Who Estimates When It’s Not Required? the Case of Subrogation
-
Daniel Ames
,
Bryan S. Graden
Abstract
The ability of an insurer to pursue and collect money from responsible third parties for paid claims is referred to as subrogation. For some insurers, the amount to be recovered may be significant and, if accrued for, represents an estimate that could be used by management to affect earnings. This study investigates factors associated with insurers’ choice to accrue subrogation for statutory accounting. For statutory accounting, where insurers can choose whether to accrue subrogation or exclude it as an offset to the claims liability, we find that publicly-traded (mutually-owned) insurers are significantly more (less) likely to accrue subrogation than privately-owned insurers. In addition, we find that publicly-traded (mutual) insurers with weak ratings are less (more) likely to accrue subrogation. Finally, we find that insurers with large amounts of subrogation are more likely to accrue subrogation, consistent with these types of insurers having the strongest incentive to influence earnings through the subrogation accrual. Our results provide evidence suggesting that insurers respond to their incentives when choosing whether to accrue subrogation for statutory reporting.
References
Abarbanell, Jeffery, and Reuven Lehavy. 2003. “Biased Forecasts or Biased Earnings? the Role of Reported Earnings in Explaining Apparent Bias and Over/Underreaction in Analysts’ Earnings Forecasts.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 36 (1): 105–146.10.1016/j.jacceco.2003.11.001Search in Google Scholar
Ames, Daniel, Bryan Graden, and Jomo Sankara. 2017. “Estimation Errors among Insurers: The Case of Subrogation.” Journal of Insurance Issues 40 (2): 159–180.Search in Google Scholar
Ames, Daniel, Chris S. Hines, and Jomo Sankara. 2014. “Are Earnings Quality Attributes Reflected in Financial Strength Ratings?.” American Journal of Business 29 (3/4): 293–311.10.1108/AJB-12-2013-0073Search in Google Scholar
Beaver, William H., Maureen F. McNichols, and Karen K. Nelson. 2003. “Management of the Loss Reserve Accrual and the Distribution of Earnings in the Property-Casualty Insurance Industry.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 35 (3): 347–376.10.1016/S0165-4101(03)00037-5Search in Google Scholar
Becker, Connie L., Mark L. DeFond, James Jiambalvo, and K. R. Subramanyam. 1998. “The Effect of Audit Quality on Earnings Management.” Contemporary Accounting Research 15 (1): 1–24.10.1111/j.1911-3846.1998.tb00547.xSearch in Google Scholar
Burgstahler, David, and Ilia Dichev. 1997. “Earnings Management to Avoid Earnings Decreases and Losses.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 24 (1): 99–126.10.1016/S0165-4101(97)00017-7Search in Google Scholar
Cohen, Daniel A., Aiyesha Dey, and Thomas Z. Lys. 2008. “Real and Accrual-Based Earnings Management in the Pre-And post-Sarbanes-Oxley Periods.” The Accounting Review 83 (3): 757–787.10.2308/accr.2008.83.3.757Search in Google Scholar
Cohen, Daniel A., and Paul Zarowin. 2010. “Accrual-Based and Real Earnings Management Activities around Seasoned Equity Offerings.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 50 (1): 2–19.10.1016/j.jacceco.2010.01.002Search in Google Scholar
Degeorge, Francois, Jayendu Patel, and Richard Zeckhauser. 1999. “Earnings Management to Exceed Thresholds.” The Journal of Business 72 (1): 1–33.10.1086/209601Search in Google Scholar
Dyreng, S.D., M. Hanlon, and E.L. Maydew. 2008. “Long-Run Corporate Tax Avoidance.” The Accounting Review 83 (1): 61–82.10.2308/accr.2008.83.1.61Search in Google Scholar
Fan, Yun, Abhijit Barua, William M. Cready, and Wayne B. Thomas. 2010. “Managing Earnings Using Classification Shifting: Evidence from Quarterly Special Items.” The Accounting Review 85 (4): 1303–1323.10.2308/accr.2010.85.4.1303Search in Google Scholar
Gaver, Jennifer J., and Jeffrey S. Paterson. 2004. “Do Insurers Manipulate Loss Reserves to Mask Solvency Problems?.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 37 (3): 393–416.10.1016/j.jacceco.2003.10.010Search in Google Scholar
Grace, M. F., and J. T. Leverty. 2012. “Property-Liability Insurer Reserve Error: Motive, Manipulation, or Mistake.” Journal of Risk and Insurance 79 (2): 351–380.10.1111/j.1539-6975.2011.01434.xSearch in Google Scholar
Greenblatt, J. 1997 . “Insurance and Subrogation: When the Pie Isn’t Big Enough, Who Eats Last?” The University of Chicago Law Review 64: 1337– 1366.10.2307/1600219Search in Google Scholar
Healy, Paul M. 1985. “The Effect of Bonus Schemes on Accounting Decisions.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 7 (1-3): 85–107.10.1016/0165-4101(85)90029-1Search in Google Scholar
Jones, Jennifer J. 1991 . “Earnings Management during Import Relief Investigations.” Journal of Accounting Research 29: 193– 228.10.2307/2491047Search in Google Scholar
Karpman, J. 2010. “Tort Reform in America: Abrogating the Collateral Source Rule across the States.” Defense Counsel Journal 75: 346.Search in Google Scholar
Kohlbeck, Mark, and Terry Warfield. 2010. “Accounting Standard Attributes and Accounting Quality: Discussion and Analysis.” Research in Accounting Regulation 22 (2): 59–70.10.1016/j.racreg.2010.07.001Search in Google Scholar
Levitt, Jr, A. 1998. “The Numbers Game.” The CPA Journal 68 (12): 14.Search in Google Scholar
Ma, Y. L., and Y. Ren. 2012. “Do Publicly Traded Property–Casualty Insurers Cater to the Stock Market?.” Journal of Risk and Insurance 79 (2): 415–430.10.1111/j.1539-6975.2011.01438.xSearch in Google Scholar
Mayers, David, and Clifford W. Smith, Jr. 1988. “Ownership Structure across Lines of Property-Casualty Insurance.” In Foundations of Insurance Economics, 532–559. Springer Netherlands.10.1007/978-94-015-7957-5_26Search in Google Scholar
McVay, Sarah Elizabeth. 2006. “Earnings Management Using Classification Shifting: An Examination of Core Earnings and Special Items.” The Accounting Review 81 (3): 501–531.10.2308/accr.2006.81.3.501Search in Google Scholar
National Association of Insurance Commissioners. 2017. “Statement of Statutory Accounting Principles No. 55: Unpaid Claims, Losses and Loss Adjustment Expenses.” Accounting Practices and Procedures Manual.Search in Google Scholar
Nelson, Mark W., John A. Elliott, and Robin L. Tarpley. 2002. “Evidence from Auditors about Managers’ and Auditors’ Earnings Management Decisions.” The Accounting Review 77 (s–1): 175–202.10.2308/accr.2002.77.s-1.175Search in Google Scholar
Pengelley, N. 2013. When Can an Insurer Exercise Its Right of Subrogation? (SSRN Scholarly Paper No. ID 2222167). Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network. Retrieved from http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2222167Search in Google Scholar
Pengelley, P. 2006. ‘Time’s Up!’ Limitation Periods for Subrogated Actions in Canada (SSRN Scholarly Paper No. ID 1159431). Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network. Retrieved from http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=1159431Search in Google Scholar
Perillo, J. M. 2009. “The Collateral Source Rule in Contract Cases.” San Diego Law Review 46: 705.Search in Google Scholar
Petroni, Kathy Ruby. 1992. “Optimistic Reporting in the Property-Casualty Insurance Industry.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 15 (4): 485–508.10.1016/0165-4101(92)90003-KSearch in Google Scholar
Rinaldi, E. 1993. “Apportionment of Recovery between Insured and Insurer in a Subrogation Case.” Tort and Insurance Law Journal 29: 803.Search in Google Scholar
Schipper, Katherine. 1989. “Commentary on Earnings Management.” Accounting Horizons 3 (4): 91–102.Search in Google Scholar
Sebok, A. J. 2014. Should the Law Preserve Party Control? Litigation Investment, Insurance Law and Double Standards (SSRN Scholarly Paper No. ID 2271762). Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network. Retrieved from http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2271762Search in Google Scholar
Zhang, Juan. 2017. “Conservatism and Asymmetric Timeliness of Loss Reserves Management in Property-Liability Insurance Industry.” Working paper, Temple University.10.2139/ssrn.2915656Search in Google Scholar
© 2019 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
Articles in the same Issue
- Featured Articles
- Planned Solvency III Regulation: Should It Be Adopted Outside the European Union?
- Who Estimates When It’s Not Required? the Case of Subrogation
- Dynamic Monitoring and Forecasting of the Soundness of U.S. Insurers in a Cyclical Environment
- Equity Incentives and Crash Risk in China’s A-Share Market
Articles in the same Issue
- Featured Articles
- Planned Solvency III Regulation: Should It Be Adopted Outside the European Union?
- Who Estimates When It’s Not Required? the Case of Subrogation
- Dynamic Monitoring and Forecasting of the Soundness of U.S. Insurers in a Cyclical Environment
- Equity Incentives and Crash Risk in China’s A-Share Market
