Home “Philosophy and Christianity can never be united”: The Role of Sibbern and Martensen in Kierkegaard’s Reception of Schleiermacher
Article
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

“Philosophy and Christianity can never be united”: The Role of Sibbern and Martensen in Kierkegaard’s Reception of Schleiermacher

  • Jon Stewart
Published/Copyright: December 22, 2017
Become an author with De Gruyter Brill
Author Information
Kierkegaard Studies Yearbook
From the journal Kierkegaard Studies Yearbook Volume 2017 Issue 1

Abstract

The present article explores the possible influence of Schleiermacher on Kierkegaard based primarily on a reading of the famous journal entry AA:13, in which the young Kierkegaard declares “Philosophy and Christianity can never be united.” It is argued that Kierkegaard’s reflections here and later constitute a part of an ongoing critical discussion with a number of Danish thinkers who were likewise interested in the issue of the relation of philosophy to Christianity or knowledge to faith. Schleiermacher’s thought can thus be seen to have passed through a Danish filter, which is the primary context for Kierkegaard’s engagement with it.

Published Online: 2017-12-22
Published in Print: 2017-12-20

© 2017 by Walter de Gruyter Berlin/Boston

Articles in the same Issue

  1. Titelei
  2. Preface
  3. Contents
  4. Section 1: Interpreting Kierkegaard: Problems and Perspectives
  5. Unfinished Business: The Time and Space of Irony
  6. Textual Immediacy and Sexual Intimacy: Kierkegaard’s Diary of a Failure
  7. The Politics of Selfhood with Constant Reference to Kierkegaard
  8. Der Mensch als Selbst. Zum Begriff des präreflexiven Selbstbewusstseins in Kierkegaards Krankheit zum Tode (1849)
  9. Prayer as God-knowledge (via Self)
  10. Le phénomène de la souffrance comme élément constitutif de la théophilosophie affirmative de Kierkegaard
  11. Re-reading the Religious – Aesthetically: A Literary Analysis of “The Woman Who Was a Sinner” and The Lily in the Field and the Bird of the Air
  12. De te fabula narratur. A Re-active Interplay with Kierkegaard’s Authorship
  13. Section 2: Sourcework Studies
  14. “Everything Has Its Time.” Kierkegaard’s Reading of Ecclesiastes
  15. Schelling in the Kierkegaardian Project: Between Kantian Critique and the Second Ethics
  16. On Kierkegaard’s Reaction to H.N. Clausen
  17. “Philosophy and Christianity can never be united”: The Role of Sibbern and Martensen in Kierkegaard’s Reception of Schleiermacher
  18. On the Origins of Kierkegaard’s Climacus Writings and Paradox Christology
  19. Section 3: Kierkegaard Reception
  20. Kierkegaard’s Reception in Lithuania
  21. The Voice of Conscience, Kierkegaard’s Theory of Indirect Communication, and Buber’s Philosophy of Dialogue
  22. A Promise Kept, a Self Repeated? Reading Gjentagelsen with Ricoeur
  23. «Être sans destin»: Imre Kertész, ou le concept d’existence constamment rapporté à Kierkegaard
  24. Section 4: Primary Texts in Translation
  25. Hans Lassen Martensen’s “The Present Religious Crisis”
  26. Section 5: Bibliography
  27. Kierkegaard Literature from 2005 to 2013. A Descriptive Bibliography
  28. Abbreviations
  29. List of Contributors
https://doi.org/10.1515/kierke-2017-0012

Articles in the same Issue

  1. Titelei
  2. Preface
  3. Contents
  4. Section 1: Interpreting Kierkegaard: Problems and Perspectives
  5. Unfinished Business: The Time and Space of Irony
  6. Textual Immediacy and Sexual Intimacy: Kierkegaard’s Diary of a Failure
  7. The Politics of Selfhood with Constant Reference to Kierkegaard
  8. Der Mensch als Selbst. Zum Begriff des präreflexiven Selbstbewusstseins in Kierkegaards Krankheit zum Tode (1849)
  9. Prayer as God-knowledge (via Self)
  10. Le phénomène de la souffrance comme élément constitutif de la théophilosophie affirmative de Kierkegaard
  11. Re-reading the Religious – Aesthetically: A Literary Analysis of “The Woman Who Was a Sinner” and The Lily in the Field and the Bird of the Air
  12. De te fabula narratur. A Re-active Interplay with Kierkegaard’s Authorship
  13. Section 2: Sourcework Studies
  14. “Everything Has Its Time.” Kierkegaard’s Reading of Ecclesiastes
  15. Schelling in the Kierkegaardian Project: Between Kantian Critique and the Second Ethics
  16. On Kierkegaard’s Reaction to H.N. Clausen
  17. “Philosophy and Christianity can never be united”: The Role of Sibbern and Martensen in Kierkegaard’s Reception of Schleiermacher
  18. On the Origins of Kierkegaard’s Climacus Writings and Paradox Christology
  19. Section 3: Kierkegaard Reception
  20. Kierkegaard’s Reception in Lithuania
  21. The Voice of Conscience, Kierkegaard’s Theory of Indirect Communication, and Buber’s Philosophy of Dialogue
  22. A Promise Kept, a Self Repeated? Reading Gjentagelsen with Ricoeur
  23. «Être sans destin»: Imre Kertész, ou le concept d’existence constamment rapporté à Kierkegaard
  24. Section 4: Primary Texts in Translation
  25. Hans Lassen Martensen’s “The Present Religious Crisis”
  26. Section 5: Bibliography
  27. Kierkegaard Literature from 2005 to 2013. A Descriptive Bibliography
  28. Abbreviations
  29. List of Contributors
Sign up now to receive a 20% welcome discount
Institutional Access
How does access work?
Have an idea on how to improve our website?
Please write us.
© 2025 De Gruyter Brill
Downloaded on 23.9.2025 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/kierke-2017-0012/html
Scroll to top button