Insights into the Human Face of the Ontario Basic Income Pilot: Fragments of a Shattered Social Experiment in Thunder Bay, Canada
-
Ravi Gokani
,
Janice Thibault
Abstract
In 2018 the Ontario Basic Income Pilot was launched in three Ontario cities and was cancelled abruptly months later after a change in government. This paper summarises the results of a qualitative study in one of those cities, Thunder Bay, Ontario. In partnership with a local community legal clinic, we interviewed 20 former recipients of the program and 13 key informants to understand two things. First, how did people experience the Ontario Basic Income Pilot for the time it was active? Second, how did people experience the cancellation of the Ontario Basic Income Pilot? After analysing the interviews using Thematic Analysis, we provided answers by way of themes. In general, the Ontario Basic Income Pilot was experienced as positive. Recipients discussed six main benefits: (a) improved financial security; (b) improved food security; (c) increase mental and physical health; (d) improved social mobility; (e) increased humanization; and (f) improved social inclusion. The cancellation on the other hand had largely negative effects. This includes a reversal of all of the aforementioned benefits as well as a decreased trust in government. We conclude the paper with a brief discussion covering two points. First, we explore what our small qualitative study suggests about the intended aims of the Ontario Basic Income Pilot; we do this by loosely comparing our findings with the preliminary survey administered on behalf of the provincial government. Second, we consider what a basic income might mean for the unique circumstances in which Thunder Bay finds itself.
Acknowledgments
The authors dedicate this publication to Angie Lynch of Kinna-Aweya Legal Clinic, who worked with the first author to establish this study, and without whom data collection would have been impossible. We also thank Charla Robinson of the Thunder Bay Chamber of Commerce for her support and colleagueship. Thank you to Brooklyn Wilson, M.S.W., R.S.W. for support during the research process.
References
Altman, J. 2016. “Basic Income for Remote Indigenous Australians: Prospects for a Livelihoods Approach in Neoliberal Times.” In Basic Income in Australia and New Zealand: Perspectives from the Neoliberal Frontier, edited by J. Mays, G. Marston, and J. Tomlinson, 179–205. London, UK: Palgrave McMillan.10.1057/9781137535320_9Suche in Google Scholar
Blueprint. 2018. Ontario Basic Income Pilot Baseline Survey. Retrieved from: https://hamiltonpoverty.ca/preview/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/OBIP-Baseline-Survey-Preliminary-Analysis-1.pdf.Suche in Google Scholar
Boyd, M. R. 2014. “Community-Based Research: Understanding the Principles, Practices, Challenges, and Rationale.” In The Oxford Handbook of Qualitative Research.10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199811755.013.006Suche in Google Scholar
Braun, V., and V. Clarke. 2006. “Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology.” Qualitative Research in Psychology 3 (2): 77–101. https://doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa.Suche in Google Scholar
CBC News. 2019. “Something Called a Job” Is the Way Out of Poverty, Not Basic Income, Ford Says. The Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved from: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/thunder-bay/ford-resolute-thunder-bay-1.4878364.Suche in Google Scholar
Commito, M. 2015. Making the Grade: Education Trends in Northern Ontario. Thunder Bay: Northern Policy Institute.Suche in Google Scholar
Di Matteo, L. 2021. “Arrested Development: A Brief Economic History of Northern Ontario, 1870-2020.” In Paper Prepared for Presentation at the Meetings of the Canadian Economic Association, June 2021.10.1080/02722011.2022.2042139Suche in Google Scholar
Ferdosi, M., T. McDowell, W. Lewchuk, and S. Ross. 2020. Southern Ontario’s Basic Income. Retrieved from: https://labourstudies.mcmaster.ca/documents/southern-ontarios-basic-income-experience.pdf.Suche in Google Scholar
Fleury, D., and M. Fortin. 2006. When Working is Not Enough to Escape Poverty: An Analysis of Canada’s Poor. Ottawa: Human Resources and Social Development Canada.Suche in Google Scholar
Forget, E. L. 2011. “The Town with No Poverty: The Health Effects of a Canadian Guaranteed Annual Income Field Experiment.” Canadian Public Policy 37 (3): 283–305. https://doi.org/10.1353/cpp.2011.0036.Suche in Google Scholar
Gibson, M., W. Hearty, and P. Craig. 2018. “Potential Effects of Universal Basic Income: a Scoping Review of Evidence on Impacts and Study Characteristics.” The Lancet 392: S36, https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(18)32083-x.Suche in Google Scholar
Gilbert, R., N. Murphy, A. Stepka, M. Barrett, and D. Worku. 2018. “Would a Basic Income Guarantee Reduce the Motivation to Work? an Analysis of Labor Responses in 16 Trial Programs.” Basic Income Studies 13 (2): 20180011. https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2018-0011.Suche in Google Scholar
Glass, K. 2017. “Karen Glass: Ontario Basic Income Pilot.” In [Presentation]. 16th Annual North American Basic Income Congress, NYC, US. https://usbig.net/papers/NABIG%20DECK%20June%2016%20NYC%20conference%20-%20Ontarios%20BI%20Pilot.pdf.Suche in Google Scholar
Hamilton, L., and J. Mulvale. 2019. ““Human Again”: The (Unrealized) Promise of Basic Income in Ontario.” Journal of Poverty 23 (7): 576–99. https://doi.org/10.1080/10875549.2019.1616242.Suche in Google Scholar
Jongbloed, L. 2003. “Disability Policy in Canada: An Overview.” Journal of Disability Policy Studies 13 (4): 203–9. https://doi.org/10.1177/104420730301300402.Suche in Google Scholar
Maki, K. 2011. “Neoliberal Deviants and Surveillance: Welfare Recipients under the Watchful Eye of Ontario Works.” Surveillance and Society 9 (1/2): 47–63. https://doi.org/10.24908/ss.v9i1/2.4098.Suche in Google Scholar
McDowell, T., and M. Ferdosi. 2020. “The Experiences of Social Assistance Recipients on the Ontario Basic Income Pilot.” Canadian Review of Sociology 57 (4): 681–707. https://doi.org/10.1111/cars.12306.Suche in Google Scholar
McDowell, T., and M. Ferdosi. 2021. “The Impacts of the Ontario Basic Income Pilot: A Comparative Analysis of the Findings from the Hamilton Region.” Basic Income Studies 16 (2): 209–56. https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2020-0034.Suche in Google Scholar
Mendelson, M. 2019. Lessons from Ontario’s Basic Income Pilot. Toronto: Caledon Institute of Social Policy.Suche in Google Scholar
Ministry of Children, Community and Social Services. 2017. Ontario Basic Income Pilot. https://www.ontario.ca/page/ontario-basic-income-pilot#:∼:text=Payment%20amount&text=Following%20a%20tax%20credit%20model,50%25%20of%20any%20earned%20income.Suche in Google Scholar
Monsebratten, L., and R. Ferguson. 2018. Ontario Government Scraps Basic Income Pilot Project, Limits Welfare Increase to 1.5 Per Cent. Retrieved from: https://www.thestar.com/news/queenspark/2018/07/31/ontario-government-scraps-basic-income-pilot-project-limits-welfare-increase-to-15-per-cent.html.Suche in Google Scholar
Ontario. 2016. https://www.ontario.ca/page/ontario-basic-income-pilot.Suche in Google Scholar
Ontario. 2018. Ontario’s Government for the People Announces Compassionate Wind Down of Basic Income Research Project. Retrieved from: https://news.ontario.ca/en/release/49980/ontarios-government-for-the-people-announces-compassionate-wind-down-of-basic-income-research-project.Suche in Google Scholar
Painter, A. 2016. “A Universal Basic Income: the Answer to Poverty, Insecurity, and Health Inequality?” BMJ 355. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.i6473.Suche in Google Scholar
Regehr, S., and J. Scheidler-Benns. 2019. “Signposts to Success: Report of a BICN Survey of Ontario Basic Income Recipients.” In Basic Income Canada Network. https://basicincomecanada.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/BICN-Signposts-to-Success.pdf.Suche in Google Scholar
Ross, A. 2020. Assessing Labour Market Shortages in the City of Thunder Bay. Northern Policy Institute. https://www.northernpolicy.ca/thunder-bay-labour-market-2020.Suche in Google Scholar
Ruckert, A., C. Huynh, and R. Labonté. 2018. “Reducing Health Inequities: Is Universal Basic Income the Way Forward?” Journal of Public Health 40 (1): 3–7. https://doi.org/10.1093/pubmed/fdx006.Suche in Google Scholar
Shahidi, F. V., O. Sod-Erdene, C. Ramraj, V. Hildebrand, and A. Siddiqi. 2019. “Government Social Assistance Programmes Are Failing to Protect the Health of Low-Income Populations: Evidence from the USA and Canada (2003–2014).” Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health 73 (3): 198–205. https://doi.org/10.1136/jech-2018-211351.Suche in Google Scholar
Standing, G. 2016. “The Precariat, Populism and Robots: Is Basic Income a Political Imperative.” World Economic Forum 20.Suche in Google Scholar
Tarasuk, V. 2017. Implications of a Basic Income Guarantee for Household Food Insecurity. Thunder Bay: Northern Policy Institute.Suche in Google Scholar
Thunder Bay District Social Services Administration Board. 2016a. Thunder Bay Point in Time Count 2016 Data. Lakehead Social Planning Council. https://www.lspc.ca/2016-point-in-time-count/.Suche in Google Scholar
Thunder Bay District Social Services Administration Board. 2021. Thunder Bay Point-In-Time Count 2021. Lakehead Social Planning Council. https://www.lspc.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021-Point-in-Time-Count-infographic-LSPC.pdf.Suche in Google Scholar
Thunder Bay District Social Services Administration Board. 2018. District of Thunder Bay Point-In-Time Count of People Experiencing Homelessness. Lakehead Social Planning Council. https://www.lspc.ca/wp-content/uploads/2018-Point-In-Time-Count-.pdf.Suche in Google Scholar
Wall, K. 2017. Low income among persons with a disability in Canada. Statistics Canada. Retreived from: https://publications.gc.ca/collections/collection_2017/statcan/75-006-x/75-006-2017-20-eng.pdf.Suche in Google Scholar
Wilson, B., E. Lightman, and A. Mitchell. 2009. “Sick and Tired: The Compromised Health of Social Assistance Recipients and the Working Poor in Ontario.” Wellesley Institute. Retreived from: https://www.oaith.ca/assets/files/Publications/sick-and-tired-for-web.pdf.Suche in Google Scholar
Wilson, N., and S. McDaid. 2021. “The Mental Health Effects of a Universal Basic Income: A Synthesis of the Evidence from Previous Pilots.” Social Science and Medicine 287: 114374, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2021.114374.Suche in Google Scholar
Zon, N., and H. Aldridge. 2018. Why is lone-parent poverty so high and what can we do about it? Maytree. Retreived from: https://maytree.com/wp-content/uploads/Policy-Brief-Lone-Parent-Poverty.pdf.Suche in Google Scholar
© 2025 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
