Home Cancel Culture in the Middle Ages
Article
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

Cancel Culture in the Middle Ages

Projecting and Negating Minds in Old Norse Literature
  • Stefka G. Eriksen EMAIL logo
Published/Copyright: April 6, 2022
Become an author with De Gruyter Brill

Abstract

The aim of this article is to explore how non-Christian deities are described, in comparison to the Christian God, in three Old Norse texts, belonging to different genres: Heimskringla, Barlaams saga og Jósafats, Elíss saga ok Rosamundu. These texts describe the pantheons of the Nordic cultures, the Babylonians, the Greeks, the Egyptians, and the Saracens. The main question that I discuss is whether these texts may be seen as transmitting useful knowledge and information about these religions and pantheons to their Nordic audiences or whether they are meant to mainly serve the mandate of their Christian authors. I interpret my results by deploying cognitive literary theory and the concept of mentalization. To conclude, I discuss whether the way non-Christian deities are described may be seen as a mental guide for Old Norse readers to practise mentalization according to the Christian empathetic scripts, in order to reach a deeper cognitive and religious conviction and thus strengthen their Christian identities and communities during the times of the Crusades.

References

Primary Sources

Black, Russell C. (ed.) 2014: Breta sögur from AM 544 4to. An Edition and Translation. [PhD dissertation], University of Washington.Search in Google Scholar

Finlay, Alison/Anthony Faulkes (transl.) 2011: Snorri Sturluson, Heimskringla vol. I. The Beginnings to Óláfr Tryggvason, Viking Society for Northern Research. London.Search in Google Scholar

Finlay, Alison/Anthony Faulkes (transl.) 2014: Snorri Sturluson, Heimskringla vol. II. Óláfr Haraldsson (The Saint), Viking Society for Northern Research. London.Search in Google Scholar

Hartman, A. Richard/Sandra C. Malicote (eds. and transl.) 2011: Elye de Saint-Gille. A chanson de geste. New York.10.2307/j.ctt1t88tvsSearch in Google Scholar

Kinck, H. K. 1852: Barlaam og Josaphat. En religiøs Roman. Christiania.Search in Google Scholar

Kålund, Kristian (ed.) 1917: Kirialax saga. Copenhagen.Search in Google Scholar

Kölbing, Eugen (ed.) 1971: Elís saga ok Rosamundu. Mit Einleitung, deutscher Übersetzung und Anmerkungen. Niederwalluf.Search in Google Scholar

Loth, Agnete (ed.) 1980: Karlamagnús saga. Branches I, III, VII et IX: édition bilingue. Copenhagen.Search in Google Scholar

Olrik, J./H. Ræder (eds) 1931: Saxo Grammaticus. Saxonis gesta Danorum vol. 1. Hauniæ.Search in Google Scholar

ÓsH = Bjarni Aðalbjarnarson (ed.) 1945: “Óláfs saga Helga.” In: Snorri Sturluson, Heimskringla II. (= Íslenzk fornrit 27) Reykjavík.Search in Google Scholar

ÓsT = Bjarni Aðalbjarnarson (ed.) 1941: “Óláfs saga Tryggvasonar.” In: Snorri Sturluson, Heimskringla I. (= Íslenzk fornrit 26) Reykjavík.Search in Google Scholar

Regal, Martin S. (trans.) 1997: “The Saga of the Sworn Brothers.” In: The Complete Sagas of Icelanders vol. II, ed. Viðar Hreinsson. Reykjavík. 329–402.Search in Google Scholar

Rindal M. (ed.) 1980: Barlaams ok Josaphats Saga. Manuscript No 6 fol, in the Royal Library Stockholm and the Norwegian Fragments. Oslo.Search in Google Scholar

Rindal M. (ed.) 1981: Barlaams ok Josaphats Saga. Oslo.Search in Google Scholar

Unger, Carl Richard (ed.) 1860: Karlamagnus saga ok kappa hans. Christiania.Search in Google Scholar

Secondary Sources

Aavitsland, K./L. Bonde (eds) 2021: Tracing the Jerusalem Code. Berlin/Boston. [https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110639438].10.1515/9783110639438Search in Google Scholar

Adams, James/Cordelia Heß 2015: “Encounters and Fantasies. Muslims, Jews and Christians in the North.” In: Cordelia Heß/Jonathan Adams (eds): Fear and Loathing in the North. Berlin et al. 3–28. [https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110346473-005].10.1515/9783110346473Search in Google Scholar

Adams, James/Cordelia Heß (eds) 2015: Fear and Loathing in the North. Berlin et al. [https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110346473].10.1515/9783110346473Search in Google Scholar

Aalto, Sirpa 2010: Categorizing Otherness in the King’s Sagas. Joensuu.Search in Google Scholar

Bandlien, Bjørn 2015: “Trading with Muslims and the Sámi in Medieval Norway.” In: Cordelia Heß/Jonathan Adams (eds): Fear and Loathing in the North. Berlin et al. 31–48. [https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110346473-006].10.1515/9783110346473-006Search in Google Scholar

Bandlien, Bjørn 2018: “Images of Muslims in Medieval Norway and Iceland.” In: Kurt Villads Jensen et al. (eds): Fighting for the Faith. The Many Crusades. Stockholm. 96–137.Search in Google Scholar

Bateman, I.A./P. Fonagy (eds) 2012: Handbook of Mentalizing in Mental Health Practice. Washington DC.Search in Google Scholar

Beck, Heinrich 1994: “Yngvi Tyrkja konungr.” In: Gísli Sigurðsson et al. (eds): Sagnaþing helgað Jónasi Kristjánssyni sjötugum 10. apríl 1994. Reykjavík. 64–68.Search in Google Scholar

Budal, Ingvil Brügger 2012: “Ei historie om naselause kvinner og varulvklede.” In: Karl G. Johansson/Rune Flaten (eds): Francia et Germania. Studies in Strengleikar and Þiðreks saga af Bern. Oslo. 203–230.Search in Google Scholar

Cole, Richard 2017: “Snorri and the Jews.” In: Pernille Hermann et al. (eds): Old Norse Mythology. Comparative Perspectives. Cambridge. 243–268.Search in Google Scholar

Eriksen, Stefka G. 2019: “Teaching and Practicing the Quadriga in Medieval Norway. A Reading of Barlaams ok Josaphats Saga.” In: Acta ad archaeologiam et artium historiam pertinentia 31. 225–244.10.5617/acta.7809Search in Google Scholar

Faulkes, Anthony 1978–79: “Descent from the Gods.” In: Medieval Scandinavia 11. 92–125.Search in Google Scholar

Fialho, Olivia 2019: “What Is Literature For? The Role Of Transformative Reading.” In: Cogent Arts & Humanities 6 (1). [https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2019.1692532].10.1080/23311983.2019.1692532Search in Google Scholar

Haugen O. E. 2009. “Forteljingane i forteljinga.” In: Karl G. Johansson/M. Arvidsson (eds): Barlaam in nord. Legenden om Barlaam och Josaphat i den nordiska medeltidslitteraturen. Oslo. 47–74.Search in Google Scholar

Haugen, O. E./Karl G. Johansson 2009: “De nordiske versjonene av Barlaam-legenden.” In: Karl G. Johansson/M. Arvidsson (eds): Barlaam in nord. Legenden om Barlaam och Josaphat i den nordiska medeltidslitteraturen. Oslo. 11–31.Search in Google Scholar

Jakobsson, Sverrir 2016: “Saracen Sensibilities. Muslims and Otherness in Medieval Saga Literature.” In: JEGP 115 (2). 213–238.10.5406/jenglgermphil.115.2.0213Search in Google Scholar

Johansson, Karl G. 2021: Review of “Vera Johanterwage: Buddha in Bergen. Die altnordische Barlaams ok Josaphats saga”. In: European Journal of Scandinavian Studies 51. 360–364. [https://doi.org/10.1515/ejss-2021-2042].10.1515/ejss-2021-2042Search in Google Scholar

Johanterwaga, Vera 2019: Buddha in Bergen. Die altnordische Barlaams ok Josaphats saga. Heidelberg.Search in Google Scholar

Kalinke, Marianne E. 2017: Stories Set Forth with Fair Words, the Evolution of Medieval Romance in Iceland. Cardiff.Search in Google Scholar

Katona, Cseta 2021: “Otherness along the Austurvegr. Cultural Interactions between the Rus’ and the Turkic Nomads of the Steppe.” In: Rebecca Merkelbach/Gwendolyne Knight (eds): Margins, Monsters, Deviants. Alterities in Old Norse Literature and Culture. Turnhout. 189–214.10.1484/M.NAW-EB.5.119612Search in Google Scholar

Lassen, Annette 2003: “Den prosaiske Odin. Fortidssagaerne som mytografi.” In: Annette Lassen et al. (eds): Fornaldarsagornas struktur och ideologi. Uppsala. 205–219.Search in Google Scholar

Lassen, Annette 2005: Odin på kristent pergament. En teksthistorisk studie. Copenhagen.Search in Google Scholar

Lassen, Annette 2009: “Skurðgoð, trégoð, hofgyðjur og heiðinglig hof. En gruppe hedenske elementer og deres kontekst i Ǫrvar-Odds saga, Sturlaugs saga starfsama og Bósa saga.” In: Agnete Ney et al. (eds): Fornaldarsagaerne. Myter og virkelighet. Copenhagen. 255–280.Search in Google Scholar

Lassen, Annette 2018: “The Tower of Babel and the Diffusion of World Languages and Religions.” In: Margaret Clunies Ross (ed): The Pre-Christian Religions of the North. Research and Reception, Volume I: From the Middle Ages to c. 1830. Turnhout. 105–118.10.1484/M.PCRN-EB.5.115247Search in Google Scholar

Leverage, Paula et al. (eds) 2011: Theory of Mind and Literature. West Lafayette, Ind.Search in Google Scholar

Lönnroth, Lars 1969: “The Noble Heathen. A Theme in the Sagas.” In: Scandinavian Studies 41. 1–29.Search in Google Scholar

Martin, John Stanley 1990: “Attitudes to Islam from the Chansons de geste to the Riddarasögur.” In: Parergon 8 (2). 81–95. [https://muse.jhu.edu/article/494625].10.1353/pgn.1990.0001Search in Google Scholar

McDonald, Roderick W. 2020: “Surface, Rupture, and Contextualities. Conflicting Voices of the Iberian ‘Other/s’ in Old Norse Literature.” In: Rebecca Merkelbach/Gwendolyne Knight (eds): Margins, Monsters, Deviants. Alterities in Old Norse Literature and Culture. Turnhout. 159–187.10.1484/M.NAW-EB.5.119611Search in Google Scholar

Palmer, Alan 2004: Fictional Minds. Lincoln/London.Search in Google Scholar

Rindal, M. 2009: “Barlaams ok Josaphats saga i det norske litterære miljøet.” In: Karl G. Johansson/M. Arvidsson (eds): Barlaam in nord: Legenden om Barlaam och Josaphat i den nordiska medeltidslitteraturen. Oslo. 31–46.Search in Google Scholar

Schomerus, Rudolf 1936: Die Religion der Nordgermanen im Spiegel christlicher Darstellung. Leipzig.Search in Google Scholar

Skårderud, Finn/S. Karterud 2007: “Å forstå seg selv og hverandre – intet mindre.” In: A. Bateman/P. Fonagy (eds): Mentaliseringsbasert terapi av borderline personlighetsforstyrelse. En praktisk veileder. Oslo.Search in Google Scholar

Skårderud, Finn/B. Sommerfeldt 2014: Miljøterapibogen. Mentalisering som holdning og handling. Copenhagen.10.18261/ISSN1504-2987-2014-03-02Search in Google Scholar

Stang, Margrethe C. 2021: “Enemies of Christ in the Far North: Tales of Saracens, Jews and the Sami in Norwegian Medieval Painting.” In: Kristin B. Aavitsland/Line M. Bonde (eds): Tracing the Jerusalem Code. Volume 1: The Holy City. Christian Cultures in Medieval Scandinavia (ca. 1100–1536). Berlin. 477–499.10.1515/9783110639438-023Search in Google Scholar

Taggart, Declan 2015: “Understanding Diversity in Old Norse Religion Taking Þórr as a Case Study.” [Unpublished PhD thesis], University of Aberdeen.Search in Google Scholar

Taggart, Declan 2021: “Did a Little Birdie Really Tell Odin? Applying Theory of Mind to Old Norse Religion.” In: Journal of Cognition and Culture 21. 370–398.10.1163/15685373-12340113Search in Google Scholar

Tolan, John 2002: Saracens. Islam in the Medieval European Imagination. New York.Search in Google Scholar

Weber, Gerd Wolfgang 1986: “The Decadence of the Feudal Myth. Towards a Theory of riddarasaga and Romance.” In: John Lindow et al. (eds): Structure and Meaning in Old Norse Literature. New Approaches to Textual Analysis and Literary Criticism. Odense. 415–454.Search in Google Scholar

Wellendorf, Jonas 2017: “The Æsir and Their Idols.” In: Pernille Hermann et al. (eds): Old Norse Mythology. Comparative Perspectives. Cambridge, MA. 243–268.Search in Google Scholar

Wellendorf, Jonas 2018: Gods and Humans in Medieval Scandinavia. Retying the Bonds. Cambridge, MA.10.1017/9781108677066Search in Google Scholar

Zunshine, Lisa 2006: Why We Read Fiction. Theory of the Mind and the Novel. Ohio.Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2022-04-06
Published in Print: 2022-04-30

© 2022 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston

Downloaded on 8.9.2025 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/ejss-2021-2064/html
Scroll to top button