Home Linguistics & Semiotics Against a uniform treatment of second position effects as force markers
Chapter
Licensed
Unlicensed Requires Authentication

Against a uniform treatment of second position effects as force markers

  • Krzysztof Migdalski
View more publications by John Benjamins Publishing Company
To Publisher Page
Main Clause Phenomena
This chapter is in the book Main Clause Phenomena

Abstract

This paper investigates two constructions, Verb Second and second position cliticization. These constructions involve placement of a certain element (a finite verb or clitics) in the position following the clause-initial constituent, with seemingly few restrictions as to what this constituent might be. A common way of accounting for V2 is to assume that it is a force marker. This paper challenges this view. It investigates the history of V2 and second position cliticization as well as different environments in which both constructions are found. The investigation leads to the conclusion that second position effects encompass a number of different operations, only some of which can be argued to mark force.

Abstract

This paper investigates two constructions, Verb Second and second position cliticization. These constructions involve placement of a certain element (a finite verb or clitics) in the position following the clause-initial constituent, with seemingly few restrictions as to what this constituent might be. A common way of accounting for V2 is to assume that it is a force marker. This paper challenges this view. It investigates the history of V2 and second position cliticization as well as different environments in which both constructions are found. The investigation leads to the conclusion that second position effects encompass a number of different operations, only some of which can be argued to mark force.

Chapters in this book

  1. Prelim pages i
  2. Table of contents v
  3. Introduction
  4. Main Clause Phenomena and the privilege of the root 1
  5. PART I. Explaining Main Clause Phenomena: The bigger picture
  6. Augmented structure preservation and the Tensed S Constraint 23
  7. Root transformations & quantificational structure 47
  8. Agreements that occur mainly in the main clause 79
  9. The syntax of MCP 113
  10. Towards an interface definition of root phenomena* 135
  11. Explaining matrix/subordinate domain discrepancies 159
  12. Parenthetical main clauses – or not? 177
  13. PART II. The Phenomena
  14. A. Particles and agreement markers
  15. Topic particle stranding and the structure of CP 205
  16. Splitting up force 229
  17. The syntactic position of Polish by and Main Clause Phenomena 257
  18. B. Complementizers and verb-second
  19. A main clause complementizer 279
  20. The status of complementizers in the left periphery 297
  21. Minimality and embedded V2 in Scandinavian 319
  22. Against a uniform treatment of second position effects as force markers 345
  23. C. Adverbial clauses
  24. The syntax-discourse interface in adverbial clauses 365
  25. Subjunctive mood, epistemic modality and Main Clause Phenomena in the analysis of adverbial clauses 385
  26. On two types of adverbial clauses allowing root-phenomena 405
  27. Index 431
https://doi.org/10.1075/la.190.15mig

Chapters in this book

  1. Prelim pages i
  2. Table of contents v
  3. Introduction
  4. Main Clause Phenomena and the privilege of the root 1
  5. PART I. Explaining Main Clause Phenomena: The bigger picture
  6. Augmented structure preservation and the Tensed S Constraint 23
  7. Root transformations & quantificational structure 47
  8. Agreements that occur mainly in the main clause 79
  9. The syntax of MCP 113
  10. Towards an interface definition of root phenomena* 135
  11. Explaining matrix/subordinate domain discrepancies 159
  12. Parenthetical main clauses – or not? 177
  13. PART II. The Phenomena
  14. A. Particles and agreement markers
  15. Topic particle stranding and the structure of CP 205
  16. Splitting up force 229
  17. The syntactic position of Polish by and Main Clause Phenomena 257
  18. B. Complementizers and verb-second
  19. A main clause complementizer 279
  20. The status of complementizers in the left periphery 297
  21. Minimality and embedded V2 in Scandinavian 319
  22. Against a uniform treatment of second position effects as force markers 345
  23. C. Adverbial clauses
  24. The syntax-discourse interface in adverbial clauses 365
  25. Subjunctive mood, epistemic modality and Main Clause Phenomena in the analysis of adverbial clauses 385
  26. On two types of adverbial clauses allowing root-phenomena 405
  27. Index 431
Sign up now to receive a 20% welcome discount
Institutional Access
How does access work?
Have an idea on how to improve our website?
Please write us.
© 2026 De Gruyter Brill
Downloaded on 27.2.2026 from https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1075/la.190.15mig/html
Scroll to top button