Chronic pain after whiplash injury is a largely unresolved medical and social problem. By definition, symptoms follow a trauma, which is in most cases a motorvehicle accident. The majority of patients recover, but for those who have persisting complaints an odyssey begins. Imaging techniques rarely reveal changes that explain the magnitude of symptoms [1]. As a result, patients are frequently told that they have nothing serious. Nevertheless, pain persists and is frequently associated with disability and depression. Many sufferers stop working. Some patients experience progressive spread of pain to body regions that are distant from the site of injury [2], which additionally complicates the understanding of the disease. Not uncommonly, the lack of understanding of the cause of pain leads to mistrust and questions as to whether the symptoms are real, or rather some sort of gain is behind the complaints. The resulting sense of perceived injustice is an additional factor for disability [3], further worsening the overall clinical picture.
The general perception of clinicians, lawyers, judges and insurances is that the nature of whiplash-associated disorders is unknown. However, an evaluation of the available literature reveals that many aspects of the pathophysiology of this condition have become clear. Basic research in animal models, kinematics, kinetics and biomechanics support the concept that lesions occur after a whiplash injury and these lesions can produce nociception [4]. Clinical research has provided strong evidence that the zygapophysial (facet) joints are sources of pain in whiplash patients [5,6], which is concordant with extensive data from animal and bioengineer research [7,8]. Unfortunately, these lesions are not visible by imaging techniques. A recent investigation with magnetic resonance imaging has shown that patients in the acute phase of a whiplash injury have more pathological findings than matched healthy controls, but reliability, sensitivity and specificity of the findings is poor [1]. Positron Emission Tomography has revealed signs of inflammation in whiplash patients, but the clinical significance needs to be investigated by further studies [9]. On average, patients with pain after whiplash injury display facilitation of central pain processes [2,10,11], which may explain exaggerated pain in the presence of limited tissue damage. Psychosocial factors are associated with central hypersensitivity [12] and have been shown to affect the outcome of whiplash injuries [13]. Thus, important progresses have been made in our understanding of the pathophysiology of whiplash. Because the importance of different mechanisms is likely to vary across patients, the clinical challenge is to identify which factors play a role in the determination of symptoms in individual patients. To date, a comprehensive assessment of the different potential contributors is essential to formulate a working hypothesis for an individualized treatment.
Whenever the cause of pain cannot be identified or removed, drug treatment is an option. Oddly, research on the efficacy of analgesics in whiplash-associated disorders is extremely sparse [14]. The paper by Persson et al. in this issue of the Scandinavial Journal of Pain [15] analyzes the response of patients with chronic pain after whiplash injury to intravenous infusions of morphine, ketamine and an active placebo (midazolam). The drugs were administered as single doses. A variety of assessments of the psychosocial status and quality of life were made. Responses were categorized as positive or negative based on the cutoff of 50% pain relief. The study was completed in 94 patients, which is a considerable number in the frame of whiplash clinical research. Among patients who did not respond to placebo, 47% were morphine responders, 41% ketamine responders, 25% responded to both drugs and 37% to neither drug.
Because of the extreme paucity of data on the efficacy of drugs in chronic pain after whiplash injury, this study is important. It suggests that this pain condition might be modulated by opioids and NMDA-antagonists in part of patients. Although links between this finding and mechanistic aspects should be made with caution, the data support the view that whiplash injury is associated with changes in central modulatory processes. The interindividual response was variable, and some patients did not respond to any drug. In the field of chronic pain, this is not a unique feature of whiplash. Several factors may account for lack of analgesic effect, such as individual dose–response relationship or pharmacogenetic polymorphisms [16]. Interestingly, the group of patients who did not respond to morphine or ketamine displayed a trend for a worse performance in some of the psychometric tests, supporting clinical observations that psychic disorders may represent obstacles to the efficacy of treatments. Clearly, this finding needs to be confirmed by studies that are designed and powered to address this question.
The study has limitations. Responses to single drug doses do not necessarily imply long-term efficacy. On the other hand, lack of effect after a single administration does not rule out efficacy with long term treatment, since central modulating effects might become clinically detectable after days or weeks of drug exposure. The study did not test the combination of the two drugs. In a study on patients with post herpes zoster pain, a chronic central and peripheral neuropathic pain, morphine and ketamine had a more pronounced analgesic effect when both drugs were given together, compared with single drug administrations [17]. The use of midazolam as active placebo may be questioned, due to the antihyperalgesic and hypoalgesic effects of GABAA-agonists in a large amount of animal studies [18], confirmed by some clinical investigations [19]. Thus, an undetermined proportion of the placebo responders might actually be responders to GABAA-agonists.
In summary, the study by Persson et al. shed some additional light on the pathophysiology and management of whiplashassociated disorders. Most patients do respond to drug treatment, at least in the short term. The hope is that most of these patients would respond also on the long term, a hypothesis that needs to be tested by further clinical trials. Furthermore, the finding does not support the view that pain after whiplash injury has nothing to do with nociceptive processes. Hopefully, the study will motivate researchers to perform pharmacological trials on the middle- and long-term efficacy of drugs in whiplash-associated disorders.
DOI of refers to article:10.1016/j.sjpain.2012.01.003.
References
[1] Anderson SE, Boesch C, Zimmermann H, Busato A, Hodler J, Bingisser R, Ulbrich EJ, Nidecker A, Buitrago-Tellez CH, Bonel HM, Heini P, Schaeren S, Sturzenegger M. Are there cervical spine findings at mr imaging that are specific to acute symptomatic whiplash injury? A prospective controlled study with four experienced blinded readers. Radiology 2012;262:567–75.Suche in Google Scholar
[2] Kasch H, Qerama E, Kongsted A, Bach FW, Bendix T, Jensen TS. Deep muscle pain, tender points and recovery in acute whiplash patients: a 1-year follow-up study. Pain 2008;140:65–73.Suche in Google Scholar
[3] Sullivan MJ, Thibault P, Simmonds MJ, Milioto M, Cantin AP, Velly AM. Pain, perceived injustice and the persistence of post-traumatic stress symptoms during the course of rehabilitation for whiplash injuries. Pain 2009;145:325–31.Suche in Google Scholar
[4] Curatolo M, Bogduk N, Ivancic PC, McLean SA, Siegmund GP, Winkelstein BA. The role of tissue damage in whiplash-associated disorders: discussion paper 1. Spine 2011;36:S309–15.Suche in Google Scholar
[5] Lord SM, Barnsley L, Wallis BJ, Bogduk N. Chronic cervical zygapophysial joint pain after whiplash. A placebo-controlled prevalence study. Spine 1996;21:1737–45.Suche in Google Scholar
[6] Lord SM, Barnsley L, Wallis BJ, McDonald GJ, Bogduk N. Percutaneous radi of requency neurotomy for chronic cervical zygapophyseal-joint pain. N Engl J Med 1996;335:1721–6.Suche in Google Scholar
[7] Winkelstein BA. How can animal models inform on the transition to chronic symptoms in whiplash? Spine 2011;36:S218–25.Suche in Google Scholar
[8] Siegmund GP. What occupant kinematics and neuromuscular responses tell us about whiplash injury. Spine 2011;36:S175–9.Suche in Google Scholar
[9] Linnman C, Appel L, Fredrikson M, Gordh T, Soderlund A, Langstrom B, Engler H. Elevated [11c]-d-deprenyl uptake in chronic whiplash associated disorder suggests persistent musculoskeletal inflammation. PLoS One 2011;6: e19182.Suche in Google Scholar
[10] Sterling M, Hodkinson E, Pettiford C, Souvlis T, Curatolo M. Psychologic factors are related to some sensory pain thresholds but not nociceptive flexion reflex threshold in chronic whiplash. Clin J Pain 2008;24:124–30.Suche in Google Scholar
[11] Sterling M, Jull G, Vicenzino B, Kenardy J. Sensory hypersensitivity occurs soon after whiplash injury and is associated with poor recovery. Pain 2003;104:509–17.Suche in Google Scholar
[12] Jensen TS. High prevalence of posttraumatic stress disorder (ptsd) and pain sensitization in two scandinavian samples of patients referred for pain rehabilitation. Scand J Pain 2012;3:38.Suche in Google Scholar
[13] Carroll LJ, Holm LW, Hogg-Johnson S, Cote P, Cassidy JD, Haldeman S, Nordin M, Hurwitz EL, Carragee EJ, van der Velde G, Peloso PM, Guzman J. Course and prognostic factors for neck pain in whiplash-associated disorders (wad): results of the bone and joint decade 2000-2010 task force on neck pain and its associated disorders. Spine 2008;33:S83–92.Suche in Google Scholar
[14] Peloso PM, Gross AR, Haines TA, Trinh K, Goldsmith CH, Aker P. Medicinal and injection therapies for mechanical neck disorders: a cochrane systematic review. J Rheumatol 2006;33:957–67.Suche in Google Scholar
[15] Persson M, Sörensen J, Gerdle B. Whiplash-associated disorders (wad): responses to pharmacological challenges and psychometric tests. Scand J Pain 2012;3:151–63.Suche in Google Scholar
[16] Stamer UM, Stuber F. Genetic factors in pain and its treatment. Curr Opin Anaesthesiol 2007;20:478–84.Suche in Google Scholar
[17] Stubhaug A. Ketamine in the treatment of spontaneous ongoing pain and evoked pain. Studies in humans with chronic neuropathic pain, acute postoperative pain, or experimental pain (thesis d. Med. Science). Olso: University of Oslo; 1999.Suche in Google Scholar
[18] Zeilhofer HU, Zeilhofer UB. Spinal dis-inhibition in inflammatory pain. Neurosci Lett 2008;437:170–4.Suche in Google Scholar
[19] Ho KM, Ismail H. Use of intrathecal midazolam to improve perioperative analgesia: a meta-analysis. Anaesth Intensive Care 2008;36:365–73.Suche in Google Scholar
© 2012 Scandinavian Association for the Study of Pain
Artikel in diesem Heft
- Editorial comment
- Spontaneous pain is reduced by conditioning pain modulation in peripheral neuropathy but not in fibromyalgia—Implications for different pain mechanisms
- Clinical pain research
- Differential pain modulation in patients with peripheral neuropathic pain and fibromyalgia
- Editorial comment
- Pulsed radiofrequency—Time for a clinical pause and more science
- Clinical pain research
- Pulsed radiofrequency in peripheral posttraumatic neuropathic pain: A double blind sham controlled randomized clinical trial
- Editorial comment
- Phantom pains and sensations – how does it feel? Only the patient really knows
- Clinical pain research
- Phantom phenomena – Their perceived qualities and consequences from the patient’s perspective
- Editorial comment
- Impact of mental stressor on conditioned pain modulation
- Original experimental
- The effect of a mental stressor on conditioned pain modulation in healthy subjects
- Editorial comment
- Pharmacological modulation of chronic pain after whiplash injury
- Clinical pain research
- Whiplash Associated Disorders (WAD): Responses to pharmacological challenges and psychometric tests
- Editorial comment
- Why are autonomic responses to pressure pain different from those to heat pain and ischaemic pain?
- Original experimental
- Cardiovascular responses to and modulation of pressure pain sensitivity in normotensive, pain-free women
- Correspondence
- Piriformis muscle injection guided by sciatic nerve stimulation: Quick, simple, and safe technique
- Correspondence
- Musculus piriformis syndrome: Localization and injection therapy—Comment to letter from Mayo-Moldes M et al. [1]
- Abstracts
- The “pain matrix” reloaded
- Abstracts
- Endpoints in animal pain models
- Abstracts
- Evaluating pain-related behavior in spinal cord injury
- Abstracts
- The role of the amygdala in sensory and emotional-like pain behavior in neuropathic animals
- Abstracts
- Peripheral and central pain mechanisms—From animal models to clinical research
- Abstracts
- Human experimental models of central sensitization—Do they bridge the gap between animal models and clinical observations?
- Abstracts
- Assessment of central sensitization in the clinic. Is it possible?
- Abstracts
- Migraine neurobiology and treatment
- Abstracts
- Chronic headaches–Goals and obstacles
- Abstracts
- Trigeminal neuralgia and other cranial neuralgias
- Abstracts
- Temporomandibular disorders: Pathophysiology and diagnosis
- Abstracts
- HIV-associated painful polyneuropathy
- Abstracts
- Keynote: Neuronal and glial signalling in pain neuroplasticity
- Abstracts
- Neuropathic pain—From guidelines to clinical practice
- Abstracts
- Postoperative pain treatment. What’s the evidence—And how to use it?
- Abstracts
- NSAIDs in postoperative pain
- Abstracts
- How should we prevent persistent postoperative pain?
- Abstracts
- Opioids: Genetics and receptors
- Abstracts
- Chronic pain and sleep disorders
- Abstracts
- Population-based studies on chronic pain: The role of opioids
- Abstracts
- Living beyond pain: Acceptance and commitment therapy
- Abstracts
- Modality specific alterations of esophageal sensitivity caused by longstanding diabetes mellitus
- Abstracts
- Validation of a porcine behavioural model of UVB induced inflammatory pain
- Abstracts
- Recovery after a lumbar disc herniation is dependent on a gender and OPRM1 Asn40Asp genotype interaction
- Abstracts
- Pain sensitivity changes in chronic pain patients with and without spinal cord stimulation assessed by nociceptive withdrawal reflex thresholds and electrical pain thresholds
- Abstracts
- Acceptance and commitment therapy for fibromyalgia: A randomized controlled trial
- Abstracts
- Sortilins in neuropathic pain
- Abstracts
- Systematic review of neuropathic component in persistent post-surgical pain
- Abstracts
- Pain prevalence in a university hospital in Iceland
- Abstracts
- The effect of tail-docking neonate piglets on ATF-3 and NR2B immunoreactivity in coccygeal dorsal root ganglia and spinal cord dorsal horn neurons: Preliminary data
- Abstracts
- Na+/K+-ATPase dependent regulation of astrocyte Ca2+ signalling: A novel mechanism for modulation of long-term pain?
- Abstracts
- Glutamate attenuates nitric oxide release from isolated trigeminal ganglion satellite glial cells
- Abstracts
- Acute behavioural responses to tail docking in piglets – Effects of increasing docking length?
- Abstracts
- Dose and administration-period play a key role in the effect of ceftriaxone on neuropathic pain in CCI-operated rats
- Abstracts
- Translational aspects of rectal evoked potentials: A comparative study in rats and humans
- Abstracts
- Time-course of analgesic effects of botulinum neurotoxin type A (BoNTA) on human experimental model of pain induced by injection of glutamate into temporalis muscle
- Abstracts
- The effect of nerve compression and capsaicin on contact heat evoked potentials (CHEPs) related to Aδ and C fibers
- Abstracts
- Effect of specific trapezius exercises vs. coordination training on corticomotor control of neck muscles
- Abstracts
- SNP in TNFα T308G is predictive for persistent postoperative pain following inguinal hernia surgery
- Abstracts
- Chronic pain in thoracotomy
- Abstracts
- The variability in thermal threshold-assessments in post-thoracotomy pain syndrome
- Abstracts
- Persistent pain, sensory disturbances and functional impairment after adjuvant chemotherapy for breast cancer
- Abstracts
- Neuroplastic alterations in brain responses to painful visceral stimulations reflects individual neuropathic symptoms in diabetes mellitus patients
- Abstracts
- Exercise and conditioned pain modulation have different effects on cuff pressure pain tolerance in humans
- Abstracts
- Hyperalgesia in human skin and deep-tissues inside and outside of a UVB irradiated area
- Abstracts
- Effect of experimental jaw muscle pain on bite force during mastication
- Abstracts
- Reflex threshold assessment methodology for evaluation of central sensitisation is vulnerable to EMG crosstalk
- Abstracts
- Cognitive modulation of experimental pain at spinal and cortical levels
- Abstracts
- Influence of emotionally loaded visual and gustatory stimuli on pain perception
- Abstracts
- Modulating pain with augmented reality
- Abstracts
- Offset analgesia: A reproducibility study
- Abstracts
- Visualization of painful process in peripheral tissue using positron emission tomography and [11C]-D-deprenyl
- Abstracts
- Mirror-image sensory dysfunction in the post-thoracotomy pain syndrome
- Abstracts
- Genetic variation in opioid receptor genes and sensitivity to experimental pain in male and female healthy volunteers
- Abstracts
- Mechanical sensitivity in migraine patients during attack, remission, and pain-free periods:A preliminary study
- Abstracts
- Multivariate pattern analysis of evoked brain potentials by temporal matching pursuit and support vector machine
- Abstracts
- Pain following stroke: A prospective study
- Abstracts
- Chronic thoracic pain in children after cardiac surgery
- Abstracts
- Chronic pain after breast augmentation is associated with both signs of peripheral nerve injury and central nervous mechanisms
- Abstracts
- Sensory phenotypes in patients with peripheral neuropathic pain evaluated with quantitative sensory testing
- Abstracts
- Is health related quality of life related to the pattern of chronic pain?
- Abstracts
- Comparison between ropivacaine local infiltration analgesia with ketorolac or placebo for total knee replacement surgery
- Abstracts
- Treatment with topical capsaicin: Experience from a pain clinic
- Abstracts
- Distribution of concussion related symptoms after whiplash injury in risk strata
- Abstracts
- HIV/AIDS in different cultures
- Abstracts
- Pain perception is altered in patients with medication-overuse headache but can improve after detoxification
- Abstracts
- Detoxification in a structured programme is effective for medication-overuse headache
Artikel in diesem Heft
- Editorial comment
- Spontaneous pain is reduced by conditioning pain modulation in peripheral neuropathy but not in fibromyalgia—Implications for different pain mechanisms
- Clinical pain research
- Differential pain modulation in patients with peripheral neuropathic pain and fibromyalgia
- Editorial comment
- Pulsed radiofrequency—Time for a clinical pause and more science
- Clinical pain research
- Pulsed radiofrequency in peripheral posttraumatic neuropathic pain: A double blind sham controlled randomized clinical trial
- Editorial comment
- Phantom pains and sensations – how does it feel? Only the patient really knows
- Clinical pain research
- Phantom phenomena – Their perceived qualities and consequences from the patient’s perspective
- Editorial comment
- Impact of mental stressor on conditioned pain modulation
- Original experimental
- The effect of a mental stressor on conditioned pain modulation in healthy subjects
- Editorial comment
- Pharmacological modulation of chronic pain after whiplash injury
- Clinical pain research
- Whiplash Associated Disorders (WAD): Responses to pharmacological challenges and psychometric tests
- Editorial comment
- Why are autonomic responses to pressure pain different from those to heat pain and ischaemic pain?
- Original experimental
- Cardiovascular responses to and modulation of pressure pain sensitivity in normotensive, pain-free women
- Correspondence
- Piriformis muscle injection guided by sciatic nerve stimulation: Quick, simple, and safe technique
- Correspondence
- Musculus piriformis syndrome: Localization and injection therapy—Comment to letter from Mayo-Moldes M et al. [1]
- Abstracts
- The “pain matrix” reloaded
- Abstracts
- Endpoints in animal pain models
- Abstracts
- Evaluating pain-related behavior in spinal cord injury
- Abstracts
- The role of the amygdala in sensory and emotional-like pain behavior in neuropathic animals
- Abstracts
- Peripheral and central pain mechanisms—From animal models to clinical research
- Abstracts
- Human experimental models of central sensitization—Do they bridge the gap between animal models and clinical observations?
- Abstracts
- Assessment of central sensitization in the clinic. Is it possible?
- Abstracts
- Migraine neurobiology and treatment
- Abstracts
- Chronic headaches–Goals and obstacles
- Abstracts
- Trigeminal neuralgia and other cranial neuralgias
- Abstracts
- Temporomandibular disorders: Pathophysiology and diagnosis
- Abstracts
- HIV-associated painful polyneuropathy
- Abstracts
- Keynote: Neuronal and glial signalling in pain neuroplasticity
- Abstracts
- Neuropathic pain—From guidelines to clinical practice
- Abstracts
- Postoperative pain treatment. What’s the evidence—And how to use it?
- Abstracts
- NSAIDs in postoperative pain
- Abstracts
- How should we prevent persistent postoperative pain?
- Abstracts
- Opioids: Genetics and receptors
- Abstracts
- Chronic pain and sleep disorders
- Abstracts
- Population-based studies on chronic pain: The role of opioids
- Abstracts
- Living beyond pain: Acceptance and commitment therapy
- Abstracts
- Modality specific alterations of esophageal sensitivity caused by longstanding diabetes mellitus
- Abstracts
- Validation of a porcine behavioural model of UVB induced inflammatory pain
- Abstracts
- Recovery after a lumbar disc herniation is dependent on a gender and OPRM1 Asn40Asp genotype interaction
- Abstracts
- Pain sensitivity changes in chronic pain patients with and without spinal cord stimulation assessed by nociceptive withdrawal reflex thresholds and electrical pain thresholds
- Abstracts
- Acceptance and commitment therapy for fibromyalgia: A randomized controlled trial
- Abstracts
- Sortilins in neuropathic pain
- Abstracts
- Systematic review of neuropathic component in persistent post-surgical pain
- Abstracts
- Pain prevalence in a university hospital in Iceland
- Abstracts
- The effect of tail-docking neonate piglets on ATF-3 and NR2B immunoreactivity in coccygeal dorsal root ganglia and spinal cord dorsal horn neurons: Preliminary data
- Abstracts
- Na+/K+-ATPase dependent regulation of astrocyte Ca2+ signalling: A novel mechanism for modulation of long-term pain?
- Abstracts
- Glutamate attenuates nitric oxide release from isolated trigeminal ganglion satellite glial cells
- Abstracts
- Acute behavioural responses to tail docking in piglets – Effects of increasing docking length?
- Abstracts
- Dose and administration-period play a key role in the effect of ceftriaxone on neuropathic pain in CCI-operated rats
- Abstracts
- Translational aspects of rectal evoked potentials: A comparative study in rats and humans
- Abstracts
- Time-course of analgesic effects of botulinum neurotoxin type A (BoNTA) on human experimental model of pain induced by injection of glutamate into temporalis muscle
- Abstracts
- The effect of nerve compression and capsaicin on contact heat evoked potentials (CHEPs) related to Aδ and C fibers
- Abstracts
- Effect of specific trapezius exercises vs. coordination training on corticomotor control of neck muscles
- Abstracts
- SNP in TNFα T308G is predictive for persistent postoperative pain following inguinal hernia surgery
- Abstracts
- Chronic pain in thoracotomy
- Abstracts
- The variability in thermal threshold-assessments in post-thoracotomy pain syndrome
- Abstracts
- Persistent pain, sensory disturbances and functional impairment after adjuvant chemotherapy for breast cancer
- Abstracts
- Neuroplastic alterations in brain responses to painful visceral stimulations reflects individual neuropathic symptoms in diabetes mellitus patients
- Abstracts
- Exercise and conditioned pain modulation have different effects on cuff pressure pain tolerance in humans
- Abstracts
- Hyperalgesia in human skin and deep-tissues inside and outside of a UVB irradiated area
- Abstracts
- Effect of experimental jaw muscle pain on bite force during mastication
- Abstracts
- Reflex threshold assessment methodology for evaluation of central sensitisation is vulnerable to EMG crosstalk
- Abstracts
- Cognitive modulation of experimental pain at spinal and cortical levels
- Abstracts
- Influence of emotionally loaded visual and gustatory stimuli on pain perception
- Abstracts
- Modulating pain with augmented reality
- Abstracts
- Offset analgesia: A reproducibility study
- Abstracts
- Visualization of painful process in peripheral tissue using positron emission tomography and [11C]-D-deprenyl
- Abstracts
- Mirror-image sensory dysfunction in the post-thoracotomy pain syndrome
- Abstracts
- Genetic variation in opioid receptor genes and sensitivity to experimental pain in male and female healthy volunteers
- Abstracts
- Mechanical sensitivity in migraine patients during attack, remission, and pain-free periods:A preliminary study
- Abstracts
- Multivariate pattern analysis of evoked brain potentials by temporal matching pursuit and support vector machine
- Abstracts
- Pain following stroke: A prospective study
- Abstracts
- Chronic thoracic pain in children after cardiac surgery
- Abstracts
- Chronic pain after breast augmentation is associated with both signs of peripheral nerve injury and central nervous mechanisms
- Abstracts
- Sensory phenotypes in patients with peripheral neuropathic pain evaluated with quantitative sensory testing
- Abstracts
- Is health related quality of life related to the pattern of chronic pain?
- Abstracts
- Comparison between ropivacaine local infiltration analgesia with ketorolac or placebo for total knee replacement surgery
- Abstracts
- Treatment with topical capsaicin: Experience from a pain clinic
- Abstracts
- Distribution of concussion related symptoms after whiplash injury in risk strata
- Abstracts
- HIV/AIDS in different cultures
- Abstracts
- Pain perception is altered in patients with medication-overuse headache but can improve after detoxification
- Abstracts
- Detoxification in a structured programme is effective for medication-overuse headache