Kant and Whewell on Bridging Principles between Metaphysics and Science
-
Steffen Ducheyne
Abstract
In this essay, I call attention to Kant's and Whewell's attempt to provide bridging principles between a priori principles and scientific laws. Part of Kant's aim in the Opus postumum (ca. 1796–1803) was precisely to bridge the gap between the metaphysical foundations of natural science and physics by establishing intermediary concepts or ‘Mittelbegriffe’ (henceforth this problem is referred to as ‘the bridging-problem’). It will be argued, on the basis of a close reading of Whewell's Notebooks on Induction, that Whewell's account of the Idea of Cause (and by extension, his doctrine of Fundamental Ideas in general) grew out of his dissatisfaction with Kantian philosophy of science and its seeming inability to solve the bridging-problem. This analysis throws new light on the importance of Kantianism in Whewell's philosophy, for it will be shown that Whewell took over and transformed Kant's idea of a priori principles as conditions for the establishment of proper knowledge about the world (without always clinging to Kant's exact differentiation between them) and that Whewell was trying to address a typical Kantian topic: namely, to show how scientific knowledge could be both empirical and necessary and how the gap between metaphysics and physics could be bridged.
© Walter de Gruyter 2011
Artikel in diesem Heft
- A Revolution in Method, Kant's “Copernican Hypothesis”, and the Necessity of Natural Laws
- Kant and Whewell on Bridging Principles between Metaphysics and Science
- The Structure of the Theoretical Power of Judgment. Kant and the Value of Our Empirical Cognitions
- Der Kummer der Vernunft. Zu Kants Idee einer allgemeinen Geschichtsphilosophie in therapeutischer Absicht
- Der Briefwechsel zwischen Immanuel Kant und Jeronimo de Bosch. Oder ein Beitrag zum holländisch-deutschen Austausch über die kritische Philosophie
- Gründlich zerstört oder gründlich gelesen? Eine Replik auf Brandts alternative Lesart des § 9 der Tugendlehre
- Buchbesprechungen
- Siglenverzeichnis
- Appel à communications: Kant: Théologie et religion
- Die Kant-Gesellschaft trauert um Hans-Martin Gerlach
Artikel in diesem Heft
- A Revolution in Method, Kant's “Copernican Hypothesis”, and the Necessity of Natural Laws
- Kant and Whewell on Bridging Principles between Metaphysics and Science
- The Structure of the Theoretical Power of Judgment. Kant and the Value of Our Empirical Cognitions
- Der Kummer der Vernunft. Zu Kants Idee einer allgemeinen Geschichtsphilosophie in therapeutischer Absicht
- Der Briefwechsel zwischen Immanuel Kant und Jeronimo de Bosch. Oder ein Beitrag zum holländisch-deutschen Austausch über die kritische Philosophie
- Gründlich zerstört oder gründlich gelesen? Eine Replik auf Brandts alternative Lesart des § 9 der Tugendlehre
- Buchbesprechungen
- Siglenverzeichnis
- Appel à communications: Kant: Théologie et religion
- Die Kant-Gesellschaft trauert um Hans-Martin Gerlach
