Horace’s Roman Odes: A Book within a Book?
Abstract
This paper suggests that Horace’s Roman Odes (Odes 3.1-6) can be read as a unit which mimics key features of a Latin poetic book: shared meter, book-like length, a proem in the middle, a consistently high level of intratextual connection in both themes and language, and a ring-compositional closure. The combination of these features is unique within the Odes, and has the effect of separating Odes 3.1-6 into its own shorter coherent unit, which nevertheless forms part of a Horatian lyric book of regular length.
Abstract
This paper suggests that Horace’s Roman Odes (Odes 3.1-6) can be read as a unit which mimics key features of a Latin poetic book: shared meter, book-like length, a proem in the middle, a consistently high level of intratextual connection in both themes and language, and a ring-compositional closure. The combination of these features is unique within the Odes, and has the effect of separating Odes 3.1-6 into its own shorter coherent unit, which nevertheless forms part of a Horatian lyric book of regular length.
Chapters in this book
- Frontmatter I
- Acknowledgments V
- Contents VII
- Abbreviations XIII
- List of Figures XVII
- Introduction: Lucia Athanassaki, φαεννὸν ἄστρον 1
-
Part I: Greek Epic and Lyric
- Three Homeric Puzzles 9
- Sappho and the Ethereal: A Reading of Sappho fr. 2 27
- Choruses of Young Women and (Homo)erotic Ritual Poetry: Sappho Again 51
- Geryon, Stesichoros, and the Vase-Painters Revisited 67
- Sympotic Gazes, eros, and Commitment: Ibycus 287 PMG 105
- Two Ancient Greek Babies: Simonides 543 PMG, Iliad 6.466–473 123
- Singing into Being 139
- The Archilochus Diet: Comedy and Empty Calories in Pythian 2 155
- Pausanias on Corinna and Pindar 175
- The Good Old Days: Pederastic Nostalgia from Theognis to Theocritus 181
- How Real is Sympotic Prayer? 199
- Penis or Phanes? Αἰδοῖον in OF 8 (P. Derv. xiii.4) 215
- Saint Gregory of Nazianzus on the Difficulty of Being Good (Carm. I.2.9, ed. Migne) 251
- Eros, Love Elegy, and Epic Artistic Contests in the Subtext of Cadmus’ Pastoral Singing in Nonnus’ Dionysiaca 1 263
- A Tree Named for Friendship: Reading Homer’s phylia through Nonnus 275
- Pindar’s Poetic Art and George of Pisidia’s Bellum Avaricum 291
-
Part II: Greek Drama
- The Sleep of the Furies in Aeschylus’ Eumenides as a Dramatic Device 313
- Torture’s Untruths: Tragic Visions of Testimony under Duress 329
- Towards a Renewed Panhellenism: Iliadic Resonances and Epinician Panegyric in Euripides’ Andromache 351
- Myth and Supplication: Thetis in Euripides’ Andromache 381
- Happy Citizens in Euripides 399
- “What Shall I Do?”: Choice-making and Sophocles’ Philoctetes 411
-
Part III: Greek Prose
- Shaping Female Ritual Leadership in Greek Literature 427
- The Language of Same-sex Love in Ancient Greece 445
- Rhetorical Portrayals of Metics in Lysias 471
- On Fourth-century Demagogues: Demosthenes and Others 493
- A Missing Person at the Banquet? A New Emendation (Xen. Symp. 1.4) 509
- The Construction of Space in Plato’s Phaedrus: A Phenomenological Approach 521
- “Those Whom Zeus Does Not Love”: Plato and Pindar on the Concept of Poikilia 539
- “Correcting” Pindar in the Laws: A Platonic Defense of νόμος πάντων βασιλεύς 559
- Put the Blame on Her: The Case of Nanis and the Fall of Sardis 577
- Polybian Temporalities 595
- A Man for All Genres: Alexander in Plutarch 611
- Emotions Related to Vices and Diseases in Plutarch 627
- Fragments of Wisdom? The Manipulated Use of the Citations by the Authors of the Second Sophistic 647
- What Does Ixion Represent? The Treatment of His Story from Pindar to Julian 661
- A Hippopotamus is a Horse Designed by a Committee 671
-
Part IV: Latin Literature
- The Price of Desire: Narrative Conflict in Plautus’ Casina 709
- Horace’s Roman Odes: A Book within a Book? 727
- The Poetics of the Roman Triumph 745
- Fatum, Memory, and Gender in Roman Epic 763
- The Fallibility of the Human Condition in Petronius’ Satyricon 75.1 and 130.1 779
-
Epilogue
- An Appreciation of Lucia Athanassaki from the International Plutarch Society 797
- List of Contributors 799
- General Index 807
Chapters in this book
- Frontmatter I
- Acknowledgments V
- Contents VII
- Abbreviations XIII
- List of Figures XVII
- Introduction: Lucia Athanassaki, φαεννὸν ἄστρον 1
-
Part I: Greek Epic and Lyric
- Three Homeric Puzzles 9
- Sappho and the Ethereal: A Reading of Sappho fr. 2 27
- Choruses of Young Women and (Homo)erotic Ritual Poetry: Sappho Again 51
- Geryon, Stesichoros, and the Vase-Painters Revisited 67
- Sympotic Gazes, eros, and Commitment: Ibycus 287 PMG 105
- Two Ancient Greek Babies: Simonides 543 PMG, Iliad 6.466–473 123
- Singing into Being 139
- The Archilochus Diet: Comedy and Empty Calories in Pythian 2 155
- Pausanias on Corinna and Pindar 175
- The Good Old Days: Pederastic Nostalgia from Theognis to Theocritus 181
- How Real is Sympotic Prayer? 199
- Penis or Phanes? Αἰδοῖον in OF 8 (P. Derv. xiii.4) 215
- Saint Gregory of Nazianzus on the Difficulty of Being Good (Carm. I.2.9, ed. Migne) 251
- Eros, Love Elegy, and Epic Artistic Contests in the Subtext of Cadmus’ Pastoral Singing in Nonnus’ Dionysiaca 1 263
- A Tree Named for Friendship: Reading Homer’s phylia through Nonnus 275
- Pindar’s Poetic Art and George of Pisidia’s Bellum Avaricum 291
-
Part II: Greek Drama
- The Sleep of the Furies in Aeschylus’ Eumenides as a Dramatic Device 313
- Torture’s Untruths: Tragic Visions of Testimony under Duress 329
- Towards a Renewed Panhellenism: Iliadic Resonances and Epinician Panegyric in Euripides’ Andromache 351
- Myth and Supplication: Thetis in Euripides’ Andromache 381
- Happy Citizens in Euripides 399
- “What Shall I Do?”: Choice-making and Sophocles’ Philoctetes 411
-
Part III: Greek Prose
- Shaping Female Ritual Leadership in Greek Literature 427
- The Language of Same-sex Love in Ancient Greece 445
- Rhetorical Portrayals of Metics in Lysias 471
- On Fourth-century Demagogues: Demosthenes and Others 493
- A Missing Person at the Banquet? A New Emendation (Xen. Symp. 1.4) 509
- The Construction of Space in Plato’s Phaedrus: A Phenomenological Approach 521
- “Those Whom Zeus Does Not Love”: Plato and Pindar on the Concept of Poikilia 539
- “Correcting” Pindar in the Laws: A Platonic Defense of νόμος πάντων βασιλεύς 559
- Put the Blame on Her: The Case of Nanis and the Fall of Sardis 577
- Polybian Temporalities 595
- A Man for All Genres: Alexander in Plutarch 611
- Emotions Related to Vices and Diseases in Plutarch 627
- Fragments of Wisdom? The Manipulated Use of the Citations by the Authors of the Second Sophistic 647
- What Does Ixion Represent? The Treatment of His Story from Pindar to Julian 661
- A Hippopotamus is a Horse Designed by a Committee 671
-
Part IV: Latin Literature
- The Price of Desire: Narrative Conflict in Plautus’ Casina 709
- Horace’s Roman Odes: A Book within a Book? 727
- The Poetics of the Roman Triumph 745
- Fatum, Memory, and Gender in Roman Epic 763
- The Fallibility of the Human Condition in Petronius’ Satyricon 75.1 and 130.1 779
-
Epilogue
- An Appreciation of Lucia Athanassaki from the International Plutarch Society 797
- List of Contributors 799
- General Index 807