Cornell University Press
Logics of War
-
and -
Funded by:
About this book
Most wars between countries end quickly and at relatively low cost. The few in which high-intensity fighting continues for years bring about a disproportionate amount of death and suffering. What separates these few unusually long and intense wars from the many conflicts that are far less destructive? In Logics of War, Alex Weisiger tests three explanations for a nation's decision to go to war and continue fighting regardless of the costs. He combines sharp statistical analysis of interstate wars over the past two centuries with nine narrative case studies. He examines both well-known conflicts like World War II and the Persian Gulf War, as well as unfamiliar ones such as the 1864–1870 Paraguayan War (or the War of the Triple Alliance), which proportionally caused more deaths than any other war in modern history.
When leaders go to war expecting easy victory, events usually correct their misperceptions quickly and with fairly low casualties, thereby setting the stage for a negotiated agreement. A second explanation involves motives born of domestic politics; as war becomes more intense, however, leaders are increasingly constrained in their ability to continue the fighting. Particularly destructive wars instead arise from mistrust of an opponent's intentions. Countries that launch preventive wars to forestall expected decline tend to have particularly ambitious war aims that they hold to even when fighting goes poorly. Moreover, in some cases, their opponents interpret the preventive attack as evidence of a dispositional commitment to aggression, resulting in the rejection of any form of negotiation and a demand for unconditional surrender. Weisiger's treatment of a topic of central concern to scholars of major wars will also be read with great interest by military historians, political psychologists, and sociologists.
Author / Editor information
Alex Weisiger is Assistant Professor of Political Science at the University of Pennsylvania.
Reviews
When are wars short and limited and when they are long and destructive? Alex Weisiger supports his theoretically innovative answer to this important but neglected question with systematic statistical analysis and rich historical analysis. Logics of War is an important extension of the bargaining model of war, a wonderful exemplar of multimethod research, and essential reading for all serious students of interstate war.
Hein Goemans, University of Rochester, author of War and Punishment: The Causes of War Termination and the First World War:
Logics of War unpacks the so-called black box of war to look at the often overlooked mechanisms that connect the beginnings to the ends of war. Blending qualitative and quantitative analysis in a very ambitious and successful multimethod strategy, Alex Weisiger not only examines the duration of war but also endeavors to offer new explanations for the severity of war. Weisiger presents a new and highly original explanation for the handful of exceptionally long and deadly wars in which one side sincerely demands unconditional surrender.
Topics
-
Download PDFPublicly Available
Frontmatter
i -
Download PDFPublicly Available
Contents
v -
Download PDFPublicly Available
Acknowledgments
vii -
Download PDFOpen Access
Introduction
1 -
Download PDFOpen Access
1. Explanations for Limited and Unlimited Wars
11 -
Download PDFOpen Access
2. Research Strategy and Statistical Tests
54 -
Download PDFOpen Access
3. War to the Death in Paraguay
86 -
Download PDFOpen Access
4. World War II: German Expansion and Allied Response
105 -
Download PDFOpen Access
5. Additional Commitment Problem Cases: The Crimean, Pacific, and Iran-Iraq Wars
141 -
Download PDFOpen Access
6. Short Wars of Optimism: Persian Gulf and Anglo-Iranian
159 -
Download PDFOpen Access
7. The Limits on Leaders: The Falklands War and the Franco-Turkish War
178 -
Download PDFOpen Access
Conclusion: Recapitulations, Implications, and Prognostications
203 -
Download PDFOpen Access
Notes
219 -
Download PDFOpen Access
Bibliography
261 -
Download PDFOpen Access
Index
281