Suche in Google Scholar
Ryan, C. 2013. “Language Use in the United States: 2011.” U.S. Department of Commerce Economics and Statistics Administration. https://www2.census.gov/library/publications/2013/acs/acs-22/acs-22.pdf (accessed May 3, 2020).Suche in Google Scholar
Short, K. G. 2018. “What’s Trending in Children’s Literature and Why it Matters.” Language Arts 95 (5): 287–98.10.58680/la201829584Suche in Google Scholar
Swedish Code of Statutes. 2010. Skollagen [Education Act]. Stockholm. Stockholm: Government Offices of Sweden.Suche in Google Scholar
SWON. n.d. “Past Events.” Southwest Ohio and Neighboring Libraries Consortium. https://swonlibraries.org/events/event_list.asp?show=past&group=&start=&end=&view=&cid=16629 (accessed May 3, 2020).Suche in Google Scholar
United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. 2017. “Education for Sustainable Development Goals: Learning Objectives.” UNESCO. https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000247444 (accessed January 10, 2022).Suche in Google Scholar
United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. 2019. “Framework for the Implementation of Education for Sustainable Development Beyond 2019.” UNESCO. https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000370215.locale=en (accessed January 10, 2022).Suche in Google Scholar
Wickham, M., and M. Sweeney. 2018. “Are we Still Transmitting Whiteness? A Case Study of a Southern, Rural Library’s Youth Collections.” Library Trends 67 (1): 89–106. https://doi.org/10.1353/lib.2018.0027.Suche in Google Scholar
Williams, A., and J. R. Steele. 2019. “Examining Children’s Implicit Racial Attitudes Using Exemplar and Category-Based Measures. Child Development 90 (3): 322–38, https://doi.org/10.1111/cdev.12991.Suche in Google Scholar
Winkler, E. 2015. “Why Does Latin@ Youth Literature Matter? How Children Learn about Race.” In The Americas Award Honoring Latin@ Children’s and Young Adult Literature of the Americas, edited by L. Henderson, 7–26. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.Suche in Google Scholar
Wopperer, E. 2011. “Inclusive Literature in the Library and the Classroom.” Knowledge Quest 39 (3): 26–34.Suche in Google Scholar
© 2022 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
Artikel in diesem Heft
- Frontmatter
- Disinformation and Its Negative Impact in the Changing World of Mass Media (Specifically Focused on the COVID-19 Pandemic in the Czech Republic)
- User Participation in Archival Knowledge Structures: Archival Description as Domain and Testing Ground
- Contextual Factors Affecting the Cooperation of Vietnamese Academic Libraries in Information Resource Sharing
- Investigating Role of Technological and Organizational Factors Towards Students’ Knowledge Sharing Behavior in Pakistan
- A Note on Law and Economics of Legal Deposit Systems
- Depictions of Diversity in Books Recommended for Storytime: A Cautionary Tale
- The Roles of Social Media in Information Services: Systematic Review and Expert Scrutiny
- Libri Best Student Research Paper Award 2023
Artikel in diesem Heft
- Frontmatter
- Disinformation and Its Negative Impact in the Changing World of Mass Media (Specifically Focused on the COVID-19 Pandemic in the Czech Republic)
- User Participation in Archival Knowledge Structures: Archival Description as Domain and Testing Ground
- Contextual Factors Affecting the Cooperation of Vietnamese Academic Libraries in Information Resource Sharing
- Investigating Role of Technological and Organizational Factors Towards Students’ Knowledge Sharing Behavior in Pakistan
- A Note on Law and Economics of Legal Deposit Systems
- Depictions of Diversity in Books Recommended for Storytime: A Cautionary Tale
- The Roles of Social Media in Information Services: Systematic Review and Expert Scrutiny
- Libri Best Student Research Paper Award 2023
